• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Ash's development

Cloud5001

Well-Known Member
I decided to share my thoughts on Ash's level of progression, I know it's most likely I'm reading too much into it and probably giving the writers too much credit, but looking at it my way is fun so I'm doing this. I'll do one for Pikachu if people like this.

Kanto-Ash being a new trainer he makes all the rookie mistakes you expect a rookie to make, and a few mistakes that make us laugh. By the time Ash battled Lt.Surge he was mainly just getting by on luck and his kind heart. His third gym attempt helped both him and Pikachu get better at battles. He does battle Erica but he once again earns a badge for helping the gym leader. However starting with Koga he started earning his badges by winning battles with the only exception being Sabrina, yes his last badge was against Team Rocket but considering they were electrocuting him every time his pokemon got hurt I'd count it as a challenge. Ash did great for his first time in the Pokémon league but he was lacking some experience so his finish in the top 16 was pretty fair.

Orange Islands-This arc in my mind helped Ash develop his out of the box strategies as the gym leaders in this arc all forced Ash to win in different ways rather than just the usual battling. It sharpened his battle skills which showed when he beat Drake. He manages to gain Charizard's respect in this arc as well. However all of his time in the Orange Island wasn't enough to beat Gary in their first official battle.

Jhoto- Ash's battle skill this region improved with each gym battle he faced here. He also learned to win without relying on his heavy hitter. His growth showed the most when he faced Gary in the Silver Confrence and won. However his loss to Harrison showed he still had a lot to learn. However he finishes the league this time in the top 8

Hoenn-Deciding to use only Pikachu this region, he proved he could train a whole bunch of new pokemon and get an impressive rank in the league, once again finishing in the top 8. His creativity in his battles were really superb, however Ash lacked a permanent rival to really drive him. This would come into play during Sinnoh.

Battle Frontier- He faced tough challenges during the Battle Frontier, his skill here remained pretty much the same except when he had to battle Brandon who proved more than a match for Ash. Defeating Brandon on his third try helped him overcome an important obstacle that really improve his skill. However he still didn't have a rival pushing him to do better than he usually does.

Sinnoh-It is here that we are introduced to Paul, an experienced trainer who is pretty much Ash's opposite. In their first battle Ash and Paul tie meaning this trainer was going to be a real threat to Ash. Of all their encounters before the league Ash only get's one win against Paul, with his rival slaughtering him every other time. This definitely gave Ash the drive to get stronger, his skill level was at his absolute best in this region blending his creative battle style with his faith in his pokemon nicely. Ash proved it during the final battle against Paul where he uses the pokemon Paul thought to be weak to defeat one of his toughest rivals yet. He went on to challenge Tobias, and even though this was an obvious cop out it still showed Ash and his pokemon were strong enough to bring down legendaries. That's why the next region baffles people.

Unova-I think it's safe to say that Ash's top 4 ranking made him arrogant and well downright sloppy as newbie trainer Trip was giving Ash a hard time even though he shouldn't have. However around the fourth gym leader Ash finally got it together and started regaining some of that skill he had in Sinnoh. It took him quite awhile to reclaim it fully however, but by the Unova League it was clear both he and Pikachu had finally knocked off all the rust one shotting that stupid OP Serperior proving that fact. However Ash got it too late as he could only finish in the top 8 again. Now I think Ash figured out he can't get too relaxed after a league is over or he'll suffer the same thing he did in Unova. So even though I think Unova isn't the best of series it does show how getting lazy and arrogant can affect ones performance.

XY- Ash has none of that sloppiness in this region, here he's battling like how he was at the end of Sinnoh. He's thinking through his moves when he battles and his overall creativity is back. Xy hasn't finished yet but from the way he has been acting I'm hoping for at least a second place finish this time if they still plan to make Ash loose.

