• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Existentialism

Stockholm

The Executive Player
Upon viewing the Debate Forums, i noticed that a large amount of threads simply Pertain to Religion V.S. Non-religion. Why even such topics are allowed to exist are beyond me. It all boils down to one Principle, "Existentialism: Arrogance versus Pessimism."

So which is more Valuable? both have their Advantageous qualities, but conflct Principally and Naturally...

The Arrogant individual is an Artist, and a Magician of sorts, for he Equates existance to being founded upon something more than himself; entirely subject to a state of Superficiality, Deceptive, to portray Emperical truth, seeing reality as a pallet of events contributing to a world of dramatic interpretation: that anything and everything has a purpose beyond what simple linear observation would deduce. that all the worlds Justice can be paralled to the life of a Garbage Man: Saves thousands of Lives a day, yet amounts no prestige. What is Value to the Arrogant? The Difference between a beautiful sunset, and a drastically polluted horizon... it is all what we wish it to be, order by the grace of the human condition.

The Pessimist Individual is a Genius, thriving naturally in a world presented before his own two eyes. A Paradoxical Utilitarian, believing that superficiality is not to desire the unattainable, or the unbelievable, but to view reality as trivial and practical. Facts, over Conjecture, and is nonetheless happy about it. What are you than more than a man? and as such, perpetually searching for that ever escaping purpose, all the while denying it. A man of the Tangible, who will find happiness in Self-serving gestures, as his happiness is derived from nothing outside his own world... life is only an end.

To be blunt, such arguments are no more complex than viewing a Glass, and asking the Question, "is it Half-full, or Half-empty?" you'll never get a correct answer. but that is not the point of Sharing Contrasting Rhetoric. the whole point of Dialogue is to neither Condone nor Condemn, but to share ideas in hope of understanding one another...

You know where I stand, who are you?...
 
Last edited:
You guys "debate" an awful lot about religion, but why bother? These always degenerate to "stubborn idiot versus stubborn idiot". Let's call them A and B respectively.

Idiot A is a dreamer who believes in something unprovable.

Idiot B is a pragmatist who will believe it when he sees it.

Both positions are futile because A and B, through nurture, have different perspectives. Each would stop being an idiot if, instead of trying to prove the other wrong, A and B tried to understand the opposing point of view.

</paraphrase>

Agreed.

For the most part, debating anything here is a strange game; the only winning move is not to play. Thus I post succinct arguments and avoid being drawn into a spiral of semantics and strawmen.

Re: Half full/empty

To the engineer, the glass is twice the size it needs to be. That is, there would be no room for conjecture nor subjective error if we narrow the argument to what humanity can actually comprehend.
 
Last edited:
The Arrogant individual is an Artist
I dunno why an artist has to be arrogent...
Just let people debate, Its their right to share their opinions where or not they look stubborn.
I would have changed it from The Arrogant individual is an Artist to The Arrogant individual is an Existentialist.
 
I dunno why an artist has to be arrogent...
Just let people debate, Its their right to share their opinions where or not they look stubborn.
I would have changed it from The Arrogant individual is an Artist to The Arrogant individual is an Existentialist.


Existentialism is not a specific set of beliefs, but rather a field of thought: Metacognition for example. Most people equate beliefs as the end, when in fact they are the Means of which we found our conclusions. you dont believe in something to find Questions, you believe in something to find answers. My ideas concerning conflicting natures, is that the pessimist would see the opposition as having an unecessary value of within and of itself, that they (like the pessimist) are simple, and ulitimately worthless in retrospect, thus the artist is inherently arrogant, for he believes he excedes normality, and acknowledges and embraces improbable answers...
 
My ideas concerning conflicting natures, is that the pessimist would see the opposition as having an unecessary value of within and of itself, that they (like the pessimist) are simple, and ulitimately worthless in retrospect, thus the artist is inherently arrogant,
What does "The pessimist" have to due with "The Artist". You pulled that out of nowhere...its weird to genralize artist as arrogant. Every one is an artist in their own way. And not every one is arrogant...
 
Upon viewing the Debate Forums, i noticed that a large amount of threads simply Pertain to Religion V.S. Non-religion. Why even such topics are allowed to exist are beyond me. It all boils down to one Principle, "Existentialism: Arrogance versus Pessimism."

