• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Description.

Praxiteles

Friendly POKéMON.
Description. Yes, folks, that newbie's nightmare, that great big review section over which writers have debated and discussed since writing's humble and unknown beginnings.

In this thread, I'd like to discuss some fundamental, controversial questions about it. What is its point? What does it mean to writers?

For this reason, I have made a few questions which I would like poeple to answer with their own opinions. They are as follows:

1. What is the point of description? Is it to paint a picture in the reader's mind, or should it mainly be used to forward the story? Or should it set the mood/scene?

2. What is the 'threshold' for purple prose? When does 'descriptive' become 'overdescription'? Does it depend on the reader's attention/interest?

3. How can large amounts of description exist without becoming purple prose? Again, how much is the reader connected to this? I've seen in one of my experiments that, with work, description which may be exceedingly boring otherwise can keep the reader hooked for long. Does this, then, exist to serve only the purpose of the reader?

4. If the answer to Q3 is yes, then how, exactly, can description be made interesting? What is the art to it? Even I don't fully understand this one.

5. Should description constitute the bulk of a story, or should action and dialogue be mostly used? Does this depend on the mood?

Mods, notify if there is another thread like this.

Opinions, please!
 
Err... wow. These questions are tough. O.o... I shall try to answer the best I can though.

What is the point of description? Is it to paint a picture in the reader's mind, or should it mainly be used to forward the story? Or should it set the mood/scene?

To me, descripition is just like what is akin for an artist to hold a paintbruch and draw, for I myself learn art in real life. An artpiece, when wonderfully done, can convery a certain feeling/mood towards the general viewier, much as well-done descrpition can help to create the scene within one's mind. It is a given that descrpition do make the majority of a fic, and some resort to over descrbing in order to make the story seem, well, longer, when all it does is to halt one's train of thoughts and overall, lose interest in the story. Its like to say in art, does anyone goes to inspect every little detail, every hole that is not covered onto the canvas? Unless you're inspeacting or the artist itself, I daresay not. So to me, descrpition is just like the all important colors that a painting needs in creating that masterpiece.

What is the 'threshold' for purple prose? When does 'descriptive' become 'overdescription'? Does it depend on the reader's attention/interest?

I have to admit, there are times when one's personal limit of patience does unconciously create an opinion on the line between descrpition and overdescrpition. Like take a two people, one cool tempered and the other hot, and give them a book like Harry Potter and the Order Of The Phoenix. Undeniably, the hot tempered one would put down the book by an hour and wouldn't wish to read it anymore, given the fact that its long. However, a cool tempered person will most likely be able to finish it and not get annoyed by its length. Of course, interest also plays a part in this. If you were never interested in Eragon, would you go and read it? ^^;;; IMHO, I think the threshold for 'purple prose' would be when an author focuses too much on descrpition and loses sight of the true story (ie. he begins to elaborate a single thing within one chunky paragraph) Personally, I do have a level of high tolerence, and only see overdescrpition when they exggerate on a partulicar item too much.

How can large amounts of description exist without becoming purple prose? Again, how much is the reader connected to this? I've seen in one of my experiments that, with work, description which may be exceedingly boring otherwise can keep the reader hooked for long. Does this, then, exist to serve only the purpose of the reader?

No. Every noble author in this forum has put all their time and effort into every word and sentece which we all read. While we all vary in age, difference and other things, we are all still tied to the same reason in which why we're al here. One, of course, whould be our love of Pokemon in general, and the other would be our love for writing and reading these literal masterpieces. We toil and sweat and crack our brains for words which would, if caputre us, would also capture the readers as well. Simply put, we place ourselves into another person's shoes and see if our words are adequete enough to attract and hold a reader's attention. After all, if our own works disgust us, what would the reaction of the general audience be? ><;

Should description constitute the bulk of a story, or should action and dialogue be mostly used? Does this depend on the mood?

