• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Equality

I think most people see the current relationship between humans and pokemon as somewhat immoral. That is, pokemon being taken against their will, keeping them confined most of the time and forcing them to fight other pokemon for no real purpose other than to prove their trainer's tactical brilliance or idiocy. Even the games and anime have some room for that opinion and it has been expressed... a little. So what if the human element of the pokemon world suddenly realized "Hey, pokemon are sentient. They have expressed their ability to think so many times it isn't funny, and saved our arses countless times" and decided "we realy should try to seek better relations with them." There are a million and one good reasons for doing so. Not the least of which is the very saftey of humanity. We've all read the revolution fanfics, and pokemon revolution against humans is not unthinkable. In small scale it happened with Mewtwo. Plus I think the exploitation must run deeper than what is shown. I for one and am convinced that some kind of mind control device exists in the pokeballs and badges that silph isn't talking about. It's the only way you can explain why most pokemon are so obediant as soon as they're caught. Think about it. Is it like some unwritten rule that a pokemon caught must obey? Did humans and pokemon sign a pact or something? Of course not, yet especialy in the game as soon as a newly caught pokemon comes out of the ball it's your gung-ho servant. That is, unless the pokeball's mind device needs another badge to make it stronger.

So, what if humans decided to cast away the exploitation and welcome pokemon as equals. How could this be done? It creates some unique problems, like regards food. What will humans eat? Will everyone become vegans? I sure hope not, but in the real world at least it has always been our unwritten rule that if ever we found and animal that could think we wouldn't eat it. So the question should be, are all pokemon fully sentient, or are some more than others? If so I could see an alliance between humans and the more carnivorous types who would probably be smarter.

Another problem would be social. How do you intergrate pokemon and human society? Could a sentient pokemon vote for the president. Could he run for president? What about communication? What about occupation?
 
I think humans and pokémon already have good relations. I consider such small towns as an example of this. Humans and pokémon live together in harmony, so humans don't knock down huge amounts of land to put cities in. Even large cities in the game are only a couple of dozen houses large. Towns go where they fit, which is a clear sign that the builders want to keep the balance of nature and human.

Pokémon recognise this too, and are happy enough to be caught and trained. It only only improves themselves, but also benefits the trainers (bragging rights, mostly).

But in the end, pokémon don't interfere with the human world (such as politics as you suggested), and humans don't interfere with the pokémon world.

Of course, every so often you'll find an exception. Team Galactic, Mewtwo, etc..
 
I think humans and pokémon already have good relations. I consider such small towns as an example of this. Humans and pokémon live together in harmony, so humans don't knock down huge amounts of land to put cities in. Even large cities in the game are only a couple of dozen houses large. Towns go where they fit, which is a clear sign that the builders want to keep the balance of nature and human.

Pokémon recognise this too, and are happy enough to be caught and trained. It only only improves themselves, but also benefits the trainers (bragging rights, mostly).

But in the end, pokémon don't interfere with the human world (such as politics as you suggested), and humans don't interfere with the pokémon world.

Of course, every so often you'll find an exception. Team Galactic, Mewtwo, etc..
 
Its an interesting point, but I get the impression (especially in the games) that most pokemon are violent by nature, as they attack anyone who walks by them. So as long as the trainer treats them right and trains them to be stronger they feel equal to them.

As far as eating goes, there was a book in the library in Diamond and Pearl that said when a pokemon is eaten another one is born to replace it, so its ok to eat them as long as the killer puts their body to good use.

And some Pokemon are already intergrated into society, such as machokes being used for industry and moving. However it is a good point as to whether they have to same rights as humans. Do they get paid? Or are they slaves to their bosses?
 
According to some lore from D/P:
Long ago, when Sinnoh had just been made, Pokémon and humans led seperate lives. That is not to say they did not help each other. No, indeed they did. They supplied each other with goods, and supported each other. A Pokémon proposed to the others to always be ready to help humans. It asked that Pokémon be ready to appear before humans always. Thus, to this day, Pokémon appear to us if we venture into tall grass.
If this can be believed, then a Pokemon appearing in the wild basically means it's volunteering to work for a worthy trainer.
 
yeah and another folklore states that pokemon and humans were really close to equals to the point that we ate at the same table, that is why pokemon grow more powerful with friendship not mindcontrol and technology has allowed for more safty i mean if your walking with your severly weak caterpie and a hungry skarmory flies by your in trouble poke balls allow trainers to provide more protection to their partners not slaves.
 
I mainly agree with Maruno. You can see that, though nearly fully sentient, Pokemon are not involved in the kind of societal behavior humans are. They are strictly wild animals (not in a dark sense, merely that they are natural creatures), and don't follow or participate in human-level communities.

There are instances in which Pokemon are involved in human lives, outside of battling, however. They can be kept as pets, or caught and simply half-trained, which is what I expect is the case with the moving Machokes. This doesn't equate with any sort of slavery, to me. When you pick up a stray dog, you feed it and provide it health and safety, and in return you enjoy its company and perhaps teach it to do tricks or tasks (i.e: fetching slippers or guarding the yard). That is a relationship built upon mutual friendship, not mutual service. I think it's the same with Pokemon.
 
Your topic hits points that make me say "what?".
In any case I think the obvious anwser that everyone can and will say is that.
"It's a game. Logic and Fiction don't mix. Even Reality doesn't mix with logic sometimes."
 
They can be kept as pets, or caught and simply half-trained, which is what I expect is the case with the moving Machokes. This doesn't equate with any sort of slavery, to me.
It could even be suggested that the moving Machokes are the runts, since they're willing to belong to a moving service rather than training extensively up on mountains lifting boulders and the like. In that case, the movers are helping them, by providing them a job and a life. The Machokes get to stay out of potentially harmful encounters with wild pokémon (being less or completely unable to defend themselves), and the movers get a strong humanoid creature to help them move things. They may be runts, but they still have their muscles.

Another example would be Misty's Psyduck, which suffers from a chronic headache (unlike normal Psyduck, I believe).

It's certainly not slavery, in any case. The movers will take good care of the Machoke.
 
I don't get the feeling Pokémon are sentient in the games. When reading the Pokédex entries I get the feeling that they are all mere animals with the same instincts and intelligence as them. The most intelligent among them, like Lapras, probably have an intelligence simular to dolphins or apes.
 
I don't get the feeling Pokémon are sentient in the games. When reading the Pokédex entries I get the feeling that they are all mere animals with the same instincts and intelligence as them. The most intelligent among them, like Lapras, probably have an intelligence simular to dolphins or apes.
 
Meh.

You're forgetting Poke'mon are NOT animals.

Compared to our animals, Poke'mon are extremely intelligent beings. And...they seem to enjoy fighting. Look at the anime battles, until they faint, they are ALL smiling. They are having fun.

Not to mention, in most cases, they are considered as friends. They get to see the world, get stronger, have much more security than they would in the wild, and are free to leave when and if they want. They have the choice to fight or not to fight.

They are not slaves, they are partners.

~Gotta save `em, gotta, save `em all...~
 
Presicely *spelling? pokemon are our friends and partners not slaves now excuse me i'm going to start making posters with "Save the Pokemon" everywhere
 
The entire purpose of the games are to fight with Pokemon. There's no use complaining about "equality" when Nintendo is obviously not gonna change a thing. Some people may care about this, but I can safely say that I don't.
 
Another example would be Misty's Psyduck, which suffers from a chronic headache (unlike normal Psyduck, I believe).

No, if the dexes and such are acurate, that's normal, Psyduck gets a headache from using it's powers, Misty may just be overworking hers.
 
pokemon if wanted too could they could just run away when you send them out all they would have to is run away and then they'd be free. so this brings up the point that being inside of a pokeball cannot be all that bad and that they generally have a uncanny sense of trust and loyalty back in the first season we the charmander wouldnt leave his original trainer
 
pokemon if wanted too could they could just run away when you send them out all they would have to is run away and then they'd be free. so this brings up the point that being inside of a pokeball cannot be all that bad and that they generally have a uncanny sense of trust and loyalty back in the first season we the charmander wouldnt leave his original trainer
 
pokemon if wanted too could they could just run away when you send them out all they would have to is run away and then they'd be free. so this brings up the point that being inside of a pokeball cannot be all that bad and that they generally have a uncanny sense of trust and loyalty back in the first season we the charmander wouldnt leave his original trainer
 
Back
Top