3 out of the 20 topics on this page pertain to religion. Let's not blow things out of proportion. Religious topics are allowed because I like seeing others kill eachother for my own personal amusement.
 
What does "The pessimist" have to due with "The Artist". You pulled that out of nowhere...its weird to genralize artist as arrogant. Every one is an artist in their own way. And not every one is arrogant...


making claims or pretensions to superior importance or rights; overbearingly assuming; insolently proud- Arrogant

a person who produces works in any of the arts that are primarily subject to aesthetic criteria.- Artist

an entertainer who is skilled in producing illusion by sleight of hand, deceptive devices- Magician

pertaining to, involving, or concerned with pure emotion and sensation as opposed to pure intellectuality- Aesthetic

a person who habitually sees or anticipates the worst or is disposed to be gloomy.- Pessimist

natural ability or capacity; strong inclination- Genius

a statement or proposition that seems self-contradictory or absurd- Paradox (Paradoxical)

having regard to utility or usefulness rather than beauty, ornamentation, etc.- Utilitarian

real or actual, rather than visionary- Tangible

Hopefully--- defining the worlds will aid clarification as to the principle i am trying to convey...
 
3 out of the 20 topics on this page pertain to religion. Let's not blow things out of proportion. Religious topics are allowed because I like seeing others kill eachother for my own personal amusement.

To be fair, while those topics aren't the most numerous, they tend to be the ones that soak up the most posts.

Away from that, this topic seems more like a speculative psychoanalytic pseudo-Freudian rendering of supposed "personality" types. In layman's terms, utter bullshit. People will have their views and perspectives on life, but there is no need to create idealised categories of different types of people depending on their "perspective". Just please don't go the next two steps forwards (or in my opinion, backwards): (i), starting to categorise people into those categories; and (ii), trying to offer "psychotherapy" based on those categories. Besides your categories are complete over-generalisations, as all categories of personalities tend to be, and certainly offer no "solution" if you like to the topic of religion since there are "pessimistic" theists and "arrogant" atheists.

The bottom line is simply that humans are humans and what that entails is there is going to be a massive range in the way people behave. Putting people into personality categories is just as bad as saying all humans are the same, as the latter is basically the former with only one category.
 
To be fair, while those topics aren't the most numerous, they tend to be the ones that soak up the most posts.

Away from that, this topic seems more like a speculative psychoanalytic pseudo-Freudian rendering of supposed "personality" types. In layman's terms, utter bullshit. People will have their views and perspectives on life, but there is no need to create idealised categories of different types of people depending on their "perspective". Just please don't go the next two steps forwards (or in my opinion, backwards): (i), starting to categorise people into those categories; and (ii), trying to offer "psychotherapy" based on those categories. Besides your categories are complete over-generalisations, as all categories of personalities tend to be, and certainly offer no "solution" if you like to the topic of religion since there are "pessimistic" theists and "arrogant" atheists.

The bottom line is simply that humans are humans and what that entails is there is going to be a massive range in the way people behave. Putting people into personality categories is just as bad as saying all humans are the same, as the latter is basically the former with only one category.

Amen

While the statements you have written are very well written, no doubt something you have paraphrased from your psychology textbook, we can read and understand how this is pure crap. You are overgeneralizing people and trying to apply logic to them for your own self-assurance. Ironically, this is a paradox because according to your words, you are yourself an arrogant being, or an artist as you put it, as you have created something that makes sense for you, which puts you at rest. Humans are not computers; we are complex and a mixture of all types of emotions and personalities. Get off your mountain because anyone can make themselves feel secure by thinking they have figured out how the world work, but to believe, to trust, to surrender to what you can't sense by any worldly definition of human senses, that is hard. We don't believe because it helps us to live with a sound mind, we know because it has been revealed to us by Love. Don't speak of things you don't understand and stop trying to be at peace by using your pitiful human logic, because peace is only obtained by faith.
 
