• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

The Burqa

I don't really mind the Burqa being worn, though I do sympathize with people that wish for it to be taken off in places like airports and banks, or not just that, but really any place that requires photo identification. It's not that big of a deal, I don't think. You simply take off your hood for a short period of time, and you let the person with match up your face with your ID. If Muslim women feel uncomfortable doing that, why not simply ask for another woman to identify you? Problem solved, it would seem. Blanket bans on soley the Burqa and even the hijab as seen in Europe, I believe is too much.

2) They pose a security risk. Can you identify a nun in a habit? Try it. I can't tell them apart. I can't even tell what color their hair is! How can we ID these people?! How can we tell if a monk walking into a bank has a gun under his robe? We obviously can't trust anyone in bulky clothing.

While I do enjoy Colbert's satire, this becomes a little less funny when you realize certain things don't really apply. For one, I can tell them apart. Hair alone isn't the sole identifying factor in a person. A nuns face is still pretty visible. Even in your photo, I could tell all the nuns looked different from eachother. If I saw a photo ID of a nun without the habit and compared it right next to her face in person, I'd be able to tell. So...would anyone else. Unless you're blind. You can't ID a muslim in a Burqa unless the head covering comes off. There's just no way around that. Granted, I'm sure there's no epidemic of thugster burqa wear'n women going around robbing banks, but leniencies can be taken advantage of. If people know they won't be asked for an ID just because they're wearing a burqa, what's to stop a person that's not even Muslim from wearing one to commit a crime? Why wear a ski mask and rouse suspicion, when you can just wear a burqa and slip right under the radar. If the place in question has alternative means of identification (Finger prints, facial recognition, etc) as mentioned earlier, then that's fine too. The catch is, not everywhere has those fancy bells and whistles. So, if a person asks for you to briefly take your burqa off for ID verification, you should do it. That, or be asked to leave.

Also on an unrelated note, simply because some Islamic women choose to wear the burqa, doesn't mean that the burqa isn't an object of oppression. Sure, this is the ethnocentric Westerner coming out, but listen. When we look at theocratic Islamic nations, no one disputes that they are second class citizens. That women have hardly any rights. We look at those regimes and we say that they are oppressive. However, aren't those laws based on Islamic teachings, non? Sharia law. I'm sure plenty of the women there accept their situation and truly don't believe they are oppressed. Now, someone will say, we aren't talking about the radical teachings of Islam, or the policies of theocratic dictatorships, but the practices and laws in these regimes all come from the same place. The Koran. People throw around the word radical and extremist, when those "radical" and "extremist" interpretations are completely and logically justified. It's right there in the book.

For example here are just a few questionable verses,

http://www.opposingviews.com/arguments/the-quran-promotes-violence

But apparently, that's only a few out of...109. Supposedly. So, if all these regimes are so oppressive and the majority of people think they are, when they base their laws upon very clear verses in the Koran, why does everyone take such a relativist stance on the burqa? The object at heart is still an oppressive object, in my opinion. Just because few Muslim women choose to wear it doesn't make it less so.
 
Last edited:
But apparently, that's only a few out of...109. Supposedly. So, if all these regimes are so oppressive and the majority of people think they are, when they base their laws upon very clear verses in the Koran, why does everyone take such a relativist stance on the burqa? The object at heart is still an oppressive object, in my opinion. Just because few Muslim women choose to wear it doesn't make it less so.

You're blaming the religion as the cause of the oppression in Middle East dictatorships. I blame the cause of oppression to the actual dictators who just so happen to be using Islam as their religion of choice.
 
I'm just going to declare a stalemate right there. I don't have the time nor patience to play a game of chicken or egg. Your point is acknowledged though.
 
OK so I haven't read every single post of this thread and honestly, I won't, I'll just give my opinion.

I'm French and I'm telling you, all this ban-burqa law thingy was the most debated and controversial decision, and it still is. I understand the fact that France is a secular country, in which it is not convenient to shove your religion and beliefs into everybody's throat, that's understandable.

France is a democratic country, based on the principle of equality and liberty. Thus, I can see why the burqa has been banned from school, public places... But if the government really wanna go through the whole concept of equality, secular country, why is it just the burqa that is banned? Why isn't there the same law for, IDK, Jewish hats? Or nun habits? Those are basically the same things: clothes that are somehow linked to a religion.

