• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Question

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well what did you like more? About the only thing I really liked was Wobbufett being captured by Jessie, everything else was a step down.

Well I enjoyed the region over Kanto game wise so seeing it anime wise was fun

I also like the fillers over the DP fillers

Whirl Island arc was fun too and so was the league

I do wish they gave more attacks to Ash's Roster
 
BY FREAKING ARCEUS. Kanto CANNOT be replicated. So I'm damn annoyed by all this Unova and Kanto comparissons. Unova TRIED to make Ash act like he did in his Kanto days, but that's IMPOSSIBLE. Why? Because the character has GROWN and DEVELOPED as an individual. Even if his stuck in timeless limbo. He has become a better person. Regressing him is impossible, he'll always end up as late Johto/AG/DP Ash. So why they bothered is beyond me.

Second. Kanto was the first, and was made when the direction the show was headed to was unknown. We basically know what'll happen when Unova ends. No one had any idea how the first series would play out.

I want Unova to be it's own thing. I don't want it to be like Kanto. I don't want it to be like AG. I don't want it to be like DP. I want it to learn from the past and improve. Learn from it's predecessors mistakes and provide the best story possible. But it's ridiculously failing at this.
 
BY FREAKING ARCEUS. Kanto CANNOT be replicated. So I'm damn annoyed by all this Unova and Kanto comparissons. Unova TRIED to make Ash act like he did in his Kanto days, but that's IMPOSSIBLE. Why? Because the character has GROWN and DEVELOPED as an individual. Even if his stuck in timeless limbo. He has become a better person. Regressing him is impossible, he'll always end up as late Johto/AG/DP Ash. So why they bothered is beyond me.

Second. Kanto was the first, and was made when the direction the show was headed to was unknown. We basically know what'll happen when Unova ends. No one had any idea how the first series would play out.

I want Unova to be it's own thing. I don't want it to be like Kanto. I don't want it to be like AG. I don't want it to be like DP. I want it to learn from the past and improve. Learn from it's predecessors mistakes and provide the best story possible. But it's ridiculously failing at this.

I don't see how Ash is a noob again. Ok maybe in the first few eps but Ash by the Nimbasa Arc is no noob.
 
Don't remind me. Ugh. Anytime I randomly look over Johto's episode list, I'm always blown away at just how much of it was filler.

Seeing how only 65 out of 158 episodes were fillers where nothing important happened,i dont see how can this be the only thing to blame Johto for? Granted that was still more than in any other region,but poor writing wasdi pretty much main problem.

As for my opinion:
Johto had its flaws,but it also did some things right.I think there is payed too much attention to fillers being completely forgotten all good things which happened there.
There were many fillers,but majority of them was decent or even enjoyable i dare to say.There were several great episodes in which i enjoyed like "The Little big Horn","Hook,line and Stinker","Fortune Hunters","Mantine overboard",etc.

Misty and Brock may have not received enough,but how much they got in Kanto exactly? In Johto they still got more screen time,more character focused episodes, battled more and got some notable development and achievements. At least in there Misty got her own arc(Whirl Islands),had pokemon evolution,developed different techniques thanks to Corsola and Poliwhirl(compared to water gun spam in kanto)battled often TR with Ash and had notable achievements leading to some quality development. Which can be noticed in close bond she established with several characters(like Sakura, Egan, Andreas etc.
Brock also got better treatment with more focus being put on his breeding skills which can be evidenced in way he took care of pokemon and healed them,entered breeding contest with Suzie,got involved in romantic circle with characters like(Temaku or dr,Anna)not staying only on running gag(at least there).

Battles were definitely improved with gyms and battling on general being put to higher level involving more strategy.
Johto was also ground-breaker in introducing arcs in this series like Red Gyarados,Lugia three part, Whirl Cup, Larvitar arc etc. With all being entertaining and actually advancing plot in some way compared to non plot related episodes(aka fillers).
Further more Johto Silver Conference was arguably on if best leagues in pokemon history concluding in perfect way longtime rivalry between Ash and Gary.
Chemistry within main group was still good with Ash,Misty and Brock feeling like genuine group of friends having good chemistry and several memorable moments.In fact thanks to their and Jessie,James and Meowth dynamic many of those fillers were watchable compensating for poor writing.

