On premise 3, isn't it possible that you know of the most (insert abstract concept here) in the universe, but you don't know that said thing is the most (insert abstract concept here)?
Yes, but if that is the case then it still means that there is an absolute form of (insert abstract concept here), the only difference is that I can see it. we could still use it to measure (insert absract concept) and indeed it would be easier.
On premise 4 and 5, can you rule out the possibility that there is something that is as (insert abstract concept here) as something else? Do you truly expect me to believe that everything in the universe can be ranked neatly in terms of how much or how little of an abstract concept it represents? What if there's a tie as to how much of (abstract concept here) there is between two, or possibly more, objects?
Even if that is the case it doesn't actually defeat my argument. Just because things can be the same amount of goodness, does not mean therefore that all things
are the same amount of goodness. I can be the same height as someone. That does not mean that everyone in the world is the same height as me. So I can still say that there are other people taller than me, for example.
Which reminds me. Is this more of a chair than this? What about this? On a scale of one to chair, how do you rank this one?
This fails as an argument when you realise that if the form of chair exists and I could "see it" then I
actually could tell you which one is more chair like. Your argument is based on the fact that
I can't rank them, but that is only because I don't know the form of chair, not because they can't be ranked.
Can you say that I love my girlfriend any more than you love yours, if you have one? Can you tell me which work of art is the best in the world and why? Can you tell me which band produces the best music in the world? Can you tell me which place in the world is the most tranquil? Well, can you? Better yet, tell me the top 5 most tranquil places in the world in order. Can't do it can you?
No I can't, but if I could see the forms of those things then I
could.
However, because I failed to do so at the start of this debate, and I probably should have. I believe that socially morals
are subjective because no one has "seen" the forms. People can have wrong morals, there's just no way of proving that.
Premise 1: Matters of opinion can NOT be wrong.
Faulty from the get-go. Look at all the debates about God in this very board. Are you saying that both the thiests and the athiests are right at the same time?
Premise 2: People have very different morals
So? People have very different answers to exam questions. They can still be wrong.
Premise 3: People have very different opinions
See above
Premise 4: Opinions can be influenced by culture, friends, etc.
So if my culture and friends told me that Martin Luther King's real name was Jesse Jackson would I be right?
Premise 5: People with TOTALLY different opinions and morals grew up in different enviroments.
Yes.
Premise 6: Different enviroments cause different influences.
Yes.
Premise 7: Influences shape opinion and morals
Yes.
Conclusion: Morals are opinionated, and as such, can not be wrong.
Opinions however clearly can be wrong. My opinion that you are a badger is more than likely not correct. But I can still hold it. The only difference is that people can see you are not a badger. Therefore you can prove my opinion wrong. Just as, if someone could see the form of the good then they could prove my morals wrong.