pokemon fan 132
Well-Known Member
But that doesn't apply to the ENTIRE Original Series. The Shipwreck two parter is pretty early on in Kanto, ditto with Sabrina's mini-story.
Most of that creativeness went entirely out the window in Johto (and arguabl as early as late Kanto), at least as far as the (slightly) more mature plotlines. There were still some mini story arcs in Johto and Orange, but nothing like Ghost of Maiden's Peak or PokemonShipwreck.
I beg to differ.Orange Islands felt fresh,unique and had entirely different tone to it than future series.It was anime exclusive,with gyms and whole league format following different set of rules.Like having instead of gym matches shooting practice,races or making ice sculptures.Locations,gym leaders and whole stiry felt fresh,unorthpdox and out of place being one of regions where writers really could use their creativity and imagination to fullest.
Johto true didnt had such style of writing like Kanto had,but it can be noticed how it had some nice throwbacks to past.Like return of Kanto characters like Aya,Duplica,Suzie,Ritchie or Todd.It had several great and rather creative arcs like Red Gyarados,Lugia and its baby,Whirl cup and whirl islands feeling like mini region put into one,whole build up with Larvitar and quest to return it to its mother and mini arc with Clair involving old Dragonite and temple of dragons.
Recurring pokemon like Snubull or Delibird also strike to me as attempt to replicate Jigglypuff.
Regardless of what some may say Johto had some great episodes having certain doze of creativity into it when writers tried better,and original trio still had good dynamic when having chance to shin.
Yes Misty and Brock were neglected at times,but lack of screen time doesnt affect quality contributing to appeal whenever they had chance to shine.Heck even Ash suffered from lack of development in that region.
It's a shame really, I won't knock all of Johto, it did have some good plots.
It had pretty good chemistry between main cast too.I remember several memorable moments group shared feeling like throwback to Kanto days.Like when Ash battled Misty for Totodile or in Whirl Cup,when she criticized Brock for not taking initiative when it comes to girls"like "Heartbreak of Brock"),when Brock was sick with Ash and Misty having to take care of everything by themselves failing at cooking,when group got divided in forest having to pair up with Jessie,James and Meowth in "Forrest Grumps"etc,etc.And i believe "Gotta Catch Ya Later"best portrayed how strong bond those three had.
Johto had its highlights,but it seems some people only focus on fillers which werent their favorite cup of tea.
Eh who knows, I personally just blame how the time has passed over the years, everything changes, but looking back on Pokemon a lot of things have gone for it.
I still enjoy BW, so who knows maybe the second half of the saga will be a lot different.
I think it has more to do with fact how whole formula changed,back than writers werent so much focused on game promotion and cast changes like its case nowdays,having more liberty to go of road at times using their creativity to fullest.
I also agree about continuity.This anime used to have references to past much more in previous regions compared to Unova.Back than we had cameos from ex traveling companions being updated with some continuation being made,older pokemon from previous generations were still often used,there were provided several flashbacks to past like it was case with Ash in DP etc.
Not to mention way how replaced characters are treated ending up forgotten and abandoned despite having unfinished story and potential to offer more is disrespectful toward both characters and fans giving to anime bad reputation when it comes to continuity and its characters.
Its enough to take a look at Misty which is gone for 6 years,being completely ignored despite open story.Soon enough Brock,Dawn or May will fall in same hole too.