Well overall I find that Ash has grown very well on his journey if you look at it from this point of view. Indeed he has many incredible feats as a trainer, he is a great one when he's got a level head and not being arrogant which is definitely Ash's big weakness. That's why I don't think it's too out there that Ash got arrogant after Sinnoh, after all that was his best league so far and whenever Ash improves there's often a point where he lets it go to his head. Well anyways those are my thoughts for Ash's growth and I'm fully aware not everyone has to agree or like it but even so I'd love to hear what you guys think.
 
Nice post, but you give the writers too much credit. The regression of Ash in BW from DP proves the writers don't want to take Ash any further and allow him to win a league so he's kept in a cycle where he resets at a new region.

Ash really should have won the Sinnoh league with Ash Vs. Paul in the finals and Tobias simply should have never existed.
 
The difference between XY Ash and BW Ash is that XY ash's team is obnoxiously OP for no real reason(just like hoenn). Because it's natural for him to beat a mega at the third gym and one shot magnetons with frog foam.

Otherwise I don't see much of a difference.
 
The difference between XY Ash and BW Ash is that XY ash's team is obnoxiously OP for no real reason(just like hoenn). Because it's natural for him to beat a mega at the third gym and one shot magnetons with frog foam.

Otherwise I don't see much of a difference.

Its also his portrayal and the way his companions treat him. In BW Ash felt like the "kid" of the group despite being full of experience by then with Iris and Cilan teaching him.

In XY Ash is the "mentor and hero" where Serena/Clemont/Bonnie all look up to him. The difference in portrayal is obvious.
 
Its also his portrayal and the way his companions treat him. In BW Ash felt like the "kid" of the group despite being full of experience by then with Iris and Cilan teaching him.

In XY Ash is the "mentor and hero" where Serena/Clemont/Bonnie all look up to him. The difference in portrayal is obvious.

Iris would have belittled him regardless.
 
There is no doubt that Serena is and intended to be the exact opposite of Iris. More feminine, more friendly and it's obvious that Serena worships the ground that Ash walks on.
 
Nice post, but you give the writers too much credit. The regression of Ash in BW from DP proves the writers don't want to take Ash any further and allow him to win a league so he's kept in a cycle where he resets at a new region.

Ash really should have won the Sinnoh league with Ash Vs. Paul in the finals and Tobias simply should have never existed.

I agree. Sinnoh was his best perfomance and he was set to win it. The final match against Tobias was anti-climactic compared to the three part match against Paul. He shouldn't have been in it. He was just there as an excuse for Ash not to win, yet again.
 
I agree. Sinnoh was his best perfomance and he was set to win it. The final match against Tobias was anti-climactic compared to the three part match against Paul. He shouldn't have been in it. He was just there as an excuse for Ash not to win, yet again.

Still getting a bad taste in my mouth if i think back about that. They should have made Ash win the Lake match to Paul, and loosing in the Final. That was way better in my opinon.
 
Still getting a bad taste in my mouth if i think back about that. They should have made Ash win the Lake match to Paul, and loosing in the Final. That was way better in my opinon.

So ash's ragtag uncompleted team at the lake should have beaten a team entirely full of fully evolved pokemon minus electabuzz? I'm sorry but that **** should have stayed in hoenn where it belongs.
 
So ash's ragtag uncompleted team at the lake should have beaten a team entirely full of fully evolved pokemon minus electabuzz? I'm sorry but that **** should have stayed in hoenn where it belongs.

Ash's team was set to do rather well at the lake to be fair, although I agree that he shouldn't have won, but Paul could've afforded to lose at least one more of his team.

I mean, Gliscor wore down Paul's starter to the point where it could've probably landed only one more move and defeated it, had Torterra not clamped down and landed that Giga Drain.. so if the last capture on Ash's team could do that much damage to the first Pokemon that Paul ever owned, then its not like his other Pokemon were going to be unbeatable and Pikachu especially should've been able to destroy one..
 
I decided to share my thoughts on Ash's level of progression, I know it's most likely I'm reading too much into it and probably giving the writers too much credit, but looking at it my way is fun so I'm doing this. I'll do one for Pikachu if people like this.

