• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

repetitive?

Mech_Master

Active Member
I don't know about anyone else, but I am REALLY tired of the fact that every pokemon game follows the EXACT same structure. Wake up, go get one of three grass, fire, or water pokemon, go to 8 gyms, then go fight the elite four. It's the same in every game. I think gamefreak really needs to switch things up a bit this time or at least add a lot more scripted moments and add some more to the story. Daimond and Pearl will be great regardless if the structure of the game changes or not, but it just feels like we're almost playing the same game over and over only in a different world.
 
I don't know about anyone else, but I am REALLY tired of the fact that every pokemon game follows the EXACT same structure. Wake up, go get one of three grass, fire, or water pokemon, go to 8 gyms, then go fight the elite four. It's the same in every game. I think gamefreak really needs to switch things up a bit this time or at least add a lot more scripted moments and add some more to the story. Daimond and Pearl will be great regardless if the structure of the game changes or not, but it just feels like we're almost playing the same game over and over only in a different world.

Game Freak DID do that once.

The result was Poke'mon Colosseum and Poke'mon XD. Both of which didn't do too well review-wise or sales-wise compared to the "normal" Poke'mon games.
 
The reason that they are "repetitive", is because people like them.
 
what do you want to do, join team rocket (that would be cool). but still, its like the tradition of the game. besides, they might have new features
 
I dont think GF made Colloseum and XD
 
Then don't buy it. If you think it's boring then don't rat out even more nintendo sales.
 
What about Pokemon Ranger and Misterious Dungeon. They gave players a chance at something different.
 
So what?Don't fix what isnt broken.

-Judai
Well see after 3 generations of games I would think they would at least pace the game a little differently or give you some new type of objectives by now.

I'm not saying they should do a dramatically different game like Pokemon Ranger or Colloseum. I'm just saying they shouldn't put the EXACT same objectives in every single game. Some of you people are getting way too defensive. I said the game will turn out great one way or another, but it will definitley be much better if they make the game more fresh.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, it's repetitive. But people like it. Besides, there's more to a great game besides story. And Pokemon's story isn't what's caused it to become a great franchise over the years. Pokemon is good because of the concept of building a team of Pokemon and battling and trading with your friends, which will be greatly improved with WiFi. After all, no two teams are exactly the same.

And all those things you mentioned (the G/F/W triangle, 8 gyms, E4, etc.) are tradition, and messing with tradition ends up disappointing fans.

If you want a game with "scripted moments" and "added stuff to the storyline" and crap like that, go play Final Fantasy or something. Otherwise, like Judai Yuki said, "Don't fix something that isn't broken."
 
And all those things you mentioned (the G/F/W triangle, 8 gyms, E4, etc.) are tradition, and messing with tradition ends up disappointing fans.

If you want a game with "scripted moments" and "added stuff to the storyline" and crap like that, go play Final Fantasy or something. Otherwise, like Judai Yuki said, "Don't fix something that isn't broken."
Well even still they may not have to take out the elite four and gyms or anything, but some new things could happen along the way. I liked how in r/s/e they added a bit more storyline and included a few brief cut scenes. The DS is more powerful than the GBA obviously, so I think it'd be nice if more moments like that were added and a bit more story was added. And FR/LG also had some nice touches as well that weren't in any of the other games. There's nothing wrong with expanding the games. If they stay exactly the same forever even the most hardcore fans will get bored eventually.
 
Back
Top