• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Morality

Status
Not open for further replies.
The thing is, even if absolute morality exists, who knows what 'right' or 'wrong?' Maybe the God(ess), God(esse)s, or divine force that rules the universe (I'm going to assume it's a toss up) WANT us to murder, rape, and pillage? How are we poor, ignorant mortals to know what the divine really think?
 
eh, i dont think deities have anything on the matter personally. yeah, they created the universe, but morals are still abstract. people will still find murder wrong even if god came down and ordered us. our opinions are simply from our upbringing and evolution; not god.
 
Perhaps, but even then, what IS right and wrong? We still have not clue.
 
On premise 3, isn't it possible that you know of the most (insert abstract concept here) in the universe, but you don't know that said thing is the most (insert abstract concept here)?
Yes, but if that is the case then it still means that there is an absolute form of (insert abstract concept here), the only difference is that I can see it. we could still use it to measure (insert absract concept) and indeed it would be easier.

On premise 4 and 5, can you rule out the possibility that there is something that is as (insert abstract concept here) as something else? Do you truly expect me to believe that everything in the universe can be ranked neatly in terms of how much or how little of an abstract concept it represents? What if there's a tie as to how much of (abstract concept here) there is between two, or possibly more, objects?
Even if that is the case it doesn't actually defeat my argument. Just because things can be the same amount of goodness, does not mean therefore that all things are the same amount of goodness. I can be the same height as someone. That does not mean that everyone in the world is the same height as me. So I can still say that there are other people taller than me, for example.

Which reminds me. Is this more of a chair than this? What about this? On a scale of one to chair, how do you rank this one?
This fails as an argument when you realise that if the form of chair exists and I could "see it" then I actually could tell you which one is more chair like. Your argument is based on the fact that I can't rank them, but that is only because I don't know the form of chair, not because they can't be ranked.

Can you say that I love my girlfriend any more than you love yours, if you have one? Can you tell me which work of art is the best in the world and why? Can you tell me which band produces the best music in the world? Can you tell me which place in the world is the most tranquil? Well, can you? Better yet, tell me the top 5 most tranquil places in the world in order. Can't do it can you?
No I can't, but if I could see the forms of those things then I could.

However, because I failed to do so at the start of this debate, and I probably should have. I believe that socially morals are subjective because no one has "seen" the forms. People can have wrong morals, there's just no way of proving that.

Premise 1: Matters of opinion can NOT be wrong.
Faulty from the get-go. Look at all the debates about God in this very board. Are you saying that both the thiests and the athiests are right at the same time?

Premise 2: People have very different morals
So? People have very different answers to exam questions. They can still be wrong.

Premise 3: People have very different opinions
See above

Premise 4: Opinions can be influenced by culture, friends, etc.
So if my culture and friends told me that Martin Luther King's real name was Jesse Jackson would I be right?

Premise 5: People with TOTALLY different opinions and morals grew up in different enviroments.
Yes.

Premise 6: Different enviroments cause different influences.
Yes.

Premise 7: Influences shape opinion and morals
Yes.

Conclusion: Morals are opinionated, and as such, can not be wrong.
Opinions however clearly can be wrong. My opinion that you are a badger is more than likely not correct. But I can still hold it. The only difference is that people can see you are not a badger. Therefore you can prove my opinion wrong. Just as, if someone could see the form of the good then they could prove my morals wrong.
 
i think when strants talks about opinions, they are only wrong when they conflict with facts.
 
My goodness. I typed so much up from the last thread, I'll be making a few quotes. I will reiterate my main argument. I believe that there are moral relativists and that there are moral absolutes. An example of relativist morals would be whether you think stealing to burn CD's. An example of an absolute moral would a situation say, your family was brutally murdered and raped and the person that did it, did it for fun. You will not find a soul on this planet that agrees that murdering and raping ones family is good. Perhaps a few satists but then why should we give them the BOTD when they don't even argue for what they think is moral in the first place? If morals are a human construct, and every person agrees on whether a certian moral is good or bad, then that particular moral is objective. Period. Panda, if you want to bring up hypothetical cases again, you may do that.

