• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Iris

Status
Not open for further replies.
Wouldn't XY be the one that feels out of place considering its lack of continuity compared to the other series'? True Ash in XY had good battling skills but other then that, there were hardly anything in XY that touched upon the things Ash did in the past such as League standings, old companions, etc.
 
Wouldn't XY be the one that feels out of place considering its lack of continuity compared to the other series'? True Ash in XY had good battling skills but other then that, there were hardly anything in XY that touched upon the things Ash did in the past such as League standings, old companions, etc.

BW didn't have too much continuity until Dawn showed up from what I remember. And of course they also brought back Charizard fairly late in the series. Pacing problems were had with XYZ because of Sun/Moon being announced so quickly and continuity was some sort of oversight apparently.
 
Iris is my favorite Companion Pokegirl.
First of all, Aoi Yuki is the only VA which does her justice.

With that aside, I'm surprised we never had a character aspiring to be a Dragon-master before, seeing how popular Dragons are in fiction. I also enjoyed her early feeling of mystery, what's with already having an Excadrill prior to meeting with Ash. Her backstory eps are fun in general too.

Mostly, I enjoyed how she acted like an actual person, rather than fangirling over anything Ash does, like, well, many of the other girls, especially now in Alola.

BW didn't have too much continuity until Dawn showed up from what I remember.

Blame the earthquake, Looker was supposed to appear fairly early in the series.
 
With that aside, I'm surprised we never had a character aspiring to be a Dragon-master before, seeing how popular Dragons are in fiction. I also enjoyed her early feeling of mystery, what's with already having an Excadrill prior to meeting with Ash. Her backstory eps are fun in general too.

.

*Points to Clair*
 
With that aside, I'm surprised we never had a character aspiring to be a Dragon-master before, seeing how popular Dragons are in fiction. I also enjoyed her early feeling of mystery, what's with already having an Excadrill prior to meeting with Ash. Her backstory eps are fun in general too.

.

*Points to Clair*

Clair is a Dragon-type gym specialist, not a trainer aspiring to be a Dragon-master. There's a difference.
 
Clair is a Dragon-type gym specialist, not a trainer aspiring to be a Dragon-master. There's a difference.

Considering that Gym specialists are implied to be trying to become (or already are) masters of their chosen types (e.g. Misty, Iris), my point remains valid.
 
BW didn't have too much continuity until Dawn showed up from what I remember. And of course they also brought back Charizard fairly late in the series. Pacing problems were had with XYZ because of Sun/Moon being announced so quickly and continuity was some sort of oversight apparently.
...when Dawn showed up doesn't really matter. What matters is that we got continuity in the end.

XY blatantly ignoring past series really makes it feel out-of-place. And I feel like that is too big of a thing to be an oversight. It seems intentional.
 
XY blatantly ignoring past series really makes it feel out-of-place. And I feel like that is too big of a thing to be an oversight. It seems intentional.

I believe the director said in an interview that the lack of continuity was both because of oversight and due to Sun/Moon coming out so quickly. Technically, XY got continuity at the very end too in the form of a short phone call. Also, that one random reference to Piplup in the Magikarp episode.
 
BW didn't have too much continuity until Dawn showed up from what I remember. And of course they also brought back Charizard fairly late in the series. Pacing problems were had with XYZ because of Sun/Moon being announced so quickly and continuity was some sort of oversight apparently.

Best Wishes had lots of continuity. From what I recall we got flashbacks of Brock and Misty in the episode Charizard came back and at the end of DA all his traveling companions had flashbacks. Not to mention Clair and professor Oak made appearances in DA. I also remember Dawn mentioning she's gonna do the Wallace Cup that year and mentioning Brock himself and how much Cilan reminds him of him. To be honest it was just XY(Z) that had lack of continuity
 
...when Dawn showed up doesn't really matter. What matters is that we got continuity in the end.

XY blatantly ignoring past series really makes it feel out-of-place. And I feel like that is too big of a thing to be an oversight. It seems intentional.

Yeah I don't know how the writers and higher ups could unintentionally forget to add some kind of continuity like Iris appearing. I mean they could have gotten rid of a few of those boring, horrible fillers for an Iris appearance.
 
Yeah I don't know how the writers and higher ups could unintentionally forget to add some kind of continuity like Iris appearing. I mean they could have gotten rid of a few of those boring, horrible fillers for an Iris appearance.

Say what you want but I found it incredibly weird how Cilan was able to get an appearance but Iris was overlooked and yet it was claimed it wasn't due to "popularity" and was just an "overlook". Best Wishes had 142 (mind you 20 of those episodes were DA fillers and weren't a badge quest) and XY had 140 episodes. You mean to tell me Best Wishes were able to include Dawn for 9 episodes have an Iris arc and wrap up the league but XY couldn't have included Iris or a bit more continuity? Bleh some of those XY filler episodes could of been towards Iris
 
In a perfect world we would've seen this, though the fact that Iris was almost lynched by fans for daring to catch a Dragonite is still a sad double standard since if Ash had done it, no one would've whined. :/

I dunno if Ash getting Dragonite in Iris' place would've gone over well either however. If I had to guess, I'd say that alot of fans would rather see characters catch base stage Pokemon so that we'd see them evolve. So maybe that's why Iris catching Dragonite was so disliked during Best Wishes. ^^;
 
I also enjoyed her early feeling of mystery, what's with already having an Excadrill prior to meeting with Ash. Her backstory eps are fun in general too.

I remember thinking that Ash would face Iris in the Opelucid Gym back when BW began. I'm kind of sad that this didn't happen since Iris wasn't a Gym Leader in the cartoon.
 
I remember thinking that Ash would face Iris in the Opelucid Gym back when BW began. I'm kind of sad that this didn't happen since Iris wasn't a Gym Leader in the cartoon.

I honestly had a theory about Iris simply faking her lack of experience and was simply studying Ash for her gym battle where she would give him a run for his money because she can see a pattern to his supposed unpredictability.
 
Wouldn't XY be the one that feels out of place considering its lack of continuity compared to the other series'? True Ash in XY had good battling skills but other then that, there were hardly anything in XY that touched upon the things Ash did in the past such as League standings, old companions, etc.

Both series sucked in terms of continuity. BW 'reset' Ash in skill and maturity, but had weird bouts of continuity. XY returned Ash to DP levels, but had next to zero continuity. SM has bits of continuity, but Ash is more enthusiastic than his XY persona so the transition is off. Honestly, OS->DP feels like one continuous story, whereas BW, XY, and SM feel like disconnected sagas with a version of Ash/Pikachu.


I believe the director said in an interview that the lack of continuity was both because of oversight and due to Sun/Moon coming out so quickly. Technically, XY got continuity at the very end too in the form of a short phone call. Also, that one random reference to Piplup in the Magikarp episode.

I don't buy that at all. How do you just forget about continuity while making a series for 3 years?
 
I can't speak for everyone who didn't like Iris as everyone who hates her has their own individual reasons (for example, the "such a little kid" thing did not bother me but it really bothers some people), but here are my reasons for not liking Iris:

1) That comment about how she can't train a Charizard because it's not a dragon type. This is from a girl who owns an Emolga, and whose starter pokemon was a Drilbur (now Excadrill). Now, there had been a lot about Iris that irked me before this, but this moment is, well... I believe the phrase is "The straw the broke the camel's back." This it the moment that finally made me go "That's it, Iris, I'm done. I can't deal with you anymore. I've tried liking you in spite of everything else, but you've just completely ruined it all. If that's how you really feel, give Ash your Excadrill, send Emolga to Bianca (she wanted it more than you anyway) and just get off the screen." - This reaction from me wasn't the only one of its kind that the BW series provoked. Oshawott did it too. I'm not sure of the exact point I gave up on him, but I do remember seeing Ash send it out against Cheren's Herdier and just switching the tv off because I knew Ash's loss as inevitable (checked the internet later and was proved right btw)

2) Dragonite. I bothered me at first that she just up and got one with little effort of her part, but I mostly don't care about that now. What does bug me though is all those times where it clearly wasn't listening to her, but no one did anything. This is especially notable in the Junior Cup thing they all took part in during Dawn's return arc and I will forever love Georgia for pointing out that Iris did not win, only her Dragonite did. Thankfully Ash's Krokorok evolved and put a stop to it because it didn't look like anyone else was going to. But even once it started listening to its trainer, this still wasn't a good thing because it hasn't won a fight since. Then there's the fact that since she caught Dragonite all her other pokemon have been pretty much redundant.