Amen

While the statements you have written are very well written, no doubt something you have paraphrased from your psychology textbook, we can read and understand how this is pure crap. You are overgeneralizing people and trying to apply logic to them for your own self-assurance. Ironically, this is a paradox because according to your words, you are yourself an arrogant being, or an artist as you put it, as you have created something that makes sense for you, which puts you at rest. Humans are not computers; we are complex and a mixture of all types of emotions and personalities. Get off your mountain because anyone can make themselves feel secure by thinking they have figured out how the world work, but to believe, to trust, to surrender to what you can't sense by any worldly definition of human senses, that is hard. We don't believe because it helps us to live with a sound mind, we know because it has been revealed to us by Love. Don't speak of things you don't understand and stop trying to be at peace by using your pitiful human logic, because peace is only obtained by faith.

Again with the linear, "My god can beat up your god."

My religion believes that while indeed, Faith leads to peace, our existance isnt limited to using it as a ploy whenever somebody logical comes around. the fact that you use your religion, or your faith as a weapon is fallacious enough, you simply prove my point. you State, "pitiful human logic" as if you were beyond Normality, above everyone else... did you even read what I wrote? you sir just proved my point entirely

Back to your flawed argumentation, im sure that Christ believes that we should measure our faith like males measure genetalia, the bigger the better... yeah, thats how we obtain eternal salvation. maybe we should also go around the internet bashing peoples beliefs in the name of faith as well. while we're at it why dont we just ignore logic, and reason, if it even sounds anti-god... yeah that will work. because god gave us faith to use as a weapon right?

you sir are a fool.

my religion believes, "the Glory of God is Intelligence" and being the purpose of existance is to become like god, we must gain as much as we can. not simply throw faith in front of the incoming train of logic, and facts, but to accept all truth. for truth is of god.

since none of you have caught on yet, my first post, was to invent a way to debate the validity of religion without even mentioning it, but apparently its not ready for a Pokemon themed internet forum...
 
Last edited:
... peace is only obtained by faith.

... Faith leads to peace...

What?! I would agree if there is only one religion. However, history is bloody testament to the exact opposite when competing religions exist. Peace is only obtained through understanding and tolerance. Objectively, faith has nothing to do with it. If anything, faith mixed with ignorance promotes prejudice and segregation.

Stockholm

I am not sure what your agenda is... are you really surprised when somebody misinterprets your point? Do you realise how ridiculous and pretentious your verbosity appears? Nobody is impressed. Self awareness is an underrated quality, you should look into it.

... apparently its not ready for a Pokemon themed internet forum...

I would argue that the evidence suggests that it is you who is not ready to debate on any public forum. While you have a point, it is half baked and you have a roundabout way of expressing yourself. It gives me no pleasure to post this, but you need to wake up.
 
What?! I would agree if there is only one religion. However, history is bloody testament to the exact opposite when competing religions exist. Peace is only obtained through understanding and tolerance. Objectively, faith has nothing to do with it. If anything, faith mixed with ignorance promotes prejudice and segregation.

Stockholm

I am not sure what your agenda is... are you really surprised when somebody misinterprets your point? Do you realise how ridiculous and pretentious your verbosity appears? Nobody is impressed. Self awareness is an underrated quality, you should look into it.

I would argue that the evidence suggests that it is you who is not ready to debate on any public forum. While you have a point, it is half baked and you have a roundabout way of expressing yourself. It gives me no pleasure to post this, but you need to wake up.


Regarding your first contention, I was merely commenting on how fallacious it was to use faith as a means to retaliation, it was not directed at anything other than that single individual, furthermore i was elaborating on how one could argue religion, without even mentioning religion. i would ask that you read my postings more extensively in the future. and by extensively, i mean the whole thing, because i clarify this in the same post you targeted.

second, you cannot possibly deny the validity in Religion (faith) bringing peace of mind to its proponents, incidental byproducts of religion are nontopical at best, being it is not part of the dialogue.

Third: you, just proved my pessimist thesis, so haha, and thank you. you have a blatant distaste for anything created from perspective. favoring blatant intellectuality, over perceptive vision...

fourth,hopefully you do not think of multi-syllabaic words are verbose, i use the words that are appropriate. as such, it is highly immature of you to attack someones writing style, especially vocabulary; Exceptions being blatant disregard for spelling, grammar, and inductive context.

concluding, my "agenda" was to get people to think outside of the box. im quite bored with the A-typical topics, and thought an Excercise in Metacognition was in order. a narrative on Motives, and purpose, and the very real reality that humans can be simply divided into two categories. of course this is a generalization, i never said otherwise, but you all (except for that first reply) missed it completely, which is perfectly fine. it is simply a testament into how far people think. you are simply average. nothing wrong with that.
 
