Oh, forgot about the pincers. Maybe I should elaborate a bit more on my original theories.
Two of Ash's rivals own the same turtle-like Pokemon Ash has. Gary has Squirtle while Paul had a Turtwig (it's now a Torterra). So there is the possibility of the 5th Gen rival having a fire turtle-like Pokemon. This seems unlikely though, since there is may be a pattern established amongst the rivals: Gary was the rival throughout the first two gens, there was no rival in the third gen, and Paul is the rival in the fourth gen with the possibility of him appearing in the 5th gen as well.
Similarly, Ash has four Pokemon that are also owned by four Gym leaders: Falkner with Pidgeot, Flannery with Torkoal, Winona with Swellow and Gardenia with Turtwig. So there is the possibilty of this trend continuing with another flying type (the pattern is flying, fire, flying, grass - contiued would be: flying, water (likely but not definite)).
In addition, several Gym leaders have owned evolved or pre-evolved forms of Ash's Pokemon. These are Lt. Surge with Raichu, Cissy with Blastoise, Falkner with Hoothoot, Bugsy with Metapod and Wake with Floatzel.This trend is likely to continue. Also note that three of the four female gym leaders that are in this pattern own turtle-like Pokemon; one fire, one grass and one water.
Ash also owns a Pokemon that appeared in a movie from the generation before that Pokemon. These are: Donphan (appeared in Movie One), Aimpom (Movie 3 and 5 and 8) and Buizel (Movie 9) So when we finally get to the 11th movie, keep an eye out for any strange Pokemon that we haven't seen yet.
(On a side note: all of Ash's Pokemon that have evolved twice (Charizard, Sceptile and Butterfree have cross counterparts on May's team (Blaziken, Venusaur and Beautifly))
So far, Ash's team is like this:
Pikachu
Grass type starter that will evolve once
Fire type saved by a trainer or Pokemon
Water type that can fight on land
Flying type that will fully evolve (whether it be caught at first, second or final stage)
A Pokemon that cannont be determined through a pattern.
So now we also have a sort of criteria:
One of these will most likely be turlte based
One of these will also be owned by a rival, assuming Ash gets a new rival in the 5th Gen
One of these will be owned by a gym leader. Also, a gym leader will own the evolved or pre-evolved form of one.
One Pokemon that is likely to show up in a 4th gen movie.
There's probably more I can add but I'll stop here.