• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Paul

Status
Not open for further replies.
Paul and Silver have a few similarities but they are totally 2 different characters.

Yeah, but the guy is believed to have been based on Silver, to the point where they even dress similarly and have similar hairstyles. The Johto Pokemon being reintroduced in Sinnoh doesn't help much either.
 
paul and sliver were the same like ash and red were the same
 
How is it an insult? Paul looks exactly like Silver. I thought Paul was actually based on him. He looks just like him and even acts like him too.

Paul may resemble Silver and have a similar approach to Pokemon, but he doesn't act that much like him (Silver could at least show some emotions!), and his character progressed way differently than Silver's did. Paul doesn't even have the virtue of having an interesting backstory. He's just a jerk because the writing of the show required him to be so. Silver wasn't nearly that boring.

Paul and Silver have a few similarities but they are totally 2 different characters.

Uh-huh, this is true. Silver may have been the basis for Paul, but Paul isn't Silver.
 
Last edited:
Have you ever heard of the terms Jerk Sue and Karma Houdini? Paul, that detestable little jerk, DEFINES those terms.

And that's all I'm gonna say about him.
 
I thought this was about the movie :p

But l think it was harsh how he treated chimchar especially, now that chimchar kicked butt, l think ash is better. I think he shouldve been the rival in 4th gen
 
I notice out of the people saying they hate him, its members that are most likely female. Just going by the icons you've all chose, your signatures, names, and way of speaking.

Ladies, good shows need conflict. Sweet, sugary chararcters don't make a good or believable story. All people have skeletonsin their closet and all good stories should avoid Mary Sues as much as possible. Morally, Ash is a little too much of a goody two shoes for my taste. Hes never even had to give a second thought about doing the right thing. Its not realistic
 
Ladies, good shows need conflict. Sweet, sugary chararcters don't make a good or believable story. All people have skeletonsin their closet and all good stories should avoid Mary Sues as much as possible. Morally, Ash is a little too much of a goody two shoes for my taste. Hes never even had to give a second thought about doing the right thing. Its not realistic

I'll take THAT over a monster like Paul any day of the week.
 
I notice out of the people saying they hate him, its members that are most likely female. Just going by the icons you've all chose, your signatures, names, and way of speaking.

Ladies, good shows need conflict. Sweet, sugary chararcters don't make a good or believable story. All people have skeletons in their closet and all good stories should avoid Mary Sues as much as possible. Morally, Ash is a little too much of a goody two shoes for my taste. Hes never even had to give a second thought about doing the right thing. Its not realistic

But Paul is a Stu, and not some perfect goody two-shoes like any other Stu. He's a Jerk Stu who gets away with everything he does and doesn't even apologize to Infernape after all the abuse it got as a Chimchar.
I enjoy conflict, and being in the centre of it makes me like the whole thing even more, but just look at how long Sinnoh was. In that time, they could've shown a softer side to Paul, that he wasn't just some arse with a thin backstory that makes little sense. What we got was.....him being somewhat respectful to his elders?
Pitiful, they focked him up bigger and better than any of the previous rivals, and here I was thinking that Ritchie was cheap!

*sniff*

At least....he had a rather sexy voice, and his VA did a good job with making him sound like an uncaring brute, but that isn't enough to make him good, is it?
 
Paul is my favorite character. He has an awesome voice and gravity-defying hair... *ahem* Anyway, I love his Pokemon and his strategies kick a**. At least Paul actually uses good moves, his Pokemon's abilities, and strategy. The writers only make Ash good once in awhile when he HAS to win for the plot. Ash is SO annoying. The show needs more characters like Paul. That's just my opinion, don't hate me because I'm a Paul fangirl...
 
Ladies, good shows need conflict. Sweet, sugary chararcters don't make a good or believable story. All people have skeletonsin their closet and all good stories should avoid Mary Sues as much as possible. Morally, Ash is a little too much of a goody two shoes for my taste. Hes never even had to give a second thought about doing the right thing. Its not realistic

Ok, for one that's stereotyping females as if all females hate rude characters. There are plenty of females who love Paul and there are quite a few males who dislike him.

That being said, I am a fan of Paul. He brought a heated rivalry to the show and some slightly darker themes (he pretty much abused Chimchar). So far I consider the best rival on the show, period. Besides what he did to Chimchar (which was horrible), his training methods were simply that of a Drill Sergeant Nasty. However the writers seriously messed him up as a character.

1. His backstory- "OMG my brother loses to a guy with legendaries so now I'm going to push all my Pokemon extremely hard. Even if that means seriously injuring them just to get their special ability to activate" That was possibly the weakest backstory ever. Up until that point, there was no indication that Paul even looked up Reggie. There was a lot they could have done with that.

For example maybe Reggie was harsh trainer when he was younger and Paul, idolizing Reggie, wanted to follow in his footsteps. After Reggie's lost to Brandon, Reggie rethinks his relationship with his Pokemon and then tries to convince Paul to not make the same mistakes. Paul being stubborn, refuses to listen to his older brother and calls him weak for giving up on his past views.

