• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

WikiLeaks

I'm not sure how this applies.

Considering the Taliban have this thing where they hate everyone whose not in the Taliban, and elected officials have this thing where they can't be in the Taliban. I don't see how anyone was promised anonymity in this situation. (Not trying to be smart, just didn't understand)
 
I'm not sure how this applies.

Considering the Taliban have this thing where they hate everyone whose not in the Taliban, and elected officials have this thing where they can't be in the Taliban. I don't see how anyone was promised anonymity in this situation. (Not trying to be smart, just didn't understand)

Because the documents leaked go beyond Taliban fighters. You have informants who come in after getting fed up with the Taliban and who have given the U.S. information to stop them. Their names were released in some of the documents. One of the problems with the documents ( And there are alot of problems with the release of them ) is that they list names, lots of names, and that endangers lives.
 
It's really interesting to see how our media cover the WikiLeaks issue differently. In Germany they mostly focussed on American diplomats' statements about various European politicians.
Every time you turned on the radio, parts of the documents calling our foreign minister "aggressive" or whatsoever were quoted. Everyone made a big fuss about it which I found just ridiculous.
(Some characterisation even were quite accurate)

As if the German people wouldn't talk behind their representatives' backs and call them names :P
 
I believe it's horrible, and the website should be taken destroyed any way possible, and Assange needs to spend the rest of his life either in jail or facing the death penalty. The man put hundreds of millions of lives at risk, with his acts, and has shown little if any humanity for the human lives he has put at risk. The man is a danger to the world and should be treated as such.

hahahaha oh wow

on topic, WikiLeaks is all that is right with the internet
 
hahahaha oh wow

on topic, WikiLeaks is all that is right with the internet

Wikileaks released a list of some of the most vital sites in the world, including a key place that provides insulin for blood banks. These sites have relatively low security and are a perfect target for terrorism. If say the insulin site was bombed, it would really put hundreds of millions of lives in danger as a fight to get the remaining stockpiles ensues. But continue with your ignorance at the threat Wikileaks and Assange poses to world security.
 
Wikileaks released a list of some of the most vital sites in the world, including a key place that provides insulin for blood banks. These sites have relatively low security and are a perfect target for terrorism. If say the insulin site was bombed, it would really put hundreds of millions of lives in danger as a fight to get the remaining stockpiles ensues. But continue with your ignorance at the threat Wikileaks and Assange poses to world security.

For the love of everything that is sacred, have you still not realized that it doesn't matter? The terrorists could do this, could do that. They could've hijacked countless of planes the past decade and fly them into many more buildings and other important places. Yet they didn't.

I also find it funny that that list is the only thing you seem to attack.
 
Still this information that WikiLeaks provides puts infomation in terrorist's hands. Information in terrorits' hands is dangerous, what im saying is,this site makes it easier for them to choose targets and stuff
 
I also find it funny that that list is the only thing you seem to attack.

You clearly haven't read this page very well, because BigLutz did, in fact, address at least one other dangerous leak. For crying out loud! It was only four posts above yours!

I'm gonna go ahead and quote the post so you can see it:
Because the documents leaked go beyond Taliban fighters. You have informants who come in after getting fed up with the Taliban and who have given the U.S. information to stop them. Their names were released in some of the documents. One of the problems with the documents ( And there are alot of problems with the release of them ) is that they list names, lots of names, and that endangers lives.

BigLutz is right; the names of informants should not be leaked. WikiLeaks is not a group of people fighting for freedom of speech. To say they are fighting government corruption is laughable because they are highly corrupt themselves!
 
For the love of everything that is sacred, have you still not realized that it doesn't matter? The terrorists could do this, could do that. They could've hijacked countless of planes the past decade and fly them into many more buildings and other important places. Yet they didn't.

I also find it funny that that list is the only thing you seem to attack.

Oh there are plenty of things that Wikileaks has done wrong, the list just provides the highest kill ratio. That being said have you ever considered there is a reason why the terrorist havn't attacked these targets? Many of them live in tiny little holes in third world countries, they do not have the resources to search these targets out. Wikileaks has now done all the work for them.
 
