It's too late for May to come back as a main character. In fact, she "sealed her fate" (or something like that) the moment she and Max left. May left because she wanted to travel alone (and do change her training style). Well, in the show at least.
Since the writers took her off the show for advertising purposes (having Hikari come as the coordinator), they wouldn't get rid of Hikari for May- that'd be replacing a
4th generation character with a
3rd generation character for the
5th generation season. And as much as I like May, I don't see any purpose for her being back in the main cast after being gone for so long. None at all. And what would she do if Hikari stayed? Hikari already took her role as the coordinator of the group, and the writers have promoted her beyond belief. (Or something like that.) May can't just contradict everything she said and boot Hikari off the show and join up with Ash again. If she did, that'd barely be any better than the writers taking her out of the main cast.
(By the way, Hikari staying for another generation would probably be my most prefered option. Her leaving for another coordinator wouldn't satisfy things. It's not like I'd laugh at other Hikari fans if that happened. The main problem of her staying is that the other Hikari fans would be saying how great it was that Hikari was staying and that advertising didn't matter because "Hikari's such a great character", and I'm not saying that she isn't, but that contradicts what everyone was saying about May "having to go" because of advertisement.)
The "character development" thing is also enough for her to keep May off the show as a cast member. She can't just say she wants to travel alone and just come back as a permanent cast member. That'd just rub in the fact that she only left because of advertisement. (That's also the same reason why we shouldn't see May have permanent cast members with her in Johto.)
This is why I've been saying for the millionth time how May
should have stayed in the group. I'm
NOT saying that D/P would automatically be this great series if May had stayed in the group- I'm saying that I think that her staying would've been the basic thing that was supposed to happen. (And now for further controversy...) I'd have rather seen Drew and Harley head for Johto and let May have Nozomi as one of many new rivals. (I
know somebody's gonna react to that.) Then Hikari could do something even better, and fans would (hopefully) love her anyway. She could still dress in different costumes, but then again, May would've too. (And speaking of that, I don't think that May being in the contest dresses would've made the contests a whole lot better. I just don't think that wearing dresses are the main things that differentiate these Sinnoh contests.) It's not like May staying
has to involve Hikari leaving, and it's not like the gang
has to only have one girl (well, maybe the writers think otherwise, but...). Why it seems like many people think like this is beyond me. (Or maybe it's just me, I don't know...) My Ash/Hikari/May/Brock idea would've had these things.
- May stay and do contests
- Hikari do something new (making her MORE interesting)
- Two-girl interaction
- If you hated one girl, you'd have had the other (if you hate both, you're doomed)
And more. But she left, and so she can't come back as a main character anymore, IMO. Because May is gone, all I can wish is that May does really well in Johto (or at least does something worthwhile) and that Hikari does more to differentiate herself (not to mention do some kind of really special act that would make her unforgetable). Then again, I wished that May had stayed, but...
Of course, I'm all for cameo appearances. Maybe she could have an Emerald-like outfit (replace all the green with purple or dark blue) when she appeared again. I'd like to see how much she's grown (
AS A TRAINER! A TRAAAAAINEEEER!!!). But not as a main cast member.
(The reason I keep[ emphasizing that I wish she should have stayed is that I don't want to be thought of as another person upset about her departure but wanting her to come back.)