• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Question

Status
Not open for further replies.
But that doesn't apply to the ENTIRE Original Series. The Shipwreck two parter is pretty early on in Kanto, ditto with Sabrina's mini-story.

Most of that creativeness went entirely out the window in Johto (and arguabl as early as late Kanto), at least as far as the (slightly) more mature plotlines. There were still some mini story arcs in Johto and Orange, but nothing like Ghost of Maiden's Peak or PokemonShipwreck.

I beg to differ.Orange Islands felt fresh,unique and had entirely different tone to it than future series.It was anime exclusive,with gyms and whole league format following different set of rules.Like having instead of gym matches shooting practice,races or making ice sculptures.Locations,gym leaders and whole stiry felt fresh,unorthpdox and out of place being one of regions where writers really could use their creativity and imagination to fullest.

Johto true didnt had such style of writing like Kanto had,but it can be noticed how it had some nice throwbacks to past.Like return of Kanto characters like Aya,Duplica,Suzie,Ritchie or Todd.It had several great and rather creative arcs like Red Gyarados,Lugia and its baby,Whirl cup and whirl islands feeling like mini region put into one,whole build up with Larvitar and quest to return it to its mother and mini arc with Clair involving old Dragonite and temple of dragons.
Recurring pokemon like Snubull or Delibird also strike to me as attempt to replicate Jigglypuff.

Regardless of what some may say Johto had some great episodes having certain doze of creativity into it when writers tried better,and original trio still had good dynamic when having chance to shin.

Yes Misty and Brock were neglected at times,but lack of screen time doesnt affect quality contributing to appeal whenever they had chance to shine.Heck even Ash suffered from lack of development in that region.

It's a shame really, I won't knock all of Johto, it did have some good plots.

It had pretty good chemistry between main cast too.I remember several memorable moments group shared feeling like throwback to Kanto days.Like when Ash battled Misty for Totodile or in Whirl Cup,when she criticized Brock for not taking initiative when it comes to girls"like "Heartbreak of Brock"),when Brock was sick with Ash and Misty having to take care of everything by themselves failing at cooking,when group got divided in forest having to pair up with Jessie,James and Meowth in "Forrest Grumps"etc,etc.And i believe "Gotta Catch Ya Later"best portrayed how strong bond those three had.

Johto had its highlights,but it seems some people only focus on fillers which werent their favorite cup of tea.

Eh who knows, I personally just blame how the time has passed over the years, everything changes, but looking back on Pokemon a lot of things have gone for it.

I still enjoy BW, so who knows maybe the second half of the saga will be a lot different.

I think it has more to do with fact how whole formula changed,back than writers werent so much focused on game promotion and cast changes like its case nowdays,having more liberty to go of road at times using their creativity to fullest.

I also agree about continuity.This anime used to have references to past much more in previous regions compared to Unova.Back than we had cameos from ex traveling companions being updated with some continuation being made,older pokemon from previous generations were still often used,there were provided several flashbacks to past like it was case with Ash in DP etc.

Not to mention way how replaced characters are treated ending up forgotten and abandoned despite having unfinished story and potential to offer more is disrespectful toward both characters and fans giving to anime bad reputation when it comes to continuity and its characters.
Its enough to take a look at Misty which is gone for 6 years,being completely ignored despite open story.Soon enough Brock,Dawn or May will fall in same hole too.
 
I was specifically addressing the point that OS had some "darker" (like Ghost of Maiden's Peak, Pokemon Shipwreck, Sabrina's arc) plots, and I countered that with most of that not only being in Kanto, but pretty early Kanto. Orange, I greatly enjoyed for showcasing different styles of gyms and Double Battles, but didn't have those more traditional elements of Japanese anime that existed in early Kanto.
 
I was specifically addressing the point that OS had some "darker" (like Ghost of Maiden's Peak, Pokemon Shipwreck, Sabrina's arc) plots, and I countered that with most of that not only being in Kanto, but pretty early Kanto. Orange, I greatly enjoyed for showcasing different styles of gyms and Double Battles, but didn't have those more traditional elements of Japanese anime that existed in early Kanto.

I see,though if i recall right even in late Kanto there were some storylines which had "darker"tone to it like Viridian gym and Giovanni following first movie canon and whole thing with Mewtwo,or episode about giant Gengar and Alakazam("Ancient Puzzle of Pokemopolis").Even slapstic humor still existed in some form in earlier part of second half as well.

Though i know what you mean,other regions didnt had as much reference to Japan traditional culture like Kanto did.

p.s.Regardless i noticed not just Kanto,but orange Islands and Johto(in some aspects)had wackier plots and different tone to it sticking with games in smaller degree compared to future sagas.

