• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Why?

Status
Not open for further replies.
I was not talking about the game, but about the gen, the Pokemon. As I said before I think that this is the best game but with the worst Pokemon, and to talk about it I can only base my opinion in the Pokemon because I haven't played the game.

Then why state your opinion in the first place if I stated in the first post "they never even played the game yet". You only have biased opinions only based on the pokemon, which is not a good assumption. I didn't favor the pokemon at first but, they've grown on me. You are really incapable of reading. Really, re-read my first post (the very first one).
 
Now if this is in the wrong forum please move it.

Well, as you all know, the newest installment of Pokemon has come to Japan. People, who probably never played it, are saying it's the worst gen. Why? And give me more reasons then simply the "horrid" evo's. Do you know the story line? Have you played it? If these answers are no, then why is Diamond and Pearl so bad? I just find it ridiculous that people are having preconcieved notions of a game they never played yet.

This is pretty much exactly what I think. You cannot judge a game with pictures and a whole site based on it, you have to play the game to form your own opinion. I think D/P is a great game (having had actually play it) and I don't see why people complain about the pre-evos and evos. Here is the point. Pre-evos give good moves to the older Pokemon. Like how Subomii can learn Water Sport. And evolutions, I cannot believe people actually complain about them. They are made to make an older Pokemon that wasn't so good better. It does not mean they are running out of ideas. And the plot thing, it's better than you think. I don't think this plot is dull and boring, but maybe thats because I've played the game. I dunno.

No, seriously. I loathe people who say a game sucks without playing it.
 
How can anyone call this the worst Pokemon game ever???
It has EVERYTHING that R/B had and more, primarily Wi-Fi battling and trading. Not to mention the underground secret bases, a battle tower with buyable prizes, contests, loads of pokemon to collect, more box storage than any game to date other than Pokemon box R/S, all of the extra abilities from emerald (quick hatching with flame body/magma armour, everstone for better chance of getting the same nature as a parent, ect.), New moves and pokes, now including all of the new ones you have almost 500 different pokes to train and collect.
Not to mention the secret base decorating, capture the flag, and digging that you can do underground.

And when you get bored you can do something else, there is no downside to these games, If you don't like a new poke, ignore it. Don't like a new evo? don't evolve into it. Don't like a new baby, don't breed with the incense. Easy as that.
 
And when have I talked about the game? I said that the game was going to be the best for what I've seen, nothing else. The rest of the time I was talking about the Pokemon, and I wasn't basing my opinion of the game in them. In fact, I said that I was going to enjoy the game because I was not going to use the new Pokemon.
 
The new game rocks and the new evo's rock, Weavile, Rozureido, Manmuu, Erureido, Glion, Glacia, Leafia, Muumajii, Megayanma, Jibacoil. Plus all the other cool new ones, Diaruga, Rioru, Sukatanku, Floatsel, Korinku line, Mukkuhawk, Enpureto, Dotaitos. D/P RULES!
 
And when have I talked about the game? I said that the game was going to be the best for what I've seen, nothing else. The rest of the time I was talking about the Pokemon, and I wasn't basing my opinion of the game in them. In fact, I said that I was going to enjoy the game because I was not going to use the new Pokemon.

Pretty hard to do since all you see are new pokemon in the beggining of the game.
 
Come up with a deep and intense storyline that doesn't screws up the typical Pokémon gameplay.

Pokémon Colosseum and XD diverted from the typical cartridge storyline. Most of the fanbase condemned them as awful games. Precisely because the storyline limited you to catch a set of Pokémon and not much else on your own.

Tell me... why divert from the basic plotline if that makes the fans angry? I think Colosseum/XD are awesome games because they diverted from the typical stuff. Most dull fans don't...

Plus, it's not as if they haven't improved either. The base storyline is the same, but the "in-between" has improved drastically. From dragged-on takeovers and whiney fools to enviromentalists that reached their ambitions and twisted wrongdoers that want to remake the Universe at their will. Plus, since RSE, the main character has a story of his/her own separated from the opposite gender character, unlike RBY/FRLG or GSC. Not to mention the first 5 didn't even have a girl...

Base storylines are seen all the time anyway. Mario (BOWSER KIDNAPPED PEACH! GO BEAT HIM!), Final Fantasy (AN EVIL BEING IS LOOKING FOR POWER TO CONTROL EVERYTHING! WE MUST STOP IT!), Zelda (Read Final Fantasy, basically...), Metroid (CHAOS IN SOME PLANET/STATION! I HIRE YOU TO SAVE US!), and so on. Albeit better realized and deeper than Pokémon, the base concept is still the same all the time. As is in Pokémon... :)



Oh the irony...

Falkner is a most convinced guy devoted to the Type he trains. Roxanne is a curious girl willing to learn more. MUCH better than generic "I'M STRONG I'LL CRUSH YOU WITH MY ROCK-HARD POWER!"

