• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

2 type attacks?

Emporar

Rocket rules.
Would attacks having two types work? (like blaze kick being fire/fighting)
Please comment!
 
Seems..
Over powered?

Imagine electric\grass on water.
 
The problem is it simply doesn't work for working out the type weaknesses. It would overcomplicate the game to a degree where people would get infuriated.

Anyway, this sort of thread has been done too many times before for me to do a better argument, so good day to you all.

ungulateman
 
Far too complicated to really work out.

Hmmm.... I have a Fire/Fighting Pokemon, and he's using a Fire/Fighting move. I'm using it against a Rock/Bug. So.. half damage on Rock and super effective on Bug, so that's null, wait, Fighting's super effective against Rock but half on Bug, but I've got STAB twice, wait is that 1.5 x 1.5, or something else?

BRAIN BREAK.

It'd also be too broken, as I point out with double STAB.
 
This theory is similar to the paradox of having three types, since many Pokemon would be valid for such a thing, e.g. Heracross: Bug/Fighting/Flying, Beedrill/Dustox: Bug/Poison/Flying.

It wouldn't necessarily over-complicate the system since this is quite easy to achieve in programming, but it will certainly alter the game to a degree where it won't be as enjoyable as before. Nintendo certainly wouldn't want to jeopardize their profits simply because of an non-business-oriented individual from some fanbased forum.

But don't be disappointed, this can be done. All Nintendo would really need to do is tweak the battle algorithm so it includes these checks. However, the game will be unbalanced from my understanding since only certain moves will be dual-typed. You can't necessarily kill two birds with one stone in this case. Maybe you'll make your own rehashed version of a Pokemon game that incorporates this concept =).
 
Last edited:
Things are good the way they are. This would only make things uneccessarily complicated.
 
Yes. I have a problem beating paras, so a fire/flying move by ho-oh is especially appreciated.
 
No, it's just like Triple Type. One side will become beyond Uber and the other side would bearly even sting.
 
Yes. I have a problem beating paras, so a fire/flying move by ho-oh is especially appreciated.

If you can't beat a paras with ho-oh (or any other fire or flying type) there's something wrong...............
 
I think it would make the moves too powerful, like ~Spacial_Rendation~ said, its like the triple type thingo... I want a challenge when battling, this would make it too easy..
 
I'm pretty sure pikadon was joking.

Probably. But you can never tell with this forum. The things some people have said and meant it..............
 
If you took my words for real something is already wrong.

Trust me. Some people on this forum have made claims just as bad as that and meant it e.g. "all non-damaging moves suck because in the series they only use attacking moves" or "evolutions ruin standalone pokemon such as Yanma and Tangela".
Its hard to tell if people are actually joking when they say things on this forum.
 
THis type of suggestion are heard before and rejected by most
 
Trust me. Some people on this forum have made claims just as bad as that and meant it e.g. "all non-damaging moves suck because in the series they only use attacking moves" or "evolutions ruin standalone pokemon such as Yanma and Tangela".
Its hard to tell if people are actually joking when they say things on this forum.

You can usually tell by the grammar and spelling of the statement.
 
Hmmmmmm. More than one type attacks could make for some interesting battles. But of course there would be a lot of complications if an attack was super effective times 4. EG. Maccargo hit by a move with type water and ground. But it is an interesting concept. I would like to see it in some games in the future. Especially with tri attack.
 
Back
Top