• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Why?

Status
Not open for further replies.
I simply hate most, if not all, of the new Pokémon. Especially Aruseus.

Oh, and the fact that D/P have almost the exact same storyline as the past generations. Three times was enough. I don't to hear the same generic storyline over and over again.

I suppose this makes me " a EbIl PoEkMuN h8TeR!1111 lol" =/
Yes cause an evil organization trying to steal pokemon from the first gen to the evil organization trying to rebuild itself in the second gen to two maniacs trying to expand the land and sea and some loser trying to be a god is all the same.......

Small detail? The games called \"Pokemon\" if the pokemon are crappy thats more than a small detail, the story lines no fun with crappy pokemon.

Yes and those new evos you hate so much arent even counted in the regional dex so you wont have to battle them during the main plot. And those guys make up about 3% of the pokemon and there are others to play as. No one is forcing you to use togekiss or mojanbo. And yes the game is called "Pokemon" not "Lets all force our Pokemon to evolve" so that doesnt mean that you have to evolve them. Why do you think GF made it so complicated for some of them, incase yopu hated them then dont use them.

Yes cause 10 new evos that are crappy out of 107 new pokemon is really something to worry about especially since a lot of these guys dont even show up til the main plot is done

You know have any of you who are saying it sucks actually played the game or are you all just a bunch of a-holes who just hate it cause of the things youve seen so far? Have any of you tried its new features? Have any of you battled on Wi-Fi? The only people who can truely say it sucks are the people who played it and actually hated it.(I mean wanted to kill themselves for buying the game not those evos are annoying)

What I love is the people who say there not gonna buy the game cause of the pokemon in it. Well guess what people there are about 400 other pokemon to use besides those guys so use them and enjpy the game instead of complaining all the time.
 
Last edited:
Now if this is in the wrong forum please move it.

Well, as you all know, the newest installment of Pokemon has come to Japan. People, who probably never played it, are saying it's the worst gen. Why? And give me more reasons then simply the "horrid" evo's. Do you know the story line? Have you played it? If these answers are no, then why is Diamond and Pearl so bad? I just find it ridiculous that people are having preconcieved notions of a game they never played yet.

THANK YOU! :D

I've been waiting for something like this. A friend of mine hates the games purely because he thinks the majority of the Pokémon are revolting. Simply not true.
 
Thats so stupid hating a gen just cause of the pokemon.

I loved the second generation pokemon but I hated the gameplay cause of the weak *ss trainers. Thats why second gen isnt my favorite
 
i dont see whats wrong with Diamond and Pearl
the evolutions are fine with me
 
People are actually playing Pokemon for the storyline?

...

I know, Funny aint it? If it was just all badges I'd be fine cause I couldnt care less about whether or not tht crazy a-hole became a god or not as long as I can batte.
 
I would guess that they don't like the look of the new poke's. Or mabey they like old school better.
 
Can't they just train the old Pokemon if they hate the new ones. A lot of the old Pokemon learn some really cool attacks and most of the old Pokemon can be gotten in Paealr and Diamond. To be honest if you just had Pearl and Diamond you can get almost all of them except for beginners, Pokemon requiring GBA connected eg. getting a Pokemon holding a new item to evolve like Magby and Elekid and old legendaries. Why on earth are people complaining. I hated the new Pokemon at first. The reason I bought Pearl was because the old Pokemon learned some really Cool attacks. It's just when I got it and started playing I grew to like the new ones that's all.

It's not like the new Pokemon are the only things in the game. You can ditch your beginner when the old Pokemon do start appearing. You are not forced to use your beginner. It's not like the game says you have to train it.

Pearl and Diamond at least has the majority of the old Pokemon on Release. When Ruby and Sapphire were released alot of the old Pokemon were not capable of getting. There's a big difference here.
 
Thats so stupid hating a gen just cause of the pokemon.

I agree, I actually find the idea of 'hating' a group of pixels depicting a fictional creature a bit umm... 'silly' ;) I always felt that feelings such of those were better aimed at... real life?

Its not as if the new pokemon completely replace the old is it. There is now just a whole lot more variety in the pokemon you can choose.

Also people seem to forget the fact that D/P offers so much more than a bunch of new pokemon.
 
I agree, I actually find the idea of 'hating' a group of pixels depicting a fictional creature a bit umm... 'silly' ;) I always felt that feelings such of those were better aimed at... real life?

Its not as if the new pokemon completely replace the old is it. There is now just a whole lot more variety in the pokemon you can choose.

Also people seem to forget the fact that D/P offers so much more than a bunch of new pokemon.

Then loving a group of pixels and defending it is also silly? Come on.

Thats so stupid hating a gen just cause of the pokemon.

And what else is a new gen appart from the Pokemon? The storyline? Recycled one. The gims? The only good leaders were the Kanto ones (they had personality) The towns and cities? I prefer London and Paris thank you. I don't see any sense at all in that affirmation.
 