Honestly speaking, it has to depend on the body itself, and just what you want the chapter to have. Take my fic, Midian for example. I had a chapter in where there was all talk and no action, but yet my reviewers said it was a pretty good chapter. And then when I added in the action and almost no talk, they also said it was good. I really can't say much for this question - all I can honestly admit that for this, it would seriously depend on the chapter itself.

Knightblazer ;262;
 
Description. Yes, folks, that newbie's nightmare, that great big review section over which writers have debated and discussed since writing's humble and unknown beginnings.

In this thread, I'd like to discuss some fundamental, controversial questions about it. What is its point? What does it mean to writers?

For this reason, I have made a few questions which I would like poeple to answer with their own opinions. They are as follows:

1. What is the point of description? Is it to paint a picture in the reader's mind, or should it mainly be used to forward the story? Or should it set the mood/scene?
It should do all of that. If you don't describe things, its sort of hard to get into the story. If its undescribed, I have a hard time getting into the story, because I can't view the charecters, or because I'm reading the story from a viewpoint that doesn't fit it, the story becomes akward.

2. What is the 'threshold' for purple prose? When does 'descriptive' become 'overdescription'? Does it depend on the reader's attention/interest?
I love description. Its a great thing. But when you start to ramble and talk about things that aren't pertinent to the setting, story, or charecters, then its a little much. A good way to avoid purple prose is create a scenario of sort of "gray time" where the story slows down for a moment for you to give a description of the charecter or place. If you can slowly incorprate the description with dialouge or other tidbits before moving on with the story, it tends to be quite interesting, and prevents you from rambling.

And purple prose is also relitive to the reader. Some people like fast moving stories where they can sit on the edge of their seats and read the chapter. This is where blocks of description might slow the story down. However, if you keep the block exciting with dialog, or by describing the setting or charecter in some engaging action, then you can do what you want.
3. How can large amounts of description exist without becoming purple prose? Again, how much is the reader connected to this? I've seen in one of my experiments that, with work, description which may be exceedingly boring otherwise can keep the reader hooked for long. Does this, then, exist to serve only the purpose of the reader?
Like I said before, if they're incorperatied into the story in some way without totally stopping the story to do it, then you can ramble without loosing intrest.

Another good tip is to add a point of mystery in your description to keep the readers guessing. This is a great way to foreshadow, and can be used for anything.

And overall, description is mostly a thing for the reader. But its importiant, because it's a basic foundation for the reader, and it helps them understand the story's elements.

4. If the answer to Q3 is yes, then how, exactly, can description be made interesting? What is the art to it? Even I don't fully understand this one.
See every other awnser for this one.
5. Should description constitute the bulk of a story, or should action and dialogue be mostly used? Does this depend on the mood?

Mods, notify if there is another thread like this.

Opinions, please!
This is totally relitive to the scene. If some interaction is needed to further the story, then use the interaction. Otherwise, go crazy, but try to keep your readers attached with some dialog. One thing that I dislike though is describing every little action the charecters make while in dialog. If it doesn't relate to their emotions or feelings about what's being talked about, its sort of a waste of time to put in. This goes the same for any other time, but its most common in dialouge.
 
My opinions:

1. What is the point of description? Is it to paint a picture in the reader's mind, or should it mainly be used to forward the story? Or should it set the mood/scene?
To paint imagery in the readers mind, so they can imagine whats happening cleared and it gives a better view of how the author sees his/her characters.

2. What is the 'threshold' for purple prose? When does 'descriptive' become 'overdescription'? Does it depend on the reader's attention/interest?
I personally don't mind overdescription, especially if the writer if good at describing thing and scenes, yet I think this one depends of the person reading a fic. Its different with everyone...

3. How can large amounts of description exist without becoming purple prose? Again, how much is the reader connected to this? I've seen in one of my experiments that, with work, description which may be exceedingly boring otherwise can keep the reader hooked for long. Does this, then, exist to serve only the purpose of the reader?
To be honest, I'm not really sure on this one. Again, its always different for different readers.