Granted our heroes often stood in background in episodes which revolved around COTD and helping their pokemon,but when they played some role and got focus they were delivered as enjoyable group having that spark they were liked for.

Writers had successful and well liked cast which had potential,but unfortunately thanks to ex head writer frustration and disagreements within writing staff which was inexperienced to know how to pan out properly long arcs(this was their first one)they dropped ball not utilizing material properly.

Original group deserved better and if i were to ask i would reunite them once more to give them last hurah(delivering closures to stories and more development), and redemption for past flaws.
 
Sorry I just wanted to say, I respect everyone who thinks Kanto was the best... but would anyone really really be happy if Ash had only...

Pikachu - Emboar (Disobeying) - Oshawott - Snivy - Leavanny (evolved and released) - Unfezant (evolving then released at the end) - Garbodor (rotting at Junipers/Oaks) and similar plotlines??

I don't think so, everyone would find it boring... I personally feel Orange Islands was the worst followed by Kanto... All recent saga's I find much more professional and insteresting.
 
I've constantly stated this before, but the reason why I believe the Anime is terrible now is that its just become one big advertisement for the Pokemon games. Sure, in the beginning in the Original Series, it was still about advertising for the games, cards, and various other products. But back then, the show had a meaning to it. It was about friendship, through thick and skin, about caring for others, no matter the circumstances. Think of episodes like "Snow Way Out!" and "Pikachu's Good-Bye!", and maybe even "The Pi-Kahuna!" They were all about friendship between Ash and his Pokemon, as they each showed the utmost love and care for one another, while a different persepective was taken in "The Pikahuna" from the main character, Victor's, eyes. It displayed the long-lastingness of friendship and caring and the great, profound effect that they can have on people.

Nowadays, the show is just there for the sake of advertising. It is about the cool battles and drama, stuff that will sell. Rarely is there a deeply emotional moment, or a heart-fulfilling or lesson-learning segment.

To basically sum it up in one perfect sentence:

The old show was entertainment with advertising, while the new show is advertising with entertainment.

...Well, I used to have the perfect quote with more fluent wording, but that's essentially it in a nutshell.

You are 100% right, the anime nowadays is following the games too strictly. Way too strictly. No emotion or entertainment. I agree with you as well, except for one thing. You said "The old show was entertainment with advertising, while the new show is advertising with entertainment." I think of it like this: "The old show was entertainment with advertising, while the new show is advertising WITHOUT entertainment."

Everything in the Original Series is better than the Unoriginal Series. Here's a long list of reasons why I prefer the Original Series over the newer saga's. But it's all a matter of preference.

- Nostalgia.
- The start of Pokemon anime.
- The old Pokemon (Gen I and II) are awesome, the newer Pokemon are bad (Gen IV and V, Gen III had acceptable Pokemon).
- Misty.
- Psyduck.
- PokeShipping.
- No May, Dawn, Iris and Cilan.
- The episodes and battles were enjoyable.
- Humorous moments.
- Emotional moments.
- Gary "was here, Ash is a loser" Oak.
- Ash's Bayleef.
- Brock was awesome in the Original Series, and after that, he was boring when there were no hot women around.
- Team Rocket was awesome in the Original Series, and after that, they weren't that awesome anymore...
- Ash being funny, and not as boring as in the newer sagas.
- Better movies.
- No Piplup.
- Bad fillers, Kanto, Orange Islands and Jotho had great fillers!
- Good arcs like the SS.Anne, the Whirl Islands and the Dragon saga with Clair.
- Better music.
- Original Series didn't follow the games that much, which is great. The newer sagas follow the games too closely. Original arcs, and no character replacement just to advertise the games (like May>Misty and Dawn>May).
 
