• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Objectivity? Really?

MissDigitalis

love at first sting
I don't believe that objectivity exists in the realm of opinions. For just about everything there has to be a subjective value involved. Where does this subjective value come from? Emotional attachments and reactions usually.

I don't care how "objective" you think you're being, the fact is that you're basing your "objectivity" on something that you subjectively perceive. It doesn't matter that 99% or even 100% of the population agrees with you, it's still subjective.

Sure you can draw mathematics into this and say "the car went 10 miles per hour" but that's not so much an opinion as a fact. If you said "the car went slowly" that's an opinion. Maybe if you were trying to catch up to a car that was going 10 miles per hour you would think of it as faster.

It's a pretty low move to say to someone in a debate that they're "spouting emotional garbage" considering that debates on ethical matters are completely subjective and both sides are equally guilty.

TL;DR? Nothing has inherent value, therefore you're emotionally biased.
 
I think Objectivity comes when you are willing to look at a opposing view not as an affront to you but as a new perspective. I don't always manage this, but I don't normally get to a point where I'm not listening to you, I am just disagreeing because, Your perspective hasn't changed my view... yet.

Oh and sometimes Emotional Garbage is the right reason to disagree, debate or not.
 
Ah, another relativist comes out of the shadows.

I spend 50% of my history degree trying to learn the names of historians to cite in exam essays, rather than come up with original ideas. I spend the other 50% of the time wrangling with assertions that "there is no such thing as absolute truth", that facts don't exist outside of mathematics, and that "there is no such thing as a recoverable past".

Opinions based on facts can always be contradicted by opinions based on other facts, or opinions based on the same facts that are being used in a different way, or opinions based on facts that may or may not actually be forgeries and not actually facts at all.

Absolute objectivity is just a chimaera; but subjectivity can be tackled, if not averted. Looking at the evidence in the first place, accepting new work that invalidates your own argument, and conducting vigorous research before stating your opinion is a preferable way to wade into a debate.

But seeing as this is less about debates and more about whether "someone's spouting emotional garbage", I fail to see what the evidence is for or against the claim. I haven't even seen the remark that caused it. At the moment then, each opinion is equally valid.

And if you were to go all postmodernist and ask "what is emotion anyway", etc etc I will get very upset. Postmodernists spoil my degree course, and make me feel spiteful. (Not that you would, but just in case)
 
Last edited:
I think Objectivity comes when you are willing to look at a opposing view not as an affront to you but as a new perspective. I don't always manage this, but I don't normally get to a point where I'm not listening to you, I am just disagreeing because, Your perspective hasn't changed my view... yet.

Oh and sometimes Emotional Garbage is the right reason to disagree, debate or not.

Being open minded isn't necessarily being objective.




Every time I read one of your posts I can't help but to think you're upset at someone here.

???
I'm actually not mad at anyone.
"there is no such thing as a recoverable past".
Not sure what you mean by that unless you mean that history can never be accurately recorded.

Looking at the evidence in the first place, accepting new work that invalidates your own argument, and conducting vigorous research before stating your opinion is a preferable way to wade into a debate.
Well sure. It always makes sense to have your facts straight as possible but it doesn't change the fact that you hold an opinion for an emotional reason.

But seeing as this is less about debates and more about whether "someone's spouting emotional garbage", I fail to see what the evidence is for or against the claim. I haven't even seen the remark that caused it. At the moment then, each opinion is equally valid.
It's not so much about a specific debate as any debate that involves "right" and "wrong" since those are only concepts based on feelings.


And if you were to go all postmodernist and ask "what is emotion anyway", etc etc I will get very upset. Postmodernists spoil my degree course, and make me feel spiteful. (Not that you would, but just in case)
I'm pretty certain that I know what emotions are. I would say that they're complex chemical reactions in our brains in response to stimuli whether it be internal or external.
 
Last edited:
All opinions are subjective, unless you're God or a being that alters the laws of the universe.

I was taught this in third grade...

Of course, this is my opinion, so it's subjective too. Unless it's really a fact...

Aaargh, I'm confused now.
 
All opinions are subjective, unless you're God or a being that alters the laws of the universe.
I was taught this in third grade...
This is kind of a funny thing to say since it's possible to disagree with the Christian "God" for example. What's good or bad to him may be the opposite to you.

Of course, this is my opinion, so it's subjective too. Unless it's really a fact...

Aaargh, I'm confused now.
This is actually a common argument that absolutests use to "debunk" relativism.
 
Being open minded isn't necessarily being objective.
This is true, but at least you are willing to listen to the opposition and honestly think about what they are proposing. You may well still think you are more right than they are, but if you listen you may learn something to alter your perspective. If you are being objective.
 
This is true, but at least you are willing to listen to the opposition and honestly think about what they are proposing. You may well still think you are more right than they are, but if you listen you may learn something to alter your perspective. If you are being objective.

Nah, you're just being emotionally swayed by their arguments.
 
It's a pretty low move to say to someone in a debate that they're "spouting emotional garbage" considering that debates on ethical matters are completely subjective and both sides are equally guilty.

Can't help think that this has something to do with GhostAnime.

TL;DR? Nothing has inherent value, therefore you're emotionally biased.

And no, not everything is emotionally bias. I can feel one way but decide to go the other.
 
It's part of the definition of an opinion that it either is about a subjective subject, about something that isn't testable or is about something that is testable but one doesn't not know the result of such a test (separating from fact, no definiteness). If it's about a subjective subject, the opinion needs to be subjective and if it's about something that isn't known, it can't be definite and will therefore not be objective. Do note the difference between "It's likely that [...]", that is a fact (objective) and "Because it's likely, I think that [...]", that is a guess and therefore influenced by something and is subjective.
 
Maybe it does, maybe it doesn't. But that's something that subjective. :p

http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/objective

BTW... I remember the quote, but not where it's from!

I dont either, its a 4chan meme.

"not influenced by personal feelings, interpretations, or prejudice; based on facts; unbiased: an objective opinion."

Huh. I always thought that if subjective was synonymous with relative, then objective was synonymous with absolute.

The more you know.
 
all of your threads suck and you make too many

next time you're pissed, do something creative
 
Last edited:
Back
Top