• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

The Burqa

The whole point of liberalism (the real one, not the Fox news version of liberalism) is that people should be free to live their lives how they wish.

That's idealistic and extremely flawed. That people should be able to live their lives how they wish OBVIOUSLY only goes up to a certain extent. As mentioned in my first post, what about being naked? Naturists and nudists are prohibited from being naked in most public places. Should we allow them to be naked in public just so that everyone can be "free to live their lifes how they wish"? The fact is that being naked in public is inappropriate, and covering your entire face in public is not only unecessary and extreme, but also a security risk. As mentioned before the Hijab is a MUCH more realistic substitute.

Clearly, the burka needs to be removed in places/situations like banks, ID checks and other such examples. But banning the burka in streets or supermarkets? That's fascist.

Wearing the full burqa in streets and supermarkets is still somewhat of a security implication. After all if the person wearing it commits any crime, they would be indistinquishable from every other burqa in the world. If I go into a supermarket wearing a hockey mask security would likely question me, and yet a garment which covers the full body is seen as normal. There is no reason that a woman should have to wear any such clothing, especially when the far more suitable hijab exists.

You mention that the burka is a barrier to social inclusion; and I agree, the inability to see a face or body language is not conductive to trust and communication. However, this is the whole point of freedom; you make a choice and you accept the consequences. What's next? will the state declare that piercings are illegal because they are unsightly? Will the state now declare that insults are illegal because people's feelings get hurt?

Of course not. I mentioned the Burqa being a barrier to social inclusion to show how ridiculous the item of clothing is in the first place. However, simply preventing social inclusion isn't something alone that should cause it to be banned. However it does show how much more suitable the hijab is in comparison, and adds to why it should be worn instead of the full burqa.

My opinion on it is irrelevant. I'm not Muslim. People who practice the Muslim faith that reside in the United States deserve the same rights to freedom of religion that all other people enjoy. Banning the burqa is absolutely outrageous and any legislation should be deemed unconstitutional.

So you're saying that anyone not muslim has an irrelevant opinion on the matter? That's a foolish opinion because as outsiders surely we're more suited to ciriticise such things, especially as within their own religion they wouldn't dare even question it. People should be able to follow their religion, but not to the point where they get more rights than any non religious citizen (e.g. to use a previous example again, a naturist who wishes to be nude in public). Besides, how much do you know about Islam? do you really think that the burqa is compulsory to wear? I think that wearing the burqa in the first place is outrageous.


You made an incorrect assumption.

This thread is for more than just you, and there have been people I've spoken to who don't know what the burqa is.

It's a religious garment. People wear it in an act of worship.

No they don't, it has nothing to do with worship. I don't think you know much about Islam.
 
What are you not understanding here? Do you think Muslims are exempts from the laws of a country or something?

You are unbelievably stupid. I genuinely feel like I'm sighing IQ points out of my body whenever I read your posts.

On topic, what that point referred to was the patronising notion that I fail to understand that muslims can also be tried under and in non-religious legal systems. Though of course domestic abuse is another thing of which there is very little condemnation in Islamic religious texts, and the poster seems to assume that all recipients of domestic abuse will speak out against.
 
Last edited:
A) Amish folk don't go into public places airports or other high security public areas that have modern technology.

The Amish actually are a common site in a set of hospitals that are near my university. They pay cash, but still utilize medical services. The Menonites are even less extreme with regards to technology. This wiki article details that there are many uses of modern technology, and I wouldn't put it beyond belief for an Amish community to have some type of group bank account or whatnot.

B) The Amish demographic poses zero terrorist threat to the U.S. government/soil. It never has.

And no terrorist attack in the US has ever been committed by someone decked out in traditional Islamic dress. The infamous Christmas Day shoe bomber was in something like jeans and a t-shirt.

It honestly should be banned in banks and airports and the like. When you go to the teller/whoever is there, you have to show I.D. I can't just walk in a bank, with a skimask thinking they will accept it assuming it was me.

