• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Conscription

Catatonic

Internet Tough Guy
I imagine this could be a pretty good topic for debate. Many different issues can be argued about it, but I'll start it off with:

Should conscription be put in place in the modern world, particularly in the United States?

Personal opinion is no, it shouldn't, because I feel it restricts the right of people drafted.
 
The draft? No, I don't agree with it at all. Some people are not cut out for the military, and it's a violation of that person's rights to be forced into a war that they may not have even wanted.
 
I mean technically it is in place its just a matter of when they decide to start the draft. Once you get turn eighteen you have to register through the selective service system. But should a draft be allowed? Currently I think not because we have more than enough volunteer troops. However if WWIII were to break out I could see it being necessary. Technically its a duty as a citizen to defend your country
 
I can see in which a draft would be needed, for example to defend against a invading force that could destroy your country. There are some times in which the need for a fighting force far out weighs a person's right to choose to go to war or not. Those in France or Britain fighting desperately to save their country against Nazi Germany for example.
 
If the United States government operated like the Swiss, I would definitely support it. But nowadays? No, I dont. I believe it is an individuals choice whether or not they want to join the armed forces. There are many ways you can serve your country besides the military. I want to join the military anyway though.

The only way I can see where its needed is if there is a large invading force attacking us but im sure our local militias and State militaries would step up to the plate.
 
It's deemed constitutional, and I don't see the Supreme Court changing that any time soon. I also don't see a draft happening in our lives. I believe that a draft is unconstitutional and that it's too much of a stretch to be an implied power, but I don't really consider it something that's worth fighting over.
 
absolutly not, you should not force boys/man to do such a thing it is highly disgusting, you are forcing people to die.
 
it is constitutional, but no politician in their right mind would vote for one if they want to get re-elected. not to mention that were scaling don the size of the armed forces, now that were not seriously involved in Iraq (and sooner or later Afghanistan) due to budget cuts. and military life isnt for everyone. theres a statistic somewhere I cant find that only 25% or so of americans (at least less than half) are capable of military service, either because theyre not fit, theyre pacifists, have a criminal record, or used drugs. and in combat do you really want your life dependent on someone who never wanted to be in the military in the first place and would shoot their foot to get out?

however there are some arguments for setting up a mandatory public service requirement, where you would have to do something with the peace corps/ americorps, military service, or religious work for 2 years or something. germany has something like this IIRC. of course, it is kind of an infringement on personal freedom

absolutly not, you should not force boys/man to do such a thing it is highly disgusting, you are forcing people to die.
youre actually more likely to die in a car accident than in the military
 
Last edited:
youre actually more likely to die in a car accident than in the military
but driving in a car is a personal choice ;)
 
Depends on the circumstance. If the country is being invaded, that's a pretty good reason to call on everyone to protect their home. But for military exercises that we're having right now, that the government hesitates to even call war, a draft isn't necessary. The draft is definately an infringement upon personal rights, and until those the continuity of those rights are in danger, we shouldn't need it.
 
In my opinion, the draft doesn't need to be brought back, and therefore shouldn't be brought back. Things are calming down with the war, on our part, concerning Iraq and (somewhat) in Afgahnistan. Really, I think that even if another war did start up, a draft shouldn't be put into action because there's already so many serving in the military service. Plus, as others have already brought up, some people really aren't suited for Military Service for many possible reasons.
 
The simplest answer to this is no, with as many volunteers as we have today I don't believe we will use the draft in our lifetime(s). Plus, Private Military Firms are a BOOMING business currently, nearly half of the people in Iraq right now are contracted through the government. So with all these trained 'mercenaries' that know how to fight and be useful on a battlefield the draft is almost obsolete.
Think of it as do you want a man trained in combat by a retired veteran or a random businessman off Wall Street to go fight in WWIII? I for one, trust the country's safety with a paid contractor
 
Ethics aside, all volunteer based armies in the world have one other thing in common; they are highly professional. The USA, Australia, Britain etc all have well trained, disciplined, thoughtful soldiers because their top brass know that they can't rely on "meat grinder" tactics that conscription may encourage. Also, if one nation uses a draft, you then have to deal with low morale, deserters, lack of willpower and having to waste training and resources on a person who has no wish to be there; if I were a soldier, I wouldn't want the guy beside me to be a gibbering, terrified wreck with thoughts of desertion. Conscription is only necessary when a whole nation is threatened with a massive attack or is engaged in total war (like WWII).

Both were and are unlikely in the post-WWII world.
 
Back
Top