Last edited:
It does not matter who you direct something at if I find fault with it.

I do not deny your second point.

Where did you get your third idea from? Disagreement with what you think =/= distaste for anything created from perspective, or opposing perspectives.

It is highly appropriate to point out self delusion in the hope that you will either 1) piss off or 2) learn.

No, your agenda is apparent and nothing to do with what you claim; this was an exercise in narcissism.

Edit: regarding your vocabulary - while it is sometimes useful to wax lyrical, can you not see the folly of doing so on a forum where the vast majority of posters are unlikely to understand you? There is no need to flaunt your supposed intellectual superiority. Indeed, the better man can talk to prince and proletariat, and he does so by communicating in different terms to suit the audience.
 
Last edited:
It does not matter who you direct something at if I find fault with it.

I do not deny your second point.

Where did you get your third idea from? Disagreement with what you think =/= distaste for anything created from perspective, or opposing perspectives.

It is highly appropriate to point out self delusion in the hope that you will either 1) piss off or 2) learn.

No, your agenda is apparent and nothing to do with what you claim; this was an exercise in narcissism.


You disagree with a Nontopical subject, that has nothing to do with the debate, which is abusive, if we had rules you would automatically lose.

Faith leads to peace

i said this

Objectively, faith has nothing to do with it. If anything, faith mixed with ignorance promotes prejudice and segregation.

poliwag2 said this-----proving my pessimist thesis...

but now that i think about it, i think he misinterpreted what i said, are you refering to political peace, because there is no context that supports that was the topic, and being you agree that:

you cannot possibly deny the validity in Religion (faith) bringing peace of mind to its proponents

you well understood the topic, and are simply arguing for no reason, other then to get a reaction. thats twice you are abusive towards the topic.

concluding, how on earth did you get poor Narcesse mixed up with metacognition? why speak, when you have nothing to say?
 
Have you not considered then, that my failure to correctly interpret your comment could also be a failure on your part to communicate? Or are you incapable of such a thing? Also, read my previous edit.

I don't care for reaction and I don't care if you find me abusive. Indeed, I find it a hypocrisy when you yourself have committed ad hominems in this thread. Suppose that I am picking a fight for the sake of it. I would argue that I am doing you a favour by highlighting a character flaw or two. If that gets me infracted, so be it.
 
Have you not considered then, that my failure to correctly interpret your comment could also be a failure on your part to communicate? Or are you incapable of such a thing? Also, read my previous edit.

I don't care for reaction and I don't care if you find me abusive. Indeed, I find it a hypocrisy when you yourself have committed ad hominems in this thread. Suppose that I am picking a fight for the sake of it. I would argue that I am doing you a favour by highlighting a character flaw or two. If that gets me infracted, so be it.

So you speak of character flaws, when you admit to bring an internet troll? have you made a topical comment yet?

as to the ad hominems, i vary the simplification of argumentation depending on the situation, i call it adaptability. calling you average is not a personal attack, anymore than your blatant trolling, except my remarks are topical.

this thread has no hope, half of the posts are myself responding to misconception, and a troll...
 
Wow

I'm inclined to not really care but

1. This debate is vague to say the least and doesn't really seem to be going anywhere any time soon.
2. People participating rather toot their own horn and provoke eachother than debate.
3. I can close this with two strikes right?

W/e I'll leave it open for the time being.
 
My first post was topical. I said what needed to be said while providing a layman's paraphrase. The Panda said everything else.

Feed your ego elsewhere.

My work here is done.
 
Weather or not arguing religious beliefs or lack of belief will bring any chang to anyone, it still is interesting to find out WHY people think theway they do. It helps you understand the mind set that different beliefs entails. So in that regard , it helps you grow as you understand your others more. Its not about changing other beliefs anyway. Its about seing why you think the way you do.
 
Weather or not arguing religious beliefs or lack of belief will bring any chang to anyone, it still is interesting to find out WHY people think theway they do. It helps you understand the mind set that different beliefs entails. So in that regard , it helps you grow as you understand your others more. Its not about changing other beliefs anyway. Its about seing why you think the way you do.


Absolutely. im glad somebody understands what Metacognition is...
 
Back
Top