Everything in the Original Series is better than the Unoriginal Series.

What the hell is an "unoriginal series?" Seriously, that's the most laughable thing I've seen on this forum in a long time.

Nostalgia.
- The start of Pokemon anime.
- The old Pokemon (Gen I and II) are awesome, the newer Pokemon are bad (Gen IV and V, Gen III had acceptable Pokemon).

So in other words, its all nostalgia.


Got stale in Johto.


Stopped appearing in Johto.

-
PokeShipping.

OK.

No May, Dawn, Iris and Cilan.

And all these characters are better or more enjoyable than the original set. I don't like all of them the same, but they sure as hell are handled better than most original characters.

The episodes and battles were enjoyable.
- Humorous moments.
- Emotional moments.

The newer episodes all have these.

-
- Brock was awesome in the Original Series, and after that, he was boring when there were no hot women around.
- Team Rocket was awesome in the Original Series, and after that, they weren't that awesome anymore...

Fair enough.

Ash being funny, and not as boring as in the newer sagas.
- Better movies.

Debateable.

- Bad fillers, Kanto, Orange Islands and Jotho had great fillers!
- Good arcs like the SS.Anne, the Whirl Islands and the Dragon saga with Clair.

There have been a ton of story arcs in the series since then. Johto was also filled with horrendous fillers besides the TR ones.


- Original Series didn't follow the games that much, which is great. The newer sagas follow the games too closely. Original arcs, and no character replacement just to advertise the games (like May>Misty and Dawn>May).

No characters to advertise the games? Is this a goddamn joke? Why the hell do you think Misty and Brock were travel companions? They were Gym leaders of course in RBY of course!
 
What the hell is an "unoriginal series?" Seriously, that's the most laughable thing I've seen on this forum in a long time.

Because Gen I and II are Original Series, I made up that nickname for the newer sagas. Sorry!

So in other words, its all nostalgia.

Not only nostalgia. I admit nostalgia plays a role, but it's more than just nostalgia.

Got stale in Johto.

She didn't. For me, she was still enjoyable. But there are no facts, it's personal and a matter of preference.

Stopped appearing in Johto.

It still got some nice appearances.

And all these characters are better or more enjoyable than the original set. I don't like all of them the same, but they sure as hell are handled better than most original characters.

You say newer characters are better than the original ones. That's not a fact, that is your personal opinion and I disagree. I think Misty and Brock are better than May, Dawn, Max and Cilan.

The newer episodes all have these.

Matter of opinion, I think the newer episodes don't have humourous or emotional moments.

There have been a ton of story arcs in the series since then. Johto was also filled with horrendous fillers besides the TR ones.

The difference is that the OS arcs entertained me, but the newer ones didn't. It's a matter of opinion. And I enoyed the Jotho fillers, and hate the fillers in newer sagas.

No characters to advertise the games? Is this a goddamn joke? Why the hell do you think Misty and Brock were travel companions? They were Gym leaders of course in RBY of course!

OK, but I think a playable character like May or Dawn is more advertisable than gym leaders with very small roles in the games, like Misty and Brock.
 
Because Gen I and II are Original Series, I made up that nickname for the newer sagas. Sorry!

WOW. AG and DP aren't even, "new" anymore. AG began over 10 years ago for goodness sakes.

She didn't. For me, she was still enjoyable. But there are no facts, it's personal and a matter of preference.

And in that case, you should have accepted her departure like most people in the fandom did. Her character ran her course.

You say newer characters are better than the original ones. That's not a fact, that is your personal opinion and I disagree. I think Misty and Brock are better than May, Dawn, Max and Cilan.

You're fine to think that, but I am willing to bet if any of these characters existed in the older seasons, or if Iris/Cilan were reversed with Misty/Brock, you would be saying how much you like Iris/Cilan and not Misty/Brock.

Matter of opinion, I think the newer episodes don't have humourous or emotional moments.

You aren't looking hard enough then. AG had plenty of eps like this, and the DP eps about Chimchar and Dustox.