It really is a safty hazard in some situations.

But this isn't the type of ban being talked about. In some European countries, it's being banned in public areas.

A lot of children are forced into believing that their parent's religion is right and are essentially brainwashed.

Okay, I get it. You think religion sucks and anyone who believes in it is probably brainwashed.

But then again, these are parents and this is their children.

You know what else parents do? They pass down all types of social and cultural norms and even personality traits and opinions to their children, probably untentionally.

If two liberals raise a child, that child will probably have liberal political beliefs.

Children of lawyers will probably at some point try to become lawyers

There's any number of political and entertainment dynasties where the children of these well known people try to follow in their footsteps.

Are they also "brainwashed" into doing these things and believing in these ideas and opinions?

It's part of how people raise children. Always has been.

If you look into certain documentaries, there's always a huge point being made about how both Muslim men and women would not dare to do certain things because of the consequences and how their society would view them.

And these "certain documentaries" and "certain things" would be....?

This meaning that most have to put up with what their parents want them to be.

Whoa, wait a second.

Are you saying that those DERN MOSLEM parents set standards for their children?

Golly gee whiz, what is this world coming to?

I was watching a documentary about Homosexuality in Islam, but it can also be related to how women may be forced into wearing Burqas or Hijabs or whatever else Muslim people have to do within their societies.
Just to make it clear, I mentioned Islam, but I'm not singling them out. I believe that brainwashing children occurs in every religion and even with those who aren't religious.

So you watch some documentary, that says women are "forced" into wearing burqas, without providing any evidence.

Yeah, rage against the machine, bro.

Which in many cases they are born into. If this is the case, they are led to believe that anything but Islam is the wrong path.

Yes, parents raise their children with cultural and social norms. This isn't new.

Especially because apostasy is punishable by death in Islamic law and culture.

Okay, let's deal with this right now.

Religious law is actually not literally THE LAW as in law enforcement. It is just a set of beliefs. Christians have laws. Jews have laws. Muslims have laws. Over the thousands of years these religions have been around, at some point they were adopted by socieities because Islam (and Catholicism and Judaism and other religions) became state sanctioned religions, but in the modern world, religious law holds absolutely no power in modern, civilized, western societies.

As for apostasy, just like with many religious texts and laws, there is debate over what is actually defined as apostasy and what the punishment for it is. Considering the only places that death for apostasy is enforced is third world nut job countries, I think my point stands that there is a difference between them and law abiding Muslims in western civilization.

Do you know how much harder it is for a woman to divorce her husband under Islamic law? The religion was created precisely to enforce patriarchal culture.

It's hard to break any religious marriage. There's no shortage of people who get married within a church or religious body, but never go through the process of a formal dissolvment of the religious marriage and move on with their lives. There's nothing preventing them from dissolving the civil marriage, remarrying in front of a judge, etc...

Yeah but we all know that this claim is ********,

And is this statement factual or is this an anti-Islam or anti-religion bias?

It really isn't. In traditional Islam, that's exactly what the burqa is for (weird how I have all these facts on my side). For modesty. Keep in mind there are millions of practicing (and non practicing) Muslims who, similar to Jews who don't keep strict kosher or kosher at all, who wear whatever they want in day-to-day living and might only dress in Islamic garb in religious services.

Or, in many cases, they don't have a choice. I wonder how many women there will be on the streets of Tehran and Riyadh today with their faces and clothes visible?

I don't know if you choose to ignore or you skipped the part of my post where I made a distinction between radicalized sects of Islam and the millions of Muslims living probably within a few miles of you (scary, I know), but I did. Go back and read it.

What is this "law" you speak of?

Municipal, state, federal laws. Seriously? Are you that dense?

