• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Plot vs. Characters?

IJuggler

how much words
As the title suggests, which do you prefer to read/write about? Why? If plot, then what types of plots do you like, and is there a reason why? The same could be asked if you picked characters.

Furthermore, how closely should the two be related? Obviously people would grow through the story, but do you find it better or worse to have one skip ahead of the other (e.g. a time skip where character development happens with little plot, or a stretch where a lot of plot happens with little character development)?

I ask because I'd like to start a short story, but I don't quite know what to focus on. I personally like plot, but characters need just as much (if not more) development as the plot, too. Perspective is everything, after all.
 
I've always thought about this, myself. Anybody who knows my writing knows that I'm very character-centric. My fic "Never in the Wrong Time or Wrong Place" was extremely character driven and, up until recently, there wasn't too much of an over arcing plot aside from journeying. Most of the plot was due to the characters' reactions to certain situations. And apparently, the readers of the story had no problem with that.

I always say that you can have the most spectacular plot with the greatest plot twists, but if you don't have solid, deep, relatable or empathetic characters, then you're not going to get that far. However, plot is definately a good thing too. You can have great characters, but if you don't know where you're going, that's no great either, partially because character development is often tied to plot.

So yeah, I tend to emphasize characters over plot because the characters are the heroes of the story and they're the ones who you're rooting for or against. However, plot is important too, especially in short stories.

As for characters I like, that depends. I like all sorts of characters, but I have a very soft spot of aloof, self-sacrificing kinds. I don't really like when characters are too over the top and "cartoony" I guess. I prefer them to feel real.
 
I find I'm much better with plots than I am with building characters, but I'm trying to work on the later.

Very often, I find myself having to stop every time I introduce a new character, and write three clear adjectives about their personality before moving forward. In addition, the personality of this newly-introduced has to be different from the other characters in the story. If I don't do this, essentially every character ends up being the same, usually a serious, dense, and determined personality. Having variance among characters is a must in order to make it realistic and to appeal to many different types of readers. You need a guy that's determined, a guy that's a little aloof from the others, a guy for comic relief, one that's timid and sheepish, and so on, AND you need to know how to manage them and be aware of which is which and why. If you don't do this, then the characters just end up in a soup together where they agree with each other far more often than they should. With characters each having their own unique personalities, you have more room to create interesting conflicts with each other, and moments when they get along and moments where they disagree. Otherwise, everyone in the story is just a yes-man to everyone else, and the story becomes a very linear and easily predictable experience.

Characters also need strengths AND faults, and not just one or the other. A character with too many strengths becomes a Mary/Gary Sue that people actually WANT to see fall flat on their face, while a character with only faults just becomes an annoying obstruction to the story (like Jar-Jar Binks). Also, don't consider luck to be a strength. I've noticed that people tend to hate characters that win victories simply because of luck and nothing else. While this supplemental trait is great for villains (getting readers to love your main protagonists but hate your villains is a good thing actually!), don't use it for your main protagonist characters. Also, a trait of bad luck only works well for a comic relief character. Don't use it for your main protagonist.

Plots, I find are easier to manage, as I tend to find building settings much more enjoyable. Plots very often revolve around the setting. Horror settings usually have plots of trying to survive and endure the nightmare. Post-apocalyptic settings usually focus on the hopes and aspirations of the lucky few people that survived the disaster that left the world in shambles. And mysteries need to work like puzzles that send the reader in for a rollercoaster of assumptions and plot twists. Every genre of fiction has its own outlook of the kinds of things that are to be expected in it. Typical settings usually result in typical plots, which is best avoided. If you look at all the stories and novels that got popular and respected, chances are good they avoided the status-quo in terms of settings and plots. Harry Potter wasn't just about a boy learning magic, it turned what we know of human society as a whole, spun it on its head, and featured a unique setting where magic is real in the world we know, but it's hidden and secret with so many kinds of new implementations where magic improvises solutions instead of technology. Meanwhile, the plot of each individual book was a clever and well-designed mystery of cunning and intrigue that collectively created an outstanding saga of books and a great ongoing storyline. It's this kind of open-minded creativity and thinking that makes a novel a winner as opposed to more of the same slush.

All in all, having both a killer plot and memorable characters is the key to a good story, you can't rely on one or the other. Both need creativity and development, and both need careful attention and dedication.
 
When I write, my stuff tends to be very character-focused. My characters are alive to me and tend to have a lot of control over the plot; a good deal of my plotting happens while I'm writing some conversation or something where the characters suddenly realize something or decide something that I had never thought of before.

This, however, does result in my plots being a bit of a mess, and I've had a lot of headaches trying to get everything to make some modicum of sense after my characters have completely changed their minds about the plot several times. I don't think the characterization can make up for that so much as it can potentially make a reader willing to look past it.

