It really goes to show how much Sarah has improved over the years and that's why I really have no preference, beyond the fact that Veronica will always be the original.
She has not improved at all right now if you ask me: in fact, I can easily pick up on the difference between the two (not hard to tell for me), and her XY performance is one of Sarah's worst yet as Ash: not only is his voice deep again, but there's almost zero emotion in it other than this perpetually angry and pissed off feeling: he was supposed to sound encouraging to Clemont recently, and instead, he sounds growly and rough, almost ordering him to, while doing it. Out of any of Natochenny's performances as the character, the only one I was able to tolerate was early-mid BW, but since late BW she's been getting inconsistent and rougher in delivery, and that has only gotten worse since XY's dub with him now sounding angry and pissed off all the time. I think she's been
deproving lately, personally.
Veronica Taylor is really the only English VA for Ash I think did a great job: I'm honestly not satisfied with Sarah Natochenny at all in the role, and I couldn't be more displeased with how she's done overall (seriously, Kid Ash sounding like Johanna recently? WRONG). Ash is a 10 year old boy, yet now he sounds 17 and like he's smoked one too many cigarettes (objectively bad)-- that right there, is a huge problem to me, and frankly I would rather have Bryce Papenbrook (the guy who did Red) take over as Ash than listen to Sarah anymore in the role-- he did a good job with his role, and I feel he could be a good Ash replacement. Kayzie was even worse than Sarah, though, I admit.
I don't prefer Veronica because she's the original: I prefer her as Ash because she managed to keep Ash's voice consistent after settling into the role, always made Ash emote with passion in her acting, and he always sounded like a little boy to me. She is the one and only English actress that I feel I can truly say was, is, and will always be Ash Ketchum at this point-- at least unless another actor/actress manages to come along and do it right. Neither Sarah, nor Kayzie, got it down correctly, IMO.
I still stand by my original opinion of all are equal, even the deep one because it reminds me of me.
Reminds me of me? Man, you're even talking like the current Ash now...that sounded SO stupid when he said that back in DP dubbed (no offense-- I just have bad memories of Ash saying this from "Strategy Begins at Home!")
Anyway, I respect your opinion, but the only one I feel did the role justice was Veronica Taylor, his 1st actress. I really can't stomach Kayzie Rogers' take on him, or Sarah Natochenny's take on him, anymore-- both feel so incredibly subpar and inadequate for me that it doesn't even match the character to me, be it his age, personality, or anything. Ash feels so soulless and emotionless now in the dub to me: it hurts.