Radical aspects of Islam? The apostasy law is in the Hadith, hardly a minor Islamic text. Polygamy is pretty much encouraged in mainstream islamic texts. Admittedly it is by no means the law to wear the Burqa, but in a culture where the man's word carries so much more authority, is it really surprising that this is often the case? There is nothing radical about sexism in Islam, it's jsut par for the course.

Yep. You're right. All Muslims are just polygammist marrying sexists horrible people.

Well I wouldn't go up to her and tell her, but if the conversation arose, of course I would.

What you're essentially saying here is that I have no right to criticise Islam. It is beyond criticism. Your last sentence is equally farcical.

Not beyond criticism. You're just ignoring the millions of law abiding Muslims who live and work in every day society (there may be one living within a few miles of you! oh my god!) and lumping all of them in with the nutcases who live in Iran.

This analogy fails on so many levels.

No, it's a perfect analogy. You're making broad assumptions on approximately one billion people, claiming they brainwash their children, treat their wives like crap up to the point of abuse, and don't follow the secular laws that they live under. Religious bigotry (or in your case, anti-religious bigotry) is just as despicable as racism (and in the case of Islam, may in fact be supportive of racism because many Muslims are *gasp*...brown people.)
 
You are unbelievably stupid. I genuinely feel like I'm sighing IQ points out of my body whenever I read your posts.

On topic, what that point referred to was the patronising notion that I fail to understand that muslims can also be tried under and in non-religious legal systems. Though of course domestic abuse is another thing of which there is very little condemnation in Islamic religious texts, and the poster seems to assume that all recipients of domestic abuse will speak out against.
There's nothing patronizing about it. Muslims are tried under non-religious legal systems every day. The majority of the world's governments are non-muslim.
"They aren't oppressed as long as they don't believe they are" is basically what you just said. Which is pretty stupid, tbh.
Could you explain why you think it is stupid? My particular flavor of religion has numerous "thou shalt nots" but I don't feel oppressed at all. I see our rules as liberating. I see you, bound by your sins and physically unable to fulfill the will of God, as oppressed. If a Muslim woman doesn't see the Hijab as oppressive, it is not oppressive to her. Just because she doesn't live by your personal definition of freedom doesn't mean there's anything wrong with the way she chooses to live and define her surroundings. What gives you the right to define her personal values?
That is the most grossly hideous and repulsive analogy I've ever read.

A) Amish folk don't go into public places airports or other high security public areas that have modern technology.
[img139]http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_wdemp3Pka3E/TPXBYYiTKjI/AAAAAAAAE0o/eJB6biIsff4/s1600/airport%2Bphoto.JPG[/img139]
B) The Amish demographic poses zero terrorist threat to the U.S. government/soil. It never has.
orly?
C) Amish people dress modestly. They do not obcsure their face or identity. Beards make little difference in determining identity these days because of advanced computer technology. We can simulate what a person will look like without a beard. Can you make out facial structure with a burga? No. It's about identity.
There's this amazing advanced computer technology called fingerprint identification too. It doesn't require a conservative Muslim woman to shame herself by forcing her to remove her burqa. And what is this nonsense about computer-facial-recognition. I don't know where you live, but no one uses that around here (Missouri). Tons of businesses and government institutions around here use fingerprint identification. Heck, if you buy gas up at the Mobil on the corner there's a thumb print scanner on the pumps. What you are suggesting doesn't fit the reality any of us live in.
Then you go off about skirts, which was really silly. Wearing a skirt is clearly different than actually wearing what are basically drapes that mask not only your identity but your body structure even. Much easier to wrap a bomb in a burga then it is to straddle one under a skirt.
Would you mind explaining for all of us how would putting a bomb under a full dress would be any different than putting one under a full burqa? They both cover her legs.
 
Last edited:
Yes, parents raise their children with cultural and social norms. This isn't new.

Which obviously highlights my point that there is a significant chance that the wearing of the burqa etc. is not a choice which was/is made with all the relevant information and facts in hand.