Before you go off at me I addressed the power of hypothetical situations in the God thread. Simply, if you or anyone is trying to prove something a posteriori which are so evidently doing, you must show that the hypothetical situations that would discount your case are impossible. As long as they remain possible your argument is not proven. Also, I noticed you chose to use the word "objective", while in your next paragraph you give a definition. If morality is "objective", then why did you bother with an a posteriori argument for it!

Second I will point out that simply because there are humans that disagree with certian morals, that doesn't mean that the morals in question are not absolute. It merely casts doubt on whether they are or not. By the very definition of objective, it is true regardless of another persons opinion. So you are dead wrong in saying ____ moral is absolute because ____ people in _____ country disagree. That's hardly an argument for moral relativism.

No it's not, rather it's an argument against the use of a posteriori arguments for the absolutism of higher morality.
 
i think when strants talks about opinions, they are only wrong when they conflict with facts.
Thank you, GA. What I meant is, so long as you do not try to make your opinions a fact, they are not wrong. For example, if I thought that gravity did not exist, I'd be wrong. But if I thought grilled cheese sandwiches tasted good (and they do!), I could not be wrong, it is an OPINION.
Fact: People die.
Opinion: Some people deserve to die.
The two can be related, they just aren't the same.
 
Ok, now tell me why they can't be the same. Do not just say "because they are opinions". That is not a good enough answer.

Tell me honestly, with logically thought out evidence why opinions on morals can't be facts. I have shown that morals are indeed facts (or at least, no one has come up with a good refutation) so surely opinions based on them are also facts.

Or at least, if my hypothesis on the forms is correct, then at least acknowledge that morals are absolute.
 
if morals are facts, then you can logically prove someone wrong in the morals they currently have.

so how would you go about proving someone's moral wrong logically if this so-called form existed?
 
So? People have very different answers to exam questions. They can still be wrong.

The above comparison, I should say, is quite ridiculous- simply because there are wrong answers and right answers to exam questions and that's what's absolute. We cannot change the fact that 'diffusion' (for example) has been established as the movement of particles from an area of high concentration to an area of relatively lower concentration- you either state that and get your marks is an exam or not.

On the other hand, 'Good' and 'Bad' morals are not absolute. They are not defined. One man's meat is another man's poison. What some people find 'good' is what some people find 'bad'. Furthermore, who's to say that one man's meat is indeed another man's poison? It's all a matter of personal thoughts and views- opinions- and that's what the concept of 'morality' is based on.

I think that your points are weak; you think that they are strong. Neither point can be proven as it is all a matter of opinion.
 
I think dogs are cool. Prove me wrong. If you can, opinions are facts; if not, they are not.
 
I think dogs are cool. Prove me wrong. If you can, opinions are facts; if not, they are not.

To decide whether dog are 'cool' one would have to asses the 'coolness' of a dog and 'coolness' is not absolute, it's variable. Paris Hilton may find her dog 'cool' because she likes the fur. On the other hand, I may think that such a dog is 'not cool' because it is too small. Opinions, opinions, opinions! Dogs are mammals and that's a fact!

I think dogs are cool. Prove me wrong. If you can, opinions are facts; if not, they are not.

Please elaborate as I don't understand what you just said.
 
On the other hand, 'Good' and 'Bad' morals are not absolute. They are not defined. One man's meat is another man's poison. What some people find 'good' is what some people find 'bad'. Furthermore, who's to say that one man's meat is indeed another man's poison? It's all a matter of personal thoughts and views- opinions- and that's what the concept of 'morality' is based on.
Perhaps you should read my earlier posts. I have clearly stated (and have yet to be refuted) why good and bad morals are absolute.

I think dogs are cool. Prove me wrong. If you can, opinions are facts; if not, they are not.
And the same should probably apply to you. Just because I say morals are absolute does not mean I know which ones are right and which ones are wrong. I'm not Jesus.
I do not need to prove what morals are right for them to be so.

Personally I'm getting the feeling that some people are only giving me rediculous arguments because they can't counter my arguments and don't like it's implications. Quit stalling and give me something decent.
 
why arent you answering my question?
 
What some people find 'good' is what some people find 'bad'

The point of the forms of good and bad is that regardless of whatever a person thinks about a thing, there still exists the true form of that thing as an abstract concept.

If I find savagely raping, beating, putting a pair of humiliating bunny ears on, and murdering little boys to be good, that doesn't change the fact that it's bad.
 