Then loving a group of pixels and defending it is also silly? Come on.

Yes.
I'd assume that when most people use the words hate/love they mean dislike/like. (although some fans of particular pokemon might want to argue otherwise :p).
I myself am 'guilty', as many are, of mixing the meanings of such words. I was trying to illustrate that fact. How many times do people say the hate a certain food or love a song. When at the same time use the same words to describe their feelings for a bad person, an unethical act, a family member or someone they admire?
My comment was more a general one, not directed at a specific. It was just my response to a number of comments I've read recently across the internet (and not just about Pokemon - but in this case I was focusing on that).

I do think that there is more to D/P then the new pokemon, they have changed the attacks, therefore breathing life into a system which (some) would come to criticise as stale.
The story line is not just a re-use of the old. It might seem to be at first but there are differences.
 
And what else is a new gen appart from the Pokemon? The storyline? Recycled one. The gims? The only good leaders were the Kanto ones (they had personality) The towns and cities? I prefer London and Paris thank you. I don't see any sense at all in that affirmation.

I guess you're not that much of a Pokemon Fan are you? Saying all that the games have to offer is the Pokemon is Ignorant. First I would like to say the game has online capabilities, which none have had or gotten before. One of the biggest region's I've seen in a while. The story line isn't recycled either. The first game, an evil organization is trying to take all the pokemon and make them servants. The second game, same team trying to get back on it's feet once more. The third, two radical enviromentalist's are trying to unbalance the world with the titans, Kyogre of Groudon. The Fourth.... I can't really say much since it hasen't been released yet. About the towns, don't expect them to be unoriginal putting real cities like Paris or London. Pokemon only play a small role in the unvieling of a next generation of pokemon. How could pixels have any personality? Gym Leaders are typically the same, meet, battle, badge, leave. You're obviously a 1998 fanboy/girl.
 
Now if this is in the wrong forum please move it.
Well, as you all know, the newest installment of Pokemon has come to Japan. People, who probably never played it, are saying it's the worst gen. Why? And give me more reasons then simply the "horrid" evo's. Do you know the story line? Have you played it? If these answers are no, then why is Diamond and Pearl so bad? I just find it ridiculous that people are having preconcieved notions of a game they never played yet.

Because a lot of the posters of this forum are idiots that couldn't make a complete sentence to save their life. My only problem with this gen is the killing of Victreebel and Flareon, and that's not even that big of a deal.
 
Because a lot of the posters of this forum are idiots that couldn't make a complete sentence to save their life. My only problem with this gen is the killing of Victreebel and Flareon, and that's not even that big of a deal.

Hmm? What do you mean by that?
 
Hmm? What do you mean by that?

Hes saying that they judge something they havent even tried yet, and thats true. Like I said the only people who can actually say they hate this game is the person that has actually played through the whole thing
 
Hes saying that they judge something they havent even tried yet, and thats true. Like I said the only people who can actually say they hate this game is the person that has actually played through the whole thing

No, I meant the Victreebel and Flareon comment.
 
I guess you're not that much of a Pokemon Fan are you? Saying all that the games have to offer is the Pokemon is Ignorant. First I would like to say the game has online capabilities, which none have had or gotten before. One of the biggest region's I've seen in a while. The story line isn't recycled either. The first game, an evil organization is trying to take all the pokemon and make them servants. The second game, same team trying to get back on it's feet once more. The third, two radical enviromentalist's are trying to unbalance the world with the titans, Kyogre of Groudon. The Fourth.... I can't really say much since it hasen't been released yet. About the towns, don't expect them to be unoriginal putting real cities like Paris or London. Pokemon only play a small role in the unvieling of a next generation of pokemon. How could pixels have any personality? Gym Leaders are typically the same, meet, battle, badge, leave. You're obviously a 1998 fanboy/girl.

I was not talking about the game, but about the gen, the Pokemon. As I said before I think that this is the best game but with the worst Pokemon, and to talk about it I can only base my opinion in the Pokemon because I haven't played the game.
 
The storyline? Recycled one.
Come up with a deep and intense storyline that doesn't screws up the typical Pokémon gameplay.

Pokémon Colosseum and XD diverted from the typical cartridge storyline. Most of the fanbase condemned them as awful games. Precisely because the storyline limited you to catch a set of Pokémon and not much else on your own.

Tell me... why divert from the basic plotline if that makes the fans angry? I think Colosseum/XD are awesome games because they diverted from the typical stuff. Most dull fans don't...

Plus, it's not as if they haven't improved either. The base storyline is the same, but the "in-between" has improved drastically. From dragged-on takeovers and whiney fools to enviromentalists that reached their ambitions and twisted wrongdoers that want to remake the Universe at their will. Plus, since RSE, the main character has a story of his/her own separated from the opposite gender character, unlike RBY/FRLG or GSC. Not to mention the first 5 didn't even have a girl...