Okay, let's deal with this right now.

Religious law is actually not literally THE LAW as in law enforcement.

Irrelevant and not what I was saying. If you can't figure it out, then let me explain it to you. In the Hadith, by no means a minor Islamic text, amongst other things is the statement that apostates should be put to death. Now, if someone is taught the teachings of the Hadith as a child, then they are hardly given the chance to believe that their choice of religion and lifestyle is "voluntary". Indeed, it would suggest the opposite. This logic extends to many aspects of Islamic life, which as a patriarchal culture means that many women are essential second-class citizens.

It is just a set of beliefs. Christians have laws. Jews have laws. Muslims have laws. Over the thousands of years these religions have been around, at some point they were adopted by socieities because Islam (and Catholicism and Judaism and other religions) became state sanctioned religions, but in the modern world, religious law holds absolutely no power in modern, civilized, western societies.

You realise that there is such a thing as power within households as well yes?

As for apostasy, just like with many religious texts and laws, there is debate over what is actually defined as apostasy and what the punishment for it is. Considering the only places that death for apostasy is enforced is third world nut job countries, I think my point stands that there is a difference between them and law abiding Muslims in western civilization.

In the same way that the bible condones child abuse, the Hadith condones murdering apostates. There is no debate to be had here. Mainstream monotheistic teachings are violent. As mentioned in my previous point (and pretty obvious in my initial) post, the apostasy point was made not in direct relation to the Burqa, but as an example as to how personal freedom is considered immoral within Islam.


It's hard to break any religious marriage.

Amazing attempt to avoid the point. It remains easier for a man, therefore it is sexist and patriarchal.

And is this statement factual or is this an anti-Islam or anti-religion bias?

Id' say it's more anti-ignorance than anything else. The protection and modesty point simply doesn't stand up to logical though, unless you are seeking to demean both your own sex and the opposite sex enough for you to believe it to be so.

It really isn't. In traditional Islam, that's exactly what the burqa is for (weird how I have all these facts on my side). For modesty. Keep in mind there are millions of practicing (and non practicing) Muslims who, similar to Jews who don't keep strict kosher or kosher at all, who wear whatever they want in day-to-day living and might only dress in Islamic garb in religious services.

You mean a patriarchal culture and society demanded its women be modest? No ****ing way. These "facts" mean nothing. Islam was created within a patriarchal culture, it was set up at a time where men went out of their way to prevent women interfering in public life or getting ideas above their station. It is worthless to use traditional Islam to justify sexual laws because they were formed with ingrained sexism on the part of their creators.

I don't know if you choose to ignore or you skipped the part of my post where I made a distinction between radicalized sects of Islam and the millions of Muslims living probably within a few miles of you (scary, I know), but I did. Go back and read it.

Ha, implying I'm scared of Muslims. Very good. Just for the record, I hate ******s too. Those watermelon smiles and spear chucking just gives me a chill down my spine. I also find the language they use to be unintelligible and base.

However, on topic, that is not my point. The point is that the Burqa's usage is strongest in these repressive patriarchal societies. Is this surprising? The obvious point we can gleam from this is that much of its (enforced) use is steeped in prejudice and sexism.

Municipal, state, federal laws. Seriously? Are you that dense?

See above.

Yep. You're right. All Muslims are just polygammist marrying sexists horrible people.

Attempt to ignore the argument.


Not beyond criticism. You're just ignoring the millions of law abiding Muslims who live and work in every day society (there may be one living within a few miles of you! oh my god!) and lumping all of them in with the nutcases who live in Iran.

Except I'm not, but hey-ho.

No, it's a perfect analogy. You're making broad assumptions on approximately one billion people, claiming they brainwash their children, treat their wives like crap up to the point of abuse, and don't follow the secular laws that they live under. Religious bigotry (or in your case, anti-religious bigotry) is just as despicable as racism (and in the case of Islam, may in fact be supportive of racism because many Muslims are *gasp*...brown people.)
[/QUOTE]

If I was a petty man, this would be report worthy because of the almost explicit idea that I'm racist. However, I'll state again that this analogy fails on many levels. It is awfully bad.
 
