• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

What If?

ChaosMage

Izit cuz I is black?
OK, it's a simple thread, and I know there have been several like it in the past. It's just a hypothetical thread for if the writers went in a different direction for one thing or another. If ANYTHING to do with shipping or competition between the leading ladies could be left out I'd appreciate it- there's plenty of other threads for that! I'll kickstart with a couple.

What if Clefairy was the chosen mascot?
Can you imagine Ash with a Clefairy? Holy hell, that would be even worse than Pikachu! It would rely on an uber metronome all the time no doubt and probably win as many battles as Pikachu does. People would also see the show as even more childish and I think the whole franchise would attract a completely different audience.

What if the AG starter division had been used for Kanto and Johto?
For Kanto, I think the "all three to Ash system" used is the right one, but otherwise Ash would have had Bulbasaur (who probably would have evolved), Brock would have Charmander and Misty would get Squirtle. As another fire and water type I imagine Ash would get Growlithe and Krabby, who might evolve but I can't decide.
 
Yeah, give Brock Charmander...so it could rot. >:)

Ash having Kingler on his mian team would rock! And...maybe for Fire...Magmar? And then YEARS later get Magmortar?
 
hm...what if the show didnt reek like horse butt?

what if they had factured the show more like the ***** or the games?
 
What if they had chosen Brendan and Lukas instead of May and Dawn?

What if they'd made a Colosseum/XD special or two?

What if they hadn't done Orange Islands?

What if they had serious bad guys instead of Jessie, James, and Meowth?

What if Wallace/Janine/Will/Wally/Insert-character-name-here had appeared?
 
What if Ash was the age he should be.
*Imagines shipping episodes and LOTS of them.
 
What if Ash, Pikachu and all the Spearow died from that explosion at the beginning of Pokemon?
*thinks of us following the adventures of Kenta*
 
In answer to Jonah's questions

Q: What if they had chosen Brendan and Lukas instead of May and Dawn?
A: The whole show would be a sausage-fest and the phrase "that show is so gay" would take on a whole new, probably accurate, meaning

Q: What if they'd made a Colosseum/XD special or two?
A: I wouldn't really care. How much of interest could they achieve in one special?

Q: What if they hadn't done Orange Islands?
A: We wouldn't have the magic of Tracey, Togepi would have done ABSOLUTELY nothing, we wouldn't have Snorlax or Politoed, Pidgeot would have been replaced even more quickly, Ash would have to wait all the way until the Johto League to have a six-on-six battle, Brock would have a perfect attendance record, we wouldn't have tasted the sweet honey of possibility by seeing Misty with a Golduck, Misty/prima shipping wouldn't exist (or Tracey/Oak shipping come to think of it), Charizard wouldn't have become obedient until it was too late! FWAH!!! So, overall, I can't decide if it would be good or bad...

Q: What if they had serious bad guys instead of Jessie, James, and Meowth?
A: We did, and they got cocked up. The movies typically have more serious villains

Q: What if Wallace/Janine/Will/Wally/Insert-character-name-here had appeared?
A: We'd have one interesting episode per character. I doubt any of them would recur.
 
Here's an interesting, yet really out-of-this-world what if.
What if Pokemon took place in New Jersey, New York and Pennsylvania?
 
What if Harley wasn't gay?.

What if Dawn had picked Turtwig/Chimchar and not Piplup?

What if Ash had win Indigo, Johto and Hoenn, and lost Orange?.

What if Ash woke up early that day and picked a worthy starter and not Pikachuuu!!! D:.
 
Last edited:
What if all of Ash's released Pokemon went and attacked him?
 
Here's an interesting, yet really out-of-this-world what if.
What if Pokemon took place in New Jersey, New York and Pennsylvania?
They'd be lost in forests even more frequently than they are now. And they'd be training animals, since Pokemon don't exist in our world.

What if Harley wasn't gay?.
He would be lamer. Definitely.

What if Ash woke up early that day and picked a worthy starter and not Pikachuuu!!! D:.
We'd have two DEM Squirtle on the show. And the Squirtle Squad would replace Team Rocket as the main villains, and eventually kill someone.
 
I wouldn't mind seeing the squad kill somebody.
 
Okay, I'll revise that.

What if they Brendan in AG and Lukas in DP instead of Brock?
 
What if... Casey was the Johto Female lead instead of Misty?

What if... Pokemon could devolve as well as evolve (with similar frequency)?

What if... mobile phones were as plentiful in the Pokemon World as they are in this one?
 
What if Ash had caught Magby in Kanto instead of Aipom?
 
Back
Top