• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Type Effectivity Changes

Pokegoth

My Chinese Village
Heys, people! This is a thread for what you would change about type effectivity, like ______ should be supereffective/ineffective/etc. against ______, BECAUSE... Don't get it? I'll give you some examples:

I think that:

Ice should be supereffective against Water because Ice freezes Water.

Psychic should be supereffective against Steel because of the Psychics who can bend metal with their minds.

Poison should not effect Ghost because Ghosts are dead, they can't be poisoned.


Got it? Good. Here are my rules:

1. Follow Serebii Forum Rules, of course.

2. Be courteous. You may disagree, but be polite about it.

3. Back up your ideas with information. Don't just say "dark shood be good against ice!!11122``1!111!" Tell us WHY.

4. Try your best to use proper Enlgish, PLEASE.

5. FOLLOW MY RULES.

That's all. (I'm not very good at starting threads, so bear with me, okay?)
 
Psychic should be supereffective against Steel because of the Psychics who can bend metal with their minds.That would take out the point in the existence of Steel types.

Poison should not effect Ghost because Ghosts are dead, they can't be poisoned.So lets make Poison types even crappier!


5. FOLLOW MY RULES.I'll ignore this for now.

That's all. (I'm not very good at starting threads, so bear with me, okay?)

Comments in bold.
 
Poison should effect Ghosts, but be not very effective against them like they are now. And if Ghost Pokémon are dead, how do they reproduce?
Water requires a long-term exposure to cold temperatures in order to freeze. Part of the reason Ice-attacks are not very effective against Water is that Ice is Water, just in a different form.
 
Comments in bold.

Um... thanks for your post? *offended*

Fine. Stuff for Poison:

Poison should be supereffective against Water, because of Water pollution.
Poison should be supereffective against Bug, like in the First Gen.
Poison could be supereffective against Steel because of Acids.
Poison could be supereffective against Normal because they seem to have less resistance than other pokemon. (don't hurt me for that!)

These are stupid, but:
Ice should be supereffective against Psychic because of brainfreeze.
Psychic should be supereffective against itself because their brains would be more susceptable(sp?) to it because they're always using it.
Psychic should be supereffective against Normal because their brains are also more susceptable(sp?) to it because they're simpler than others.
 
Water requires a long-term exposure to cold temperatures in order to freeze. Part of the reason Ice-attacks are not very effective against Water is that Ice is Water, just in a different form.

That's why I think Ice should also resist water. Seems a bit unfair that water resists Ice but Ice doesnt resist water. Water should be weak against poison, because of the whole pollution thing.
 
Fine. Stuff for Poison:

Poison should be supereffective against Water, because of Water pollution.
Poison should be supereffective against Bug, like in the First Gen.
Poison could be supereffective against Steel because of Acids.
Poison could be supereffective against Normal because they seem to have less resistance than other pokemon. (don't hurt me for that!)
Water dilutes Poison, so it cancels out. Plus, Pokémon like Dorapion and Venusaur aren't polluting the enviroment last time I checked.
Some bugs and such actually resist poison.
Not all poisons are corrosive. Think about it- most metals block poisons.
Uhh... sure.

And Psychic shouldn't get more powerful- the main reason for the advent of Dark and Steel types was to weaken Psychic.
 
Um... thanks for your post? *offended*

Fine. Stuff for Poison:

Poison should be supereffective against Water, because of Water pollution.
Poison should be supereffective against Bug, like in the First Gen.
Poison could be supereffective against Steel because of Acids.
Poison could be supereffective against Normal because they seem to have less resistance than other pokemon. (don't hurt me for that!)

These are stupid, but:
Ice should be supereffective against Psychic because of brainfreeze.
Psychic should be supereffective against itself because their brains would be more susceptable(sp?) to it because they're always using it.
Psychic should be supereffective against Normal because their brains are also more susceptable(sp?) to it because they're simpler than others.

Ah yes, Normal types are simpler then others, Kecleon, Ditto, Smeargle, Castform, Regigigas and Aruseus to name a few.

Your logic makes little sense, it's like suggesting Fire > Water because of Evaporation, and GeorgeBush > Ice because of Global Warming.

Personally, Rock type should resist Electric type attacks, and before people go 'omfgyounoobitalreadydoeslololol' go use thunderbolt on a Nosepass.
 
Depending what kind of rock it is, Rock should either resist or be weak to Electric. It depends on the composition of the rock.
Yes I am in chemistry.
 
Ah yes, Normal types are simpler then others, Kecleon, Ditto, Smeargle, Castform, Regigigas and Aruseus to name a few.

Your logic makes little sense,

Um... okay. I make little sense. And I meant normals in GENERAL. Of course there are exceptions. And Kecleon, Castform, and Arseus barely count as normal, for they all change types.
 
Um... okay. I make little sense. And I meant normals in GENERAL. Of course there are exceptions. And Kecleon, Castform, and Arseus barely count as normal, for they all change types.

Yes but in what way do they have worse defenses in general? And why would they be more susceptable to psychic types then any other type?
Your reasons were BARELY specific enough...
 
Poison > Bug because of pesticides
Poison > Water because of water pollution
Ice > Rock cause when ice freezes a rock it expands the tiniest cracks in the rock and causes it to crumble.
Ghost > Normal... Poltergeists

Ground should resist Fire cause you can't set fire to dirt...
Ghost should resist Psychic cause ghosts are out of this realm and are hard to contact even with psychic powers
Bug should resist Psychic cause psychics are scared of bugs
Water should resist Ground cause liquid can't break and takes the shape of its container
 
Last edited:
Poison > Bug because of pesticides
Poison > Water because of water pollution
Ice > Rock cause when ice freezes a rock it expands the tiniest cracks in the rock and causes it to crumble.
Ghost > Normal... Poltergeists

Ground should resist Fire
Ghost should resist Psychic
Bug should resist Psychic
Water should resist Ground

I agree with all the above except the Bug & Psychic, Ghost & Psychic, and Water & Ground ones.
 
Care to explain why you disagree?

Whoops. Well, I think that even though Bugs have less developed brains, they are still as susceptible(sp?) to Psychic attacks as other pokemon. I'd explain my other ones, but they're not good arguments, to tell the truth.
 
Steel > Dragon cause of a swords killing dragons

Steel should resist poison instead of having no effect because how can you tell me pokemon like Lucario can't get poisoned?
Ground should be neutral to Poison cause I see no reason why it has a super effective status against it
 
Steel > Dragon cause of a swords killing dragons

Steel should resist poison instead of having no effect because how can you tell me pokemon like Lucario can't get poisoned?
Ground should be neutral to Poison cause I see no reason why it has a super effective status against it

I agree with that, swords, spears etc,
 
Electric should also be super effective against Steel cause if there ever was a toaster pokemon Rotomu should land super effective hits against it....
 
Should'nt STEEL be weak to ELECTRIC since STEEL conducts ELECTRICITY like WATER does?

Also SHOULD'NT FIRE also be weak to ICE because when ICE hits the FIRE it turns to WATER which puts out the FIRE?

Why should FLYING be weak to ICE?

Because of snowstorms that cancel flights?

FIRE should be immune to FIRE not resist it and WATER should also be immune to WATER...you get my point..

If you want awesome Trainer Cards, click this link:

http://www.serebiiforums.com/showthread.php?t=177691

signed-
Gregory ;026;
 
I always thought Water should be supper-effective against Steel, because many other people also refer to Steel as Metal (ie. in TCG). Water rusts metal, why not?

Though that'd be making water stronger...and speaking of it, should the Water/Electrice type difference go both ways?

~fuzzy out~
 
Back
Top