Last edited:
As mentioned in my first post, what about being naked? Naturists and nudists are prohibited from being naked in most public places.

That's because they are frankly revealing stuff that people don't want to see.

Is someone dressed in traditional religious clothes showing something that is visibly repulsive to you? Would small children be exposed to sexual organs if someone is dressed like a nun?

but also a security risk. As mentioned before the Hijab is a MUCH more realistic substitute.

Being in public, in an open space, a security risk?

Fortunately, I don't live my life in fear. Seriously, do you live in fear walking down the street? Do people in your country or city or whatever just get randomly stopped in public areas?

Different sects of Islam judge modesty differently. Depending on the circumstances and so on. I'm betting the hijab and burqa both exist for a reason and aren't interchangeable.

Wearing the full burqa in streets and supermarkets is still somewhat of a security implication. After all if the person wearing it commits any crime, they would be indistinquishable from every other burqa in the world.

If anything it makes them easily identifiable since in most parts of the western world, Islam is a minority religion, and traditional Islam (IE those who would most likely be wearing the burqa in public) even more so.

And seriously: You live in fear when at the supermarket?

There is no reason that a woman should have to wear any such clothing, especially when the far more suitable hijab exists.

Hi. My name is CAH and I have no understanding of any culture that isn't my own.

So you're saying that anyone not muslim has an irrelevant opinion on the matter? That's a foolish opinion because as outsiders surely we're more suited to ciriticise such things, especially as within their own religion they wouldn't dare even question it.

While you're free to criticize, you're approaching it with your own biases that don't account for how people within the religion view their practices and traditions. While you might see yourself as being more "open minded" about criticizing Islam from the outside, those knowledgable about Islam might say you're criticism is based in ignorance.

I think that wearing the burqa in the first place is outrageous.

Then Islam isn't for you. Feel free to choose another religion.
 
Last edited:
Which obviously highlights my point that there is a significant chance that the wearing of the burqa etc. is not a choice which was/is made with all the relevant information and facts in hand.
Parents raising their children with their preferred societal norms =/= taking a child's choice away, as is borne out by the reality that not all women wear the burqa in most majority Muslim countries.
 
Attempt to ignore the argument.

It really isn't. But I see no real reason to continue this with you because it's clear you clearly have a biased, bigoted view of Islam (And possibly of just any religious person in general) so I don't really see a point in continuing a conversation with you when it's just going to be refuted with "psh, religious people, bunch of sheeple *eyeroll*"

If I was a petty man, this would be report worthy because of the almost explicit idea that I'm racist. However, I'll state again that this analogy fails on many levels. It is awfully bad.

Is this the new, cool thing in the Debate forum? Publicly declare that you WERE going to report someone, and then not because you're taking the "high road"?

It's a perfect analogy. You have a bigoted view of Islam. People in the KKK have a bigoted view of blacks. Bigotry is bigotry. Simple as that.

And yes, a lot of anti-Muslim rhetoric does stem from them looking and dressing different, which can in part be based in racial fears. This goes for Erope too, which is generally very white and hey, what are the two differences between the immigrants in Europe and the Europeans? They're white and lapsed Christians, and the immigrants are black and Muslim.
 
Parents raising their children with their preferred societal norms =/= taking a child's choice away, as is borne out by the reality that not all women wear the burqa in most majority Muslim countries.

Yes because the Burqa is the only example of children being negatively affected by their parents.
 
It is an example of what you personally have called "children being negatively affected by their parents". It is being taught from their scriptures, and young women are choosing to not follow it. Your claim is either outright false, or grossly, intentionally exaggerated.
 
