I don't really mind the Burqa being worn, though I do sympathize with people that wish for it to be taken off in places like airports and banks, or not just that, but really any place that requires photo identification. It's not that big of a deal, I don't think. You simply take off your hood for a short period of time, and you let the person with match up your face with your ID. If Muslim women feel uncomfortable doing that, why not simply ask for another woman to identify you? Problem solved, it would seem. Blanket bans on soley the Burqa and even the hijab as seen in Europe, I believe is too much.
While I do enjoy Colbert's satire, this becomes a little less funny when you realize certain things don't really apply. For one, I can tell them apart. Hair alone isn't the sole identifying factor in a person. A nuns face is still pretty visible. Even in your photo, I could tell all the nuns looked different from eachother. If I saw a photo ID of a nun without the habit and compared it right next to her face in person, I'd be able to tell. So...would anyone else. Unless you're blind. You can't ID a muslim in a Burqa unless the head covering comes off. There's just no way around that. Granted, I'm sure there's no epidemic of thugster burqa wear'n women going around robbing banks, but leniencies can be taken advantage of. If people know they won't be asked for an ID just because they're wearing a burqa, what's to stop a person that's not even Muslim from wearing one to commit a crime? Why wear a ski mask and rouse suspicion, when you can just wear a burqa and slip right under the radar. If the place in question has alternative means of identification (Finger prints, facial recognition, etc) as mentioned earlier, then that's fine too. The catch is, not everywhere has those fancy bells and whistles. So, if a person asks for you to briefly take your burqa off for ID verification, you should do it. That, or be asked to leave.
Also on an unrelated note, simply because some Islamic women choose to wear the burqa, doesn't mean that the burqa isn't an object of oppression. Sure, this is the ethnocentric Westerner coming out, but listen. When we look at theocratic Islamic nations, no one disputes that they are second class citizens. That women have hardly any rights. We look at those regimes and we say that they are oppressive. However, aren't those laws based on Islamic teachings, non? Sharia law. I'm sure plenty of the women there accept their situation and truly don't believe they are oppressed. Now, someone will say, we aren't talking about the radical teachings of Islam, or the policies of theocratic dictatorships, but the practices and laws in these regimes all come from the same place. The Koran. People throw around the word radical and extremist, when those "radical" and "extremist" interpretations are completely and logically justified. It's right there in the book.
For example here are just a few questionable verses,
http://www.opposingviews.com/arguments/the-quran-promotes-violence
But apparently, that's only a few out of...109. Supposedly. So, if all these regimes are so oppressive and the majority of people think they are, when they base their laws upon very clear verses in the Koran, why does everyone take such a relativist stance on the burqa? The object at heart is still an oppressive object, in my opinion. Just because few Muslim women choose to wear it doesn't make it less so.
2) They pose a security risk. Can you identify a nun in a habit? Try it. I can't tell them apart. I can't even tell what color their hair is! How can we ID these people?! How can we tell if a monk walking into a bank has a gun under his robe? We obviously can't trust anyone in bulky clothing.
While I do enjoy Colbert's satire, this becomes a little less funny when you realize certain things don't really apply. For one, I can tell them apart. Hair alone isn't the sole identifying factor in a person. A nuns face is still pretty visible. Even in your photo, I could tell all the nuns looked different from eachother. If I saw a photo ID of a nun without the habit and compared it right next to her face in person, I'd be able to tell. So...would anyone else. Unless you're blind. You can't ID a muslim in a Burqa unless the head covering comes off. There's just no way around that. Granted, I'm sure there's no epidemic of thugster burqa wear'n women going around robbing banks, but leniencies can be taken advantage of. If people know they won't be asked for an ID just because they're wearing a burqa, what's to stop a person that's not even Muslim from wearing one to commit a crime? Why wear a ski mask and rouse suspicion, when you can just wear a burqa and slip right under the radar. If the place in question has alternative means of identification (Finger prints, facial recognition, etc) as mentioned earlier, then that's fine too. The catch is, not everywhere has those fancy bells and whistles. So, if a person asks for you to briefly take your burqa off for ID verification, you should do it. That, or be asked to leave.
Also on an unrelated note, simply because some Islamic women choose to wear the burqa, doesn't mean that the burqa isn't an object of oppression. Sure, this is the ethnocentric Westerner coming out, but listen. When we look at theocratic Islamic nations, no one disputes that they are second class citizens. That women have hardly any rights. We look at those regimes and we say that they are oppressive. However, aren't those laws based on Islamic teachings, non? Sharia law. I'm sure plenty of the women there accept their situation and truly don't believe they are oppressed. Now, someone will say, we aren't talking about the radical teachings of Islam, or the policies of theocratic dictatorships, but the practices and laws in these regimes all come from the same place. The Koran. People throw around the word radical and extremist, when those "radical" and "extremist" interpretations are completely and logically justified. It's right there in the book.
For example here are just a few questionable verses,
http://www.opposingviews.com/arguments/the-quran-promotes-violence
But apparently, that's only a few out of...109. Supposedly. So, if all these regimes are so oppressive and the majority of people think they are, when they base their laws upon very clear verses in the Koran, why does everyone take such a relativist stance on the burqa? The object at heart is still an oppressive object, in my opinion. Just because few Muslim women choose to wear it doesn't make it less so.
Last edited: