• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

ash voice

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think you and others are allowing nostalgia to cloud your judgement. The voice acting was horrible in Battle Frontier but that was because they were just starting out and were trying to imitate the 4Kids dub. Once DP came around it was much better and by its end surpassed the one before it.

This is just like the situation with DBZ. When Funimation took over the dub from Ocean, many people hated it but over time have come to love it more than its predecessor. I wonder how long it will take before pokemon fans do the same.

Are you actually being serious? How does nostalgia do with ANYTHING? Sarah sounds too old to voice Ash, and not to forget she has a smoker voice, and she doesn't even get much acting into it.

DP was awful interms of acting too. Brock, James, and Meowth were the worst. Instead of imitating James older voice he sounded like a sick stuffy nose guy. and I think YOU are letting your obsessive love for DP cloud your judgment because that's all you care about. I haven't seen you point out ONE flaw on that arc.

Who said many ? DBZ was still awesome after Funimation took over. Funimation is awesome, and I can easily argue with someone who says it isn't

It takes a real person to actually know talent--so don't you dare throw out the usual nostalgia crap at me.

I wonder how the dub would have been if Funi picked it up instead of TCPI

Better my friend. Unlike the newer dubbing company (which has zero talent) Funimation has full talent.
 
Are you actually being serious? How does nostalgia do with ANYTHING? Sarah sounds too old to voice Ash, and not to forget she has a smoker voice, and she doesn't even get much acting into it.

DP was awful interms of acting too. Brock, James, and Meowth were the worst. Instead of imitating James older voice he sounded like a sick stuffy nose guy. and I think YOU are letting your obsessive love for DP cloud your judgment because that's all you care about. I haven't seen you point out ONE flaw on that arc.

Who said many ? DBZ was still awesome after Funimation took over. Funimation is awesome, and I can easily argue with someone who says it isn't

It takes a real person to actually know talent--so don't you dare throw out the usual nostalgia crap at me.

Agreed. To add to this, I prefer The Origin's English voice acting by far to the TPCi dub(s), and I actually liked Bryce Papenbrook as Red, JYB as Brock, and Kyle Hebert as Professor Oak, so obviously I'm not nostalgic when I say that JYB was far better as Brock than Bill Rogers ever was, and same goes for Kyle Hebert vs. Carter Cathcart as Professor Oak. I would gladly take Bosch and Hebert as Brock and Prof. Oak over Rogers and Cathcart, any day of the week, yet even then I still think Eric Stuart and Stuart Zagnit were the best Brock and Prof. Oak in English (respectively).

There's a difference between "nostalgia" and being able to tell when something is genuinely better and more fitting, but I guess some people will never be able to tell the difference.

The FUNimation DBZ cast (excluding some like King Kai, Recoome, and such) actually improved as time went on as well, while I'd say the TPCi Pokemon cast has actually gotten worse and worse as time went on, not better.

To name just a few examples, Brock in DP and BW116 sounded even worse than in BF, TR in XY sounds worse than in BF, DP, or BW, Prof. Oak in BW sounded even worse than in BF or DP, same goes for Delia in BW142 v. in BF, DP, or earlier BW. I could go on, but it speaks for itself.
 
Last edited:
LOL @ chalkus saying those who prefer the 4Kids cast are "nostalgic". There are some 4Kids voices I don't like (James, Meowth's second voice), but as a whole, the voice cast is better.

And let's not start on the awful script writing...

To name just a few examples, Brock in DP and BW116 sounded even worse than in BF, TR in XY sounds worse than in BF, DP, or BW, Prof. Oak in BW sounded even worse than in BF or DP, same goes for Delia in BW142 v. in BF, DP, or earlier BW. I could go on, but it speaks for itself.

And May sounded worse in DP than in BF...
 
Last edited:
LOL @ chalkus saying those who prefer the 4Kids cast are "nostalgic". There are some 4Kids voices I don't like (James, Meowth's second voice), but as a whole, the voice cast is better.

And let's not start on the awful script writing...

And May sounded worse in DP than in BF...

Or the awful intros, endings, and subpar + languid dub BGM, but I digress.

Even Prof. Stan Oak will say either of James' 4Kids voices and Meowth's second voice are better than Carter's current renditions of those characters, and she doesn't even like them-- says a lot right there.

Correct on May.

Back on topic, Taylor was the best English Ash, easily.

I wonder how the dub would have been if Funi picked it up instead of TCPI

Better, not worse (it's also spelt TPCi, but that's not the important part).
 
Last edited:
I can name plenty of 4kids VA's I don't like either.
But I love Maddie xD
For example, I dislike Liza Ortiz's work (she mainly does characters of the day, or recurring characters)
I feel like her voice is sometimes too obnoxious. So I dislike. How is that nostalgic, chalkus? hmm?
 
I can name plenty of 4kids VA's I don't like either.
But I love Maddie xD
For example, I dislike Liza Ortiz's work (she mainly does characters of the day, or recurring characters)
I feel like her voice is sometimes too obnoxious. So I dislike. How is that nostalgic, chalkus? hmm?

Same here.
Me too: I like Stuart as James, too-- more so in Kanto, OI and Johto, though, but that's just me.

Yeah, I didn't like Lisa Ortiz much (I still don't like her work in the current dub) in Pokemon-- she was great in Slayers as Lina Inverse, but here? Literally the same voice for all COTDs, Pokemon, etc.