4. If the answer to Q3 is yes, then how, exactly, can description be made interesting? What is the art to it? Even I don't fully understand this one.
Yes, I think theres an art to it, something I haven't got yet, nor probably will ever get... :(

5. Should description constitute the bulk of a story, or should action and dialogue be mostly used? Does this depend on the mood?
A mixture of all I think, weighed out in equal measures of course :)

Just my views...
 
Personally, I think it all depends on style. Writing style is so important in judging the sucess of a story, most particularly in the description area. I often find myself troubled with desciption because I write in first person. Sometimes, I've had readers ask if it really makes sense for the narrator to outlining things so eloquently. Of course, it's no excuse, and I still try to use as much description as I can, although more than usual when the main charcter is especially focusing on something.

I often find that the descriptive style that tends to impress the most are the figurative styles. Y'know, when people way overuse similes and metaphors and other things that are confusing as hell, with the feeling of incomprehension often evolviong into one of inferiority. Personally, I'm not a big fan of this style, myself. There's no doubt that it's impressive, but it tends to just irk me. But then, I love dialogue and character devlopment. ^^ In the end, however, it all depends on the story itself. Large description is best suited to darker, more serious works (or so it seems).

Lastly, I think that description for tone's sake is always a good thing. Also, for the obvious purpose of painting a picture, but sometimes in my fic, there's something I want to describe, but it would just be so out of place. For example, random setting overdescription in a fast-paced action scene is never a good thing. But description of all the movement going on is. It all depends on what the emphasis is on, and likewise, the narration style plays a large role too.

I know I didn't really answer the questions, I just wanted to add my two cents. =P

~Chibi~;249;;448;
 
1. What is the point of description? Is it to paint a picture in the reader's mind, or should it mainly be used to forward the story? Or should it set the mood/scene?
To "paint a picture in the reader's mind" with description tends to be overrated, because of the simple fact that stating A boy threw a Pokéball will in the end tell the reader a very great deal more than something heading more towards A singular boy tossed out a spherical object, which possessed the approximate diameter of an orange colored citrus fruit from a semi-tropical tree. One half of the globe was a bright crimson with a spot of white glare where the light caught on the orb's polished surface and was redirected outward, while the other half was an achromic color. The ruby and pearl of the spheriod were separated by a band approximately the width of a fat pen that was cinereal in color, which had a rounded circular protrusion of the same ashen shade that was slightly larger in diameter than the circlet of neutral coloration. The two half-circular sections of differing color separated with only the area directly opposite the button-like area remaining attached and the rest of the seam opening in such a way as to exactly bisect the thick line of ashen cast, with the distance greatest between the button and its opposite concave mirror area. (Example not mine; I nabbed it from this piece of utter brilliance which an awful lot of people really need to read). Description is for a) clarifying things that the reader must know to understand what is going on, and b) smoothen the pace of the story by fleshing out slow scenes with relevant, interesting detail. Going great lengths to describe everything in an action scene does not paint a picture in the reader's mind; it makes the scene appear to be proceeding in slow motion and eventually just gets too tedious for the reader to continue if you go on for too long like that.

2. What is the 'threshold' for purple prose? When does 'descriptive' become 'overdescription'? Does it depend on the reader's attention/interest?
In my opinion, the story should flow naturally throughout at the speed at which the reader is reading, excluding transitions, because of how stories play out in the reader's head - like a movie. For short, if it takes longer for the reader to read your description of a Pokéball being thrown than it takes for the ball to be thrown in the reader's head, it is too much. If it takes longer for the reader to read your description of a Pokémon than a scene from a movie would stop with the camera pointed at the Pokémon with the Pokémon standing still, it is too much. I would think this should be fairly universal, as I can't picture anyone with the attention span to watch a Pokéball being thrown or a Charizard breathing for thirty seconds straight before something actually happens.

