• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Question

Status
Not open for further replies.
For those who like the original series over recent, tell us exactly what you think the recent season is doing wrong that makes the original so much better?

Like, keeping the same characters and region (Unova), what would you change to make it as good as Kanto?
 
For those who like the original series over recent, tell us exactly what you think the recent season is doing wrong that makes the original so much better?

Like, keeping the same characters and region (Unova), what would you change to make it as good as Kanto?

i love all series and unova is far better then hoenn or sinnoh if you actually look at it, but i still think best wishes needs to be alot more emotional, and we need more episodes dedicated to cilan and iris' but i do wish team rocket would return to there old selves, the people who claim the first season is better are nothing more then nostalgic idiots who havn't given the recent series a chance.
 
Personally i like BW,having good chemistry between Ash,Iris and Cilan,decent animation,endearing rivals etc.TR change of role becoming more competent and serious also i felt refreshing until writers started to go nowhere with them leaving mission on standstill.

However i still prefer original series over Unova for various reasons.Because there was more comedy,i enjoyed more in character interaction,anime stick less with games having unpredictable anime exclusive plots not adding so many game characters like future series did.All three sagas Kanto,OI and Johto have their pros and cons giving lot of funny moments,smart and funny humor with original trio playing well as group overcoming their differences feeling like real group of friends with good personalities.
Group of Ash,Misty and Brock played out very well having good dynamic and interaction.From Ash naive and stubborn attitude,Misty temper,sarcasm and smart alec jokes being wrapped up with wise and cool attitude from Brocks character having undrainable source of knowledge and helpful tips.
They felt like family having excellent flamboyant dynamic and interactions between them being fun to see them starting to maturel,over time opening more themselves to each other strengthening their friendship while providing lot of good comedy feling like very close and genuin group(which transferred to OI and Johto in its better parts especially toward end).

Group dynamic in Unova is operating on completely different level original trio had missing that charm first series had.Back in Kanto we had Ash who was just starting out with Misty and Brock fulfilling role as his mentors and guidelines with Unova not being focused so much on humor,conflict and goofiness Kanto had with writers often going of the board with several things passing under radar.Bw trio is good,but it simply lacks originality original trio had and that level of individuality and i doubt it ever will because you cant copy chemistry someone had with different cast.

Anime felt also very creative to me at that time,with writers not following games "close to close" as they do now with gym leaders being depicted in unique light(like famous Sabrina arc,Giovanni,grumpy Pryce which had one of best backstories out of all gym leaders.Clair and fantastic arc with Dragonite etc),more anime exclusive characters and arcs being delivered along getting region which didnt existed anywhere in games like Orange Islands implementing gyms in totally different and unique light involving tasks instead of usual battling.I also liked TR goofy attitude and more references to Japanese culture being provided.

Now dont get m wrong,i like Unova alot.Its just i preferred original more.

the people who claim the first season is better are nothing more then nostalgic idiots who havn't given the recent series a chance.

That was uncalled for.Reason why some people prefer older saga over BW is because they enjoyed more in chemistry within group when their favorite characters were part of pokemon anime,because style of writing was different(like first seasons containing more reference to Japanese culture,wacky plots and humor for example,use of real guns causing some episodes to be banned because of that though etc),because anime stick less with games(like whole mini region in form of Orange Islands which was anime exclusive and several anime only events like Whirl Islands,various contests like bug catching tournament ,pokemon using more than four moves per battle) with less game characters being included etc.

Nostalgia will often play important part in someones liking for certain things but its needed to understand how this is only part of reason why someone may like older series better over new ones.

Why this cant be respected is beyond me.
 
Last edited:
Well in all honesty, it's not that the recent seasons are doing anything wrong, it's just the whole atmosphere of the OS that the writers can't seem to bring back.

The show feels too immature and childish (yes it's aimed at kids, but so was the OS and that still felt more mature).

At this point in time now, the show just feels like it's being made for the sake of it, the show has always been to promote the games, but at least the OS felt like it was heading somewhere and branched off different ideas. It feels as if no effort goes into the writing at all anymore, TR vs TP looked pretty promising, but besides that...

Don't get me wrong, I like BW, it is fun and brings back a lot of aspects the OS had, it's just the overall atmosphere BW lacks which imo the OS had.

It's hard to explain what I mean, but im sure at least one person understands what im getting at.
 
Not sure. I like BW a lot better than season 1. Most of season 1 was completely retarded, IMO. o_O
 
While its true that original "feel" of the Kanto saga has been lost...it was pretty much lost when Orange Islands started IMO.

Then Johto eradicated what was left of it. You watch Kanto and Johto side by side, and despite using the same cast, the two sagas are nothing alike in terms of tone or writing.
 
Then Johto eradicated what was left of it. You watch Kanto and Johto side by side, and despite using the same cast, the two sagas are nothing alike in terms of tone or writing.

When was last time you watched Johto?It changed some things,but it still had some elements of Kanto writing implemented into it,feeling like continuity of first two sagas.

As for Orange Islands it was classic as much as Kanto was imo having unique style of writing,which was never copied again.

As for Johto,it wasnt nearly as bad as you say it was.
Original trio(Ash,Misty and Brock) in Johto still actually felt like genuine group of friends having good chemistry and several memorable moments.They felt like group which knew themselves very well having their principles,certain spark and better dynamic than it was case with some other groups with departing episode emphasizing on how close they were as friends,and Jessie,James and Meowth were still goofy bringing tension.

Battles were a lot better compared to first 2 seasons,Ash sidekicks actually battled more receiving some notable focus and growth,we got several great arcs and memorable gym leaders,return from older characters(like Todd,Duplica or Aya)being nice throwback to Kanto and there are many episodes from this region i always like to go back and watch being well written and enjoyable.
There were also several great episodes introducing legendaries like Entei,Suicune,Zapdos,Lugia,Artuicuno etc.
And Jigglypuff and Delibird were definitely among Johto highlights bringing comedy and many funny moments. Snubull wasnt that bad as recurring pokemon though i feel he lacked some substance to make him truly shine with writers trying to reciprocate some things specific for Kanto with use of such pokemon.
 
Last edited:
I think BW is by far the worst season for these reasons
1. there is no humour. its almost as if they are aiming pokemon for babies
2. team rocket are less funny
3. brocks not there
4. All the fillers are boring and not worth waiting a week to see
5. ash has already caught loads of pokemon, but it was better when he caught them along his journey, not all at once
6. he hasnt mentioned his past adventures AT ALL. doesnt he remember misty may and dawn?
7. Oshawott and emolga are the only pokemon with humour (scraggy is funny, but angry)
8. they should have the pokemon contests again. they cant ONLY be in sinnoh. cilan and iris could enter and end in a draw... mabye?
9. bianca replaced barry. barry was annoying and funny, but bianca is just annoying
10. I miss piplup!!!!!

All seasons are good, but this season is (so far) the worst
 
more emotion between ash and his pokemon. I still remember the episode of the original series where ash gets lost in a blizzard. ash eventually holes up in a cave and recalls all his pokemon to keep then warm. he tries to do that with pikachu but it refuses and eventually all of ashs pokemon popped out of their balls to keep him warm. it was at that point you realised just how close ash was to his pokemon. I would love an episode like that in best wishes
 
1. there is no humour. its almost as if they are aiming pokemon for babies

There's no slapstick humor (IE Misty with a mallet), but there's humor. See: Oshawott.

2. team rocket are less funny

Kind of the point, Ace.

3. brocks not there

Because Brock was such an important character before?

4. All the fillers are boring and not worth waiting a week to see

Every season of Pokemon has fillers. If fillers are a disqualification for you, you might want to watch something else.

5. ash has already caught loads of pokemon, but it was better when he caught them along his journey, not all at once

He...hasn't caught them "all at once"?

6. he hasnt mentioned his past adventures AT ALL. doesnt he remember misty may and dawn?

Are you new to Pokemon?

The show RARELY references the past. It's been that way since day one.

However, at least until recently, there was an entire thread dedicated to documenting the mentions of past events in Unova. BW001 literally started in Ash's room, showing several trophies and suvonoirs he got in Sinnoh, and showcased prominently two of the oldest characters (in age and in time featured in the series) in the series, Oak and Ash's Mom.

People who are saying BW doesn't reference past series are just not paying attention.

8. they should have the pokemon contests again. they cant ONLY be in sinnoh. cilan and iris could enter and end in a draw... mabye?

Sounds like you're setting unrealistic expectations for a region that was promoted as not having contests.
 
At this point in time now, the show just feels like it's being made for the sake of it, the show has always been to promote the games, but at least the OS felt like it was heading somewhere and branched off different ideas. It feels as if no effort goes into the writing at all anymore, TR vs TP looked pretty promising, but besides that...

Don't get me wrong, I like BW, it is fun and brings back a lot of aspects the OS had, it's just the overall atmosphere BW lacks which imo the OS had.

It's hard to explain what I mean, but im sure at least one person understands what im getting at.

Well since you're an experienced veiwer of the show, it's inevitable that the recent episodes are going to feel like they're being made for the sake of it. You've seen it all before, after all.

What the OS had going for it was the "new" factor, and an air of unpredictability because none of the trends we're all accustomed to now hadn't been established yet. As you say, BW has a lot of things that the OS had, but as experienced viewers, there are going to be things we've seen many times before.

Basically, I don't think it's necessarily the writers' fault that they can't replicate the same atmosphere the OS had.
 
Well since you're an experienced veiwer of the show, it's inevitable that the recent episodes are going to feel like they're being made for the sake of it. You've seen it all before, after all.

What the OS had going for it was the "new" factor, and an air of unpredictability because none of the trends we're all accustomed to now hadn't been established yet. As you say, BW has a lot of things that the OS had, but as experienced viewers, there are going to be things we've seen many times before.

Basically, I don't think it's necessarily the writers' fault that they can't replicate the same atmosphere the OS had.

I know what your saying and your right, but there is still something about the OS that no other season has ever had again.

It was more of a mature and mysterious tone to it. If you look back at episodes like 'Abra and the Psychic Showdown', 'Pokemon Shipwreck' etc. The viewer was always on the edge of the seat since the characters were always in a tense situation, everything's all too happy in BW. Yeah Pokemon is a kids show but it was a kids show back then aswell.

There's a whole handful of other episodes but they're just examples.

I actually wondered at first if it was just the OS artstyle being used which made me think this but it's not, im sure of it.
 
I know what your saying and your right, but there is still something about the OS that no other season has ever had again.

It was more of a mature and mysterious tone to it. If you look back at episodes like 'Abra and the Psychic Showdown', 'Pokemon Shipwreck' etc. The viewer was always on the edge of the seat since the characters were always in a tense situation, everything's all too happy in BW. Yeah Pokemon is a kids show but it was a kids show back then aswell.

There's a whole handful of other episodes but they're just examples.

I actually wondered at first if it was just the OS artstyle being used which made me think this but it's not, im sure of it.

But that doesn't apply to the ENTIRE Original Series. The Shipwreck two parter is pretty early on in Kanto, ditto with Sabrina's mini-story.

Most of that creativeness went entirely out the window in Johto (and arguabl as early as late Kanto), at least as far as the (slightly) more mature plotlines. There were still some mini story arcs in Johto and Orange, but nothing like Ghost of Maiden's Peak or PokemonShipwreck.

I think there's a clear change in tone when you compare the first half or so of Kanto, which was produced under the pretense that the series would end with Kanto and likely never be seen outside of Japan, and the later half of Kanto where it was produced with the intention of airing to the entire world and in an ongoing fashion.
 
I know what your saying and your right, but there is still something about the OS that no other season has ever had again.

It was more of a mature and mysterious tone to it. If you look back at episodes like 'Abra and the Psychic Showdown', 'Pokemon Shipwreck' etc. The viewer was always on the edge of the seat since the characters were always in a tense situation, everything's all too happy in BW. Yeah Pokemon is a kids show but it was a kids show back then aswell.

There's a whole handful of other episodes but they're just examples.

I actually wondered at first if it was just the OS artstyle being used which made me think this but it's not, im sure of it.