Naturally those who like that games are followed as close as possible may have disliked this,but to me it created opposite effect making anime feel more original and unpredictable.

On side note i watched some of Johto awhile ago,and im still amazed how many positive things this saga had are being completely overlooked.Main cast received some nice development there too contrary to some belief(specifically Master Quest),though it was definitely too little for such a long region.
 
Last edited:
I think the Original Series (Kanto, Orange Islands, Johto) had a whole different atmosphere and feel to it, the writers failed to replicate this in AG, DP & BW.

I could watch the first 276 episodes again and again and they never got old for me.

AG was really good too but it just didn't feel the same. DP's plot was the best of all seasons but there something that put me off (starting with the horrible dub)

Best Wishes had a lot of potential but being honest the TR vs TP fiasco killed it a little bit for me.

EDIT: Cyber I wonder if you ever watched Johto, because the "chemistry" between the group was there, I have watched Johto many times in my original language and I watched it subbed recently.

The feel of Johto was the same as Kanto IMO it's just they stretched things because you know Pokemon was here to stay for the long haul.
 
Last edited:
Outside of maybe a handful of eps here and there, Johto wasn't anything like Kanto. The entire original trio was completely different.

- Misty didn't have much of a temper anymore thanks to Togepi and she stopped arguing with Ash outside of maybe a few eps, so there was no "humor" in terms of their arguments anymore. Ash and Misty didn't fight often, Brock didn't keep them in line.

- Ash stopped needing advice from Misty and Brock because he became a better trainer. Brock started his decline as a character that would continue into AG and eventually hit rock bottom in DP.

- Bulbasaur/Squirtle/Charizard were split up, and Ash's Johto team failed to duplicate the dynamic of Ash's original Kanto starters.

- Ash himself felt like a weird mix of still his stupid Kanto self and what he'd eventually become in AG, but he was still mostly an idiot.

- Most of the fillers were way too tedious. Sometimes you would get a really funny Johto episode, but other times they were the same boring plot over and over. Most Johto eps didn't even have anything that could be called "a battle" outside of a TR blast off.

- Gary barely appeared, so even the whole Ash/Gary rivalry was non-existent for 90% of Johto.
 
- Misty didn't have much of a temper anymore thanks to Togepi and she stopped arguing with Ash outside of maybe a few eps, so there was no "humor" in terms of their arguments anymore. Ash and Misty didn't fight often, Brock didn't keep them in line.

- Ash stopped needing advice from Misty and Brock because he became a better trainer. Brock started his decline as a character that would continue into AG and eventually hit rock bottom in DP.

- Bulbasaur/Squirtle/Charizard were split up, and Ash's Johto team failed to duplicate the dynamic of Ash's original Kanto starters.

- Ash himself felt like a weird mix of still his stupid Kanto self and what he'd eventually become in AG, but he was still mostly an idiot.

- Most of the fillers were way too tedious. Sometimes you would get a really funny Johto episode, but other times they were the same boring plot over and over. Most Johto eps didn't even have anything that could be called "a battle" outside of a TR blast off.

- Gary barely appeared, so even the whole Ash/Gary rivalry was non-existent for 90% of Johto.

You hit the nail on the head, those are some of the most noticeable. there are a few more differences buy yea.. your spot on...

-KK
 
I think there's a clear change in tone when you compare the first half or so of Kanto, which was produced under the pretense that the series would end with Kanto and likely never be seen outside of Japan, and the later half of Kanto where it was produced with the intention of airing to the entire world and in an ongoing fashion.

I sorta agree with what you're saying, but what I'm wondering is when they really started producing episodes with the intent of them airing to the entire world. Wait... my guess by Orange Islands, like CyberCubed mentioned...

And yet... I definitely think they were factoring the world seeing the episodes during the time of the four-month hiatus brought out by the Porygon episode incident.
 
Last edited:
Eh the only reason why OS felt more "mature" was because it was new and most of us were 5-8 watching it back then, I don't get what makes it seem more mature though. I swear OS had so much sappy stuff imo. Maybe I just take Pokemon more serious now because I watch it RAW and I make up what half they are saying. xDDD
 
Few things to address in here.

Misty didn't have much of a temper anymore thanks to Togepi and she stopped arguing with Ash outside of maybe a few eps, so there was no "humor" in terms of their arguments anymore. Ash and Misty didn't fight often, Brock didn't keep them in line.

They didnt fight as much as they used in Kanto,but that was hardly only thing which made interacting between characters interesting.Misty still teased Ash on frequent basis,being cynical and spunky.She was spunky but less violent in getting her message across,showing other sides of her(from being girly and obsessive over water types to have tendency to fall sometimes naively for cute things)along with teasing coming in form of sarcasm being used more instead of temper which provided nice balance to her aggressive side starting to mature.Togepi only allowed that various sides of character come on surface with character with its help becoming better friend with Ah,

For record Misty had Togepi in Knto and OI too,so your kinda contradicting yourself with such statement.

I remember Misty still being lively,romantic character having flare in her but she also started to mature getting some good character development.
This can be noticed in way she interacted with several other characters like Sakura,Egan,Dorian etc getting in conflicts and having opposite viewpoints,but she also becoming more mature and levelheaded enough to get over her complex of inferiority caused by sisters not being bothered much about it helping Sakura how to deal with her older siblings for example as well being over course of Johto willing to admit her own mistakes and take criticism in much better manner compared to early days.Which is testament to character growth.

Character development is positive and necessary thing because it builds up on character enriching his personality and if they dont evolve characters end up stale and one dimensional.

Ash,Misty and Brock all started to mature getting to know each other better developing tolerance toward their flaws while still having good interacting,.I remember Ash was still naive and stubborn but also started to mature not going with "head through wall so much",Misty became more supportive to Ash and Brock becoming closer as friends while still still being stubborn and possessive being passionate about things,but instead of being so violent she used more of her cynical and spunky side.While Brock was making sure to keep them out of trouble serving as caretaker for them with his calm and wise attitude still providing help in some battle strategies and being eccentric about girls.

You could get feeling how hey felt like family having fun together.Something which wasnt exactly case with some other groups like DP trio.

- Ash stopped needing advice from Misty and Brock because he became a better trainer. Brock started his decline as a character that would continue into AG and eventually hit rock bottom in DP.

I strongly suggest that you rewatch Johto than,because thats not completely true.While Ah became more experienced not needing advice anymore so much from his traveling companions,it can be noticed he still needed their help.Like when Brock or Misty advice him what type of pokemon to use hen battling gym leaders like Falkner or Pryce with his stubornness costing him duel.For instance such thing happened when he used Phanphy against Pryce Dewgong.

Or when they helped him to choose which pokemon to use in Whirl Cup.Misty borrowing him her water types in tournament where pokemon were used to distinguish fire.In Johto league when they helped him to select pokemon for Gary and Macy etc.

They also provided moral support helping him to grow stronger as trainer and person.This can be noticed with Ash not being so bratty and hotheaded like he used to be in Kanto being more strategic and rational in his battles actually using head,and how much his friends meant to him was best emphasized in later half of "Gotta Catch Ya Later"when he manage to beat TR,knowing they will always be by his side even if theyre not present.

- Bulbasaur/Squirtle/Charizard were split up, and Ash's Johto team failed to duplicate the dynamic of Ash's original Kanto starters.

Intention was never to duplicate Kanto starters.Johto pokemon were supposed to be different team being treated as new,individual set.You can thank to poor writing and repartition of screen time why some of them ended up terribly neglected.Yes Totodile im looking at you.

- Ash himself felt like a weird mix of still his stupid Kanto self and what he'd eventually become in AG, but he was still mostly an idiot.

Thats called character growth,you cant expect that everyone reminds completely same.Point of following character journey is to have him go from point A to point B.

- Most of the fillers were way too tedious. Sometimes you would get a really funny Johto episode, but other times they were the same boring plot over and over. Most Johto eps didn't even have anything that could be called "a battle" outside of a TR blast off.

Thats more matter of opinion than anything else.Something which may have been stale to you,doesnt necessarily mean its going to be boring to others.I agree Johto had several terrible episodes(which region doesnt?) but it had several great ones too being one of best episodes this show had.Like "Hook,line and Stinker","Little big horn","Hocus Pokemon","Dues and Donts","One Trick Phoney"etc.

To sum it up best part of Johto was definitely Master Quest fixing on several mistakes Johto had having multiple arcs,giving some development to Ash and Misty by getting over some issues and advancing goal through Whirl Cup,reducing on fillers with more focus being put on storyline,resolving rivalry with Gary and having great league.
 
Last edited:
Outside of maybe a handful of eps here and there, Johto wasn't anything like Kanto. The entire original trio was completely different.

- Misty didn't have much of a temper anymore thanks to Togepi and she stopped arguing with Ash outside of maybe a few eps, so there was no "humor" in terms of their arguments anymore. Ash and Misty didn't fight often, Brock didn't keep them in line.

- Ash stopped needing advice from Misty and Brock because he became a better trainer. Brock started his decline as a character that would continue into AG and eventually hit rock bottom in DP.

- Bulbasaur/Squirtle/Charizard were split up, and Ash's Johto team failed to duplicate the dynamic of Ash's original Kanto starters.

- Ash himself felt like a weird mix of still his stupid Kanto self and what he'd eventually become in AG, but he was still mostly an idiot.

- Most of the fillers were way too tedious. Sometimes you would get a really funny Johto episode, but other times they were the same boring plot over and over. Most Johto eps didn't even have anything that could be called "a battle" outside of a TR blast off.

- Gary barely appeared, so even the whole Ash/Gary rivalry was non-existent for 90% of Johto.


Ash and Misty only fought like 4 or 5 types in Kanto anyway.

At least the fillers were not DP fillers ugh.

Even in Kanto the way they did the rivals sucked. It was not until May came around they decided to do rivals right.
 
Gary at least appeared on a regular basis throughout Kanto.

In Johto we only see him 3 times prior to the league. Can you imagine in DP if Paul only got 3 episodes before the Sinnoh league? How the hell would anyone get into the rivalry?

The ONLY reason I think people are defending Johto is because of nostalgia for the 4kids voice actors now. And if that's the case, Hoenn has the same VA's too and I feel they were done better there, especially the way Veronica Taylor deepens Ash's voice in Hoenn.
 
For those who like the original series over recent, tell us exactly what you think the recent season is doing wrong that makes the original so much better?

Like, keeping the same characters and region (Unova), what would you change to make it as good as Kanto?

I like Kanto over the newest series is because it doesn't feel like Ash took so much of a step back. In Kanto, Ash was actually new to being a Pokémon trainer so I could accept his bad mistakes but not so much fifteen years later. I didn't care for his two new sidekicks and his rival is worse (errr less interesting) than Gary which I didn't think was possible. I also dislike the animation and music of the new series but yeah.

So yeah: better music, better animation, better Ash are my big three here.
 
Since people took it the wrong way about what i said before, i will simplify it

In OS Pokemon was funny and worth waiting to see the next episode. i remember being excited for the next episode to come out
AG was great, but not as good as OS.

DP was also like OS, AMAZING! At this point i was thinking to myself "pokemon is the best show ever"

BW Is a good series, but season 1 (the season that has been airing recently) isnt what i expected. i wasnt as excited for the episodes as i was with OS and DP, but it os ok
The good thing about BW is that it wasnt AS repetitive as some of the DP episodes. some episodes are predictable, but its ok
 
I felt like the series in general has hit a repetitive slump ever since Hoenn ended. OS was good because it was the first so we saw a lot of things happened. Hoenn amazing because it tried out new things and made Pokemon fun again (plus I love Kanto BF). After that, I felt as if the serious got stale.
 
Hoenn was the best. I could not help but feel DP was just shoved down your throat though. It was all in your face which annoyed me. idk maybe its just me for some odd reason. I did not really mind DP from the first 100 eps but after that it went downhill fast
 
The DP saga did a number of great things, such as great rivals with Paul and Barry, real evil competent villains like Pokehunter J and Galactic, and arguably the best battles of the series via the Gyms.

Ash's Sinnoh team was also handled very well, at least until Torterra evolved and got screwed over.

DP's only flaws was its length, and the lack of chemistry with the DP trio with Brock being neglected. Also Team Rocket pretty much wore out their welcome in DP.
 
I love all generations of Pokemon and have really been enjoying Best Wishes. With that said I still think there's something about the original series that had so much charm. In general, the original cast had an amazing chemistry so that contributes to why I feel that why. A couple other reasons people may prefer the OS is when Pokemon first came out it was this whole new universe and everything was so new and exciting. We know what to expect now (ie: Ash not winning a league, starter pokemon in the main cast, etc). If many of us grew up later on we might not feel this way. I'm just happy Pokemon knew to move on and change things up.
 
From Kanto (and the Original Series really) I enjoyed seeing how humans coexisted with Pokemon being the subject of episodes. A good example is " Dig those Diglett " where the plot involved humans building a dam that would've been damaging to the surrounding era and even Ash's Pokemon trying to stop them from stopping the Diglett's countermeasure. Another more predominate example was the St. Anne arch where the group ultized almost all of their Pokemon in creative ways to escape from the ship. It was more then " there's a fire, put it out Squirtle " or " grab that thing with Vine Whip! ". The show often took a realistic approach and connect plots to real world problems.

I'd almost say the show is too focused on the Training aspect of the Pokemon world but that's blasphemous.
 
i have recently watched every episode of the original series and the johto series and johto isn't as bad as cyber make's it out to be, but it isn't nearly as good as kanto, johto suffered from filler to filler and at one point i flipped through 2 cd's without an episode with any importiance at all.... but 4 kids did a damn good job with johto, and the comedy in every filler episode i watched is beyond enjoyable, it was amazing!

my opinion > everyone elses :0
 
tbh Johto was the first time the writers took on a full region for a good amount of years so of course its going to be hard to handle. People tend to forget this and hate on Johto
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top