• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Nitpicking.

Come on you can't be serious. Scyther is taller and weighs more, meaning that it should be able to lift the player.
Pidgey is 1 foot tall and weighs 4lb, if the player tries to fly on it, it will be crushed.

An NPC in Mistralton City literally says that even the tiniest of birds are capable of human transport with no issues.
 
And Gyarados has even been shown to fly in the Anime. -_-

You can't rely on anime for Pokelogic because if you go by Anime Logic, Pikachu delevels if you poketransfer your Pokemon to the next region. Strictly speaking, when you're referring to Pokelogic, things should only be brought up from the games and its mechanics. And btw, the -_- face irks me for some reason.

Since we're already picking on Gyarados. It's been bothering me since gen 1. I could never wrap my head around the idea of Gyarados being Water/Flying instead of Water/Dragon. Dragon typing would be more appropriate from both visual and cultural reference points of view. I'm not even sure if Gyarados was ever portrayed as flying instead of swimming (with the exception of few games where all water Pokemon float anyway). After all these years, I still believe it was a mistake made in the first game that was never corrected for the sake of consistency.

I doubt it was whatever you said. They could've easily changed it Gen 2 when Magnemite and other mons were getting type changes, and the type echart was modified. I doubt their true intention was to make Gyarados a dragon. Just sayin.
 
I agree kinda, I think low level pokemon you should need to make them faint to get a x2 or 3 chance or something but only once, maybe 5x for legendary or something or not for legendarys at all

This would be nice, but only allow for one ball only to be thrown while the pokemon is in a fainted state.
 
Gyarados isn't Water/Dragon because of balance - in basically every game it is common and available very early, so it would not be fair to have a Dragon so early. Having said this, it is still a Dragon despite not being of the type.

Actually, Gyarados is a Flying-type because its physical design is based on a kite- those windsocks designed like carp. It is still partially based on sea serpents, yes, but I doubt they didn't make it Water/Dragon due to balance. GameFreak have never given a crap about game balance.

Also, it bugs me to no end that the Porygon line is not Electric type. It is literally a personification of a computer program. Why wouldn't it be Electric? Normal/Electric or pure Electric would make much more sense.

Finally, I will never understand how Normalize is supposed to work.

EDIT: Also, on the thing about not being able to catch a Pokemon that has fainted, I've always imagined that it's sort of a taboo to try to catch a Pokemon that can't fight. It's dishonorable to throw a Poke Ball at anything that can't fight back, because then they have no choice in the matter. Same goes for Master Balls.
 
You can't rely on anime for Pokelogic because if you go by Anime Logic, Pikachu delevels if you poketransfer your Pokemon to the next region. Strictly speaking, when you're referring to Pokelogic, things should only be brought up from the games and its mechanics. And btw, the -_- face irks me for some reason.

Then I argue that Scyther's wings just exist for show. It can't fly. Pokepark is a spin off, so it doesn't count.
 
Then I argue that Scyther's wings just exist for show. It can't fly. Pokepark is a spin off, so it doesn't count.

I agree with this, mostly due to Scyther's FireRed entry- "It tears and shreds prey with its wickedly sharp scythes. It very rarely spreads its wings to fly."

Also, Scizor is specifically said not to be able to fly. It's kinda like Nincada not learning Attract, so that the genderless Shedinja can't get it.
 
Actually, Gyarados is a Flying-type because its physical design is based on a kite- those windsocks designed like carp. It is still partially based on sea serpents, yes, but I doubt they didn't make it Water/Dragon due to balance. GameFreak have never given a crap about game balance.

I really don't think it's design is based on a kite. Mantine is designed like a kite, and is 'The Kite pokemon' but I really don't see it with Gyarados.
 
I really don't think it's design is based on a kite. Mantine is designed like a kite, and is 'The Kite pokemon' but I really don't see it with Gyarados.

If you look up some of those carp windsocks, they do look an awful lot like Gyarados- segmented body, mouth wide open, ridiculous amount of detail.

Besides, there would be literally no other reason to make Gyarados Flying.

Also, WHY THE HELL DOES LIEPARD NOT GET PICKPOCKET AS AN ABILITY? It's ENTIRE SHTICK is that it steals stuff. Ugh.
 
If you look up some of those carp windsocks, they do look an awful lot like Gyarados- segmented body, mouth wide open, ridiculous amount of detail.

Besides, there would be literally no other reason to make Gyarados Flying.
Actually, the kites look similar because it's a generic Chinese dragon design.
You're also missing the real cultural reference behind the Magikarp family. It's based on this.
It does explain Gyarados being Flying type, but following the same logic it should still be a Dragon. Generation 1 Psychic type proves they didn't care about balance much at that point so I stand by my theory.
 
Last edited:
I don't know if I can call it nitpicking but since lately people have been putting science into pokemon realistically, no grown human could ever ride a charizard. A 10 year old child alone is pushing it. Also how can I fly using pidgey? It's just ridiculous.
 
