• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Rating

Same here. 9/10 It could be better, though. I wish you could reuse exclusive battle themes, like Team Galactic Theme, Cyrus and the admins, and Dialga/Palkia theme. They sounded really good, especially the Cyrus one. They're heard once and never again, kinda like master ball.

And I hate the E4 music. They could of composed a better theme for them instead of recyling the gym leaders'.
 
5/10

To me it seems to have lost it's spark. But that's pretty much 4th Gen right there.
 
I'll be rating it by gen and anime.

1st gen: 8/10
2nd gen: 10/10
3rd gen: 6/10
4th gen: 9/10
Anime: 7/10

Overall Rating: 82/100
 
1st gen: 5/10
Come on, don't say that the graphics were good. They were really bad. And also don't tell me that was all they could do. Gold and Silver were on the same cartridges and were light-years ahead.

2nd gen: 9/10
Much better. I'm telling you, with the improved graphics, the return to Kanto (though far from perfect) and 100 new Pokemon was pretty cool back in the day. Still is.

3rd gen: 8/10
Way better graphics, but a slightly worse plot. The addition of all of the new Pokemon helped, but there was very little replay value after the E4. FR/LG was better, but not perfect either.

4th gen: 9/10
Now we're talking! A decent story, lots of new Pokemon and it just oozes replay value. With the addition of Wi-Fi, competitive battling is opened to a whole new audience. The 3-D (come on, like you weren't impressed when you walked into Gardenia's gym).

5th gen:
Yeah right.
 
duncan said:
1st gen: 5/10
Come on, don't say that the graphics were good. They were really bad. And also don't tell me that was all they could do. Gold and Silver were on the same cartridges and were light-years ahead.
Click to expand...
Red, Blue, and Yellow were on the GameBoy, while Gold, Silver, and Crystal were on the GameBoy Color, which, if I recall correctly, had about twice the memory of the GameBoy cartridges.

Anyways, for me, the first gen is the best, and they slowly become worse, until Pearl and Diamond, where it improves slightly.
 
I'd give it a 9/10. Graphics don't matter. 5 years ago, often graphics were so bad they spoiled a game. Pokemon Green got very bad ratings, and didn't even get released in the USA, one of the reasons being that the graphics were terrible, and numerous people reported that it gave them headaches, but this is 2007, not 1995. No game's graphics is 'bad' anymore.

I think the storylines are getting better to be honest, with Emerald's being the best. Jhoto's was the worst. The character development in the game, for example, was abysmal.
 
SHUCKLE MAN said:
I'd give it a 9/10. Graphics don't matter. 5 years ago, often graphics were so bad they spoiled a game. Pokemon Green got very bad ratings, and didn't even get released in the USA, one of the reasons being that the graphics were terrible, and numerous people reported that it gave them headaches, but this is 2007, not 1995. No game's graphics is 'bad' anymore.

I think the storylines are getting better to be honest, with Emerald's being the best. Jhoto's was the worst. The character development in the game, for example, was abysmal.
Click to expand...
No, Green never got into the US because by the time they decided to make Pokemon worldwide, they already had Blue, which had better graphics.
 
cooldude101 said:
What rating would you give pokemon out of 10? Why? I would give it 9/10 because the graphic could be improved more.;026;;136;
Click to expand...

I like classic graphics better, I'd be pretty ****** if they made it 3-D.


The wortst gen: Probably 2nd. I don't understand why everyone likes to worship it >_>.
 
Last edited:
The games are the same thing every time. So is the anime. =/ I've been dissapointed. 6.5/10
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top