3. How can large amounts of description exist without becoming purple prose? Again, how much is the reader connected to this? I've seen in one of my experiments that, with work, description which may be exceedingly boring otherwise can keep the reader hooked for long. Does this, then, exist to serve only the purpose of the reader?
Large amounts of description can exist if what is being described is something interesting enough for the reader to want to look at it and observe its details in a movie for a while. If things are happening slowly, you can cram in a lot of description in between the action verbs without it putting the movie in the reader's head in slow motion.

If the thing being described is uninteresting and nothing is going on, I really can't picture anyone being hooked for more than a couple of seconds.

4. If the answer to Q3 is yes, then how, exactly, can description be made interesting? What is the art to it? Even I don't fully understand this one.
By putting it in at the sides, injecting it into action sentences, keeping it from dominating the story for more than a second. Make it relevant and alive without forcedly inserting pointless actions for the purpose of being able to describe more (please don't make every woman your main character comes across toss her head so that her [insert color here] hair flashes back).

5. Should description constitute the bulk of a story, or should action and dialogue be mostly used? Does this depend on the mood?
It depends very much on the mood and what is happening. Humour is, for example, generally quick and fast-paced, and so even very little description will make it tedious, but a darker atmosphere tends to call for a slower style with more description in addition to frequently needing some description of surroundings to set the scene properly. Description should never constitute the bulk of a story, because then it simply means nothing is happening, and nothing happening is generally not a good thing in a fic. I think most people will agree there.
 
I was going to spend the first line of this post complaining about how often these threads come up, but then Dragonfree brought up

Example not mine; I nabbed it from this piece of utter brilliance which an awful lot of people really need to read)
which distracted me because that's probably my favorite chapter of that 'fic so far, and it is in general straight-up awesome.

But anyway, back around to those questions.

View Post
1. What is the point of description? Is it to paint a picture in the reader's mind, or should it mainly be used to forward the story? Or should it set the mood/scene?
Both. Although it should be noted that I've grown to hate the phrase "paint a picture in the reader's head" because it sounds so laughably snobby and biased (who, after all, would say that "I'm against painting pictures in people's heads! They should just get images of blank canvases!"). Not to mention that I get this mental image of some guy going, "Now be sure to describe your tree as a happy tree..."

2. What is the 'threshold' for purple prose? When does 'descriptive' become 'overdescription'? Does it depend on the reader's attention/interest?
Description becomes overdescription the moment it begins to pull the reader out of the story. Description needs to flow with the work and keep up the pace of the writing while still doing its job. Purple prose, on the other hand, is where overdescription is taken to such an extent that the average reader notices it, gets annoyed, and starts to complain.

I don't understand the obsession with "overdescription"; it's no better or worse than characters who have become nothing but hollow vessels for a soul-sucking plot, or a story that has lost all direction and is just a rambling collection of locales and talking heads. Everything in moderation--description is hardly the only thing you can go overboard and, contrary to popular belief, is probably not the aspect most often weighted disproportionately.

3. How can large amounts of description exist without becoming purple prose? Again, how much is the reader connected to this? I've seen in one of my experiments that, with work, description which may be exceedingly boring otherwise can keep the reader hooked for long. Does this, then, exist to serve only the purpose of the reader?
They can if they are placed appropriately and then handled well. Ultimately, determination of quality will always be an interaction between the authors' work and the readers' perception of it; description is no different in this respect. However, that does not prevent there being "too little" description or "too much"; this determination is not solely based upon reader response, but also to an extent upon, simply, writing conventions.

4. If the answer to Q3 is yes, then how, exactly, can description be made interesting? What is the art to it? Even I don't fully understand this one.
There are many things that need to go right for large descriptive passages to work, which is why they are so tricky to pull off. Firstly, syntax, punctuation, and basic grammatical rules are vitally important in order to keep the words properly metered and everything sensical, lest the reader be lost in a sea of adjectives without remembering how they got there or where they're going.