When the French government decided to pass this law, they argued that it was so that people wouldn't be 'offended' by those exposing their religion to everybody. This is why, like I stated in my previous paragraph, it should be applicable to any religion and not the Muslim one only.

This law has caused one hell of a ruckus among the population, the Muslim one of course but not only, a huge part of the French population was against it.

I'm also Muslim and again I'm telling you this: all this cr*p about Muslim women having to wear the burqa (or even just the hijab) because it is written in the Quran is just wrong. There is nothing in the Quran that states how a woman should dress. Muslim extremists have decided to provide their own awkward interpretation of the book and thus, expanded their idea to the whole Muslim world that a woman should hide herself.

The argument provided was that a woman should not be able to seduce, attract any male other than her husband (which, by the way, is contradictory with the so-called rule that a girl has to wear the burqa as soon as she is 7 years old... I don't know any 7-year-old girl already married, just saying).

However, like I said, there's nothing like this in the Quran. It was made up by powerful men who just wanted to gain superiority over women. It's true that in the book, it's said that a woman should be respectful and obedient to her husband, but nowhere does it state that she has to wear some kind of camouflage whenever she gets out of the house.

In my family, neither my sisters nor my mother wear the burqa or even the hijab (the one which only hides your hair), we have always been against this principle of hiding yourself and putting yourself aside from the society. We are an open-minded family, but we can't understand why a woman would wanna do that. There are some women who do this because they actually want to, but most of the time, it's either because they are following what is SUPPOSEDLY written in the Quran, or because their husband/father/brother make them.

As a conclusion (gee, I feel like I'm writing an essay or something... Chill out, M!), personally, I think that this ban of the burqa can be understood inasmuch as it's something that hinders the women's living conditions: they can't find a job while wearing it (who would hire someone wearing a burqa, honestly?), they are always judged whenever they go outside, so are their children... But I think that, on the other hand, if the idea behind the ban of the burqa is to prevent a religion to be exposed to everybody, it should be applicable to any religion, not only the Muslim one (even though, like I said, this burqa thing is in no way related to the Islam).
 
Hox: Just because some people that the burqa is an object of oppression in the Middle East, doesn't change the fact that many Muslim women are willingly choosing to wear the burqa. Who are you to decide that these Muslim women are second class citizens that do not have the right to wear something as harmless as a burqa?
 
I don't think that that scripture in the Koran means that women should wear burqas.
Newsflash.
Neither do I.
Here's the problem though, as much as you'd like to move the goalposts the point of our conversation was that you claimed:
The Hijab/Burqa are not an explicit part of scripture.
Maybe for you, a non-muslim who has never read the Koran beyond snippets here and there, but for millions of conservative Muslims around the world
(O Prophet! Tell your wives and your daughters and the women of the believers to draw their cloaks (and/or veils) over their bodies. That is better that they should be known so as not to be annoyed and molested. Allah is Ever Oft-Forgiving, Most Merciful.)
is talking explicitly about the burqa. It says to draw your cloak about your body, their burqa is their cloak, they see "body" as meaning their whole body. This isn't a complex or dubious scripture to them. They look at it, they read the words, and they do what it says.

You, as an outsider who has publicly stated that they don't care to bother themselves with learning about religions don't think that's what that scripture means. No one cares. You didn't know that scripture existed two weeks ago, but now your interpretation should hold more weight than millions of Muslims who have read it daily for over a thousand years?

You can repeat your claim that the burqa is not explicitly mentioned in the Koran. I will repeat the claim that millions of conservative Muslims would tell you that that scripture explicitly mentions the burqa. There's really nothing more to argue. Your interpretation is wrong and the interpretation of the people who actually take the religion seriously are right.
 
Newsflash.
Neither do I.
Here's the problem though, as much as you'd like to move the goalposts the point of our conversation was that you claimed:

No goalposts are being/ have been moved.

Maybe for you, a non-muslim who has never read the Koran beyond snippets here and there, but for millions of conservative Muslims around the world is talking explicitly about the burqa.


Do you understand what explicitly means? Do you understand the wider points I have been making re. patriarchy and the original translators of the "word of god?" Clearly not.


It says to draw your cloak about your body, their burqa is their cloak, they see "body" as meaning their whole body. This isn't a complex or dubious scripture to them. They look at it, they read the words, and they do what it says.

