• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Badges order

Johnzaloog

Yu-Gi-Oh! LV1 Judge
I'm sorry if somebody else has already said this, but I just remembered the original series, and how ash got his badges in a different order to the RGBYFRLG games. You know, how Rainbow-Soul-Marsh became Marsh-Rainbow-Soul. Perhaps something similar could happen this time too, due to Fantina's delayed trip away from the gym. Just an idea, but maybe more. Discuss.
 
Err...you have to travel to Celestic Town before you fight Fantina in the games, also. There's no "delay" here.
 
This is dumb.
 
In the anime, it's not necessary to follow any order. Ash could fight Volkner first if he wants to. Just for that sake of simplicity, they are trying to maintain the order of the games in most arcs.
 
I think from now on they are going to follow the order of the games
 
^^ Cuz they did in Johto, Hoenn, and the first half of Sinnoh.
 
Unlike that guy who said this thread is DUMB, I think this brings us an interesting point. If we follow the games, it will be the first time a particular place was visited more than three times, besides Pallet Town, which may lead to many filler episodes, which will make Sinnoh a very long saga. Yeah, probably they'll try to mix up a bit. Well, this has been an unpredictable season, isn't it?
 
First off, this in sot dumb, i find it rather interesting.

Secondly, i prefer the right way to do it and i think so do the writers. Kanto was way too short because they skipped out alot of Game features. And there were hardly any fillers which is understandable because it was their first season. I guess they did the order after that the right way as it would've made the seasons a suitable length.

Thirdly, hwy does everyone say D/P is unpredictable? Its not people! Ash starts with Pikachu. Pikachu destroys females protaginists bike. Female gets starter which has way more limelight than it should be and makes other pokemon seem forgettable. Brock gets sh!t all treatment. Team Rocket continue on their crap ways and the rival has way more pokemon than he should. Not very un-predictable to me


Thats my lot though
 
In the anime, it's not necessary to follow any order. Ash could fight Volkner first if he wants to. Just for that sake of simplicity, they are trying to maintain the order of the games in most arcs.

^What he said.

DP is following closer to the anime than any other saga so far. Miltank milk house, Psyduck Roadblock, etc.

Kanto was sorta random..they seemed to do almost anything to AVOID story elements of the game. No TR arc at all, nothing about the cubone or the ghosts in the haunted tower.

Johto skipped most things from the games and put pointless fillers in their place.

Hoeen improved a lot from Kanto/Johto days but still skipped a lot.

Sinnoh seems to be doing the best so far.
 
In the games though you can get several badges before others as well can't you. Cna't that happena fair bit in Kanto though were this whole arguement happened?
 
I'm sorry about the mistake about not being able to battle fantina yet anyway, it's been a long time since I played DP through.
 
Well You've gotta Think, Would the Anime be any better if Ash collected his Badges in a Different Order,

Let's say Ash had went from Oreburgh to Canalave backtracking through Jubilife, then to Eterna, from Eterna to Hearthome, Then Pastoria and then Veilstone, Then Hearthome's 2nd time, and then to ( then the more logical ) Snowpoint, then Finally Hearthome again and then SunnyShore

This is kinda messy and you also have to account for Dawn's contests which seem to Follow whatever City a Gym isnt in ( excluding Hearthome ), and whatever crazyness the gang runs into
 
Well come to think of it, would it even matter if Ash got his badges in whichever order. It won't bother me in the least.
 
1. Roark
2. Gardenia
3. Maylene
4. Wake
5. Fantina
6. Byron
7. Candice
8. Volkner or someone new. Doesn't sound like Volkner has been replaced..maybe that was false info


Theres no delay, the reason Ash isn't battling Fantina in Hearthorne now is because he just had a battle with Wake a few episodes ago, they wanna visit Celestic first so that there can be somewhat of a gap between the 2 gyms
 
Back
Top