2. No punishment for the Tag Battle Tournament- Using an already weakened Pokemon against the advice of a trained professional should have raised more eyebrows than it should. Maybe a threat to his Pokemon license or something. I mean Ash would've lost his license if he continued to fight in the Cinnabar Island Gym, so how come Paul who was battling on television didn't get the same warning? You can say, "oh that was in the past, the writers can't be expected to bring up every little thing" but what Paul did to Chimchar was extreme and should have gotten more attention than it did.

While I enjoyed Paul bringing tension to the show, I feel they could have done more with his character to make him a more dynamic character. And I agree with those who say he has a sexy voice. =P
 
and doesn't even apologize to Infernape after all the abuse it got as a Chimchar.

Sparring=/= Abuse

It's like complaining about getting punched during boxing training. Again, Pokemon Trainers are pretty much coaches. For a team of team of Boxers.
 
I like Paul in a sense that he's tough and not so cutesy as all the others, not so much that he just back hands everything, but he turns out to be cool in the end so I'm all good with him
 
Have you ever heard of the terms Jerk Sue and Karma Houdini? Paul, that detestable little jerk, DEFINES those terms.

Amen, sister!

Ok, for one that's stereotyping females as if all females hate rude characters. There are plenty of females who love Paul and there are quite a few males who dislike him.

Exactly. I'm male and I detest Paul with a fiery passion. But I see dozens of Paul fangirls on many sites like this.

That being said, I am a fan of Paul. He brought a heated rivalry to the show and some slightly darker themes (he pretty much abused Chimchar). So far I consider the best rival on the show, period.

See, I'd disagree with that seeing as the "heated" rivalry always played out the same way until the end and it was always about the trainers' attitudes and approach towards raising pokemon. Over and over and over again, it was so boring. Add that to all the character problems Paul had, and I'd say he's a big contender for the WORST rival on the show, period.

For example maybe Reggie was harsh trainer when he was younger and Paul, idolizing Reggie, wanted to follow in his footsteps. After Reggie's lost to Brandon, Reggie rethinks his relationship with his Pokemon and then tries to convince Paul to not make the same mistakes. Paul being stubborn, refuses to listen to his older brother and calls him weak for giving up on his past views.

That would've been pretty interesting. And it would also give Paul a better reason to change his ways after his own loss to Brandon. But no, they probably didn't do that because Tomioka didn't think Paul had that much mistakes to learn from, seeing as he was just "a strong trainer with different-than-usual training methods".

No punishment for the Tag Battle Tournament- Using an already weakened Pokemon against the advice of a trained professional should have raised more eyebrows than it should. Maybe a threat to his Pokemon license or something. I mean Ash would've lost his license if he continued to fight in the Cinnabar Island Gym, so how come Paul who was battling on television didn't get the same warning? You can say, "oh that was in the past, the writers can't be expected to bring up every little thing" but what Paul did to Chimchar was extreme and should have gotten more attention than it did.

Oh it gets much worse than that. Remember in the second episode of the entire anime when Nurse Joy falsely accuses Ash of pushing Pikachu when it's in bad condition and says it's wrong? Or when May was called out by the contest judges in front of a whole crowd for misusing her Bulbasaur? Paul pushed a weakened Chimchar to the limit then abandoned it in battle and didn't get this treatment at all. Not only that, Barry actually SAW it happen on TV and when he's first introduced, he PRAISES Paul's methods and claims that ASH was the one messing the team up during the battles. WHAT? This sort of writing is honestly beyond bad.

Sparring=/= Abuse

It's like complaining about getting punched during boxing training. Again, Pokemon Trainers are pretty much coaches

What kind of sparring involves five-on-one, with the one not punching back? What kind of sparring involves no rest or healing afterward? And while coaches can be harsh, a good coach is the leader of a team, not just someone who uses the team to propel themselves to glory, which is what Paul does with his pokemon. He's not coaching them to get better for their sake, he's doing it for his own. They themselves are expendable to him if he deems them "weak". That IS abuse, my friend.
 
Last edited:
@AgentPierce.

You are absolutely right on everything you have said. Your comments on Barry and Nurse Joy are spot on and that really annoyed me the way Barry praised Paul and also how Paul got of scot-free while everyone else gets punished. Not only was Paul mean to Chimchar, he was also very rude to Ash and other trainers too.
 
@AgentPierce.

You are absolutely right on everything you have said. Your comments on Barry and Nurse Joy are spot on and that really annoyed me the way Barry praised Paul and also how Paul got of scot-free while everyone else gets punished. Not only was Paul mean to Chimchar, he was also very rude to Ash and other trainers too.

LOL, since when was it a crime to be rude? I guess Gary and almost every other rival falls into the same category.
 
Not only was Paul mean to Chimchar, he was also very rude to Ash and other trainers too.

LOL, since when was it a crime to be rude?

Yeah, if Paul wants to act rude, that's his choice. The "crime" is how he lets his bad attitude effect his actions in official public tournaments for the people and pokemon that are unfortunate to be anywhere close to him.

Oh and seeing the recent dubbed BW episode on TV, Iris too learns that she should understand her pokemon and not force it out into an unwinnable battle. Y'know, the lesson that Paul never freaking learned. It's shown time and again that empathy towards your pokemon is important for a trainer but Paul did not have that for Chimchar at all. Nothing he did in that situation was justified.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top