Next, the description has to flow along with the text. If the reader notices that they're been pulled over to a pit-stop paragraph in order to contemplate, say, the appearance of a pokemon, they'll be jarred out of the story, as the actual tale continues around this big fat block of text that's sitting right in the middle of it like a big rock in a river.

Perhaps most importantly, the description needs to be relevant and interesting. Attention to wholly irrelevant details impresses no one and does not help your story at all; if you're going to spend some serious wordcount describing something, it had darned well better be for good reason. Don't go off into a paragraph about, say, this green-armored scyther. We know that scyther is green; nobody cares, move on, please. Now, if you were describing a scyther that was not its usual green but instead a disturbing shade of purple, that's something that would make a reader sit up and notice and something you could devote more time to; even then, though, that detail shouldn't take you ages to consider.

It's also important to describe not in terms of what you believe to be important, but rather what your character would notice. This is less of an issue in third-person omniscient, but if you're doing first-person writing, especially, everything needs to come filtered through your character's eyes. People don't generally notice things unless they're out of place or unusual, so the moment your character steps into a room in a pokemon center, they're not going to notice every single detail, only what sets it apart from other centers they've been in, or maybe the people in the room. They aren't going to spend a long time studying a pokemon of a species with which they're already familiar unless it differs significantly from others of its kind or is unusually rare or significant to the character.

In the end, nobody, while the slavering hordes of darkness are rushing at them from the other end of the battlefield, is going to stop and contemplate at length the beauty of a rosebush lying to the side of their path.

Finally, there's simply a "feel" for description that must be acquired through trial and error and the reading of other 'fics that really can't be quantified. There's this extra quality to every aspect of writing, of course. Call it talent.

5. Should description constitute the bulk of a story, or should action and dialogue be mostly used? Does this depend on the mood?
That depends entirely upon the aim of the story. It's dependent not upon mood, but rather upon the point that you are trying to make with your writing.
 
1. What is the point of description? Is it to paint a picture in the reader's mind, or should it mainly be used to forward the story? Or should it set the mood/scene?

It is all three combined. What I have learned over the years is that readers will be more engulfed in the story when you SHOW what is happening. By showing, of course, I mean description. A story cannot be a story if description is not implemented. However, it does not necessarily need to describe scenery. It can also be used to describe emotion, mood, viewpoint, and basically makes up the largest portion of the story. Since it is the largest portion of the story, description, in my opinion, is used to advance the plot only when something important to the plot comes up. Since setting is important to the story, then description can also be used to set a mood for the scene. However, description should not primarily be used to advance the plot. The language itself should do that. There is a difference.

If description paints a picture in the reader's mind, then the language advances the story because it is everything combined. We call this voice. Or the writer's "soul" showing through the writing.

2. What is the 'threshold' for purple prose? When does 'descriptive' become 'overdescription'? Does it depend on the reader's attention/interest?

'Purple Prose' often appears in the works of beginning authors. The writer feels that he or she must describe everything to the clearest detail in order to form a story, and thus emphasis (a tad too much) is placed on description. But as I already mentioned, I believe that the Voice of the author is what primarily advances the story. If you spend too many paragraphs describing every detail of, let's say, the setting, the plot will not advance. You will only be left with unneeded detail.

The term "overdescription" is something I have gripes with personally. Once again, it depends on the language and attention to detail. If the detail is not that important but it is described in about three paragraphs anyways, then it steps into the bounds of "overdescription." This is because the author is paying too much attention to the surroundings, and doesn't understand that you should only apply enough description to present a point to the reader in your own Voice.

3. How can large amounts of description exist without becoming purple prose? Again, how much is the reader connected to this? I've seen in one of my experiments that, with work, description which may be exceedingly boring otherwise can keep the reader hooked for long. Does this, then, exist to serve only the purpose of the reader?

