• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Type changes

Jiggy37 said:
Only Acid uses acid... It seems to me that Sludge and Sludge Bomb are poisonous sludge that would probably just drip right off, and Poison Sting, Poison Fang, and Poison Tail wouldn't be able to penetrate the steel to get to the Pokemon underneath.

Sludge is still corrosive. Try pouring some industrial waste on a sheet of metal and see what happens. =P
Then again, with the new physical/special system, certain Poison attacks might affect Steel- namely Sludge, Acid, Sludge Bomb and possibly Smog.
 
Jiggy37 said:
I just want for Poison to not be weak against Psychic. I can come up with justifications for every other weakness/resistance, though some of them are difficult, but that one baffles me.
I enjoy using the thought of military tactics to rationalize this advantage: Poison is commonly used by those forces which want to go unnoticed, such as a clan of ninjas or a guerilla resistance force. If you know what they are planning - as represented by the Psychic type, the type of knowledge - you'll pin them down and vanquish them. Yet, by the same virtue, simply marching into their presence and trying to stamp them out of the area - this mentality suggested by the Fighting type - will not be as effective, thus why Poison resists Fighting.

I severely hope that if nothing else, the new type triangle for the starters will indicate that we see change in the type chart as a whole. Ice is simply crying for more resistances: let it have a defensive edge when it comes to Ground and Flying, it would help to take those moves down a fair peg. Poison could use an advantage against Water and/or Fighting types.

Other than that I don't want to see many changes.
 
1) Poison should be strong against Water.

2) Electric should be Super Effective on Steel (It has too many resistances).

3) Ghost and Dark attacks need to be uneffective/not very effective/ super effective against other types. They have the same weaknesses and resistances, and if GF changes the Physical/Special thing, they will basically be the same type.

-;179;
 
I think poison should be super effective to fighting. It makes sense and would make poison more usable. Fighting type moves are already not effective on poison types.
 
Ice should resist Dragon, for the sake of more ice resistances and dragon attack weaknesses.
 
Iveechan said:
-Dragon gets a physical weakness to steel. Hey, dragon slayers, kinda makes sense, and steel only has two strengths anyway.

Yeah but most lore about dragons being killed by knights, is that the scales the dragons have on them is so strong nothing can break through it- save a weak spot on their belly.

And dragons in some things were killed by arrows, but I don't see anyone saying Dragon Types should be weak to grass/flying :/

Anyways I'm just wondering how Dragons are weak to ice O_o I can understand being weak to eachother- but ice? eh.

I still didn't under stand the grass weak against poison thing though.

Well how do you kill weeds? Poison them :/ all plants die from poison, even 'weed killer' can kill grass unless it's specific and what not. O_o hell I've seen weedkiller kill things other than grass.

<_< like bugs and stuff. Except roaches. Roaches never die.

Personally the one weakness/resistance I came up with, that hasn't been poked at by anyone else, is Ground. Ground is resistant to poison, right? And super efective against it- ah but, in reality ground can become tainted, and etc. Best example I can give would be from radiation. But that's not poisoning like poison types. But still, poison can leach into the ground so how come ground types are resistant? :/ I can understand why rock is, and steel to an extent... but not ground.

And on the other side of the coin- why is poison weak to ground?

Ice should resist Dragon, for the sake of more ice resistances and dragon attack weaknesses

And Grass, Ice should resist grass type attacks too.
 
happy

HiroKazuma said:
Don't you guys think that some types should be weak against others
Water should be super effective against Steel.
Poison should be super effective against Normal.
Then again, it would throw off the whole attack chart.
no i dont that would be silly
 
◘Ins0mnIac◘ said:
I would like to see Poison become stong against Water. Water poisoning anyone?

It could also work the other way. Water could be strong against poison because it washes the poison away.
 
We may actually see some of these changes, people. Remember the rumor that nintendo might be tweaking the type chart? If the starters do end up being of that different triangle, they would at least take away dark's immunity to psychic, and leave it "not very efffective." As for the psychic not affecting poison types, the psychic types could use their powers to cause the poison pokemon's attack/poison to course through their own body.
 
Last edited:
If the starters do end up being of that different triangle, they would at least take away dark's immunity to psychic, and leave it "not very efffective."