Base storylines are seen all the time anyway. Mario (BOWSER KIDNAPPED PEACH! GO BEAT HIM!), Final Fantasy (AN EVIL BEING IS LOOKING FOR POWER TO CONTROL EVERYTHING! WE MUST STOP IT!), Zelda (Read Final Fantasy, basically...), Metroid (CHAOS IN SOME PLANET/STATION! I HIRE YOU TO SAVE US!), and so on. Albeit better realized and deeper than Pokémon, the base concept is still the same all the time. As is in Pokémon... :)


The gyms? The only good leaders were the Kanto ones (they had personality)
Oh the irony...

Falkner is a most convinced guy devoted to the Type he trains. Roxanne is a curious girl willing to learn more. MUCH better than generic "I'M STRONG I'LL CRUSH YOU WITH MY ROCK-HARD POWER!"

Bugsy is a most wise kid with thorough knowledge of Bug Pokémon. Brawly is dull, but at least uses surfer jargon. MUCH better than generic "I'M STRONG I'LL CRUSH YOU WITH MY WATER OFFENSIVE!"

Whitney is an easygoing and chipper girl that kicks serious posterior and always shows what she feels. Wattson is a very cheerful oldie with outstanding experience. MUCH better than generic "I SHOCKED ENEMIES WITH ELECTRICITY AS I'LL DO WITH YOU!"

Morty is a deep thinker with an extrasensorial ability. Flannery is an immature yet fiery beginner unsure of what to do or how to act, and yet she can put up a heck of a fight. No Erika bashing because she was one of FEW Kanto Leaders that ACTUALLY had a personality...

Chuck is a generic macho fighter, but at least he was the ONLY boastful guy in Johto, and completely justified. Norman is a most calm man with a huge passion for Pokémon. MUCH better than generic "I'LL DEFEAT YOU WITH MY NINJA AND POISON TRADITION!"

Jasmine is a shy and cute girl that is so strong deep within she's one of the hardest opponents ever. Winona is a graceful dancer in touch with Pokémon and able to use such ability in battles. No Sabrina bashing because she was one of FEW Kanto Leaders that ACTUALLY had a personality...

Pryce is a cold, yet awfully fit oldie that trains avidly every day. Tate & Liza are psychic twins that can talk with each other and combine attacks magistrally. MUCH better than generic "I'M STRONG I'LL BURN YOU WITH FIRE!" Though Blaine wasn't THAT bad. He at least put your Pokémon knowledge to test...

Clair is a determined girl that appreciates efforts and deeds beyond Pokémon battling. Wallace/Juan are flamboyant snobs with sophiticated jargon and unmatched grace in the battlefield. MUCH better than "I'LL BEAT YOU THIS TIME AND SAVE MY EBIL ORGANIZATION!" Giovanni was awesome in RBY, but he was killed in FR/LG. In the first, it showed he at least had hidden and most deep motives to do what Team Rocket did...

What were you saying again? :)


The towns and cities? I prefer London and Paris thank you.
Then why play videogames at all? Or better yet, wait for the 50th Generation of Consoles so you can see real-life cities and scenarios. It's like comparing an elephant with an ant. Of course the places in Pokémon won't match the real life landscapes. Neither in Pokémon, nor ANY videogame. No matter how advanced. Having a realistic metropolis would take TOO MUCH memory. And even then, it'd be just scenery while accesible areas would be minimal...

Why waste memory in scenery when you can use it in important stuff? It's not as if the cities haven't improved either. It's gone from generic buildings assorted in Kanto, to cities with nifty places in Johto, to cities mixed with nature in Hoenn. Most wonderful improvements.

The scenery, no matter how simplistic, is also something to look forward to in a Pokémon game. I'd rather have the improvements we've had in that regard than going though my fourth Kanto...


I don't see any sense at all in that affirmation.
There are so many aspects in Pokémon they should be enjoyed in unison, and not just shaft EVERYTHING for one of them. I agree that the point of the game are the Pokémon, but neglecting the characters, scenery AND storyline is very, very dull indeed. Might as well resort to NetBattle and crap for pure Pokémon battles without so-called "useless add-ons" in-between... =/

Oh well. I, for one, think the 4th Generation is possibly the best Generation yet. So many awesome ideas were materialized into Pokémon, and the new Pokémon related to old ones, save a few mishaps, are quite cool and much useful altogether. The storyline and the lore sounds soo awesome as well. The Gym Leaders and other characters look awesome, and Sinnoh is probably the biggest Region ever! Not to say it looks to be awfully variated as a whole.

I haven't played the game yet, but overall, it looks like GSC with the technology to pull all those nifty features off AND without the design flaws that made GSC a failure. What makes that of D/P? Possibly the best Pokémon games yet...

I don't need to reserve judgment, for I know Pokémon well enough to say this Generation is a milestone in the franchise. Yet, it's sad some are bashing this and saying it's teh WORST when they haven't even experienced it at all... or aren't enough in touch with the concept to understand it thoroughly...
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top