The difference is that the OS arcs entertained me, but the newer ones didn't. It's a matter of opinion. And I enoyed the Jotho fillers, and hate the fillers in newer sagas.

The Johto fillers followed the same predictable formula of Ash helping a COTD and TR stealing Pikachu. Acting like the new fillers are any worse is bizarre.

Also, why are you grouping AG, DP and BW together? All 3 series are very different from one another, they're not written the same way.

OK, but I think a playable character like May or Dawn is more advertisable than gym leaders with very small roles in the games, like Misty and Brock.

You have to be joking. Misty/Brock were advertisements, they took the first two Gym leaders and made them major characters so we'd see them in every episode. And BW has no female character, and chose Gym leaders again, so what do you say to that?

Lastly, I've seen you say you think Pokemon became unpopular because you were bullied for liking it when the new gens came out, that happens when you are in High School. In reality nobody cares, and judging this based on how people treat you in school is bizarre/
 
At the best scenario the only thing the first series has that others hasn't is the "freshness feel" it gave. The first series is, as the name hints, the first about Pokemon where everything was some sort of experiment.

But being honest, I like the new series a lot more than the first one. In my opinion, the later series turned Ash into a more likeable character and gave him better supporting characters like May, Dawn, Iris and Cilan.
 
@AquaMilotic

- The old Pokemon (Gen I and II) are awesome, the newer Pokemon are bad (Gen IV and V, Gen III had acceptable Pokemon).

I don't get what makes a Pokemon bad though. Many of them are based off of animals or myths and each one of them has something unique about them. Heck, Pokemon to me isn't just about looks...it's about what they are based on. :3

- Misty.
- Psyduck.

You sound like my dad Misty was cool back then...and I miss Psyduck.

- PokeShipping.

LIES! >.<

- No May, Dawn, Iris and Cilan.

So Max is the exception then? :D

- The episodes and battles were enjoyable.

Which battles? =o Metapod vs. Metapod was pretty win though.

- Humorous moments.

True, but there are humorous moments in the other sagas as well. Like May and Max's arguments them having to eat a sandwich with a spoon, in DP there was Barry, and in BW there is Dento with his gratuitous english and overdramatic behavior.

- Emotional moments.

Do movies count? I cried in Lucario and the Mystery of Mew. Oh yes, I also cried in the "Iris and Excadrill vs. the Dragon Buster"

- Gary "was here, Ash is a loser" Oak.

Trololol I disliked Gary when I was little. I was so ticked at him for making fun of Ash Reminds me when I watch a video with Veronica Taylor...she changed it to "Ash was here, Gary is the loser!!" XDD

- Ash's Bayleef.

She was cute, but as a Chikorita she caused a lot of problems...

- Brock was awesome in the Original Series, and after that, he was boring when there were no hot women around.

I'm probably in the minority here. Brock had me SO confused, I thought he was blind. XDD

- Team Rocket was awesome in the Original Series, and after that, they weren't that awesome anymore...

I found them funny in AG. After that...I couldn't even comprehend what they were saying anymore. XD I'm kind of happy that they are....better bad guys quite frankly...

- Ash being funny, and not as boring as in the newer sagas.

I lurved Ash in AG..."Hey I rode one of these at the carnival once!" Somehow, Ash being both mature and still silly made him lovable.

- Better movies.

Lucario!!! Dx I obsessed over that movie. XDD

- No Piplup.

No Piplup in AG or BW either :P bah I agree..xDD

- Bad fillers, Kanto, Orange Islands and Jotho had great fillers!

Scare at the Litwick Mansion was pretty epic. What were fillers in Kanto? =o I honestly don't know which ones are and aren't. XD I never watched all of Johto...but I loved that crazy Cleffa one with PMC and the "Will the Real Oak Please Stand Up"...Oh yeah and in AG "A Double Dilemma" was win..so was "Love Petalburg Style"

- Good arcs like the SS.Anne, the Whirl Islands and the Dragon saga with Clair.