While I think Assange sometimes uses the term "freedom of information" in a rather excessive way, and think that he is sometimes a bit irresponsible with qualified documents, I also think there is a great deal of hypocrisy here. Governments and companies are criticizing WikiLeaks for publishing qualified material, while they have been using their power to limit the privacy of the people they are supposed to serve more and more over the years. This is not just about a maverick journalistic website, it is also a protest against governments and companies collecting information about citizens as much as possible, possibly threathening their freedom and privacy. People are fed up with that and Wikileaks is one of those initiatives of concernced citizens who strike back at the powers that be. I believe this is a critical turning point in the way the internet promotes freedom of information. It is something that cannot be put to a stop anymore. The genie is now out of the bottle and no matter how much institutions like the US government want to put it back in, it will be possible to do so. There is always another Wikileaks or Julian Assange waiting to pick up where the persecuted members of this community left off.
 
This alleged rapist is just a megalomaniac who has a anti-American agenda, Why not target China or Russia or Glorious Nation of Iran? I'm tired of fools who think the USA is the source of most/all of the world's woes. But hey, he fights for freedom of information, so whatever Saint Assange and his minions do is acceptable, right?
 
This alleged rapist is just a megalomaniac who has a anti-American agenda, Why not target China or Russia or Glorious Nation of Iran? I'm tired of fools who think the USA is the source of most/all of the world's woes. But hey, he fights for freedom of information, so whatever Saint Assange and his minions do is acceptable, right?

Vermehlo_Steele, you hit the nail on the head! You know, it is hilarious and disturbing how many people were quick to believe what his group released about governments doing such wrong stuff, but as soon as he gets arrested, people assume offhand that the charges are probably trumped up. It's sick.
 
While I don't exactly agree with the government's harsh treatment of the guy who leaked it (he hasn't been convicted yet), I definitely am against what Julian Assange and Wikileaks did. It was disgustingly childish and seems like Julian Assange just liked the idea of feeling like some kind of spy, just to get some attention. I'm not against some of Wikileaks other leaks, such as various examples of violations of human rights by the Chinese government, etc, the leaks related to America's war in Afghanistan contained no hidden "area 51" type conspiracies or stories, it simply was a long list of screw ups, such as the accidental shooting of civilians who appeared to be armed, negative comments made about a country in an email from a politician, etc. These leaks will simply place tension on international relations and further inflame the current situation in Afghanistan. Extremists now have even more fuel to inflame civilians against the UN.

These kind of classified documents are kept classified until the situation in the foreign country stabilizes, just like documents related to the war in Vietnam were released in the years after the end of it. There was no reason to release them other than to draw attention to themselves and jump on the bandwagon of Anti-American attitude common in many countries.

As for the charges of rape brought against just after the leaks, that's obviously a smear campaign from the US just to shut him up, which is a stupid way to handle it since it just gives him more to cry about in interviews. Still, he knew full well the US government wouldn't just sit back and watch him dump a ton of sensitive documents onto the internet, so I feel no sympathy for him since his reasons were stupid and immature.
 
Last edited:
If something is kept secret by the government, there is probably a good reason they did so.
Indeed I agree, although sometimes secrecy is used to cover something naughty.
 
I have to agree with the idea of Wikileaks for the reason of that it is an additional check on government. Yes we have a check and balances system but I like knowing there is a sort of civilian check (for example woodward and bernstein could be considered like this as they took down Nixon's corruption). As for punishment to Julian Assange we have to remember that this is not the first time information was leaked to the public. For example the ship that was sent to resupply Fort Sumner just before the Civil War began was supposed to be kept secret however New York fisherman talked about the strange activities (including boats being chartered and soldiers being put on these boats) and it quickly got to the press. The press were looking for a quick scoop and it quickly became headline news so by the time it got to Fort Sumner the Confederation already knew the ship was going to be there a week in advance allowing them to have fire power in place and when they fired on the ship the Civil War then started. (I got this from a NY Times article from the "Opinionater" column under "Disunion" which has been running recently and focuses on the Civil War).
 
this is not the first time information was leaked to the public. For example the ship that was sent to resupply Fort Sumner just before the Civil War began was supposed to be kept secret however New York fisherman talked about the strange activities (including boats being chartered and soldiers being put on these boats) and it quickly got to the press. The press were looking for a quick scoop and it quickly became headline news so by the time it got to Fort Sumner the Confederation already knew the ship was going to be there a week in advance allowing them to have fire power in place and when they fired on the ship the Civil War then started. (I got this from a NY Times article from the "Opinionater" column under "Disunion" which has been running recently and focuses on the Civil War).

Yes and see how much that screwed up the Union Governments plans, huh? Yes, the leak was good for the victors, but your example just proves how much damage a leak can cause.
 
Back
Top