Like I said, there should only be enough description to prove a point to the reader in the author's language, or style. We all have our own ways of writing, and our own ways of paying attention to detail. As for the notion that long description keeps the reader, this isn't true unless your style is engaging. Elements of the plot, mood, and theme go hand in hand with description. So, this is the aspect that keep readers hooked. Otherwise, the large amount of description will just become tedious and bore the reader. But it DOES depends largely on the reader's attention span. Personally, I can't stand too much description. The author's style will also draw me in, but only if the description is enough to let me visualize everything without boring me with tedious vocabulary and too much attention to random aspects that need not be noted.

5. Should description constitute the bulk of a story, or should action and dialogue be mostly used? Does this depend on the mood?

Description IS the bulk of a story. But it should only be used enough to present a point to the reader. Dialogue and action speak for themselves, but they mostly describe the characters. The character's actions move the plot forward. Description is there to help you visualize those actions.

*plinks two cents into cup*
 
Paint. That's the magic word. Paint pictures with words. That's the greatest advice I can give anybody. Paint the pictures with words. The picture will appear in the imagination so the person reading it can say, "I can see that".

-Brian Jacques, author of the Redwall series


Mr. Jacques wrote Redwall for the children at the Royal Wavertree School for the Blind in Liverpool, where as a truck driver, he delivered milk. His style of writing is very descriptive, because of the nature of his first audience, for whom he painted pictures with words, so that they could see them in their imaginations. (He remains a patron of the school.)

Information and quote courtesy of www.redwall.org.



Description to me has always been important, even before I started reading the Redwall series, which I fell in love with. When I did some research on Brian Jacques, the author of the series, I found out the above things and since then have been truly inspired by him and his work.

The fact alone that this man’s love for writing goes so far that he tries to help sightless children see his stories is truly impressing, but the fact that he actually pulls it off wonderfully; a style with beautiful, full description, but good characterization and interesting plots, should be commended.





What is the point of description? Is it to paint a picture in the reader's mind, or should it mainly be used to forward the story? Or should it set the mood/scene?
This question seems a bit pointless to me. Description isn’t there to just make a story longer.
Description is a writer’s main tool to place a reader into the story so that they feel as if they are standing right next to the characters, seeing what they see, hearing what they hear, even feeling similar emotions and thinking similar thoughts. To do this, a setting can be described in appearance, lighting and sound, a mood can be set, whatever it takes to put a reader into a story can be done mainly through description.

I do agree that description has to do with painting a mental picture for the readers. You have many different paints you can use, some represent character growth, emotion, plot originality- all the things that make up a story. Description is many types of paints, and you have to use them in conjunction with your character paints, plot paints and all that. Mix up the description, make it diverse so you aren’t using the same few paints on the entire canvas. Even if you use all of them, using too much can ruin a painting. Plus you don’t want the reader to squint and inspect every single little brushstroke- description needs to be used to paint the big picture, because alone, it is almost useless.
:D I hope you like my painting analogy. I made up all of it, so that might explain any confusion you may have. XD



What is the 'threshold' for purple prose? When does 'descriptive' become 'overdescription'? Does it depend on the reader's attention/interest?
Well, you generally have purple prose when you start talking about ever single leaf on a branch, or all the cracks and bumps on a road, or how many eyelashes somebody has. (And apparently an author has done just that in the past.) It’s talking about the insignificant detail that nobody really cares about, even in real life.

You know you have too much description when you go so far into detail that you forget why you’re even saying these things. Sure, not all description is for plot reasons: it’s always nice to describe a sunset, even if there’s no real importance to it. But sometimes you have to keep in mind that not everything needs to be described.


Just put it this way: if your description is so long-winded that it bores not only your readers, but you as well, it’s best to cut it down.



How can large amounts of description exist without becoming purple prose? Again, how much is the reader connected to this? I've seen in one of my experiments that, with work, description which may be exceedingly boring otherwise can keep the reader hooked for long. Does this, then, exist to serve only the purpose of the reader?
I sort of answered this before, but then again, not really.