I see where you're coming from. OS had more moments where the lives or wellbeing of the cast were actually in danger, even if you knew in the end nothing was going to happen to them. That creates tension for the viewers. BW doesn't seem to take this approach. You don't see the cast trying to escape a sunk boat precariously teetering over an abyss, or running away from giant Pokemon, and so on. There was that episode where Charmander was just left to die by a trainer, too.

BW, and the other series', seem to save the tension for the battles, and not the journey. That's probably why it comes off as too happy.

Why this the case I really don't know. Perhaps it's a reflection of how kid's programming has changed over the decade, or maybe the writers are trying less to make the series memorable (OS was intended to be stand-alone, after all).
 
But that doesn't apply to the ENTIRE Original Series.

I never said it did, Im saying if you look back at episodes like that, which their were plenty of in the OS.

Most of that creativeness went entirely out the window in Johto (and arguabl as early as late Kanto), at least as far as the (slightly) more mature plotlines. There were still some mini story arcs in Johto and Orange, but nothing like Ghost of Maiden's Peak or PokemonShipwreck.

It's a shame really, I won't knock all of Johto, it did have some good plots.

I think there's a clear change in tone when you compare the first half or so of Kanto, which was produced under the pretense that the series would end with Kanto and likely never be seen outside of Japan, and the later half of Kanto where it was produced with the intention of airing to the entire world and in an ongoing fashion.

Eh, I found nearly all of Kanto had this atmosphere, I loved it.

If you look towards the miniature Mewtwo story input to the anime, Giovanni's small scenes were very dark and serious every single time he appeared, it's what gave me hope for this atmosphere to return in BW.

The moment we watched Gary get defeated by an 'unknown' Pokemon at the 8th Gym it was very tense. Infact this type of atmosphere is something nearly every other season has lacked.

I see where you're coming from. OS had more moments where the lives or wellbeing of the cast were actually in danger, even if you knew in the end nothing was going to happen to them. That creates tension for the viewers. BW doesn't seem to take this approach. You don't see the cast trying to escape a sunk boat precariously teetering over an abyss, or running away from giant Pokemon, and so on. There was that episode where Charmander was just left to die by a trainer, too.

Yeah this is another point really, the episodes have never been as creative as these ones were, they pushed the limits of the anime but never seemed unrealistic talking terms of the Pokemon World.

BW, and the other series', seem to save the tension for the battles, and not the journey. That's probably why it comes off as too happy.

Actually I won't lie, the tension of the battles in BW are brilliant (pointing fingers towards Ash vs Elesa and Clay).

But besides this, yeah maybe this is why.

Why this the case I really don't know. Perhaps it's a reflection of how kid's programming has changed over the decade, or maybe the writers are trying less to make the series memorable (OS was intended to be stand-alone, after all).

Eh who knows, I personally just blame how the time has passed over the years, everything changes, but looking back on Pokemon a lot of things have gone for it.

I still enjoy BW, so who knows maybe the second half of the saga will be a lot different.
 
For me not bringing back Charizard,and Pikachu beeing a weakling,because he LOST to Trip's Snivy.It's almost like all of a sudden,Pikachu becomes a Lv.1.
 
For me not bringing back Charizard,and Pikachu beeing a weakling,because he LOST to Corn's Panpour.It's almost like all of a sudden,Pikachu becomes a Lv.1.

Fixed that for you.
 
The Johto saga felt like a bizarre attempt to try and be like Kanto with new Johto pokemon, and failed both ways. This is probably why Ash's Kanto starters weren't immediately left behind and Misty/Brock kept their teams as well.
 
I prefer the Original series because it was what started it all and it was unique. all the newer ones just piggyback off that and it becomes ridiculous.
Some pokemon look weird too. Such as Vanillish, and Gothitelle And the writers seem to be running out of ideas. Even the new episodes are getting kinda childish. AND YES even though it is for children OS seemed more mature.

the people who claim the first season is better are nothing more then nostalgic idiots who havn't given the recent series a chance.

Wow thats rude of you, and HOW do you know they haven't given it a chance? don't assume what you cant prove. It's really uncalled for.


At this point in time now, the show just feels like it's being made for the sake of it

They don't care to be honest they really don't it's all about the money. They just want to milk pokemon till it runs dry.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top