Bugsy is a most wise kid with thorough knowledge of Bug Pokémon. Brawly is dull, but at least uses surfer jargon. MUCH better than generic "I'M STRONG I'LL CRUSH YOU WITH MY WATER OFFENSIVE!"

Whitney is an easygoing and chipper girl that kicks serious posterior and always shows what she feels. Wattson is a very cheerful oldie with outstanding experience. MUCH better than generic "I SHOCKED ENEMIES WITH ELECTRICITY AS I'LL DO WITH YOU!"

Morty is a deep thinker with an extrasensorial ability. Flannery is an immature yet fiery beginner unsure of what to do or how to act, and yet she can put up a heck of a fight. No Erika bashing because she was one of FEW Kanto Leaders that ACTUALLY had a personality...

Chuck is a generic macho fighter, but at least he was the ONLY boastful guy in Johto, and completely justified. Norman is a most calm man with a huge passion for Pokémon. MUCH better than generic "I'LL DEFEAT YOU WITH MY NINJA AND POISON TRADITION!"

Jasmine is a shy and cute girl that is so strong deep within she's one of the hardest opponents ever. Winona is a graceful dancer in touch with Pokémon and able to use such ability in battles. No Sabrina bashing because she was one of FEW Kanto Leaders that ACTUALLY had a personality...

Pryce is a cold, yet awfully fit oldie that trains avidly every day. Tate & Liza are psychic twins that can talk with each other and combine attacks magistrally. MUCH better than generic "I'M STRONG I'LL BURN YOU WITH FIRE!" Though Blaine wasn't THAT bad. He at least put your Pokémon knowledge to test...

Clair is a determined girl that appreciates efforts and deeds beyond Pokémon battling. Wallace/Juan are flamboyant snobs with sophiticated jargon and unmatched grace in the battlefield. MUCH better than "I'LL BEAT YOU THIS TIME AND SAVE MY EBIL ORGANIZATION!" Giovanni was awesome in RBY, but he was killed in FR/LG. In the first, it showed he at least had hidden and most deep motives to do what Team Rocket did...

What were you saying again? :)



Then why play videogames at all? Or better yet, wait for the 50th Generation of Consoles so you can see real-life cities and scenarios. It's like comparing an elephant with an ant. Of course the places in Pokémon won't match the real life landscapes. Neither in Pokémon, nor ANY videogame. No matter how advanced. Having a realistic metropolis would take TOO MUCH memory. And even then, it'd be just scenery while accesible areas would be minimal...

Why waste memory in scenery when you can use it in important stuff? It's not as if the cities haven't improved either. It's gone from generic buildings assorted in Kanto, to cities with nifty places in Johto, to cities mixed with nature in Hoenn. Most wonderful improvements.

The scenery, no matter how simplistic, is also something to look forward to in a Pokémon game. I'd rather have the improvements we've had in that regard than going though my fourth Kanto...



There are so many aspects in Pokémon they should be enjoyed in unison, and not just shaft EVERYTHING for one of them. I agree that the point of the game are the Pokémon, but neglecting the characters, scenery AND storyline is very, very dull indeed. Might as well resort to NetBattle and crap for pure Pokémon battles without so-called "useless add-ons" in-between... =/

Oh well. I, for one, think the 4th Generation is possibly the best Generation yet. So many awesome ideas were materialized into Pokémon, and the new Pokémon related to old ones, save a few mishaps, are quite cool and much useful altogether. The storyline and the lore sounds soo awesome as well. The Gym Leaders and other characters look awesome, and Sinnoh is probably the biggest Region ever! Not to say it looks to be awfully variated as a whole.

I haven't played the game yet, but overall, it looks like GSC with the technology to pull all those nifty features off AND without the design flaws that made GSC a failure. What makes that of D/P? Possibly the best Pokémon games yet...

I don't need to reserve judgment, for I know Pokémon well enough to say this Generation is a milestone in the franchise. Yet, it's sad some are bashing this and saying it's teh WORST when they haven't even experienced it at all... or aren't enough in touch with the concept to understand it thoroughly...

Quoted for the truth.

Now I gotta disagree with the surge thing. He's just arrogant cause he was in the army and deems you weak cause of your size. And koga cares for his daughter and is an awsome medecine man. I think this guy only said Kanto leaders had personality cause the Fame Checker made it so much easier to read into their personalities. Oh and blaines a crazy old coot who loves riddles
 
O.o, didn't have time to veiw the whole topic. But I don't think this is the worst game, far from it. I must say it's the most unoriginal Gen. There were just too much Evos for previous Gens and baby Poke'mon. Sure, I wouldn't mind them if they added NEW Poke'mon, as in fully original Poke'mon. They barely did that...
 