:< The S.S. Anne gave me nightmares..it scared me to think Ash and co. (besides Misty) would want to eat a Pokemon...the Dragon saga was a bit boring..I mean, I just wanted to see the Gym Battle. XD

- Better music.

I love a lot of Pokemon music...I think AG had a lot of good ones, but they never used all of them. BW has some great ones too from the games like "Emotion" and the End Credit theme.

- Original Series didn't follow the games that much, which is great. The newer sagas follow the games too closely. Original arcs, and no character replacement just to advertise the games (like May>Misty and Dawn>May).

After reading Pokemon Special...I actually started disliking the anime for not following the games closer...
 
WOW. AG and DP aren't even, "new" anymore. AG began over 10 years ago for goodness sakes.

When I say "newer sagas", I mean the "unoriginal series", the sagas after the original series.

And in that case, you should have accepted her departure like most people in the fandom did. Her character ran her course.

I think she didn't ran her course and that she would still be good as a main character in newer sagas. If I am a fan of a character, why should I accept her departure and not think it was a bad thing?

You're fine to think that, but I am willing to bet if any of these characters existed in the older seasons, or if Iris/Cilan were reversed with Misty/Brock, you would be saying how much you like Iris/Cilan and not Misty/Brock.

That might be true, I won't deny that nostalgia plays a big role.

You aren't looking hard enough then. AG had plenty of eps like this, and the DP eps about Chimchar and Dustox.

The difference between those and the Original Series is that I cared about the characters. I cried about Butterfree because I loved it, just like Pidgeot. I don't care about Chimchar and Dustox. Nostalgia definitely plays a role.

The Johto fillers followed the same predictable formula of Ash helping a COTD and TR stealing Pikachu. Acting like the new fillers are any worse is bizarre.

Sorry, but the old fillers entertained me and the new ones bored me. The formula might be the same, but that doesn't change my opinion.

Also, why are you grouping AG, DP and BW together? All 3 series are very different from one another, they're not written the same way.

Because that are the sagas after the Original Series, and these follow the games strictly, and the Original Series don't. That's one of the biggest differences.

It's also personal: I love the Original Series and really don't like Gen III, IV and V, so it's a group of seasons I love and seasons I hate.

You have to be joking. Misty/Brock were advertisements, they took the first two Gym leaders and made them major characters so we'd see them in every episode. And BW has no female character, and chose Gym leaders again, so what do you say to that?

OK, but in the games, Misty and Brock have marginal roles, while May and Dawn are playable characters in the games, which makes them more advertisable.

Lastly, I've seen you say you think Pokemon became unpopular because you were bullied for liking it when the new gens came out, that happens when you are in High School. In reality nobody cares, and judging this based on how people treat you in school is bizarre

When Gen III came out, I was in primary school and got bullied... While I didn't get bullied in primary school during the Gen I and II eras. I don't only judge Pokemon popularity based on how people treat me at school, but Pokemon popularity at school does indicate popularity a bit. And me getting bullied isn't why I think Pokemon became unpopular, the amount of people I knew/know liking Pokemon was very big in the Gen I and II eras, and small in Gen III and onwards. But again, these are no facts, it's my personal experience.

I don't get what makes a Pokemon bad though. Many of them are based off of animals or myths and each one of them has something unique about them. Heck, Pokemon to me isn't just about looks...it's about what they are based on. :3

Sorry, this is a matter of opinion, everybody is entitled to one and there are no facts when it comes to this.

You sound like my dad Misty was cool back then...and I miss Psyduck.

Good that you agree!

LIES! >.<

Definitely not.

So Max is the exception then? :D

Max was better than May, Dawn, Iris and Cilan, but he is no exception. He also made Brock worse, by taking his place as "the knowledged Pokemon expert".

Which battles? =o Metapod vs. Metapod was pretty win though.

Ash vs. Drake (Orange League), Ash vs. Chuck (Cianwood gym), Ash vs. Clair (Blackthorn gym), Ash vs. Gary (Jotho League) and Ash vs. Harrison (Jotho league). And many more.

True, but there are humorous moments in the other sagas as well. Like May and Max's arguments them having to eat a sandwich with a spoon, in DP there was Barry, and in BW there is Dento with his gratuitous english and overdramatic behavior.

Sorry, but then we have a different sense of humour. Think about "Showdown at Dark City", about Tom Ato, Anne Chovy and Ceasar Salad. Pikachu also had an epic ketchup moment.

Do movies count? I cried in Lucario and the Mystery of Mew. Oh yes, I also cried in the "Iris and Excadrill vs. the Dragon Buster"

We cry about other things and view other things as emotional.

Trololol I disliked Gary when I was little. I was so ticked at him for making fun of Ash Reminds me when I watch a video with Veronica Taylor...she changed it to "Ash was here, Gary is the loser!!" XDD

OK, I have always been a big fan of Gary and I still am one.

She was cute, but as a Chikorita she caused a lot of problems...

And those problems were enjoyable.

No Piplup in AG or BW either :P bah I agree..xDD

You hate Piplup as well, good.

Scare at the Litwick Mansion was pretty epic. What were fillers in Kanto? =o I honestly don't know which ones are and aren't. XD I never watched all of Johto...but I loved that crazy Cleffa one with PMC and the "Will the Real Oak Please Stand Up"...Oh yeah and in AG "A Double Dilemma" was win..so was "Love Petalburg Style"

OK, good that you loved some Jotho episodes.

:< The S.S. Anne gave me nightmares..it scared me to think Ash and co. (besides Misty) would want to eat a Pokemon...the Dragon saga was a bit boring..I mean, I just wanted to see the Gym Battle. XD

OK, sorry, I liked those.

I love a lot of Pokemon music...I think AG had a lot of good ones, but they never used all of them. BW has some great ones too from the games like "Emotion" and the End Credit theme.

Matter of opinion. We can discuss all we want, but won't agree with each other. Like lots of debates, wether it's shipping, best Pokemon or whatever.

After reading Pokemon Special...I actually started disliking the anime for not following the games closer...

OK, I think it's boring when the games are followed too strictly.
 
Last edited:
There's nothing wrong for you to prefer the older seasons, but when you're coming to a public online forum like this where people have enjoyed the sagas after Johto, I don't see why you're surprised you're being called out and met with opposition.

The writers improved the anime for the fans, and I truly must thank all the old-school pokemon fans who complained about Johto from 2001-2002 so the writers took notice of it.
 
There's nothing wrong for you to prefer the older seasons, but when you're coming to a public online forum like this where people have enjoyed the sagas after Johto, I don't see why you're surprised you're being called out and met with opposition.

The writers improved the anime for the fans, and I truly must thank all the old-school pokemon fans who complained about Johto from 2001-2002 so the writers took notice of it.

I am not surprised about opposition and people disagreeing with me, they have every right to do so. Why do you think I am? A forum is there to discuss things.

However, sometimes, there are no facts and something is a matter of preference. I think that's the case to music, favourite shipping, favourite seasons, favourite characters, opinions on following the games strictly or not following the games strictly, and many more topics revolving around the Pokemon anime.

It's nothing but rehash's after OS.

You are 100% right!
 
Last edited:
However, sometimes, there are no facts and something is a matter of preference. I think that's the case to music, favourite shipping, favourite seasons, favourite characters, opinions on following the games strictly or not following the games strictly, and many more topics revolving around the Pokemon anime.

But this is about the series, not other non-Pokemon things. And when it comes to storytelling, most people take notice of it.

You are 100% right!

Which is a rarity, since I virtually never see people obsess over the early seasons anymore outside of a few people.
 
Thanks LOL!!! It's so nice seeing OS fans OUTSIDE AG, DP & BW.

Why is it nice? That there are so few of you in the fandom now that you feel the need to stick together? All around this forum you can see what people like.

This thread was basically created by the thread starter asking why people think the older seasons are better, and from what I see only about 3-4 people actually think that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top