You can have a good amount of description. But you have to try not to concentrate on just one thing. If you want to set a good mood by describing what it’s like during the winter season, don’t just keep going on about how the snow covers everything. Talk about the bitter cold and fierce winds- how anyone outside is bundled in layers of clothing. Briefly mention the clouds in the sky and the lack of sun. You can show kids playing outside. Even describe what it’s like suddenly being inside, shedding the heavy clothing, drinking hot chocolate and sitting at a warm fireplace.

Just keep it going. Don’t linger too much, unless it’s either important or interesting for the reader.



If the answer to Q3 is yes, then how, exactly, can description be made interesting? What is the art to it? Even I don't fully understand this one.
Yes, of course it can be interesting. Not only be describing the sunset or the cold winter day, but also by incorporating it into the story. To include description, the story doesn’t need to be stopped.
You just don’t want to have to stop a story to add in description, because it’s just annoying for the reader, plus it breaks a mood. example:
Jim was looking around the schoolyard, looking for his friend, Tina. Instead of finding her, however, another girl caught his eye. She was tall, and had long pink hair. It was curly, and ended just between her shoulder blades. She was wearing a bright green t-shirt and had similarly colored emerald eyes. Her brown skirt with gold trimming reached her knees. This showed off her thin, delicate legs.

Description is also used to describe actions, so it goes with the flow of a story and doesn’t interrupt it. example:
While its opponent was preoccupied with its paralysis, Mareep closed its eyes in concentration, focusing on the task at hand. Immediately, the fluffy cotton covering its body began to ripple, and little sparks of electricity shot through it as it used its Charge attack. The Rattata stared, dumbfounded, as the sheep’s fur sparkled, the electric currents running through it making it static-y. Knowing that a charged-up electric attack would soon follow, it tried valiantly to escape, but unfortunately for the little rodent, its Paralyzes status stopped it from even lifting a paw.


Clearly, the second would be more interesting to read because in the first one, there was just a list of facts about what this girl looked like. In the second, you have a battle where, while things are still going on, the scene is still being described.
(I’ll admit that neither of those descriptions were very good, and I don’t even know if they properly proved my point. But you should get the message.)



Should description constitute the bulk of a story, or should action and dialogue be mostly used? Does this depend on the mood?
Well, it depends on many things. Such as the genre. Generally in Action/Adventure stories there is less description, and the main focus is the action and events. In Mystery stories, it is a good idea to have more description because there may be a detective, and detectives need to inspect everything around them carefully to find clues.

It can also depend on the situation, or the scene. If the scene is the characters kicking back and relaxing, you can feel free to describe a lot more things around them, let the scene happen slower. But if it’s a climactic moment in the story, like a confrontation between people, the focus should be more on what’s being said, and description might weigh it down too much and take away the focus.

And yes, it can also depend on the mood. This pretty much refers to the above paragraph: if your characters are just relaxing and chilling out, everything will generally happen slower- to slow down a scene, description is perfect. But then if it’s a climactic scene where the atmosphere is tense, description isn’t needed as much. Romantic scene? Slow it down, take your time, give it emotion, make it special and sometimes draw it out.


But generally, I don’t think description should be more than like, a third of a story. This certainly varies, but in most cases you’re not reading a story for the sake of reading descriptions of places or people. In the case of maybe a Fantasy story, this can be different, but generally a story should focus more on the plot and the characters, imo, at least.




So yeah. Those are the opinions of a rather description-obsessed chick. :3 I’ve always thought description is important, but it has to be used correctly.



…if anyone actually reads this entire post, I would be very impressed. XD

~Psychic
 
I did read that post. As well as all the others. These opinions are interestingly varied, to say the least, however, one point seems to be conveyed: description should make the reader feel as if he/she is standing right in the story, while avoiding hindering the story, and setting and/or complementing the mood and the type of scene. Of course, it was rather of a joke to attempt to define such a complex art in one sentence, but I do believe I got something right. Oh, and Psychic, the analogy is better than anything I could manage.
 
Back
Top