• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Question

Status
Not open for further replies.
tbh Johto was the first time the writers took on a full region for a good amount of years so of course its going to be hard to handle. People tend to forget this and hate on Johto

There is no excuse. Johto should have only been 100 episodes with the other 50 converted into a filler arc.
 
Hmm, I suppose Johto was quite new to things. Thinking about it realisticly, two major points made Johto bad.

-First region to have an extended amount of episodes, the writers were obviously unsure on how long to make the region last, which is probably why they waited at least until R/S/E were released, this then dragged in WAY too many fillers.

-First time handling new Pokemon onto the original team therefore causing a bit of a mess, dropping out the original crew one by one was poorly done, but this then made the writers obviously think fresh starts were the best thing to do beginning with AG to DP and then BW.

One thing I will never forgive the writers for though is dropping the GS Ball plot, they could have easily kept Movie 4 the storyline of Celebi travelling with the gang for an extended amount of time to at least make Johto a bit more bearable.

Now the GS Ball is just a really annoying plot device of the Orange Islands which ultimately had no purpose.
 
Last edited:
Johto didn't do anything new, besides maybe Ash winning his Gym battles more properly.

- No new characters were introduced

- Misty and Brock didn't really have any new developments whatsoever

- Gary stayed as the main rival, so nothing new on the rival front

- Ash's Johto team had new personalities, but couldn't live up to his Kanto team and wound up being his worst handled team overall as the series progressed

If the Johto saga was written the way Kanto was, it could have been a truly epic and worthy sequel to the original saga. Instead it just comes across as this long arc with endless fillers between Kanto/Orange and the eventual revamp of the show with AG and beyond.

I strongly believe the whole reason the original trio, Misty, and old formula was never used again was because of how Johto was received. Some might say Best Wishes is trying to be like the old series, but it has enough new elements from the AG and DP days to prevent it, even with no contests.
 
Johto didn't do anything new, besides maybe Ash winning his Gym battles more properly.

- No new characters were introduced

- Misty and Brock didn't really have any new developments whatsoever

- Gary stayed as the main rival, so nothing new on the rival front

- Ash's Johto team had new personalities, but couldn't live up to his Kanto team and wound up being his worst handled team overall as the series progressed

Very true, I believe this is because they tried to hard to keep the original formulae from Kanto though, which ultimately failed big time since nothing new was introduced to keep things 'fresh' to a level.

If the Johto saga was written the way Kanto was, it could have been a truly epic and worthy sequel to the original saga. Instead it just comes across as this long arc with endless fillers between Kanto/Orange and the eventual revamp of the show with AG and beyond.

It had a lot of potential, but looking at what it turned out to be it is quite depressing isn't it?

I enjoyed Johto, the episodes were fun and I have a lot of nostalgia for it, but besides that so many things were done wrong. It's a shame really.

I strongly believe the whole reason the original trio, Misty, and old formula was never used again was because of how Johto was received. Some might say Best Wishes is trying to be like the old series, but it has enough new elements from the AG and DP days to prevent it, even with no contests.

Yeah very true, Im interested to see if BW will keep Iris and Cilan for another saga though if im truly honest. I can see it happening and Region 6 being Johto 2.0 but better.
 
Johto didn't do anything new, besides maybe Ash winning his Gym battles more properly.

Disagreed.Johto had some improvements and new things introduced.
-gym matches and battling in general got improved being more strategic not ending up with KO left and right anymore.
-it added more characterization to Ash pokemon with their personalities being exploited more.In Kanto outside of starters anyone else had no real personality.Only problem was that Johto pokemon suffered from lack of focus clashing with Ash Kanto team which overshadowed them at times taking up unnecessary all that screen time.
-it introduced several mini tournaments(like Seaking contest,grass tournament,Pokemon sumo or bug catching contest)with purpose of putting something else on table beside only fillers which included typical COTD having problems.
-it was ground breaker in introducing anime arcs with Red Gyarados,lugia,Whirl islands and Whirl Cup,larvitar arc or arc involving Clair and Dragonite being one of best parts about Johto,.
-it depicted gym leaders in better light giving more insight in this characters and history.
-it got better at portrayal of several new pokemon with Kanto often not doing them justice
-Johto also introduced several new recurring characters like Sakura and Casey along with bringing up older ones from past(like Ritchie,Aya,Tood,Duplica etc)acting like sequel from first series.
-lastly chemistry between Ash,Misty and Brock was still fun feeling like genuine group of long time known friends.

