• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Proxies

Aberrant17

The cake is a lie!!!
Ever been to League, and someone has a fake card in their deck? How about a piece of paper with a Pokemon's name written on it, in a card sleeve? Or a fake card printed from an image on the internet?

These are examples of "proxies": temporary representations of cards a player doesn't actually have for use in their deck. It's actually a common practice at my local League. They justify it by saying that "it's allowed in League," "it's just until I get the card," "I have the card on-order." But is it right?

The purpose of this thread is to discuss whether or not proxies are fair, and if they should be allowed in League (they're obviously not allowed in tournaments). I'm not actually sure at this time if League actually allows proxies; we'll discuss that as well.

My opinion: Use the cards you have. It's not fair that I don't have two fake Claydols while I'm still trying to get them myself. That defeats the purpose of collecting the cards, and it's not fair to the opponent or anyone who actually went through the effort to get the cards. I usually refuse to battle someone just for having a proxy in their deck. League shouldn't condone practices like that.
 
It would be fair if everyone used proxies, but there are some people who pay around 100 dollars for a booster box to try and pull a card they want, or pay 20 dollars for a Lv. X they need. I don't see the big difference between fakes and proxies, except for the fact that proxies is just a lame excuse for using a type of fake cards or just a nicer way of saying it. I know proxies are different in how they are used, but it's no better than fakes, mabye even worse.
 
Proxies should never be allowed IMO. Part of the fun with te tcg is collecting and trading cards to help make a better deck. It's also way to easy for someone to lie saying they have a card on the way.
 
XD Why shouldn't they be allowed? For competitive players, this allows people to save money on cards to figure out if such card will work or not. People often build 10 decks and such for test-playing, and pure proxy decks are common.

If YOU think proxies are unfair, use them yourself. >_>; "OMG I can't get a proxy Claydol, and people might get mad at me!" No. They won't. lol League is for competitive players to practice and to introduce new players to the game, kinda, and are usually separated unless a competitive player needs to earn some League points. League isn't official, sometimes, and it's honestly optional. Play people on chatrooms or RedShark/Apprentice and "lie" about the cards you have. So what if someone lies about a card they will eventually get. It's Pokemon. Get over it. lol

Really, the only times you can complain is if someone has a pure proxy unlimited deck that rapes if it doesn't lose T1, or if someone made up a card and is using it.

~L_X_F
 
Well I'm a person who doesn't use proxies, and I'm not the biggest collector. If I'm against someone who uses proxies, that's unfair. Now if I used proxies against someone who uses them, that'd be fair. And they soil the whole point of TCG. You're not TRADING for the cards, or trading the proxies, they're not CARDS they're paper, and it's not a GAME since there's no game to it, the person with proxies wins easily if the opponent doesn't have much and uses cards they have.
 
I agree with using them to test out a deck maybe once or twice but to have a full Proxie deck is just stupid. If players want to test out a deck with 1 or 2 cards fine try it out and if it works then fine, buy the card and wait till you actually get it, if not don't keep using it in your deck.
 
I'm one of those ppl who use proxies (only 1x ;006; (the good one/Base/SF one) & 1x Claydol (GE)-which is from last yrs Worlds deck).
I use it all the time....mainly coz I don't have an extra Claydol (GE) & I don't want to take out my ;006; from my folder (unless I have to).
My Leauge leader (for Sunday's) doesn't mind at all.
 
Last edited:
If I want to test something, I'd go on Redshark or Apprentice (Both of which I'm trying to figure out) and see how they work, since everyone in there uses cards they don't have.
 
I find it hard to find someone to battle on apprentice. Besides, I feel proxies are totally acceptable. Young players without much money find it hard to get cards they want. If they have an experianced player helping them, they can easily make a proxy deck. And they will probably stop playing pokemon if they go to league every week and get crushed because they can't get the cards they want. Also, like Lucario X Frosslass mentioned, proxies are a great way to test out a card in your deck before unloading your wallet.
 
Last edited:
They justify it by saying that "it's allowed in League," "it's just until I get the card," "I have the card on-order." But is it right?

Why would somebody even do that? I realize that they do it just to be better in the TCG, but it were me, I would want the card, not some terrible quality, obvious fake straight out of my printer.
 
i Don't care if they have it "on order" they need to play fair i honestly do not think any fake cards or proxies should be allowed in the game
 
I think they are perfectly acceptable, but only in limited cases. Sometimes its just not fair on people (especially those who are new to playing Pokémon and have few cards) that they get thrashed time and time again just because the opponent has better and more expensive cards. Because sometimes it's not down to lacking skill, just lacking a material copy of a card.
I have personal experience of this matter. I rejoined the TCG after DP was released (approx GE) and all i head was 1 Torterra tin and 1 Palkia GE deck. I had plenty of the old cards because i have always collected them, but as singles only. Having found out i could only use DP cards, i desperately started buying cards. Now i don't get much money and spending all of my pocket money every week at my local league was big dedication. Yet i just didn't have those brilliant cards like Claydol and Uxie.
I knew how to play the game well so i wasn't a newb, so constantly being defeated by big decks like Dusknoir and Gyarados really put me down. So i had to do something- i made proxies. Not many, just for the 5-6 cards i was missing (Bebe's, Rare Candy, Roseannes, Claydol ect) And it worked. I started winning.
I made it first priority to obtain the cards i needed and switch out the proxies and i eventually did complete my deck. But the extra time i got playing with a proper deck really helped me develop my playing skills.

So there you go ;)
 
Back
Top