Yet it is still not explicit. The only specific part of the body mentioned is the breasts. At no point is the head or face mentioned explicitly.

You, as an outsider who has publicly stated that they don't care to bother themselves with learning about religions

Did I say that?

No one cares.

Come on now stop looking in that mirror.

You didn't know that scripture existed two weeks ago, but now your interpretation should hold more weight than millions of Muslims who have read it daily for over a thousand years?

This is an irrelevant point.

You can repeat your claim that the burqa is not explicitly mentioned in the Koran. I will repeat the claim that millions of conservative Muslims would tell you that that scripture explicitly mentions the burqa.

Yet it doesn't, so you'd be wrong.

There's really nothing more to argue. Your interpretation is wrong and the interpretation of the people who actually take the religion seriously are right.

Another irrelevant, hypocritical and pointless argument.

I suggest you read the post at the top of the page. It will prove very insightful.
 
Last edited:
I suggest you read the post at the top of the page. It will prove very insightful.

Yes, and he made the argument that the problem with those middle eastern dictatorships is Islam. I made the argument that the reason they're oppressive is the fact that they're dictatorships. Evidence is from just about any number of repressive dictatorships such as North Korea and Cuba where, similar to the religious dictatorship of Iran, human rights workers, religious dissenter, they repress speech, women, gays and lesbians, and members of the media.

What they have in common, North Korea/Cuba and Iran, are that they're dictatorships. The only real difference is that North Korea and Cuba are secular nations (where religious liberties are actively persecuted), whereas the dictatorship in Iran falls under a particular sect of Islam.

You take the religion out of the Middle East, and you very well might still end up with a dictator who actively represses the people he rules. The godless regime up in North Korea prove that.
 
Hox: Just because some people that the burqa is an object of oppression in the Middle East, doesn't change the fact that many Muslim women are willingly choosing to wear the burqa. Who are you to decide that these Muslim women are second class citizens that do not have the right to wear something as harmless as a burqa?

This is why people become frustrated with you, you gloss over the arguments made by someone, and then re-iterate a point that's already been responded to. Please, go back and re-read my post carefully and you will answer your own question.
 
Correct me if I'm mistaken but I don't recall you or anyone else addressing that point. If you disagree with it, counter it.
 
Also on an unrelated note, simply because some Islamic women choose to wear the burqa, doesn't mean that the burqa isn't an object of oppression. Sure, this is the ethnocentric Westerner coming out, but listen. When we look at theocratic Islamic nations, no one disputes that they are second class citizens. That women have hardly any rights. We look at those regimes and we say that they are oppressive. However, aren't those laws based on Islamic teachings, non? Sharia law. I'm sure plenty of the women there accept their situation and truly don't believe they are oppressed. Now, someone will say, we aren't talking about the radical teachings of Islam, or the policies of theocratic dictatorships, but the practices and laws in these regimes all come from the same place. The Koran. People throw around the word radical and extremist, when those "radical" and "extremist" interpretations are completely and logically justified. It's right there in the book.

For example here are just a few questionable verses,

http://www.opposingviews.com/argumen...motes-violence

But apparently, that's only a few out of...109. Supposedly. So, if all these regimes are so oppressive and the majority of people think they are, when they base their laws upon very clear verses in the Koran, why does everyone take such a relativist stance on the burqa? The object at heart is still an oppressive object, in my opinion. Just because few Muslim women choose to wear it doesn't make it less so.

If you don't remember, you can, you know, read the thread.

It's not so much a solid counter as it is pointing out major incongruity in what you choose to believe is oppressive and what isn't. Plus I guess people that have gone through stockholm syndrome aren't oppressed either. Those wives that always go back to husbands that beat the crap out of them? I guess they aren't oppressed either, they chose after all.

"You need to leave that dick, he treats you like crap"

"It's not a big deal. He hit me only once, and plus I should have made dinner on time like he asked! It was my fualt."

But sure. Let's go on perpetuating this fantasy that people are only oppressed if they think they are.


Telling others that their points are irrelevant is basically your catch phrase. You love to dismiss other people without even trying to understand what they say. Your arrogance is quite astounding. You think you understand a religion better than the actual followers of that religion. That would be like me tell mattj how he should interpret the Bible.

No. It's not only an irrelevant point but a fallacious one.

Let's take a look.

You didn't know that scripture existed two weeks ago, but now your interpretation should hold more weight than millions of Muslims who have read it daily for over a thousand years?