That's like saying because Ash's pikachu can shock the hell out of ground types, ground should be weak to electric :/ I don't see why Dark should drop the complete resistence to psychic type attacks- seeing as Ground is purely resistant to electric and Ghost types are not hit by Normal and Fighting type moves unless forsight is used. Dark types are just utterly immune to psychic attacks. Though would think it'd work on hypnosis too .. anyways moving on-

how would this new triangle cause the dark type to be changed to 'not very effective' over 'it just plain won't work on the type'. I mean it's not like you're gonna choose the psychic, and then be all OMG PSYCHIC POKEMON USE CONFUSION ON THAT DARK TYPE :O

>_> I mean, come on, I don't beat fire types with grass type moves. I beat them with ground. So I don't beat dark types with psychics. I use fighting :/ so really .. I don't understand why you want dark types immunity to psychic changed.
 
Yami Ryu said:
That's like saying because Ash's pikachu can shock the hell out of ground types, ground should be weak to electric :/ I don't see why Dark should drop the complete resistence to psychic type attacks- seeing as Ground is purely resistant to electric and Ghost types are not hit by Normal and Fighting type moves unless forsight is used. Dark types are just utterly immune to psychic attacks. Though would think it'd work on hypnosis too .. anyways moving on-

how would this new triangle cause the dark type to be changed to 'not very effective' over 'it just plain won't work on the type'. I mean it's not like you're gonna choose the psychic, and then be all OMG PSYCHIC POKEMON USE CONFUSION ON THAT DARK TYPE :O

>_> I mean, come on, I don't beat fire types with grass type moves. I beat them with ground. So I don't beat dark types with psychics. I use fighting :/ so really .. I don't understand why you want dark types immunity to psychic changed.

I am not saying that I want dark to lose its psychic immunity. The reason I think it will happen is because nintendo wants to keep the whole good-against-one-starter-bad-against-the-other-starter thing going. Plus, you have to remember that you are not the only person playing pokemon. There will be newbies to the game, and they wouldn't anticipate dark's immunity to psychic.
 
starterlover1 said:
We may actually see some of these changes, people. Remember the rumor that nintendo might be tweaking the type chart? If the starters do end up being of that different triangle, they would at least take away dark's immunity to psychic, and leave it "not very efffective." As for the psychic not affecting poison types, the psychic types could use their powers to cause the poison pokemon's attack/poison to course through their own body.

Rumor, not official confirmation of it being a possibility. I doubt they'd change the type chart at this point in the series.
 
There will be newbies to the game, and they wouldn't anticipate dark's immunity to psychic.

:/ I bet they haven't apriciated Ghost's resistence either, but Ghost type hasn't been changed, so I seriously, and heavily doubt it'd be changed because of newbies whining. I can understand why they made Dark and Steel types- because there were people abusing Mewtwo and the like. And Psychic was one type that was way overpowered in RBY era.

The reason I think it will happen is because nintendo wants to keep the whole good-against-one-starter-bad-against-the-other-starter thing going.

Um, even if the starters are Psychic/Dark/Fighting... it'd still be the same if Dark type stays uterly immune to Psychic.

Psychic > Fighting.
Fighting > Dark.
Dark > Psychic.

And back to the newbie thing. So what if they're new? I was once too. And I didn't complain about not knowing what was what- also I had the sense to buy a guide so I learned quickly what was good against what, and what wasn't.

I'm hoping they don't tweak with Dark type, because why waste space for one small, and seriously stupid change, when they can use the space for something else- because think about it. It'd be like using water against grass. Even in a last ditch effort, ten to one, that pokemon is going to survive to whoop your butt. It's why you teach a pokemon atleast one move that's effective against the type it's weak too. Or a normal type move or something.
 
The type weaknesse's are perfect the way they are any additions would completly change it.

-Judai
 
water should be immune to electric, cause water is NOT an conductor, only minerals wich are dissolved in the water conduct.
 
milotic111 said:
water should be immune to electric, cause water is NOT an conductor, only minerals wich are dissolved in the water conduct.

If they did that, it would screw over the game too much. Also, it's strong against water because if you're in a pond or lake and it gets hit by lightning, you'll be shocked by the lightning and die.
 
Shinin said:
If they did that, it would screw over the game too much. Also, it's strong against water because if you're in a pond or lake and it gets hit by lightning, you'll be shocked by the lightning and die.

yeach but it's not the WATER but the minerals IN the water wich conduct the lightning and kill you.
 
milotic111 said:
yeach but it's not the WATER but the minerals IN the water wich conduct the lightning and kill you.

The minerals are still in the water. Also, ever heard of the phrase "water and electricity don't mix?" You may have heard it when learning about electrical safety at age 6 or 7.
 
poison should be super effective against steel (acids vs metals)

also water should be super effective against electric because water can shortage out things

and electric being super effective to steel because metal does conduct electricity
like if you're on your roof and you have a metal chimney and you're holding on to it and thunder stricks

chances are you will be struck because of the metal

or at least shocked
 
Back
Top