It really isn't. But I see no real reason to continue this with you because it's clear you clearly have a biased, bigoted view of Islam (And possibly of just any religious person in general) so I don't really see a point in continuing a conversation with you when it's just going to be refuted with "psh, religious people, bunch of sheeple *eyeroll*"

No to be fair your previous points were really well argued so this is a good decision.

The thing is, you speak as if having a biased view of Islam/religion is a bad thing. I'm an athiest, so I'm generally going to take a dismissive view of religion. However, I'm particularly going to take a dim view of a patriarchal set of beliefs which were founded by a murderous paedophile. This is not a bad thing. I'm sure Islam, just like Christianity, assists people throughout their daily lives and good for them. However, this does not make it immune from criticism, and it does not justify the more vile aspects of their set of beliefs. Using the "ur jst prjdced" card is just a bit poor.

Is this the new, cool thing in the Debate forum? Publicly declare that you WERE going to report someone, and then not because you're taking the "high road"?

I wouldn't say I was taking the high ground so much as highlighting you plumbing the depths of "racist" finger pointing without any evidence to do so.


It's a perfect analogy. You have a bigoted view of Islam. People in the KKK have a bigoted view of blacks. Bigotry is bigotry. Simple as that.

Apparently race and religion are now the same thing everyone. Randomspot has spoken. Honestly, really? Really? You're really saying that criticising these two things are the same? Honestly?

And yes, a lot of anti-Muslim rhetoric does stem from them looking and dressing different, which can in part be based in racial fears.

While a lot doesn't.
 
This goes for Erope too, which is generally very white and hey, what are the two differences between the immigrants in Europe and the Europeans? They're white and lapsed Christians, and the immigrants are black and Muslim.

This is true for Northern Europe indeed, I think that in Spain and Italy are more people who are still believing, but for the Netherlands and England and all other northern European countries, this is a fact. Generally, there are people from Turkey and Morocco here who cause trouble by loitering. However, these are always guys from below the 25. I have never heard of seen any women who wore a Burqa and robbed a place.

Most people are saying that they shouldn't be allowed to wear it in banks for instance. However, this would beat the purpose of the burqa. It's worn by women who believe that their appearance should only been shown to their husband, not to their husband and their local bank.

Funny fact, this is all about the burqa because it conceals the apparel of someone. However, what about a guy who is clothed as Santa? That should be forbidden as well, cause you ca't identify who it is thanks to the beard, and before you know it's actually a terrorist in disguise. Or is this completely about the fact that it's about religion?

And the whole point is, when you can't identify someone, it's a terrorist.
 
Don't forget little kids on Halloween. They could be terrorists. Might want to arrest or fine them.

And Amish/Jewish men. They could commit a crime, then shave off their beard. YOU'D NEVER RECOGNIZE THEM!
 
It is an example of what you personally have called "children being negatively affected by their parents". It is being taught from their scriptures, and young women are choosing to not follow it. Your claim is either outright false, or grossly, intentionally exaggerated.

The Hijab/Burqa are not an explicit part of scripture.
 
What really gets on my nerves is that many Muslim schools actually include the burqa in the school uniform. So young girls don't even have the choice to not wear them. I have no problem with Indian women wearing their long colorful dresses because it doesn't detract their identity, or Jewish people wearing the Kippah (worn by both men and women) again because it does not detract their identity. The main problem for me though is that the burqa is definately a huge security risk. To be able to identify someone you need to be able to see a person's entire face, not just their eyes. Therefor it makes sense to make the burqa illegal in banks and if I had my way even in shopping centres cos it would be easy to walk in to steal cash/ shoot someone whatever cos without being able to see the entire face there's no way to identify the attacker. That's not to say though that just Muslim people would do this, but anyone who got their hands on a burqa could. Anyway in Australia it's not just burqa's which must be removed when going to certain places but also hoodies which have been banned in certain shops. If hoodies were allowed but not burqa's then we would have a problem.
 
Back
Top