I like Natochenny the best. I don't mind deeper voices for characters who look older than they're stated to be.
I think Rogers could've improved a lot if given the chance.
Too bad Ash is 10 years old-- that alone makes Veronica Taylor superior and the best of the bunch.
I think she could've improved a lot more than Sarah did if given the chance.
I don't feel that's the case since many characters sound older or younger than they are.
Nice attempt at trying to force your opinions everywhere, though.
I don't feel that's the case since many characters sound older or younger than they are.
Yeah, in the TPCi dub, sure they do.
Nice attempt at ignoring the facts, too-- maybe you should try thinking hard about it for a change. I'm stating my opinion with actual logic for my choice and why I feel the other two voice actors did not do the role well.
So do many people in real life.
In many dubs from works like Funimation, Viz, etc. It's not even a dub-exclusive thing.
Ignoring facts? I don't care about your opinions.
No, I'm saying you're ignoring the fact that Ash is a 10 year old boy
Ash looks thirteen at most, but he sounds about five years older. In the 4Kids dub, he sounds only three years older than ten at most.
No, I didn't. I specifically said that I don't mind if they sound older if they look it.
Ash looks thirteen at most, but he sounds about five years older in TPCi's dub. In the 4Kids dub, he sounds only three years older than ten at most.
Then it's fortunate that people can sound older than they look.
He didn't, though: he was saying at most, even if you're pushing it to extremes, he sounded that old.
Ash is 10 years old, and that's a fact. Enough said right there-- he doesn't even look older to me at all.
He didn't what?
Okay. Quite a few people thought he did, especially during Sinnoh.

Say that people can sound older than they look
He was 10 in Sinnoh, too
Honestly, my favorite one was the Sinnoh one (oh boy is Dwail going to argue on that one!). It wasn't too "sore throat" like late Battle Frontier (which was really bad, in my opinion) and it sounded like the most masculine voice Ash ever got, which I liked, actually. Ash's BW and current voice is a little bit too girly to me (I know, he's supposed to be 10, not have a masculine voice, but still) and I liked how Ash's Sinnoh voice sounded.
His Johto and Hoenn voice was just fine, if not awesome, but I had a big dislike on the fat-souding voice he had in early OS. Iw as traumatized when I first heard it.
My personal favorites;
Sinnoh > Hoenn/(early Battle Frontier) = Johto > BW = XY > (late) OS > (early) OS.
I don't prefer Veronica because she's the original: I prefer her as Ash because she managed to keep Ash's voice consistent after settling into the role, always made Ash emote with passion in her acting, and he always sounded like a little boy to me. She is the one and only English actress that I feel I can truly say was, is, and will always be Ash Ketchum at this point-- at least unless another actor/actress manages to come along and do it right. Neither Sarah, nor Kayzie, got it down correctly, IMO.
Reminds me of me? Man, you're even talking like the current Ash now...that sounded SO stupid when he said that back in DP dubbed (no offense-- I just have bad memories of Ash saying this from "Strategy Begins at Home!")
Anyway, I respect your opinion, but the only one I feel did the role justice was Veronica Taylor, his 1st actress. I really can't stomach Kayzie Rogers' take on him, or Sarah Natochenny's take on him, anymore-- both feel so incredibly subpar and inadequate for me that it doesn't even match the character to me, be it his age, personality, or anything. Ash feels so soulless and emotionless now in the dub to me: it hurts.
I'm actually wondering if I'm meant to feel insulted by the first couple of sentences... Anyway, onto the main point I wanted to make, you say you respect my opinion, so why do you keep trying to convince me I'm wrong? Because that's what it sounds like. Can you not understand that I like all his voice actors, including Veronica Taylor, and no amount of saying how awful you think the others are, is going to persuade me that I'm wrong. I apologise if I come off as rude or anything or if it was a complete accident that you sounded like this, but it's been bugging me for a while.
But onto another point that I was thinking about for a bit, if I had to choose a favourite VA, I would probably choose the AG one (whose name escapes me). Especially in the movie Pokemon Ranger and The Temple of the Sea (I think that's the title, I might be wrong), I thought that was lovely. I still love em' all though.