Exactly.
 
I can name plenty of 4kids VA's I don't like either.
But I love Maddie xD
For example, I dislike Liza Ortiz's work (she mainly does characters of the day, or recurring characters)
I feel like her voice is sometimes too obnoxious. So I dislike. How is that nostalgic, chalkus? hmm?

Same here on Lisa Ortiz. I also thought Jimmy Zoppi and Kayzie Rogers voiced too many elderly people back then.
 
Lisa ortiz was tolerable when she was only in a few roles, but then 4kids got lazy and cast her as every single girl/woman from Johto and Hoenn who appeared.

It's the same thing they did with all the little boy characters besides Max, they gave all the little boy characters Richie's voice and didn't bother making it sound different.
 
Same here on Lisa Ortiz. I also thought Jimmy Zoppi and Kayzie Rogers voiced too many elderly people back then.

Also agreed: Jimmy Zoppi (aka Carter Cathcart) was everywhere in particular-- he even got cast as the grandma in "The Problem with Paras!" IIRC.

Lisa ortiz was tolerable when she was only in a few roles, but then 4kids got lazy and cast her as every single girl/woman from Johto and Hoenn who appeared.

It's the same thing they did with all the little boy characters besides Max, they gave all the little boy characters Richie's voice and didn't bother making it sound different.

Pretty much, yeah, that's right.

I have to agree-- it was always Tara Jayne as x character for the most part.

Though, I can say this goes for the TPCi dub as well since Sinnoh up until Kalos: practically every other COTD is voiced by Tom Wayland, Marc Thompson (e.g. over 2/3 of the COTDs in BW), or Sean Schemmel (e.g. over 1/4 of the COTDs in DP and BW) using their same old voices for everyone.
 
Last edited:
Lisa ortiz was tolerable when she was only in a few roles, but then 4kids got lazy and cast her as every single girl/woman from Johto and Hoenn who appeared.

Not only that but she stopped varying her range of voices. Back then, Sabrina didn't sound like Cassandra, who didn't sound like Wendy. The same can't be said for most of the filler characters or gym leaders of Johto and Hoenn.
 
Not only that but she stopped varying her range of voices. Back then, Sabrina didn't sound like Cassandra, who didn't sound like Wendy. The same can't be said for most of the filler characters or gym leaders of Johto and Hoenn.

Yeah, I actually liked her Sabrina because it was distinct from her other roles, but afterwards she just used the same Lina Inverse voice for every COTD, more or less.

Oshawott also sounded like Lina Inverse, too, more or less, but that's a different story.
 
Not only that but she stopped varying her range of voices. Back then, Sabrina didn't sound like Cassandra, who didn't sound like Wendy. The same can't be said for most of the filler characters or gym leaders of Johto and Hoenn.

Yeah definitely, I didn't even know she did Sabrina. I was shocked given Sabrina's voice in the dub was one of my favorites.

I did think she did a good job with Flannery from Hoenn though.
 
Yeah definitely, I didn't even know she did Sabrina. I was shocked given Sabrina's voice in the dub was one of my favorites.

I did think she did a good job with Flannery from Hoenn though.

Me too: I'm surprised that sounded so good and threatening, or nothing like Lina Inverse.

Same here, but that's because it actually fit the character, IMO: Battle Girl Shauna, etc. = nope, just annoying.

Anyway, back on topic, Ash's voice-- Taylor did it best, enough said.
 
Last edited:
Lisa ortiz was tolerable when she was only in a few roles, but then 4kids got lazy and cast her as every single girl/woman from Johto and Hoenn who appeared.

It's the same thing they did with all the little boy characters besides Max, they gave all the little boy characters Richie's voice and didn't bother making it sound different.
Lol this. I think someone needs to award you for one of my favorite roles.

Anyways, I can't see how there is people who use the nostalgia excuse. There are many DuArt and TPCi actors I am very fond to. I actually prefer the other Tracey rather than Ted Lewis, but I prefer Ted Lewis as Giovanni the most.

I also like how they kept the original narrater. I mean, Hoenn's was alright, but I still prefer the one now. And Serena's VA now isn't bad.
 
Lol this. I think someone needs to award you for one of my favorite roles.

Anyways, I can't see how there is people who use the nostalgia excuse. There are many DuArt and TPCi actors I am very fond to. I actually prefer the other Tracey rather than Ted Lewis, but I prefer Ted Lewis as Giovanni the most.

I also like how they kept the original narrater. I mean, Hoenn's was alright, but I still prefer the one now. And Serena's VA now isn't bad.

I would + rep him for that post, but I can't since I already did lol.

Agreed. Yeah, I like Nicholas DiMichele, Jessica Paquet, Eli James, and Bill Timoney, to name a few I like from the TPCi/DuArt cast.
I don't on Tracey, personally: Ted Lewis gave him more character-- Craig Blair just phoned it in, IMO. Agreed on Giovanni, though.

Well, they brought him back, actually: that's the only voice for the main cast I prefer now over a previous voice-over, but then, Rodger Parsons also narrated EP001-AG020 so there's that. Also agreed.

Anyway, back on topic again, Ash's voice was best done by Veronica Taylor.
 
Last edited:
I think the thread has run its course. Now it's just the same people debating over and over, which is kinda pointless.

Moving on~
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top