- Misty and Brock didn't really have any new developments whatsoever

That isnt true.

Misty became more timid and sarcastic not being aggressive like she used to do learning how to become more patient and better control her temper side.This can be manifested in way she interacted with other characters like Sakura,Egan,Dorian etc becoming mature enough to get over her complex of inferiority which was caused by older sisters as well more confident which was show when she took care of lost Marill in "For Crying Out Loud" or when taking charge in finding Ash and Brock when group got separated from each other with Team Rocket for example.In early days she wasnt able to handle any criticism,being able to admit her own mistakes just sending out everyone to hell with zero to none patience being involved.
Her skills as water trainer have been vastly improved compared to Kanto days too receiving some character development regarding her goal of becoming water pokemon master by coming top 8 in Whirl Cup,evolving and catching water pokemon with her skills starting to become recognized by others.

Brock started to do steps forward in his breeder career receiving some development through various episodes,like when he took care of lost Stantler,entered contest for pokemon breeders along with Suzy along with his obsessiveness over girls being explored more beside just staying on running gag in some episodes like it was case with girl Temaku from "Heartbreak of Brock"or with that doctor which had Zubat.

I strongly believe the whole reason the original trio, Misty, and old formula was never used again was because of how Johto was received. Some might say Best Wishes is trying to be like the old series, but it has enough new elements from the AG and DP days to prevent it, even with no contests.

Going by that logic,how do you explain fact that May never returned to cast either?
If your going to use popularity of series as indicator why some characters disnt returned to cast,than your indirectly admitting how for same reason Honn group was nver runited afterwards as well and soon nough DP trio.

Reason why writers never brought Misty back to cast and reunited original trio afterwards is because after new characters were well received they opted to rather introduce new companions with each new generation to better go in correlation with games and their promotion.

That and as it was already explained in interview with ex pokemon director(Masamitsu Hidaka),writers rather want to switch up girls to try out new designs and provide new "eye candy"to male audience with each new generation(as sexist as that may sound).

Writers simply dont see a need to bring older characters regardless of popularity and potential when new companions are already doing fine,no matter how successful and popular previous female leads may have.

They have smarter thing to do than wasting their time around internet to read is fandom opinion about JOhto.

Reason why Johto failed was to put i simple,because writers were inexperienced not knowing how to handle long regions properly at that time.This was their first take on trying to stretch out region for 3 years before new games com out and they simply didnt had same amount of knowledge and experienced like they received later to handle some things right.

Johto didnt need to be written same like Kanto was,Orange Islands were very popular and they were fairly different from first season.
It just needed to focus more on anime plot and development of characters and pokemon,instead of having too many fillers which didnt advanced plot in any way.
 
Last edited:
JOHTO did have GOOD parts like the recurring characters, the arcs - The Whirl Cup, the Silver Leauge Tournament and parts of the Larvitar arc. Oh & unova's getting just as much hate as the people who are hating on Johto here so funny.
 
I agree Johto had some very good points, it's just a shame there wasn't enough of it. If more of those fillers were replaced by arcs it would have been better.
 
Yeah... but writers were inexperienced during that time not handling some things right. The writing started improving I believe in Master quest & then onward to hoenn.
 
Okay, let's put it this way:

If OS had more 'near death moments', then BW doesn't so, wha?

But, OS had more near-death and sad moments:

EP001 - I believe Ash almost drowned.
Squirtle threatened to kill Misty unless Ash got something.
Charmander almost died because it was left by its trainer.
The group almost died from the shipwreck.
The group and TRiO almost died from Gyarados.
Tentacruel episode (it destroyed buildings!)
Then Ghost of Maiden's Peak.
EP021 - Butterfree. Nuff said.
Ash and Pikachu died then came back to life.
Sabrina episode.
Celadon episode with Gloom and the fire.
Pikachu's Goodbye.
Giovanni's Gym.
Mewtwo Strikes Back. Ash died then came back to life.
Pokémon 2000 - Ash almost drowned.
Pallet episode - Pidgeot's goodbye (Ash never keeps promises.)
Lapras episode.
Charizard episode.

There is more, but that is all I can think of.

Unova?

Tepig episode and TR VS TP episode.

That is it.

So, while OS had a part of 'near death moments', BW is just too happy.

Yeah, you get the point.
 
I've constantly stated this before, but the reason why I believe the Anime is terrible now is that its just become one big advertisement for the Pokemon games. Sure, in the beginning in the Original Series, it was still about advertising for the games, cards, and various other products. But back then, the show had a meaning to it. It was about friendship, through thick and skin, about caring for others, no matter the circumstances. Think of episodes like "Snow Way Out!" and "Pikachu's Good-Bye!", and maybe even "The Pi-Kahuna!" They were all about friendship between Ash and his Pokemon, as they each showed the utmost love and care for one another, while a different persepective was taken in "The Pikahuna" from the main character, Victor's, eyes. It displayed the long-lastingness of friendship and caring and the great, profound effect that they can have on people.

Nowadays, the show is just there for the sake of advertising. It is about the cool battles and drama, stuff that will sell. Rarely is there a deeply emotional moment, or a heart-fulfilling or lesson-learning segment.

To basically sum it up in one perfect sentence:

The old show was entertainment with advertising, while the new show is advertising with entertainment.

...Well, I used to have the perfect quote with more fluent wording, but that's essentially it in a nutshell.
 
I've constantly stated this before, but the reason why I believe the Anime is terrible now is that its just become one big advertisement for the Pokemon games. Sure, in the beginning in the Original Series, it was still about advertising for the games, cards, and various other products. But back then, the show had a meaning to it. It was about friendship, through thick and skin, about caring for others, no matter the circumstances. Think of episodes like "Snow Way Out!" and "Pikachu's Good-Bye!", and maybe even "The Pi-Kahuna!" They were all about friendship between Ash and his Pokemon, as they each showed the utmost love and care for one another, while a different persepective was taken in "The Pikahuna" from the main character, Victor's, eyes. It displayed the long-lastingness of friendship and caring and the great, profound effect that they can have on people.

Nowadays, the show is just there for the sake of advertising. It is about the cool battles and drama, stuff that will sell. Rarely is there a deeply emotional moment, or a heart-fulfilling or lesson-learning segment.

To basically sum it up in one perfect sentence:

The old show was entertainment with advertising, while the new show is advertising with entertainment.

...Well, I used to have the perfect quote with more fluent wording, but that's essentially it in a nutshell.


Actually for me its better now. OS was boring and bad compared to AG and BW. I'm not a fan of DP for the second half but I'll admit I did enjoy the first 1120 eps or so.
 
I've constantly stated this before, but the reason why I believe the Anime is terrible now is that its just become one big advertisement for the Pokemon games. Sure, in the beginning in the Original Series, it was still about advertising for the games, cards, and various other products. But back then, the show had a meaning to it. It was about friendship, through thick and skin, about caring for others, no matter the circumstances. Think of episodes like "Snow Way Out!" and "Pikachu's Good-Bye!", and maybe even "The Pi-Kahuna!" They were all about friendship between Ash and his Pokemon, as they each showed the utmost love and care for one another, while a different persepective was taken in "The Pikahuna" from the main character, Victor's, eyes. It displayed the long-lastingness of friendship and caring and the great, profound effect that they can have on people.

Nowadays, the show is just there for the sake of advertising. It is about the cool battles and drama, stuff that will sell. Rarely is there a deeply emotional moment, or a heart-fulfilling or lesson-learning segment.

To basically sum it up in one perfect sentence:

The old show was entertainment with advertising, while the new show is advertising with entertainment.

...Well, I used to have the perfect quote with more fluent wording, but that's essentially it in a nutshell.

I agree with this. Although, I have to admit that I LOVED DP's battles.
 
Or like others, you can still enjoy Kanto and enjoy every arc afterward.

Aside from Johto's tedious filler eps, I really have enjoyed every saga of the anime to an extent. Its strange really, but something from each saga makes me want to watch it.
 
I think BW is losing the meaning of how friendship is so powerful instead they focus on pokemon evolution and battles. I know it's cool and all but pokemon has to have a meaning instead of the all powerful pokemons and the very cool evolutions. Here are the tags for pokemons century's ago. Friendship, love, fiction, helpful, and being able to stand up for your self and for your friends.Now these are BW's. Raw power, battles,evolution, showing off, and this one good thing forgivness.Now I still love pokemon and watching it but now I think the tags of love and friendship are starting to vanish. No offence to those who still think the love, friendship, and the voice is still their in pokemon.
 
Last edited:
Like, keeping the same characters and region (Unova), what would you change to make it as good as Kanto?

Er, I like Kanto the best out of any saga, but I also like the current saga second-best, and there isn't much I'd change about it....except make Team Plasma appear more, and give Ash an actual character like he had in Kanto. And maybe I'd tone down Clian a bit from how he's been behaving lately.

Well in all honesty, it's not that the recent seasons are doing anything wrong, it's just the whole atmosphere of the OS that the writers can't seem to bring back.

True....though technically, the atmosphere got lost during Johto, which was part of the OS. The way I see it, Takeshi Shudo was the heart of the series, and when he left, things just could never be the same.

You watch Kanto and Johto side by side, and despite using the same cast, the two sagas are nothing alike in terms of tone or writing.

.......Wow, for once, CyberCubed, I agree with you. Johto was at the opposite end of Kanto in terms of entertainment value, it was just boring.

Basically, I don't think it's necessarily the writers' fault that they can't replicate the same atmosphere the OS had.

Yes, but it's certainly their fault for screwing the anime up for as long as they have.

If you look towards the miniature Mewtwo story input to the anime, Giovanni's small scenes were very dark and serious every single time he appeared, it's what gave me hope for this atmosphere to return in BW.

The moment we watched Gary get defeated by an 'unknown' Pokemon at the 8th Gym it was very tense. Infact this type of atmosphere is something nearly every other season has lacked.

Agreed. Agreed 100%.

Can you imagine in DP if Paul only got 3 episodes before the Sinnoh league? How the hell would anyone get into the rivalry?.

I still can't see how the hell anyone got into the rivalry as it is in the show (where Paul appears far too often) but I digress.

I'd almost say the show is too focused on the Training aspect of the Pokemon world but that's blasphemous.

No, that's not blaspehmous, that's truth.
 
Last edited:
.......Wow, for once, CyberCubed, I agree with you. Johto was at the opposite end of Kanto in terms of entertainment value, it was just boring.

I was one of those original Pokemon fans who LOVED Kanto and liked Orange Islands. When Johto first started I thought it was going to be better than Orange and maybe even top Kanto. It didn't take long to realize the show was dumbed down though.

The first big disappointments came with Charizard and Squirtle being dumped out of the blue. At the time it was a shock to see them go...I thought they were getting the Pidgeot treatment. After that the GS ball is dropped with no resolution after nearly 2 years of build-up?

Lastly Ash's Johto team turned out to be incredibly underwhelming and disappointing, Misty's personality diminished and Gary barely appeared.

Then came the fillers. GOOD GOD. While some of them were good, the vast majority of them well the same damn stagnant predictable formula. Every goddamn episode felt like the same thing over and over again. Occasionally there would be a unique episode, but it didn't stop.

Johto also had terrible pacing. Why on earth did it need 157 episodes, when nearly 65-70% of them were filler?
 
I've constantly stated this before, but the reason why I believe the Anime is terrible now is that its just become one big advertisement for the Pokemon games. Sure, in the beginning in the Original Series, it was still about advertising for the games, cards, and various other products. But back then, the show had a meaning to it. It was about friendship, through thick and skin, about caring for others, no matter the circumstances. Think of episodes like "Snow Way Out!" and "Pikachu's Good-Bye!", and maybe even "The Pi-Kahuna!" They were all about friendship between Ash and his Pokemon, as they each showed the utmost love and care for one another, while a different persepective was taken in "The Pikahuna" from the main character, Victor's, eyes. It displayed the long-lastingness of friendship and caring and the great, profound effect that they can have on people.

Nowadays, the show is just there for the sake of advertising. It is about the cool battles and drama, stuff that will sell. Rarely is there a deeply emotional moment, or a heart-fulfilling or lesson-learning segment.

To basically sum it up in one perfect sentence:

The old show was entertainment with advertising, while the new show is advertising with entertainment.

...Well, I used to have the perfect quote with more fluent wording, but that's essentially it in a nutshell.

Missed this post before. Mostly agree, but again, I think the current saga actually has done several things right again.

So I wouldn't say the anime is "terrible now". It was terrible, but it's gotten better.

Then came the fillers. GOOD GOD.

Don't remind me. Ugh. Anytime I randomly look over Johto's episode list, I'm always blown away at just how much of it was filler.
 
Last edited:
I'll be honest enjoyed Johto over Kanto
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top