Kanto-Ash being a new trainer he makes all the rookie mistakes you expect a rookie to make, and a few mistakes that make us laugh. By the time Ash battled Lt.Surge he was mainly just getting by on luck and his kind heart. His third gym attempt helped both him and Pikachu get better at battles. He does battle Erica but he once again earns a badge for helping the gym leader. However starting with Koga he started earning his badges by winning battles with the only exception being Sabrina, yes his last badge was against Team Rocket but considering they were electrocuting him every time his pokemon got hurt I'd count it as a challenge. Ash did great for his first time in the Pokémon league but he was lacking some experience so his finish in the top 16 was pretty fair.

Orange Islands-This arc in my mind helped Ash develop his out of the box strategies as the gym leaders in this arc all forced Ash to win in different ways rather than just the usual battling. It sharpened his battle skills which showed when he beat Drake. He manages to gain Charizard's respect in this arc as well. However all of his time in the Orange Island wasn't enough to beat Gary in their first official battle.

Jhoto- Ash's battle skill this region improved with each gym battle he faced here. He also learned to win without relying on his heavy hitter. His growth showed the most when he faced Gary in the Silver Confrence and won. However his loss to Harrison showed he still had a lot to learn. However he finishes the league this time in the top 8

Hoenn-Deciding to use only Pikachu this region, he proved he could train a whole bunch of new pokemon and get an impressive rank in the league, once again finishing in the top 8. His creativity in his battles were really superb, however Ash lacked a permanent rival to really drive him. This would come into play during Sinnoh.

Battle Frontier- He faced tough challenges during the Battle Frontier, his skill here remained pretty much the same except when he had to battle Brandon who proved more than a match for Ash. Defeating Brandon on his third try helped him overcome an important obstacle that really improve his skill. However he still didn't have a rival pushing him to do better than he usually does.

Sinnoh-It is here that we are introduced to Paul, an experienced trainer who is pretty much Ash's opposite. In their first battle Ash and Paul tie meaning this trainer was going to be a real threat to Ash. Of all their encounters before the league Ash only get's one win against Paul, with his rival slaughtering him every other time. This definitely gave Ash the drive to get stronger, his skill level was at his absolute best in this region blending his creative battle style with his faith in his pokemon nicely. Ash proved it during the final battle against Paul where he uses the pokemon Paul thought to be weak to defeat one of his toughest rivals yet. He went on to challenge Tobias, and even though this was an obvious cop out it still showed Ash and his pokemon were strong enough to bring down legendaries. That's why the next region baffles people.

Unova-I think it's safe to say that Ash's top 4 ranking made him arrogant and well downright sloppy as newbie trainer Trip was giving Ash a hard time even though he shouldn't have. However around the fourth gym leader Ash finally got it together and started regaining some of that skill he had in Sinnoh. It took him quite awhile to reclaim it fully however, but by the Unova League it was clear both he and Pikachu had finally knocked off all the rust one shotting that stupid OP Serperior proving that fact. However Ash got it too late as he could only finish in the top 8 again. Now I think Ash figured out he can't get too relaxed after a league is over or he'll suffer the same thing he did in Unova. So even though I think Unova isn't the best of series it does show how getting lazy and arrogant can affect ones performance.

XY- Ash has none of that sloppiness in this region, here he's battling like how he was at the end of Sinnoh. He's thinking through his moves when he battles and his overall creativity is back. Xy hasn't finished yet but from the way he has been acting I'm hoping for at least a second place finish this time if they still plan to make Ash loose.

Well overall I find that Ash has grown very well on his journey if you look at it from this point of view. Indeed he has many incredible feats as a trainer, he is a great one when he's got a level head and not being arrogant which is definitely Ash's big weakness. That's why I don't think it's too out there that Ash got arrogant after Sinnoh, after all that was his best league so far and whenever Ash improves there's often a point where he lets it go to his head. Well anyways those are my thoughts for Ash's growth and I'm fully aware not everyone has to agree or like it but even so I'd love to hear what you guys think.