Meanwhile, I think a good plot with so-so characters can usually stand on its own without it bothering the reader per se. The thing is flaws in the plot are flaws - provided the reader notices a plot hole or logic flaw in the first place, it inevitably and objectively detracts from the quality of the work. Characterization, on the other hand, is a lot more subjective, and tends to lead less to some negative reaction in the reader than to a lack of a positive one when it's lacking (barring outrageous Mary-Sues). Your work can fail on characters alone - that's what we call the Eight Deadly Words - but that's something that only happens at the extreme end of the scale. Just okay characters with a good plot generally don't exactly bother the reader.

On the other hand, superlatively awesome characters with a mediocre plot are more likely to make the reader adore the work than a superlatively awesome plot with mediocre characters. You can admire and be excited by a plot, but you can love characters, and I don't think plotting awesomeness can ever properly replicate the emotional high you can get out of well written characters.
 
When I write, my stuff tends to be very character-focused. My characters are alive to me and tend to have a lot of control over the plot; a good deal of my plotting happens while I'm writing some conversation or something where the characters suddenly realize something or decide something that I had never thought of before.

This, however, does result in my plots being a bit of a mess, and I've had a lot of headaches trying to get everything to make some modicum of sense after my characters have completely changed their minds about the plot several times. I don't think the characterization can make up for that so much as it can potentially make a reader willing to look past it.

Meanwhile, I think a good plot with so-so characters can usually stand on its own without it bothering the reader per se. The thing is flaws in the plot are flaws - provided the reader notices a plot hole or logic flaw in the first place, it inevitably and objectively detracts from the quality of the work. Characterization, on the other hand, is a lot more subjective, and tends to lead less to some negative reaction in the reader than to a lack of a positive one when it's lacking (barring outrageous Mary-Sues). Your work can fail on characters alone - that's what we call the Eight Deadly Words - but that's something that only happens at the extreme end of the scale. Just okay characters with a good plot generally don't exactly bother the reader.

On the other hand, superlatively awesome characters with a mediocre plot are more likely to make the reader adore the work than a superlatively awesome plot with mediocre characters. You can admire and be excited by a plot, but you can love characters, and I don't think plotting awesomeness can ever properly replicate the emotional high you can get out of well written characters.

I'm in agreement with Dragonfree. I like to look at it this way: Let's say there's this movie that's being made. They hired the best writers money can buy, and they've written a deep and complex script. The producers however, skimp on the actors, they don't get any of the big names, and they just pull a couple of average-poor actors of the street. The plot more than likely won't be able to hold up these actors if they butcher the script.
 
Stephen King, in his book How to Write, said that plot was like "a jackhammer" when excavating the fossil that is your story. He says that characterisation and dialogue are far more delicate tools which allow for a more natural progression of a story. I subscribe to this theory. Yes, you should keep vague ideas like the story's premise, the key events and probably the ending in mind, but do not plan out everything in absurd detail. Instead, allow your characters to drive the plot, as opposed to the other way around. If you have strongly defined characters who are more than just cliches and walk-in roles, they will tell you want they want to do next and how they're most likely to react.

The benefit of a character-driven approach is that the story progression will be natural; you will more likely avoid devices such as deus ex machina, and the dialogue will reek far less likely of mere Expospeak.

Stick your characters in a situation and see what they do. If they are strongly defined, they will direct the story without an overt guiding hand. Use plot to guide, not direct.
 
The characters should always cause the plot, and even a weak plot can be saved by strong characters. Think of a vague idea, like Draco said, and let the characters take the wheel from there. That's why I hate the idea of outlining or planning out stories in any kind of detail: it takes control away from the characters, and you will eventually force them into doing something they don't want to. Basically what Draco and Dragonfree said: let the characters take control of the story.

His book's called On Writing, by the way.
 
The characters should always cause the plot, and even a weak plot can be saved by strong characters. Think of a vague idea, like Draco said, and let the characters take the wheel from there. That's why I hate the idea of outlining or planning out stories in any kind of detail: it takes control away from the characters, and you will eventually force them into doing something they don't want to. Basically what Draco and Dragonfree said: let the characters take control of the story.

His book's called On Writing, by the way.

Pwned. =D

I guess all those all-nighters are frazzling my mind.
 
Yeah, I agree with the majority. Oftentimes, characters hold up the plot on their backs and carry it where it needs to go. That's not to say that the plot isn't important. A plot is what motivates the characters, but they need to be the ones who drive it. As a writer, you have to work with your characters; after all, they have their own desires, motives, ethics, and relationships. All of those things can, will, and should influence a plot.
 
Back
Top