Now I gotta disagree with the surge thing. He's just arrogant cause he was in the army and deems you weak cause of your size. And koga cares for his daughter and is an awsome medecine man. I think this guy only said Kanto leaders had personality cause the Fame Checker made it so much easier to read into their personalities. Oh and blaines a crazy old coot who loves riddles
Sadly, Surge doesn't sounds as much of an army man as he should. I'd rather see him slightly stereotyped than see him as the one-dimensional character he is. Something like, "Gimme 1000 squats and then we'll battle!" or military jargon like "Ten-hut!" or crap. Something that's not generic boastful dialogue...

As for Koga... I understand pride and such. But a ninja should be silent. He can still be proud, but he should be more silent and not scream out loud. I'm against stereotypes, but sometimes, stereotypes can be better than a blankety character.

And yes. Fame Checker improved the Kanto Leaders tenfold. I just based judgment after their game dialogue. I like all Gym Leaders myself. It just baffled me to have someone diss all others without any backup...

All other Gym Leaders should get Fame Checker too... but Game Freak looves to discard the awesome features. Trainer's Eyes/Match Call, Fame Checker, Gym Leader rematches... all scrapped from D/P... :(
 
All other Gym Leaders should get Fame Checker too... but Game Freak looves to discard the awesome features. Trainer's Eyes/Match Call, Fame Checker, Gym Leader rematches... all scrapped from D/P... :(

Don't be too sure, those might be included in the third-release game.

Anyway, my opinion? When I first saw most of the new evolutions, I was somewhat surprized because they had given evolutions to several pokémon that I thought wouldn't receive one (Tanglea and Lickitung being two of them.)

While I'm not particularly happy about the number of total (too few) and the amount of legendaries and pokémon related to older ones (they should have made more pokémon that aren't related.) I've come to accept them as pokémon and anxoiusly look forward to use them when the games come to north amercia.

No, I meant the Victreebel and Flareon comment

Flareon and Victreebel have high attack stats, but their physical movepools have become so horribly limited that they're barely useable.
 
I agree people complain about the new pokemon , some of them are ugly but why not just avoid them then.

They probably do, but the fact is that these are forums and people are free to voice their opinions at will. Deal with it.
 
It might be the overdose of legendaries. Or the so called "uncreativeness" of the Pokemon. I love 4th gen, though.
 
O.o, didn't have time to veiw the whole topic. But I don't think this is the worst game, far from it. I must say it's the most unoriginal Gen. There were just too much Evos for previous Gens and baby Poke'mon. Sure, I wouldn't mind them if they added NEW Poke'mon, as in fully original Poke'mon. They barely did that...

Hmm :/ Johto had a large amount of evo's+ pre evo's and no one's complaining but, when a new generation comes (like this) they all hate it simply because of the "unoriginality" of the evo's and pre-evo's.

While I'm not particularly happy about the number of total (too few)

o.0 Johto only had 100 new pokemon, while this only had 114. So, without the Legends and future non-available pokemon Johto only has 85 while Sinnoh has 91... JOHTO HAD THE LEAST AMOUNT!!! STOP WHINING
 
This one actually had 107 I think. And with all the legends and evos trhat wernt in the regional dex, it does turn out to be small. But I dont hate it for that.

That will probably mean more ubers for people to use >_>, but I don't mind

Atleast on nintendo tourneys theyed have more original teams then just Mewtwo,Groudon,Kyogre,Blissy,Snorlax,Rayquasa,Ho oh, Lugia, Deoxys. I practically summed up all the pokemoon that participate in these tourneys.
 
o.0 Johto only had 100 new pokemon, while this only had 114. So, without the Legends and future non-available pokemon Johto only has 85 while Sinnoh has 91... JOHTO HAD THE LEAST AMOUNT!!! STOP WHINING

I never said I was whining... >_>

Christ on a crutch...
 
- Thirteen legends! I say THIRTEEN. What's legend about them actually? Legends has to have a patron in these games, like Dialga/Palkia/Giradina are similiar to Groudon/Kyogre/Rayquaza. These were great. In every gen there was a miniüber legend wich was half psychic (except for mew ofcourse) and half other type. (Mew/Celebi/Jirachi) There wasn't anything like it in de 4th. Manaphy? no. Sheimi? no. Too bad.
The trio sucks too, no additional types, wth? Why would you keep them apart at all?
Kureseira and Darkrai were a bit unneeded too, but their idea makes it ok. Hiidoran and Regigigas were terribly unneeded therefore.
- Too much unneeded evolutions!
like Jibacoil. Magneton was a triple Magemite, so why a Ufo now? The idea is fun, but they better could make it for a new one. And Togekiss... etc. etc.
And Elekible and Buurburn are Pokémon nobody asked for. Now ok, they aren't that bad, but still. (Donkrow and Muumage are way better.)
- No real fire types
now this isn't really a reason, but it's a real loss to not to catch a non-legend firePokémon (from this gen).

There are many pluses ofcourse, mostly because they're so freakin' alike to GSC.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top