I overall agree with this. Though in my opinion Tobias and all legandariesin sinnoh league where cheap shot by anime standards. Ya know never been allowed in Kanto,Johto or Hoenn officer Jenny would in other 3 regions locked Tobias up.

I also want to add to this a bit. Ash also had good friends in Kanto-Sinnoh keeping his ego in check. Misty and Ash contsantly brought each other down peg when needed in Kanto and Johto as well as in Johto having several young girl trainers be role models for which kept them from getting to cocky. And of course Brock looking out for them and saying chill when absolutely necary.
Nothing to add to on orange island.

In Hoenn Ash had Brock keeping his ego in check while being tutor to May. To keep him in check as well as wanting to be goodexample to Max.

In Sinnoh it was clear Ash saw Dawn as his little sister. And that kept his ego in check and push from Paul which is why he did as well as he did despite the Sinnoh league playing by diffrent rules.

Unova yup his companies not friends didn't help.

X and Y we have to see where it goes but at least Ash is using his head again. And clear that Clemont,Bonnie and Serena will be his friends.
 
Last edited:
I think just seeing BW as a soft reboot would be much easier for everyone, and now it doesnt even matter, since XY Ash is already around the same skill-level as his AG/DP counterpart.

takes that pesky OS out of the equation too.
 
Considering Unova, it had nothing to do with his Ego. His ego got the better of him in Hoenn after the performance in the Johto League and the wins against the fist Gym Leaders where he started to underestimate everything, but he didn't went to that Idiot LvL he reached in BW.

Ash there feels like he wasn't really written there, like there was a new trainer planned, because the mistake he made there were mistakes a rookie would make on his first days and not someone who is a trainer for years ( no Ash isn't 10 years old the announcer just lied )

I'm glad that Ash went back to the skilled trainer he was in D/P. ( Well still hasn't reached his Sinnoh League, but there is time )
 
Considering Unova, it had nothing to do with his Ego. His ego got the better of him in Hoenn after the performance in the Johto League and the wins against the fist Gym Leaders where he started to underestimate everything, but he didn't went to that Idiot LvL he reached in BW.

Ash there feels like he wasn't really written there, like there was a new trainer planned, because the mistake he made there were mistakes a rookie would make on his first days and not someone who is a trainer for years ( no Ash isn't 10 years old the announcer just lied )

I'm glad that Ash went back to the skilled trainer he was in D/P. ( Well still hasn't reached his Sinnoh League, but there is time )

All too true but you have to admit Ash getting cocky after his first top 4 finish does make sense. If I look at it the way I do then Unova doesn't depress me as much. I can like pretty much anything pokemon related but even so I felt the anime was really testing me at times during Unova. What with the poor handling of Ash and Pikachu during it.
 
In my opinion, Ash was at his best in the Sinnoh region. I understand this is still a kids show and Ash should not become to mature, but a little more mature wouldn't hurt. His childish attitude is just plain annoying sometimes. He handled his Pokémon really well in the Sinnoh League, where was that level of skill in the Unova League? Sure, he only used his Unova Pokémon but still... He should have performed way better than he did, especially against Cameron.
 
Still getting a bad taste in my mouth if i think back about that. They should have made Ash win the Lake match to Paul, and loosing in the Final. That was way better in my opinon.

I'm sure the anime will never let Ash's final battle against his rival end up like that in a Pokémon League.
 
All too true but you have to admit Ash getting cocky after his first top 4 finish does make sense.

Not really in my opinion. We never saw anything that made that evident or that even implied that. He lost to Tobias, went to Unova, and started making rookie mistakes like trying to catch wild Pokemon without weakening them; there wasn't really much time after the Sinnoh League for him to get complacent in my view.
 
Back
Top