Personally i like BW,having good chemistry between Ash,Iris and Cilan,decent animation,endearing rivals etc.TR change of role becoming more competent and serious also i felt refreshing until writers started to go nowhere with them leaving mission on standstill.
However i still prefer original series over Unova for various reasons.Because there was more comedy,i enjoyed more in character interaction,anime stick less with games having unpredictable anime exclusive plots not adding so many game characters like future series did.All three sagas Kanto,OI and Johto have their pros and cons giving lot of funny moments,smart and funny humor with original trio playing well as group overcoming their differences feeling like real group of friends with good personalities.
Group of Ash,Misty and Brock played out very well having good dynamic and interaction.From Ash naive and stubborn attitude,Misty temper,sarcasm and smart alec jokes being wrapped up with wise and cool attitude from Brocks character having undrainable source of knowledge and helpful tips.
They felt like family having excellent flamboyant dynamic and interactions between them being fun to see them starting to maturel,over time opening more themselves to each other strengthening their friendship while providing lot of good comedy feling like very close and genuin group(which transferred to OI and Johto in its better parts especially toward end).
Group dynamic in Unova is operating on completely different level original trio had missing that charm first series had.Back in Kanto we had Ash who was just starting out with Misty and Brock fulfilling role as his mentors and guidelines with Unova not being focused so much on humor,conflict and goofiness Kanto had with writers often going of the board with several things passing under radar.Bw trio is good,but it simply lacks originality original trio had and that level of individuality and i doubt it ever will because you cant copy chemistry someone had with different cast.
Anime felt also very creative to me at that time,with writers not following games "close to close" as they do now with gym leaders being depicted in unique light(like famous Sabrina arc,Giovanni,grumpy Pryce which had one of best backstories out of all gym leaders.Clair and fantastic arc with Dragonite etc),more anime exclusive characters and arcs being delivered along getting region which didnt existed anywhere in games like Orange Islands implementing gyms in totally different and unique light involving tasks instead of usual battling.I also liked TR goofy attitude and more references to Japanese culture being provided.
Now dont get m wrong,i like Unova alot.Its just i preferred original more.
the people who claim the first season is better are nothing more then nostalgic idiots who havn't given the recent series a chance.
That was uncalled for.Reason why some people prefer older saga over BW is because they enjoyed more in chemistry within group when their favorite characters were part of pokemon anime,because style of writing was different(like first seasons containing more reference to Japanese culture,wacky plots and humor for example,use of real guns causing some episodes to be banned because of that though etc),because anime stick less with games(like whole mini region in form of Orange Islands which was anime exclusive and several anime only events like Whirl Islands,various contests like bug catching tournament ,pokemon using more than four moves per battle) with less game characters being included etc.
Nostalgia will often play important part in someones liking for certain things but its needed to understand how this is only part of reason why someone may like older series better over new ones.
Why this cant be respected is beyond me.