Actually, the kites look similar because it's a generic Chinese dragon design.
You're also missing the real cultural reference behind the Magikarp family. It's based on this.
It does explain Gyarados being Flying type, but following the same logic it should still be a Dragon. Generation 1 Psychic type proves they didn't care about balance much at that point so I stand by my theory.

Game freak doesn't care much about balance, that's true. At least, not until there's a giant problem, like Psychic in Gen 1 leading them to make Dark and Steel in gen 2, as well as fix the ghost immunity, and Dragon Legendaries and the like causing Game Freak to bring in Fairy Type.

But what they really do care about is gimmicks. Think back to what gen 1 was like. What Dragons were there? Just Dragonite's line. No more dragons other than that, although it's harder to notice thanks to us being spoiled with dragons from Altaria to Garchomp to Kyurem. Dragon, being limited to one evolution line you probably wouldn't even see until you fight the last of the Elite Four, the supposed 'Final Challenge' before you would know there's a Champion to beat. You go up against Dragonite, and you don't know what to use against it, so Game Freak figured most kids would send out their starter and blast it with their best move... which they made be Not Very Effective. Dragon was neutral effective against everything at the time (Not that you would know it without any damage moves that aren't Dragon Rage), and only weak to two types. This was Game Freak trying to make Dragon some super-rare-ultra-powerful-mystery-type. Being a Dragon was Dragonite's gimmick, and so they decided it wouldn't be good to have other Pokemon be Dragon, and those Pokemon were given Flying type as a consolation prize of sorts.

By the time Gen 3 came along and there were more Dragons to justify Gyarados and Charizard being Dragons, the types were already too set in stone. However, with the whole retype thing of Gen 6 I think there's a possibility this might change.
 
a pidgey (or any other small pokmeon) using fly 0-0. Or a small poke like squirtle luvdisc etc using surf the weight of the trainer would probably drown them.
Gyarados is strong enough, and can fly, yet can't learn Fly or any Flying-type moves for that matter.
Eh gyrados can't FLY 0.0 look at it it's a gigantic sea serpent. It's typing is to balance the game and give it a weakness (although it's stupid it's not effected buy earthquake if you ask me). Plus myth (of the poke world) says that it (and magikarp) we're believed to fly across pockets of land to get water on the other side or something like that
 
I always found the idea of being able to change the weather at the drop of the hat to be a strange one. It's one thing to have it rain for ten minutes, but having something like a sandstorm for even a short amount of time could damage an entire ecosystem. You would think that a world so eco-conscious as the Pokemon world would be wary about messing with nature in such adverse ways.
 
How certain Pokemon move like Klinklang and Geodude. Also the fact that little children are allowed to play with insanely powerful monsters with no parental guidance
 
I always found the impenetrable walls of trees to be really strange anyways. I know that it was done in-game for boundary reasons, but when I imagine how bizarre these mile long tree blockades look, it makes me wonder what the trees are even made of.

Maybe there not the kind of thing we think of as a tree remember this is the pokemon world. Perhaps the tree's are really spiny or supernaturally dangerous. Same with the small trees we have to use cut on perhaps their too spiky to climb round.
 
For the love of God, Arceus is not a God!

Nope, the Pokemon can CHOOSE. It can even dodge the Pokeball's beam to not go into the Pokeball, as shown with Ash's Phanpy and also come out at will, Like May's Skitty. It does not obey you because it does not respect you, like Ash's Charizard. When you catch it and have enough badges, it respects you and listens to you.

I thought about the anime, but I was referring to the games themselves. The system in the games doesn't make sense, which is why the anime probably diverged from it. Anyways, only Ash and his friends ask a pokemon if it chooses to come with the group. Every other trainer in the anime uses the system of throwing pokeballs, capturing and training. No permission is involved.

Arceus is still considered a super-powerful pokemon even if you object to the word "God."
 
Last edited:
That's because... wait for it... Pokèmon is a game for all ages! It's not supposed to be like that, because Nintendo wants it child-friendly, and they at least tried to come up with a logical explanation.

My objection is with how the control issue is resolved, not the morality of the control. Nintendo doesn't avoid this morality issue, at least since they haven't since they made N's character, making your comment irrelevant.

The control issue isn't handled sensibly. If you completely control a pokemon, it can't rebel. If you don't, why doesn't it just leave and go to wherever it is most comfortable?


Think about a horse. If you mishandle a horse and incompetently fall off or if you don't tie it up correctly, do you know what the horse does? It grazes on its way back to its stable. You can find it later at its stable. Horses that don't rebel by bucking off riders or resisting their bridle will still wander back to their stable.

A horse that bucks or a pokemon that won't perform a move IS ACTIVELY REBELLING. A horse that returns to its stable IS FULFILLING ITS DESIRES AND NOTHING MORE.
It takes more loyalty and intelligence on the part of the horse to choose not to fulfill its own desires than it does for it to follow directions and training. Similarly, a pokemon needs to be MORE loyal to stay by a trainers side than it takes to simply follow directions.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top