3) Her goal was barely touched on for a very long time. I know people go "Oh, but she can understand the hearts of dragons now" but I say "So what?" as it hasn't really helped her on her way to becoming a dragon master. Look at the situation - yes, her Axew did learn two strong moves, but it never battles anymore and is no nearer to evolving that it was when they debuted in the show, despite it being Axew's dream to do so. And yes, her Dragonite does listen to her now, but ultimately he's worse off for it as he hasn't won anything since. And as I've already said, her other two aren't even dragon types!

4) The loss off what made her stand out in the games. In the first Black and White games, she's Drayden's apprentice and apparently his adopted Granddaughter. The anime completely removes this. In Black 2 and White 2 she has progressed above the level of her mentor and become the champion of the Unova region. Nothing in the anime suggests that such a feat could ever be possible for her.

All in all, I just found Iris painful to try and endure, but she's emblematic of just about the entire BW series. I found watching Cilan painful after about the fifth time his gimmick was used. I found Oshawott painful to watch. And Trip, Cameron, hell, a lot of the time I found Ash to be a pain to watch during the fifth generation anime.
 
I can't speak for everyone who didn't like Iris as everyone who hates her has their own individual reasons (for example, the "such a little kid" thing did not bother me but it really bothers some people), but here are my reasons for not liking Iris:

1) That comment about how she can't train a Charizard because it's not a dragon type. This is from a girl who owns an Emolga, and whose starter pokemon was a Drilbur (now Excadrill). Now, there had been a lot about Iris that irked me before this, but this moment is, well... I believe the phrase is "The straw the broke the camel's back." This it the moment that finally made me go "That's it, Iris, I'm done. I can't deal with you anymore. I've tried liking you in spite of everything else, but you've just completely ruined it all. If that's how you really feel, give Ash your Excadrill, send Emolga to Bianca (she wanted it more than you anyway) and just get off the screen." - This reaction from me wasn't the only one of its kind that the BW series provoked. Oshawott did it too. I'm not sure of the exact point I gave up on him, but I do remember seeing Ash send it out against Cheren's Herdier and just switching the tv off because I knew Ash's loss as inevitable (checked the internet later and was proved right btw)

2) Dragonite. I bothered me at first that she just up and got one with little effort of her part, but I mostly don't care about that now. What does bug me though is all those times where it clearly wasn't listening to her, but no one did anything. This is especially notable in the Junior Cup thing they all took part in during Dawn's return arc and I will forever love Georgia for pointing out that Iris did not win, only her Dragonite did. Thankfully Ash's Krokorok evolved and put a stop to it because it didn't look like anyone else was going to. But even once it started listening to its trainer, this still wasn't a good thing because it hasn't won a fight since. Then there's the fact that since she caught Dragonite all her other pokemon have been pretty much redundant.

3) Her goal was barely touched on for a very long time. I know people go "Oh, but she can understand the hearts of dragons now" but I say "So what?" as it hasn't really helped her on her way to becoming a dragon master. Look at the situation - yes, her Axew did learn two strong moves, but it never battles anymore and is no nearer to evolving that it was when they debuted in the show, despite it being Axew's dream to do so. And yes, her Dragonite does listen to her now, but ultimately he's worse off for it as he hasn't won anything since. And as I've already said, her other two aren't even dragon types!

4) The loss off what made her stand out in the games. In the first Black and White games, she's Drayden's apprentice and apparently his adopted Granddaughter. The anime completely removes this. In Black 2 and White 2 she has progressed above the level of her mentor and become the champion of the Unova region. Nothing in the anime suggests that such a feat could ever be possible for her.

All in all, I just found Iris painful to try and endure, but she's emblematic of just about the entire BW series. I found watching Cilan painful after about the fifth time his gimmick was used. I found Oshawott painful to watch. And Trip, Cameron, hell, a lot of the time I found Ash to be a pain to watch during the fifth generation anime.

This pretty much sums up BW nicely for me.
I don't actually hate Iris though after all of this, she's one of the characters I like the least (Cilan, Max and Serena are all after her, I like them much less than I do Iris), but she's still quite likeable, but I agree with all of the things you said on why she's one of the least liked characters for me.