This is a debate. You actually have to argue the points being made. Either his interpretation is good or bad. Saying that "Well Muslims know more, so your interpretation is invalid" is a red herring in an attempt to avoid the point.
 
Last edited:
This is an irrelevant point.

Telling others that their points are irrelevant is basically your catch phrase. You love to dismiss other people without even trying to understand what they say. Your arrogance is quite astounding. You think you understand a religion better than the actual followers of that religion. That would be like me tell mattj how he should interpret the Bible.
 
@Hox:
I apologize if it seemed like I hadn't read that post. I had. But, no offense, just saying "Its still oppressive, I don't care about your evidence" doesn't seem like "countering" said evidence. That's basically what was said
The object at heart is still an oppressive object, in my opinion. Just because few Muslim women choose to wear it doesn't make it less so.
 
Yes, and he made the argument that the problem with those middle eastern dictatorships is Islam. I made the argument that the reason they're oppressive is the fact that they're dictatorships. Evidence is from just about any number of repressive dictatorships such as North Korea and Cuba where, similar to the religious dictatorship of Iran, human rights workers, religious dissenter, they repress speech, women, gays and lesbians, and members of the media.

What they have in common, North Korea/Cuba and Iran, are that they're dictatorships. The only real difference is that North Korea and Cuba are secular nations (where religious liberties are actively persecuted), whereas the dictatorship in Iran falls under a particular sect of Islam.

You take the religion out of the Middle East, and you very well might still end up with a dictator who actively represses the people he rules. The godless regime up in North Korea prove that.

Well to begin with by recommending the MisterM post I was obviously drawing attention to his statement that the Burqa/Hijab are at no point explicitly mentioned in Islamic Holy texts considering that is what I have been focusing on the past page or so.

Secondly, as far as I've looked, and to be fair that isn't through the whole thread, I've only referenced the regimes in Iran etc. once, to say that in many cases these women have no choice over their choice of clothing. At no point did I make marked points on the nature of (governmental) dictatorships I don't think.
 
Last edited:
Well to begin with by recommending the MisterM post I was obviously drawing attention to his statement that the Burqa/Hijab are at no point explicitly mentioned in Islamic Holy texts considering that is what I have been focusing on the past page or so.

Secondly, as far as I've looked, and to be fair that isn't through the whole thread, I've only referenced the regimes in Iran etc. once, to say that in many cases these women have no choice over their choice of clothing. At no point did I make marked points on the nature of (governmental) dictatorships I don't think.

Were churches mentioned in the Bible? How about popes?

In the country of Labrynna, the oppressive Queen Ambi forces all boys to eat pancakes for breakfast. To counteract this, should we not allow boys to eat pancakes in America?
 
Were churches mentioned in the Bible? How about popes?
Yep. Jesus made Peter the first Pope. And there are several mentions of Church. Here's one to kill two birds with one stone:
Matthew 16:18-19 said:
"And I tell you that you are Peter, and on this rock I will build my church, and the gates of Hades will not overcome it. I will give you the keys of the kingdom of heaven; whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven.”
I strongly suggest following your own advice:
Your arrogance is quite astounding. You think you understand a religion better than the actual followers of that religion. That would be like me tell mattj how he should interpret the Bible.
 
I guess I was misinformed by my teacher. That's odd considering that he was a minister. Your quote however doesn't explain why there is a pope though.
 
Were churches mentioned in the Bible? How about popes?

In the country of Labrynna, the oppressive Queen Ambi forces all boys to eat pancakes for breakfast. To counteract this, should we not allow boys to eat pancakes in America?

Yep. Jesus made Peter the first Pope. And there are several mentions of Church. Here's one to kill two birds with one stone:
I strongly suggest following your own advice:

I guess I was misinformed by my teacher. That's odd considering that he was a minister. Your quote however doesn't explain why there is a pope though.

Ladies and gentleman, I provide you with a slice of humble pie sprinkled delicately with some ownage sauce. Thank you Kaiser Soze.
 
@Hox:
I apologize if it seemed like I hadn't read that post. I had. But, no offense, just saying "Its still oppressive, I don't care about your evidence" doesn't seem like "countering" said evidence. That's basically what was said

That was the conclusion, you ignored and didn't respond to any of the reasoning that preceded it. What evidence did you present, anyway?
 
Back
Top