• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Speed Change?

Reign G

Roggen and Rolan
I was wondering. Speed is determined by the Pokemon's level, how it was bred, and such. Well, after the change of basing Physical and Special moves from their types to how they're performed, I got thinking. What if a Pokemon's Base Speed was determined by the species rather than how it's been trained? Like, smaller or more aerodynamic Pokemon woud be faster that a bulkier Pokemon, even if the larger was many levels above it.

Here's an example: A Torterra somewhere from Level 70 to 100 against a Ponyta somewhere in the 20's, neither using or ever haved used speed-enchancing items. Ponyta is more built for Speed, but Torterra is a much higher level. In the current sytem, Torterra would have has more time for Speed enchancements via Leveling, but in this idea of mine, Ponyta, being a horse-based Pokemon would be faster due to it being more built for speed, and would attack first.

So, good or bad idea? What do you think?
 
Yes, I think that's quite a good idea, but it would upset some people who EV train slow pokemon for speed.
 
It's good idea and it would be and intresting one if nintendo implemented it.
however, you'd have to take in account of how big it's legs were too, as well as its weight.
 
Definetley good idea
 
That would be alright, but could be unfair too..
 
Well, it should matter, weight and stuff
 
That's why there is a Speed Stat. The Speed Stat is based around all those facts, and that's why Ponyta has a 90 Base Spd Stat and Torterra a 56 Base Stat.

The level makes the difference as a fully trained bulky pokémon would be faster than a newly hatched light pokémon. It makes sense as the other has experience and can run better than a baby.
 
Uh, they already are. It's why Snorlax will never out run the far more made for speed Scyther.
 
I guess I kind of misexplained it. I meant like that basic idea, but also taking into account the weight of the Pokemon. Pokemon of the same species can weigh differently, so like the Weight shown on the Pokedex. Like, two Torterras of the exact same...Everything, except for the Weight from the Pokedex. But one is slightly lighter, so has more speed and can move first. he Ruzzy sums it up pretty well:

It's good idea and it would be and intresting one if nintendo implemented it.
however, you'd have to take in account of how big it's legs were too, as well as its weight.
 
I guess I kind of misexplained it. I meant like that basic idea, but also taking into account the weight of the Pokemon. Pokemon of the same species can weigh differently, so like the Weight shown on the Pokedex. Like, two Torterras of the exact same...Everything, except for the Weight from the Pokedex. But one is slightly lighter, so has more speed and can move first. he Ruzzy sums it up pretty well:
That's what IV's are for. Ones with higher Speed IV's could be lighter.
 
would get too complicated.
some pokémon look fast, but are heavier then another pokémon who looks slow but is lighter. and you can't base speed on looks...
 
It could be either good or bad for you, and juts because some pokemon like Ponyta being fast based (race horse), it doesn't mean it has to ourtrun suposedly slower pokemon....so no thx.
 
i think its a dumb idea because in competitive battling without EVs ponyta would be faster than torterra if they were equal in level. a level 75 torterra battling a level 25 ponyta would never happen in competitive battling.

besides, it eliminates the ability of trainers to overcome their pokemons weakness, and if i was a torterra trainer (which i am), it would completely screw me over against a faster pokemon such as rapidash, even if i put effort into training torterra to become faster. EV training in that area is how you overcome pokemon's weaknesses and i think to eliminate that, even just for one stat, would greatly unbalance the metagame. the physical/special split adds more balance to it and gives pokemon such as hitmonchan, tyranitar, and flareon a much bigger edge than they had before, with physical punches, dark attacks, and fire attacks respectively.
 
hey i think they already did this a bit, like i got a lvl 50 deoxys (speed form) and its faster then my lvl 100 kyogr, because its much more speed built then kyogre. currently im taining a horseys with speed ev's and it's faster then this pokemon 15 lvls higher then him... so in some way the have putt that in already, just not as extreme as youre idea.
 
No, that means a lv smeargle could OHKO a rhyperior with sheer cold. Ever seen a human baby be faster than a full grown turtle?
 
well humans aren't really built for speed whereas a newly born horse would easily outrun a fully grown turtle because horses are built for speed.
 
Bad idea

it makes very little sense




toterra at lvl 100 is fast because it's 80 levels higher - meaning that it has more experience at going first than ponyta, who only has 20 levels worth of experience in being speedy
 
you people that are saying it makes no/little sense don't seem to get the point, a pokemon like torterra, giant, heavy. with stubs for legs, it wold make sense for it to be outran by something small and agile, even if it is a higher level and hasn't been trained in speed. we aren't talking about competitive battling, we're talking about logic, if you saw a large turtle with small legs and weighing so much trying to fight a much smaller horse, would you expect it to be faster or would you expect it to have some sort of tactical plan to defeat it.
 
Back
Top