Personally, I see no similarity in Veronica Taylor and Sarah Natochenny's performances, tbh, and I don't see how (again, IMO) the voice of a late adolescent who smokes sounds anything like a kid's voice-- in clear opposition, Veronica Taylor's Ash did, and that's why I prefer her take on Ash. Not to mention Sarah is always inconsistent with his voice and the pitch fluctuates wildly from episode to episode, never staying in a consistent tone. Don't even get me started on how she voiced Kid Ash just a few episodes back in the XY dub...that was all kinds of wrong to hear an even younger boy with the voice of Johanna, a fully grown woman. The laugh? Do I even need to go into how that doesn't sound genuine or realistic in the least to me: "ehh-ha-he-ha-he-he-he" (I seriously hear Fran the Nanny's Laugh in that).
Now if Bryce Papenbrook was Ash now (the guy who voiced Red in The Origin's English dub), I could probably live with a new voice for Ash-- I liked his work, so there's that. I'm not opposed to a new voice, but I definitely want it to fit the character's age + personality, and neither Sarah nor Kayzie ever did it for me holistically. The closest of those two was Sarah in BW (pre-116 where she regressed until the end of that saga), but of course, that's gone directly back to square one and completely regressed in XY's dub, so...:'(.
The only other thing that could work for me is if Ash actually aged already getting older, but since that's never happening, my preference is pretty strongly one-sided here in favor of Veronica Taylor. No offense to those of you who disagree, but that's my logic for my preference: it's not nostalgia that leads me to this preference.