• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Ideal Hero

angeal

Sage
If the pokemon series re-innovated the personality of the protagonist(Ash) what traits would you change? How would battles be different? And what characteristics in pokemon would be most appealing to this new ash.

;078;Ash can be described as an generic anime hero, hes a determined charactered ,focuses on a single goal and doesn't hesitate when expressing his true identity. He is intrested in pokemon that seem powerful in terms of attack but also those that are determined.

Alternate personalities can include some traits from pual;444;, lance;145;, conway;049; even ash's sceptile;355; if you like
 
I would want Ash to stop wondering what happens when a pokemon starts glowing. I just want him to get on the defensive side a little bit like Paul does.
 
I like Ash the way he is. He made a slow but sure transition from a fiery, whiny, and occasionally completely annoying kid who didn't really care about his Pokemon beyond their ability to battle to someone who deeply cares about every member of his Team to the point that he'd sooner do what his Pokemon want then what he think is best for them. The idea that Ash cares too much about his Pokemon is his most glaring weakness. He's willing to forgo even his own instinct to appease his Pokemon. His short temper does get the best of him at times but now he knows that being whiny / pouty about the situation won't fix the problem.

Over the course of the series he's matured as a Trainer considerably. I imagine it's because he doesn't drive his Pokemon like slaves in a fashion similar to Paul's that some have grown to dislike him. It can't be helped since the ongoing moral of the story is that you should treat your friends, family, and " pets " with some level of compassion.
 
Some traits I would considered:
-Someone who's enable to learn something from repeated things, (like we all know it's Team Rocket in those disguises, but conisdering it's a kids show, i guess it's an exception of a sort)
- Sometimes I think he usually makes rash decisions in a sort, probably he should think before he do. (Maybe there are some exceptions)
- Try not to do anything stupid (like roasting bikes, but I guess it would be a running gag, but it's another exception)

I guess my thoughts, they have some exceptions.
 
A character that learns, and battles using sheer knowledge learnt from written or electronic sources, and not instinct. He would be a cautious battler, with calm personality. He would also take less risks and stay out of perilous situations.
 
I like Ash the way he is. He made a slow but sure transition from a fiery, whiny, and occasionally completely annoying kid who didn't really care about his Pokemon beyond their ability to battle to someone who deeply cares about every member of his Team to the point that he'd sooner do what his Pokemon want then what he think is best for them.

How "occasionally" are we talking about here?
 
I would make him smarter.

For example, I would cut this "Don't-evolve" crud. He would evolve all his Pokemon the second he is able to.

I would also have him catch more Pokemon, even if he dosen't use them. The Tauros, for example, are excellent.
 
i would change Brock to be a llittle less boring and a bit more carefree....

i would change Dawn to not be such a crybaby every single time she loses a contest...

i would NEVER change Paul...

until now i am happy with Ash though i would like him to be a bit more tough

Misty is still my fav one

Barry is perfect in fact i would even do him more hyperactive....:)

Kenny is hopeless in my eyes

and Zoey looks nice
 
I would make him smarter.

For example, I would cut this "Don't-evolve" crud. He would evolve all his Pokemon the second he is able to.

I would also have him catch more Pokemon, even if he dosen't use them. The Tauros, for example, are excellent.

Yea I completely agree. I would also like to see a little bit more strategy instead of the, "Come on hang in there" stuff.
 
more serious make him a loner and a silent hero and a bamf like gary
 
How "occasionally" are we talking about here?

I'd say he grates my nerves about once every twenty episodes or so now as opposed to every other episode in Kanto.

For example, I would cut this "Don't-evolve" crud. He would evolve all his Pokemon the second he is able to.

He seems to be better with it now then he was in the past. Just ignore the hopeless case of Pikachu.

The Tauros, for example, are excellent.

Yes. Yes. He should make a whole Team of Tauros. Dominate the League ...

more serious make him a loner and a silent hero and a bamf like gary

I thought Gary was an arrogant jerk who got " Better " after getting knocked down a few pegs.
 
I'd say he grates my nerves about once every twenty episodes or so now as opposed to every other episode in Kanto.

Yet you didn't find that funny? Kanto Ash was such a moron you couldn't help but find it comedic. Its why people still feel Kanto had the best comedy of the series.

I do like the way Ash changed, but I always admitted he was funnier back in Kanto/Orange than in Johto, AG or DP.
 
Yet you didn't find that funny?

It just struck me the wrong way. While there were things that were genuinely funny back then the way Ash carried himself as a Trainer wasn't one of them. I can see how other people would enjoy it, though.
 
He should be the strong silent type, like Red. Less talkative, more intuitive.
 
Satoshi has changed for the better. I like the Kanto episodes, to be sure, but there are a lot of times when Satoshi comes across as a real jerk, and it's hard to root for him. The Jouto Final Conference and the start of Houen turned him into a more intelligent and mature trainer; one who still makes the occasional blunder, but who learns from the experience instead of trying to blame it on something else. He has compassion, knowledge, and a strong will, and he makes an effort to challenge himself. And he understands the needs of his Pokémon and treats them like equals, with the same level of respect he'd show to his friends.

So yeah, as far as this show is concerned, Satoshi is my ideal hero. I enjoy watching his adventures, and it's fun to see him succeed at what he does.
 
I suppose that I value courage, strength, and intelligence.

I'd want a hero who is brave, strong, and intelligent (Ash isn't so smart -_-)
 
Back
Top