I do feel a bit sorry for Iris, she sort of just, left, and without actually achieving anything, or nearing her goal, the previous girls before her, left, but at least they got nearer to their goal, Misty nearly won the Whirl Cup, and then went on to become a gym leader, the next step in her goal, May came eighth (or was it fourth) in a Grand Festival, which is a great achievement, Dawn came second, and only lost by half a point in a Grand Festival, an even greater achievement, but then Iris, she didn't achieve anything like them, she managed to bond with her Dragonite and that was it (she did win a Don George tournament early on in the series, but that I don't think furthers her dreams of becoming a dragon master), and then she just suddenly up and left, without any emotion, it felt like no thought had gone into it either. Of course this could have been fixed if they gave her an appearance in XY, she could have come back, and mentioned that she just got the job as a gym leader, and maybe wanted to show off to Ash and see if he'd grown before heading back and starting her new job, but XY messed that up with lack of continuity.
 
This pretty much sums up BW nicely for me.
I don't actually hate Iris though after all of this, she's one of the characters I like the least (Cilan, Max and Serena are all after her, I like them much less than I do Iris), but she's still quite likeable, but I agree with all of the things you said on why she's one of the least liked characters for me.

I do feel a bit sorry for Iris, she sort of just, left, and without actually achieving anything, or nearing her goal, the previous girls before her, left, but at least they got nearer to their goal, Misty nearly won the Whirl Cup, and then went on to become a gym leader, the next step in her goal, May came eighth (or was it fourth) in a Grand Festival, which is a great achievement, Dawn came second, and only lost by half a point in a Grand Festival, an even greater achievement, but then Iris, she didn't achieve anything like them, she managed to bond with her Dragonite and that was it (she did win a Don George tournament early on in the series, but that I don't think furthers her dreams of becoming a dragon master), and then she just suddenly up and left, without any emotion, it felt like no thought had gone into it either. Of course this could have been fixed if they gave her an appearance in XY, she could have come back, and mentioned that she just got the job as a gym leader, and maybe wanted to show off to Ash and see if he'd grown before heading back and starting her new job, but XY messed that up with lack of continuity.

Actually you've just reminded me of another point I wanted to bring up. Ash has always been the star of the show, no doubt about it. You have the main group of three or four, but Ash is always the star. Then there's the main travelling companion, who is there usually for guidance and cooking (though Clemont changed this) and then there's the girl, who is on the secondary level. By this I mean she's the second most important member of the group - Misty outranked Brock and Tracy in terms of importance, May outranked Brock and Max in terms of importance, but in all cases, Ash outranks both of them (whether you like Misty or May more than Ash or less than Brock, Tracy or Max is irrelevant - this is how the show's dynamic worked.)
Then Dawn came along and this changed. Suddenly the girl was as important as Ash. Dawn's contests, Dawn's rivalries, Dawn's pokemon, Dawn's story overall, it was all given the same amount of attention as Ash. Rarely was Dawn a character who got left behind. Rarely was Dawn a character who was just there. For every major episode focusing on Ash there were almost as many focusing on Dawn and if there was a chance to get them fighting side by side Dawn was usually right there alongside Ash in moments where Misty or May might have stepped back to give Ash the heroic moment.

And then Iris happened and suddenly the show is mostly the Ash show once again while the female lead was dropped back to the secondary role. But to the extent that most of the time she was actually on the same level as Cilan, the tertiary character.

As for that departure, I think it was actually fitting. Iris followed Ash for no reason and just up and left at the end.

And as for the return not happening, it is a little annoying that that tradition got dropped, but what was she going to do? The deal is that new girl beats the old one (ok, Misty and May never battled, but Dawn beat May and Iris beat Dawn (however controversially) and let's face it, Serena was never going to beat Iris ever.
It would have improved Dragonite's track record though.
 
I can't speak for everyone who didn't like Iris as everyone who hates her has their own individual reasons (for example, the "such a little kid" thing did not bother me but it really bothers some people), but here are my reasons for not liking Iris:

1) That comment about how she can't train a Charizard because it's not a dragon type. This is from a girl who owns an Emolga, and whose starter pokemon was a Drilbur (now Excadrill). Now, there had been a lot about Iris that irked me before this, but this moment is, well... I believe the phrase is "The straw the broke the camel's back." This it the moment that finally made me go "That's it, Iris, I'm done. I can't deal with you anymore. I've tried liking you in spite of everything else, but you've just completely ruined it all. If that's how you really feel, give Ash your Excadrill, send Emolga to Bianca (she wanted it more than you anyway) and just get off the screen." - This reaction from me wasn't the only one of its kind that the BW series provoked. Oshawott did it too. I'm not sure of the exact point I gave up on him, but I do remember seeing Ash send it out against Cheren's Herdier and just switching the tv off because I knew Ash's loss as inevitable (checked the internet later and was proved right btw)

2) Dragonite. I bothered me at first that she just up and got one with little effort of her part, but I mostly don't care about that now. What does bug me though is all those times where it clearly wasn't listening to her, but no one did anything. This is especially notable in the Junior Cup thing they all took part in during Dawn's return arc and I will forever love Georgia for pointing out that Iris did not win, only her Dragonite did. Thankfully Ash's Krokorok evolved and put a stop to it because it didn't look like anyone else was going to. But even once it started listening to its trainer, this still wasn't a good thing because it hasn't won a fight since. Then there's the fact that since she caught Dragonite all her other pokemon have been pretty much redundant.

3) Her goal was barely touched on for a very long time. I know people go "Oh, but she can understand the hearts of dragons now" but I say "So what?" as it hasn't really helped her on her way to becoming a dragon master. Look at the situation - yes, her Axew did learn two strong moves, but it never battles anymore and is no nearer to evolving that it was when they debuted in the show, despite it being Axew's dream to do so. And yes, her Dragonite does listen to her now, but ultimately he's worse off for it as he hasn't won anything since. And as I've already said, her other two aren't even dragon types!

4) The loss off what made her stand out in the games. In the first Black and White games, she's Drayden's apprentice and apparently his adopted Granddaughter. The anime completely removes this. In Black 2 and White 2 she has progressed above the level of her mentor and become the champion of the Unova region. Nothing in the anime suggests that such a feat could ever be possible for her.

All in all, I just found Iris painful to try and endure, but she's emblematic of just about the entire BW series. I found watching Cilan painful after about the fifth time his gimmick was used. I found Oshawott painful to watch. And Trip, Cameron, hell, a lot of the time I found Ash to be a pain to watch during the fifth generation anime.

Okay in Iris' defence in of your points... Emolga WANTED to join Iris because Iris saved her life (that's what I kinda remember) and willingly chose Iris over Bianca. It's not like Iris went on and said "I want to train this Emolga" infact the only reason she went on to go after Emolga is because Axew wanted to give her an apple. I guarantee if Emolga wanted to join Iris team and she said "na I don't want you, you aren't a dragon" fans would of lynched her for being "inconsiderate". Also this slightly off topic but Misty had the same goal but carried a Togepi. And as for Excadrill it was established she got him BEFORE she realized her dream of becoming a dragon master and the elder suggested she went on a journey imagine her saying "Excadrill I want to be a dragon master so I have to release you despite all the time we spent".

As for the Drayden thing she kinda is his "apprentice" in a sense because it's established at the end of " Iris versus Drayden past, present and future" that the whole reason he invited Iris to Opelucid city was so that one day she could inherit his gym. Also in the games I don't even think Iris is even native to Unova and just stays and lives with Drayden which wouldn't make sense to anime since she's suppose to be traveling with Ash and SHOWING HIM around.

It's been established how her goal as been touched she's travelled to fight two "dragon masters" Drayden and Claire. Not to mention her being able to calm that Hydreigon when she returned to her village. Also Dragonite not winning doesn't mean it was because he started obeying Iris. The Pokemon he won against on his own was Beartic and Mamoswine by Dawn and Georgia. And the two he's lost against was Druddigon and shiny Druddigon by Clair and Drayden. I'm pretty sure that two dragon masters are stronger than Dawn and Georgia (they're both good trainers but come on). So it wasn't a matter of Dragonite doing better on his own it was him having easier Pokemon to battle
 
I remember thinking that Ash would face Iris in the Opelucid Gym back when BW began. I'm kind of sad that this didn't happen since Iris wasn't a Gym Leader in the cartoon.

I kind of assumed that too, tho it became clearer to me as we saw Iris' team develop that a gym battle between her and Ash wouldn't have worked out well given that her only dragon type for the main Unova journey was Axew and she didn't get Dragonite until after Ash had all eight badges. :[
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top