• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

2 Types Attack

Status
Not open for further replies.

SpeedDeoxys

Am I wrong here?
I was thinking about attacks, that have 2 types. For example: Ice Punch (Ice/Fighting) or Shadow Ball (Ghost/Dark). Is this good for Pokémon or bad?
 
I have already thought on this, but it's not a nice idea. It would help to hit effectively more targets, but it would be harder to coverage attacks.
 
Well, it could work like this: each move has a 50% chance of being one type or the other. Like for example, Shadow Ball. Half the time it will do Ghost-type damage, half the time Dark-type damage. A notice would appear on the game screen that chooses the type for each use.
 
I was thinking about attacks, that have 2 types. For example: Ice Punch (Ice/Fighting) or Shadow Ball (Ghost/Dark). Is this good for Pokémon or bad?

Bad as it would break the game and very unbalance.
 
While I agree that two type attacks could be too complicated a potentially unbalancing, I think attacks that play with the type system could be interesting if used sparingly.

Like having certain moves have special clauses making them more less effective against certain types beyond the confines of the normal chart. (a little bit like how psyshock plays with the physical special split) We may already even have some moves like this, but I can't think of any off the top of my head. Of course careful thinking would still need to be done to make sure nothing that totally messes up the type system is indtroduced. (which isn't too hard to do with some decent judgement)

And of course we already got some moves like Boiling Water, which while still a water type move can burn things sort like a fire type move. (making it a sort of dual type move conceptually)
 
Last edited:
while im usually all about adding new levels of difficulty and strategy to games, i think this would increase it by waaay to much.
maybe you could set a certian move to the type that you want, or you could have it randomized, but thats all i got.
 
Well, it could work like this: each move has a 50% chance of being one type or the other. Like for example, Shadow Ball. Half the time it will do Ghost-type damage, half the time Dark-type damage. A notice would appear on the game screen that chooses the type for each use.

That would be terrible, no offense! That would make battling so much harder and mess with strategy and all....no way! Interesting idea, but no.
 
Seems a little too difficult to remember. I still sit there and try to figure out what attacks are supereffective and it takes me two hours with one type attacks. xD
 
Nah, I think it's a bad idea. For one, move combos like water/grass for example would absolutely PWN certain Pokemon. Balancing would be a nightmare. Not to mention the fact that finding a Pokemon to effectively defend against those moves would be insane. Plus what would a move like Ice Punch (Ice/Fighting) do to a Pokemon like Magnezone? Would the "Not Very Effective" from the Ice take precedent? Or would the "Super Effective" Fighting be taken into account. Overall, it sounds like it would be an utter mess.
 
It's tricky enough for the target audience of Pokemon (i. e. children) to figure out which attack will be effective or not, especially with dual-types Pokemon coming into play, but if you were to add a second type to attacks, they would not only have to calculate one move type's effectiveness against the Pokemon, but the second type too, add the results, and repeat for the other three moves they have. It's far too much for their minds, and it would simply be annoying to our minds. Now, moves or abilities that impose a secondary type on attacks while in effect could be a different story (Like Sunny Day, only it adds a fire subtype to all attacks). Although, one has to wonder how abilities like Flash Fire would factor into the equation.
 
The true closest are the TCG attacks that require 2 types of energy, and those are simplified by having them be the type of the PKMN (Quagsire, anyone?). It won't be good for the in game, as previously stated.
 
I thought about this alot as well, And then I decided it wold be horrible! It would DESTROY the gameplay and strategics
 
I have thought about this, but it would be rteally complicated. Like, double STAB, 8x damage, and many other things which would really make it much more mathematical
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top