• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Why?

Does it seem like I boring or upsetting people? It happens when I'm wiritng Sonic fanfics, I thought Pokemon I had more leeway.

Maybe someone give me some pointers on how to write a good story? Because it feels like I'm boring the audience when I write. And it makes me sad because I dont like PG13 little miss perfect fanfics like everyone else so I think that's why I'm boring people.

Or I'm making people upset by the way I'm portraying characters. I don't know but how can I avoid this in the future? Do I find someone can can review before posting or what not?

I just need some advice.
 
Are you kidding? JX has given you a huge amount of great advice and you seem to be completely ignoring it.

What you're looking for is a beta reader, pretty sure there's a thread to find one, apologies if there's not.
 
Are you kidding? JX has given you a huge amount of great advice and you seem to be completely ignoring it.

What you're looking for is a beta reader, pretty sure there's a thread to find one, apologies if there's not.

I never completely ignore advice. And actually I DID take his/her advice by actually FIXING one of my chapters and adding descriptions to my latest one. I actually did say that I fix it. So I would never do that.



And actually there isnt a thread for it. If there is, then I should apologize.
 
I never completely ignore advice. And actually I DID take his/her advice by actually FIXING one of my chapters and adding descriptions to my latest one. I actually did say that I fix it. So I would never do that.

As a side note, the reason why I haven't commented on your latest chapter is because I just don't know what to tell you anymore (and it might not be just you). I've looked over your revisions, and you still have the chicken-chocolate-staples feel to it with the unexplained contradiction between Giratina's old, "let's mess everything up and take no prisoners" attitude and her new, "let's be scared of everything that moves" attitude. If her childishness is a sign of insanity, sure, that'd be pretty cool, but it just seems like you want both the canon Giratina and the complete opposite in the personality spectrum for no apparent reason. All of your characters end up like this. You want one personality and its exact opposite with nothing in between, and it's just not registering that this isn't so much complex characterization as it is a mess of different traits that don't work well together. And I'm not sure what to tell you in order to have this make sense because I just don't think it's getting across in the simplest way possible.

Unfortunately, that's the biggest issue preventing you from getting a good story together: the characters just don't make sense. You're relying on your characterization in order to get the story across (because this fic is all about Giratina growing up), but the base just isn't there.

Of course, it also doesn't help that you do a lot of telling instead of showing, and things just sort of pop out without any warning. I mean, the majority of your fic is dialogue, which means all we're imagining are characters talking at each other. For example, the scene where Gothitelle notices the Griseous Orb. We're not told where the Griseous Orb is or even that Giratina's holding it all (because we're also not made aware of the fact that she's still in her Origin Forme). So, we have nothing to picture, and the question seems out of nowhere. Then, Giratina's encounter with the robot, despite it being a fight scene, lacks any sort of excitement because we're not made aware that there's a giant robot in front of her until it starts confronting her, and then, we're not really given any details as to what it's actually doing.

There's also the issue of suspending canon for the sake of plot. I mean, you just don't want to dump a canon character's personality just because you feel like having a villain with qualities he doesn't have, especially if the antagonist in question is popular with other fans. Also, giving Gothitelle Close Combat is a lot like giving Charizard Explosion. It just comes off as a cop-out.

But I told you most of this already, which is actually what Antithesis meant in his earlier post. These are the tips you're looking for in order to improve your work (besides "please proofread"); I just can't think of a way to explain them to you any simpler than I have been, which is why I didn't just tell them to you in another post on your story.

So, new advice. Instead of wondering why people in the Sonic fandom didn't really like your stories and why you're not that popular in the Pokémon fandom either, it might help to go back over what people told you and read it carefully. If you don't understand something, pull that quote out and ask. We don't know what you don't get if you never tell us, after all.

It might also help to read a lot of fanfiction to see how they handle characterization. We have a lot of good recs already up in the stickies thanks to the Fanfiction Awards. Look through those and find the stories that placed in the characterization entries and then go from there.

As for a beta thread, technically, we had one, but we don't anymore. The best way to get a beta is just to pay attention to who's reviewing (in detail, not the ones who are just giving people one or two lines of feedback) and then ask nicely privately. Some of them will tell you no, but there's others who would be happy to do it. Yes, it's a good idea to get a beta, especially if you're getting a lot of negative feedback. A beta reader is usually someone patient enough to go over your work with you and offer suggestions on how to shape things before you post your work, so you can learn a lot from a mentor like that. (I'm unfortunately a bit on the busy side, so I'm not taking any clients right now. Not that I'm insinuating you'd ask me or anything.)

So, yeah. Bunch of tips. Not sure if any of them will actually help you because I'm not sure how many of my tips got through to you in the first place. But if it helps, there you go.

Finally, for future reference so there's no pronoun confusion, I'm a girl.
 
Last edited:
Wait, JX IS A GIRL? Everyone who I thought was male is turning out to be female! Eh, soon I'll be suddenly changed to female too by the looks of things.

I have a rule for this kind of thing. If they're good, they're probably female, unless previously stated.

As for Silver, I'll use myself as an example.

The combined amount of reviews I got for my first three or four fics was three or four. Do you know how many I asked for in the review thread? (not sure if it's still around) Two or three. That's right, when I started posting fics, hardly anyone actually commented on them, and if they did, it's because I asked them to.

Would you rather have the attention you've gotten, or what I had and be pretty much ignored?

I didn't let it get to me, sure I was a little annoyed that no one seemed to care about my fics (the arrogance of being a writer I suppose), I decided that people would pay attention to my fics if they were better, so I worked on improving myself and my writing.

That involved paying attention to writers that I liked, seeing what they did and seeing if I could do something similar in my own way. Reading published books, reading writing advice, improving my knowledge of grammar and writing conventions (this I did in school on an English Language course)

We're all still learning, but if you know what YOU like to read, then that's what you should write.

Write for yourself, don't let anybody else decide what you should write.
 
So, new advice. Instead of wondering why people in the Sonic fandom didn't really like your stories and why you're not that popular in the Pokémon fandom either, it might help to go back over what people told you and read it carefully. If you don't understand something, pull that quote out and ask. We don't know what you don't get if you never tell us, after all.

Well there was somethings you said which I didn't understand. I understood the description part and in my newer story, I made sure I did that. I also understood the soup concept of yours.

What I didn't understand was the contradiction of personalities, which I've always had a problem with even in the Sonic fandom. It's not just here. It seemed I was making X character a cross between themselves and another character. Like I was making Ghetsis a cross between himself, Zero (from Pokemon) and Robotnik (from Sonic). I see different ideas and I corporate them in. If I said that I didn't understand, then you'd hate me which I am trying to avoid reviewers hating me.


on a side note: I always associate with being smart with being a guy
 
on a side note: I always associate with being smart with being a guy
Yeeeah, not only is this kind of offensive but it's also just woefully inaccurate when it comes to fandom, period. By far the majority of esteemed fanfic writers/critics/otherwise experienced members of the community tend to be female. There are more guys in the Pokémon fandom than many others, but there still tend to be more girls taking fanfiction seriously.

Which isn't to say it isn't easy to mistake people's gender on the internet for a wide variety of reasons anyway, but if your mental association just goes smart=guy, you'd do well to try to get rid of it. :/


The contradiction of personalities thing basically means that the character as a whole needs to make sense. If their personality seems radically different in different situations and there isn't some consistent, sensible underlying reason for it that sprouts naturally from the character's deeper mental processes, it will just feel like they have no real personality at all.

For example, it can make sense if a character who used to be a happy-go-lucky idealist goes through some kind of absolute hell and emerges from it bitter and cynical, because then what happened to him explains why he lost his faith in the goodness of the world. It also makes sense if the character is now only privately bitter and cynical but puts up a facade of being a happy-go-lucky idealist when he's around others because he doesn't want them to lose hope, even if he himself has. It does not make sense if a character is a happy-go-lucky idealist one chapter and bitter and cynical the next just because that serves your plot better. Neither does it make sense if the character is a happy-go-lucky idealist except that when he's wearing a yellow hat he turns bitter and cynical (unless the yellow hat is some sort of mind-control device).

If you couldn't write up a single, psychological explanation of what makes your character tick that always applies and that doesn't contain arbitrary exceptions (again, there can be circumstances that change the character's behaviour, but only if there is a clear psychologically sound reason the character would behave that way in those circumstances), your character is probably inconsistent.
 
Last edited:
First off, I'd like to thank Dragonfree for explaining it better than I can. Seriously, those words were just not getting out of my head sensibly.

Also, to add:

If I said that I didn't understand, then you'd hate me which I am trying to avoid reviewers hating me.

Why would a reviewer hate you for saying you didn't understand? O_o If you said it nicely enough, any reviewer would be glad to try finding better ways to explain things to you, or they'd ask around to see if someone can explain it better. After all, everyone's gone through a newbie stage where they didn't completely understand everything, and anyway, it shows us that you're actually paying attention to what we're saying.

What's not cool is continuing to make the same mistakes over and over again because you don't understand -- or worse, refusing to acknowledge what we're saying or arguing against our points without completely getting what we're talking about. If you just make the same mistakes over and over again without asking for clarification, it says to us that you're blowing us off, and the arguing or completely ignoring our advice parts? Says to us that you have no interest in listening to what we have to say. Because a fanfiction community is, well, a community, that means that communication isn't just a one-way street. A reader's job isn't just to sit and read your story; it's also to offer feedback. And if the writer doesn't want to listen to a reader or implies that she doesn't want to listen, then that's a problem because it gets the reader frustrated. After all, that kind of relationship is a lot like trying to make friends with someone who just doesn't want to acknowledge that you're there or that what you say is valuable.

I guess what I'm trying to say is it never hurts to ask, but it always hurts not to ask. No one's going to hate you or think you're annoying just because you don't understand something, but they will if you don't understand something and proceed to make the same mistakes over and over again instead of just asking for help.
 
I have a rule for this kind of thing. If they're good, they're probably female, unless previously stated.

Does that mean I'm a girl? *gets shot for arrogance*

;D

Anyway, to the topic. A sad but inevitable fact of fanfiction (and perhaps all fiction) is that people tend to read stories which cover topics that excite them. For example, if you give a Sailor Moon story to a flock of LOTR aficionados, chances are it won't get read.

Similarly, if you write a fanfic about Giratina... by anthropomorphising her into a little girl, then many people won't read it. Why? Because most Pokemon fanfics aren't about Giratina as a little girl, nor does canon give any indication that Giratina is like that. Yes, as with any story, if you have good skills, you could probably pull off even the absurdiest ideas. The LOTR people will read a Sailor Moon story if it is top-calibre, with excellent characterisations and subplots.

But chances are, you're not a Gustave Flaubert, and the strange idea won't take flight. This will be reflected in reviews.

My advice for you would be to write more layman ideas for now, at least until your skills improve a bit more. After you accumulate more experience, perhaps you could write that awesome Giratina story you dreamt of. :)

Keep fighting. Never give up.
 
Back
Top