I didn't see it. Here goes...

if morals are facts, then you can logically prove someone wrong in the morals they currently have.
Yes, that is true, if you know which ones are right and wrong that is. Otherwise you cannot do it. For example, "God exists" could be a fact. And "God does not exist" could be a fact. They cannot both be facts, and likewise they cannot both be false either.

However reading the threads about God I see no solid proof from either camp attesting to which one is the fact.

According to your theory all facts can be proven easily because of their nature as facts, and yet both thiests and athiests have failed to do so. According to you therefore both "God exists" and God does not exist" are false. unfortunately for you, that is a logical contradiction and cannot be so.

so how would you go about proving someone's moral wrong logically if this so-called form existed?
I couldn't do it any other way than getting people to see the forms... of course first I'd have to see them myself.
 
And I'll attempt to refute.

First of all, yes morals are a man made thing, designed to alleviate pressures in society. I think we can all agree on that. However, morals are all losely based on the concepts of right and wrong, good or bad. These are not man made concepts. They exist in mind because they exist as abstract forms. When a dog is kicked it feels pain and knows this pain is bad, it did not create this badness to help it within society. The badness has always existed.

So morals therefore may not seem to be absolute, but they are based on absolute concepts of good and bad. This is, I postulate, the reason why seperate societies have shared a lot of common moral ground throughout history despite a lack of communication, because all humans will have some rudimentary knowledge of these abstract forms.

The dog feels pain. It obviously does. You stated why. But if we are going to judge this kick as 'good' or 'bad' we cannot just simply say its 'bad' based on the views/feelings of the dog. Why was he kicked? Did he bite someone? Was he kicked for fun? For no reason? If he was kicked for any of these reasons then the offender surely must think this is, in a sense, 'good' or rather, the offender does not see it as 'bad'.

You failed to create a strong bond between 'morals' and 'absolute concepts of good and bad'. There are no absolute concepts of good and bad, they are variable. I've demonstrated in an earlier post. I do however see a God-based (religion-based) link in your point. You are saying (I assume) that 'God' defined what is good and what is bad, but you should surely know that humanity's view on what is 'good/bad' is variable. What's 'good' to you might be 'bad' to me, I repeat. So, if morals are man-made and humanity's (man's) 'good' and 'bad' are variable then why are you under the impression that morals are absolute. They are not. Unless you bring in the concept of a 'God'- but that's beyond the point in this debate.

Your arguments seem to be qualified on the assumption that 'God' exists whereas there may be other arguments that are qualified on the assumption that 'God' does not exist.
 
If I find savagely raping, beating, putting a pair of humiliating bunny ears on, and murdering little boys to be good, that doesn't change the fact that it's bad.
but why is it bad? because of this absolute concept of bad? what if someone disagreed with it? how would you prove them wrong?

I couldn't do it any other way than getting people to see the forms... of course first I'd have to see them myself.
i would like you to make one up for the sake of argument please.
 
You failed to create a strong bond between 'morals' and 'absolute concepts of good and bad'. There are no absolute concepts of good and bad, they are variable. I've demonstrated in an earlier post. I do however see a God-based (religion-based) link in your point. You are saying (I assume) that 'God' defined what is good and what is bad, but you should surely know that humanity's view on what is 'good/bad' is variable. What's 'good' to you might be 'bad' to me, I repeat.
Uhhhm, perhaps you should read my other earlier post, the one where I clearly laid out logical reasons for absolute morallity completely indipendant of any sort of God (which makes sense, me being athiest and all)... in fact, why not just read the entire thread. It's not that long you know.

but why is it bad? because of this absolute concept of bad? what if someone disagreed with it? how would you prove them wrong?
Just because you can't prove them wrong, does not mean they aren't wrong though. That's the point I've been trying to get across for a while now.

i would like you to make one up for the sake of argument please.
If pressed I would copy Plato's ideas of creating Philosopher Kings. Guardians of society who have seen the forms of goodness and could run the society based on morals and ethics that are known to be good because of their absolute nature.

I cannot prove which morals are right and wrong to anybody. There's no real point asking me to because I've already told you the only way to do it. I can however (and for the purposes of this debate, have, for now at least) proved moral absolutism. When someone comes up a decent rebuttal to my points, one that actually works and isn't just sprouting the same old nonsense over and over again then I will concede the point.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top