General_Ridley
Palace Maven Spenser
Honestly, the only way I could see it working is if it's very weighted, and not a simple "move counts as two types so Base 100 power Water/Grass move is base 800 against Rock/Ground before STAB is accounted for". Taking Ice Punch and Ice/Fighting as our example.
Dual type moves would need to be designated primary and secondary types. The primary type would have to account for 75% of the damage, secondary type for 25%. If there is an immunity to one type, there is immunity to the whole move. Otherwise, the type chart applies as is, as does STAB.
Ice Punch. Base Power 75, Ice/Fighting.
Let's take this move in a few ways and look, using randomly chosen pokemon simply for their types.
Against a ghost type, automatic failure due to the fighting immunity.
From a Snorlax, against a Pikachu, the damage would be based on 56.25 base ice damage + 18.75 base fighting damage, resulting in an attack that is effectively base 75 power (normally 75 power).
From Snorlax, against another Snorlax, the damage would be based on 56.25 base ice damage + 18.75 * 2 (37.5) base fighting damage, resulting an an attack that is effectively base 93.5 power (normally 75 power).
From Snorlax, against a Bellossom, the damage would be based on 56.25 x 2 (112.5) base ice damage + 18.75 base fighting damage, resulting in an attack that is effectively base 131.25 power (normally 150 power).
From Snorlax, against a Venusaur, the damage would be based on 56.25 x 2 (112.5) base ice damage + 18.75 * 1/2 (9.375) base fighting damage, resulting in an attack that is effectively base 121.875 power (normally 150 power).
From Beartic, against a Bellossom, the damage would be based on 56.25 * 2 * 1.5 (168.75) base ice damage + 18.75 base fighting damage, resulting in an attack that is effectively base 187.5 power (normally 225 power).
From a hypothetical Ice/Fighting pokemon, against Sawsbuck, the damage would be based on 56.25 * 2 * 1.5 (168.75) base ice damage + 18.75 * 2 * 1.5 (56.25) base fighting damage, resulting in an attack that is effectively base 225 power (normally 225 power).
Assuming, for a moment, a hypothetical Ice/Dragon move at base 100 power (that otherwise would be an ice move), let's look.
From Snorlax against Garchomp - base 75 ice * 4 + base 25 dragon * 2 gives 300 + 50 for 350 base (compared to base 400).
From Grarchomp against Garchomp - base 75 ice * 4 + base 25 dragon * 2 * .15 gives 375 (compared to base 400)
From Kyurem to Garchomp - base 75 ice * 4 * 1.5 + base 25 dragon * 2 * 1.5 gives 525 (compared to base 600)
Taking our corner case of Ludicolo plus a grass/water move against Golem, you have .75 *2 * 2 * 1.5 (4.5) + .25 * 2 * 2 * 1.5 (1.5), granting us a total of x6 damage, just as a water or grass move from Ludicolo already does against Golem, instead of something utterly ridiculous unweighted.
Using that system, dual type moves would stay exactly the same if you had double STAB against a pokemon weak to each component type. They would, if no STAB or super-effective type is involved, be no weaker. In the middle, they are actually weaker and only become as powerful as they are now if there is double STAB and double weakness. Ultimately, it appears that what would happen with this weighting would be ultimately a nerf to the moves changed, and any new moves would be far better if they had been single-type.
Now, increasing base power might compensate for the relative weakness of this weighting, and weighting moves at 50/50 instead of 75/25 might be less nerfy (though I'd hesitate to do it at a straight 50/50 split).
But yes, without some sort of weighting, doing this would be a monumentally stupid idea. What about Ludicolo using hypothetical grass/water move against Golem for x 18 damage (so even a base 20 move would be base 360 in that case) sounds like a good idea? None of it, really.
Dual type moves would need to be designated primary and secondary types. The primary type would have to account for 75% of the damage, secondary type for 25%. If there is an immunity to one type, there is immunity to the whole move. Otherwise, the type chart applies as is, as does STAB.
Ice Punch. Base Power 75, Ice/Fighting.
Let's take this move in a few ways and look, using randomly chosen pokemon simply for their types.
Against a ghost type, automatic failure due to the fighting immunity.
From a Snorlax, against a Pikachu, the damage would be based on 56.25 base ice damage + 18.75 base fighting damage, resulting in an attack that is effectively base 75 power (normally 75 power).
From Snorlax, against another Snorlax, the damage would be based on 56.25 base ice damage + 18.75 * 2 (37.5) base fighting damage, resulting an an attack that is effectively base 93.5 power (normally 75 power).
From Snorlax, against a Bellossom, the damage would be based on 56.25 x 2 (112.5) base ice damage + 18.75 base fighting damage, resulting in an attack that is effectively base 131.25 power (normally 150 power).
From Snorlax, against a Venusaur, the damage would be based on 56.25 x 2 (112.5) base ice damage + 18.75 * 1/2 (9.375) base fighting damage, resulting in an attack that is effectively base 121.875 power (normally 150 power).
From Beartic, against a Bellossom, the damage would be based on 56.25 * 2 * 1.5 (168.75) base ice damage + 18.75 base fighting damage, resulting in an attack that is effectively base 187.5 power (normally 225 power).
From a hypothetical Ice/Fighting pokemon, against Sawsbuck, the damage would be based on 56.25 * 2 * 1.5 (168.75) base ice damage + 18.75 * 2 * 1.5 (56.25) base fighting damage, resulting in an attack that is effectively base 225 power (normally 225 power).
Assuming, for a moment, a hypothetical Ice/Dragon move at base 100 power (that otherwise would be an ice move), let's look.
From Snorlax against Garchomp - base 75 ice * 4 + base 25 dragon * 2 gives 300 + 50 for 350 base (compared to base 400).
From Grarchomp against Garchomp - base 75 ice * 4 + base 25 dragon * 2 * .15 gives 375 (compared to base 400)
From Kyurem to Garchomp - base 75 ice * 4 * 1.5 + base 25 dragon * 2 * 1.5 gives 525 (compared to base 600)
Taking our corner case of Ludicolo plus a grass/water move against Golem, you have .75 *2 * 2 * 1.5 (4.5) + .25 * 2 * 2 * 1.5 (1.5), granting us a total of x6 damage, just as a water or grass move from Ludicolo already does against Golem, instead of something utterly ridiculous unweighted.
Using that system, dual type moves would stay exactly the same if you had double STAB against a pokemon weak to each component type. They would, if no STAB or super-effective type is involved, be no weaker. In the middle, they are actually weaker and only become as powerful as they are now if there is double STAB and double weakness. Ultimately, it appears that what would happen with this weighting would be ultimately a nerf to the moves changed, and any new moves would be far better if they had been single-type.
Now, increasing base power might compensate for the relative weakness of this weighting, and weighting moves at 50/50 instead of 75/25 might be less nerfy (though I'd hesitate to do it at a straight 50/50 split).
But yes, without some sort of weighting, doing this would be a monumentally stupid idea. What about Ludicolo using hypothetical grass/water move against Golem for x 18 damage (so even a base 20 move would be base 360 in that case) sounds like a good idea? None of it, really.
Last edited: