OK, they have "next pokemon catch" threads stickied, and I hope this will be deemed worthy of sticking as well, as the number of evolution threads could do with reducing.
As you may well know, I am an evolution nut. I generally prefer the evolved forms of most pokemon, and I believe that (within reason), most pokemon on the anime should evolve, or provide a decent reason why not. In this thread, you can discuss pokemon which you want to evolve on the team and how you felt about evolutions past. Here's my two cents;
Ash's Evolvable Pokemon
Pikachu
Let's face it, guys, it ain't gonna happen. And I admit that looking at a Raichu in every episode wouldn't be all that great. The only reason for Pikachu to evolve is if an alternate evo comes out, and even then it'll have to be marketable.
Naetle
Naetle is a Chikorita/Treecko rip-off. Therefore, it's gonna evolve at least once. I admit that Dotaitos would be a groovy addition, but for some reason I can't see it happening. It'll evolve into Nyashigame around about the fourth/fifth gym- it'll certainly come in handy in the water gym (the fourth)
Mukkubird
I can't see why Mukkuru would evolve so early unless it was gonna go all the way pretty early on. The writers may have learnt from Hoenn how a pokemon's popularity instantly increases when it evolves, and Swellow is a good example of that. We'll probably be seeing Mukkuhawk on the team before the league. It won't be much use in the later gyms, but it'll certainly be handy in the Sinnoh League.
Aipom
There's certain things that you can always be sure of in life- taxes, death, decline in quality of all forms of entertainment, Aipom evolving into Eteboss. It's there for no other reason. It's just a matter of playing the waiting game.
Corphish
It's not gonna happen, as much as I would have liked it to. Just to see a Dark-type on the team- especially one as crazy as Corphish. It stopped being funny in the BF, and I would have rather it evolve and get more battle time than become bland and forgettable as it gradually became.
Bulbasaur
Not happening now or ever, so there's not much point in discussing it. Besides, Sceptile owns it no matter what form it's in.
Squirtle
It hasn't happened in nearly 500 episodes, and it won't happen now. You can pretty much guarantee that if a pokemon at some point outdoes its evolved form (as it did in the Orange Islands firefighting episode), it won't be evolving into it any time soon.
Bayleef, Cyndaquil and Totodile
I just can't see these guys returning substantially at all. The writers clearly don't care for Ash's Johto team, and they aren't gonna be singled out to return when there's the Kanto and Hoenn pokemon as well as all the reserves. I want nothing more than to be proven wrong on this, but ultimately I've accepted this. Cyndaquil was, however, the unsung hero of Ash's gym campaign in Johto, and one of the first pokemon to develop in personality. It really should have evolved.
Brock's Evolvable Pokemon
Greggle
Will Greggle evolve? I don't know, and I can't even begin to guess. I have nothing to say for this one.
Marshtomp
You think of a reason to evolve it to which the answer won't just be "yeah, as if you're ever gonna see it" and I owe you a steak. Marshtomp is pretty cool, and Swampert would have been a welcome addition. But it won't happen.
Geodude
We're lucky the writers even remember it. With Onix's unseen evolution anything could happen, but I don't see what could come of Geodude's evolution in the long-run.
Hikari's Evolvable Pokemon
Pochama
It'll happen, and I think we all know that. We even had an early foreshadowing appearance of Pottiashi. We'll just have to wait and see.
Mimiroru
Hmm... will this Skitty-like pokemon evolve? I flat-out do not know. We don't know how the writers feel about Hikari's pokemon in regards to evolution, so it's up to them to make a decision.
Team Rocket's Evolvable Pokemon (well, James's anyway)
Mime Jr
Bonsly's evolution has freed up the chances of Mime Jr following suit. I personally hope it doesn't- a Mr Mime in every show would be down right painful. And with Mime Jr a confimred female imagine the n00b threads which will be bestowed upon us if it evolved into a female Mr Mime!
Cacnea
Just be glad it's alive, okay! With Harley gone the chances have increased VERY slightly, but it won't happen.
May's Evolvable Pokemon
Skitty
Skitty, unlike other May pokemon, didn't fall into the "ugly evolution" category that some idiots on this forum still persist to believe in- wasn't Glalie proof enough for you people? I wouldn't have minded a Delcatty on the show, it's a pretty cool pokemon.
Bulbasaur
This is one of those pokemon where stylistically evolution would have suited it, but the writers wanted it to be in a couple with Ash's Bulbasaur rather than evolve into the girlier and rarely seen Ivysaur. I guess these things happen.
Munchlax
Since May is obviously not going to return for longer than a couple of episodes, I see no reason why Munchlax has to stay unevolved anymore. Would they bother giving it a role in a May return episode? Doubt it.
Squirtle
Its evolution would mean more screentime, but would also mean some much-needed Wartortle screen-time. I'll let you decide on this one, since I doubt it'll be required to do much in any return episode for May anyway. But there's one thing we can guarantee- its power would suit it a lot better if it did evolve.
Eevee
If May re-appears, she'll have a grass or ice Eevee. Which one? Search me.
As you may well know, I am an evolution nut. I generally prefer the evolved forms of most pokemon, and I believe that (within reason), most pokemon on the anime should evolve, or provide a decent reason why not. In this thread, you can discuss pokemon which you want to evolve on the team and how you felt about evolutions past. Here's my two cents;
Ash's Evolvable Pokemon
Pikachu
Let's face it, guys, it ain't gonna happen. And I admit that looking at a Raichu in every episode wouldn't be all that great. The only reason for Pikachu to evolve is if an alternate evo comes out, and even then it'll have to be marketable.
Naetle
Naetle is a Chikorita/Treecko rip-off. Therefore, it's gonna evolve at least once. I admit that Dotaitos would be a groovy addition, but for some reason I can't see it happening. It'll evolve into Nyashigame around about the fourth/fifth gym- it'll certainly come in handy in the water gym (the fourth)
Mukkubird
I can't see why Mukkuru would evolve so early unless it was gonna go all the way pretty early on. The writers may have learnt from Hoenn how a pokemon's popularity instantly increases when it evolves, and Swellow is a good example of that. We'll probably be seeing Mukkuhawk on the team before the league. It won't be much use in the later gyms, but it'll certainly be handy in the Sinnoh League.
Aipom
There's certain things that you can always be sure of in life- taxes, death, decline in quality of all forms of entertainment, Aipom evolving into Eteboss. It's there for no other reason. It's just a matter of playing the waiting game.
Corphish
It's not gonna happen, as much as I would have liked it to. Just to see a Dark-type on the team- especially one as crazy as Corphish. It stopped being funny in the BF, and I would have rather it evolve and get more battle time than become bland and forgettable as it gradually became.
Bulbasaur
Not happening now or ever, so there's not much point in discussing it. Besides, Sceptile owns it no matter what form it's in.
Squirtle
It hasn't happened in nearly 500 episodes, and it won't happen now. You can pretty much guarantee that if a pokemon at some point outdoes its evolved form (as it did in the Orange Islands firefighting episode), it won't be evolving into it any time soon.
Bayleef, Cyndaquil and Totodile
I just can't see these guys returning substantially at all. The writers clearly don't care for Ash's Johto team, and they aren't gonna be singled out to return when there's the Kanto and Hoenn pokemon as well as all the reserves. I want nothing more than to be proven wrong on this, but ultimately I've accepted this. Cyndaquil was, however, the unsung hero of Ash's gym campaign in Johto, and one of the first pokemon to develop in personality. It really should have evolved.
Brock's Evolvable Pokemon
Greggle
Will Greggle evolve? I don't know, and I can't even begin to guess. I have nothing to say for this one.
Marshtomp
You think of a reason to evolve it to which the answer won't just be "yeah, as if you're ever gonna see it" and I owe you a steak. Marshtomp is pretty cool, and Swampert would have been a welcome addition. But it won't happen.
Geodude
We're lucky the writers even remember it. With Onix's unseen evolution anything could happen, but I don't see what could come of Geodude's evolution in the long-run.
Hikari's Evolvable Pokemon
Pochama
It'll happen, and I think we all know that. We even had an early foreshadowing appearance of Pottiashi. We'll just have to wait and see.
Mimiroru
Hmm... will this Skitty-like pokemon evolve? I flat-out do not know. We don't know how the writers feel about Hikari's pokemon in regards to evolution, so it's up to them to make a decision.
Team Rocket's Evolvable Pokemon (well, James's anyway)
Mime Jr
Bonsly's evolution has freed up the chances of Mime Jr following suit. I personally hope it doesn't- a Mr Mime in every show would be down right painful. And with Mime Jr a confimred female imagine the n00b threads which will be bestowed upon us if it evolved into a female Mr Mime!
Cacnea
Just be glad it's alive, okay! With Harley gone the chances have increased VERY slightly, but it won't happen.
May's Evolvable Pokemon
Skitty
Skitty, unlike other May pokemon, didn't fall into the "ugly evolution" category that some idiots on this forum still persist to believe in- wasn't Glalie proof enough for you people? I wouldn't have minded a Delcatty on the show, it's a pretty cool pokemon.
Bulbasaur
This is one of those pokemon where stylistically evolution would have suited it, but the writers wanted it to be in a couple with Ash's Bulbasaur rather than evolve into the girlier and rarely seen Ivysaur. I guess these things happen.
Munchlax
Since May is obviously not going to return for longer than a couple of episodes, I see no reason why Munchlax has to stay unevolved anymore. Would they bother giving it a role in a May return episode? Doubt it.
Squirtle
Its evolution would mean more screentime, but would also mean some much-needed Wartortle screen-time. I'll let you decide on this one, since I doubt it'll be required to do much in any return episode for May anyway. But there's one thing we can guarantee- its power would suit it a lot better if it did evolve.
Eevee
If May re-appears, she'll have a grass or ice Eevee. Which one? Search me.
Last edited: