• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Iris

Status
Not open for further replies.
The best thing about Iris is that damn Excadrill & Dragonite even though she didn't earn it,but I'll give her some credit for raising Excadrill into a good battler.

I dunno why alot of people claim that she didn't 'earn' Dragonite. She caught him fair and square and then had to get him to respect her, which took a while. By contrast Dawn received a Togekiss for free and only had like one episode where she bonded with it, yet she doesn't get criticized much for that.
 
I dunno why alot of people claim that she didn't 'earn' Dragonite. She caught him fair and square and then had to get him to respect her, which took a while. By contrast Dawn received a Togekiss for free and only had like one episode where she bonded with it, yet she doesn't get criticized much for that.

I think most people would have preferred to see her train a Dratini or Dragonair up since none of her Pokemon evolved over the course of the series.
 
I think most people would have preferred to see her train a Dratini or Dragonair up since none of her Pokemon evolved over the course of the series.

I kinda would of preferred Dawn raise that Togepi from that filler episode of DP (the one where they're sent to space) instead of just getting a Togekiss to fight Gallade in the battle with Zoey. Because let's be honest that was her only useful purpose.
 
I kinda would of preferred Dawn raise that Togepi from that filler episode of DP (the one where they're sent to space) instead of just getting a Togekiss to fight Gallade in the battle with Zoey. Because let's be honest that was her only useful purpose.

In a perfect world we would've seen this, though the fact that Iris was almost lynched by fans for daring to catch a Dragonite is still a sad double standard since if Ash had done it, no one would've whined. :/
 
In a perfect world we would've seen this, though the fact that Iris was almost lynched by fans for daring to catch a Dragonite is still a sad double standard since if Ash had done it, no one would've whined. :/

It's sad really, people find any excuse to hate this character based of a loosely used (at least in the original) catchphrase. Never mind that it was called out about 4 to 5 different occasions about Iris' Dragonite's strength it not being her own and how he won the battles simply by himself. Also how it took several episodes for Iris to prove herself as a trainer to him and bond with him... NOPE people only see "Omg she got a pseudo legendary before Ash she's such a Mary Sue!!!!) only to ignore the TRUE Mary Sue would be introduced in the next gen.
 
So people got triggered by the truth. Huh.

Tbh the monthly "Iris sucks!" threads always go in circles, so I don't know what more can be said about her. People seem to hate her on principle.

In that case people shouldn't hate Iris. They should hate the writers
 
No man Luke had her on the ropes, this is almost equivalent to a pokemon evolving in the middle of a battle when they are getting their sh*t pushed in and are about to lose.Plus Axew has little to no battle experience and was never comfortable in battling situations,but if you disagree with any of this more power to you.

Reminder outrage was never used again after its debut battle
 
It's sad really, people find any excuse to hate this character based of a loosely used (at least in the original) catchphrase. Never mind that it was called out about 4 to 5 different occasions about Iris' Dragonite's strength it not being her own and how he won the battles simply by himself. Also how it took several episodes for Iris to prove herself as a trainer to him and bond with him... NOPE people only see "Omg she got a pseudo legendary before Ash she's such a Mary Sue!!!!) only to ignore the TRUE Mary Sue would be introduced in the next gen.

True, Iris at least deconstructed the show's usual plot armour. She got a powerhouse easily, but it came with repercussions. She had to prove she was competent enough to use it properly, which is more than can be said for many other trainers who caught or evolved their 'mon into powerhouses with barely any effort on their part at all.

Iris still had SOME moments of plot armour, but at least there was balance, there was times she had to handle things by herself and prove she was a skilled trainer. I actually kinda felt sorry for her given how dysfunctional her team were. Add to that her more action fit character and facing dilemmas like a much more formidable Team Rocket on many occasions, I'd say Iris worked and earned her mantle plenty. And even besides that, was at least made to look like a pompous fool many times she hadn't.
 
True, Iris at least deconstructed the show's usual plot armour. She got a powerhouse easily, but it came with repercussions. She had to prove she was competent enough to use it properly, which is more than can be said for many other trainers who caught or evolved their 'mon into powerhouses with barely any effort on their part at all.

Iris still had SOME moments of plot armour, but at least there was balance, there was times she had to handle things by herself and prove she was a skilled trainer. I actually kinda felt sorry for her given how dysfunctional her team were. Add to that her more action fit character and facing dilemmas like a much more formidable Team Rocket on many occasions, I'd say Iris worked and earned her mantle plenty. And even besides that, was at least made to look like a pompous fool many times she hadn't.
The saddest part is, people either don't care or outright pretend it doesn't happen.

They decide to make her catchphrase 'you're such a kid' the core of their argument and then build everything around that, whatever is more degrading and insults the character.
 
The only thing that bothered me about Iris catching Dragonite was that, well, they gave her a Dragonite when a (more interesting) Gen V dragon like Zweilous or Hydreigon, who are known to migrate and have a general reputation for violence and destruction, would have worked just as well.

She still probably would have gotten complaints for not "earning it", but at least it would've felt a little less random than a powerful, trainer-less Dragonite showing up out of nowhere.
 
Last edited:
Eh, I don't know about Iris being "the most hated poké-girl". From what I've seen, every poké-girl after May seems to get their fair share of (often irrational) fan-hate.

Have you guys seen all the hatred for Dawn back in the day? The amount of salt was incredible. Honestly, step out of SPPF, dig out those posts from 2010-2012 and feast your eyes on the monthly bash-fests where people hate on her for "caring way too much about her hair", for "wearing a skimpy skirt" (calling her a sl*t in the process), for "being such a dumb, girly crybaby" and other ridiculous, petty "reasons". And then you have my absolute favorite -- there were actually people hating on her purely because she got a Togekiss. And it wasn't because she received the thing on a silver platter or anything; oh no -- it's because "Misty was the one who deserved it, not her!!1". Now that's pure gold right there.

And then you have Serena. Apparently, she has to have a taste of the fandom's bitterness too. Just type in "top ten worst Pokemon characters" and you'll see what I'm talking about. You might wanna bring some fries to go along with the salt there, too.

As for May, well, I wasn't around the Internet back when AG was airing/transitioning to DP, so who knows? She might've been hated as well. And she may very well have been considering the fact that she's Misty's "replacement".

I'm convinced that people are just bitter in general. So really, hang in there, Iris/BW fans. Maybe, just maybe, a new series would emerge one day as the new scapegoat for people to dump all of their bitterness on.
 
Last edited:
Eh, I don't know about Iris being "the most hated poké-girl". From what I've seen, every poké-girl after May seems to get their fair share of (often irrational) fan-hate.

Have you guys seen all the hatred for Dawn back in the day? The amount of salt was incredible. Honestly, step out of SPPF, dig out those posts from 2010-2012 and feast your eyes on the monthly bash-fests where people hate on her for "caring way too much about her hair", for "wearing a skimpy skirt" (calling her a sl*t in the process), for "being such a dumb, girly crybaby" and other ridiculous, petty "reasons". And then you have my absolute favorite -- there were actually people hating on her purely because she got a Togekiss. And it wasn't because she received the thing on a silver platter or anything; oh no -- it's because "Misty was the one who deserved it, not her!!1". Now that's pure gold right there.

And then you have Serena. Apparently, she has to have a taste of the fandom's bitterness too. Just type in "top ten worst Pokemon characters" and you'll see what I'm talking about. You might wanna bring some fries to go along with the salt there, too.

As for May, well, I wasn't around the Internet back when AG was airing/transitioning to DP, so who knows? She might've been hated as well. And she may very well have been considering the fact that she's Misty's "replacement".

I'm convinced that people are just bitter in general. So really, hang in there, Iris/BW fans. Maybe, just maybe, a new series would emerge one day as the new scapegoat for people to dump all of their bitterness on.
The problem is that all the hatred for the other Pokegirls eventually evaporated or lessened significantly.

It has been years since BW ended and people still hate on Iris like the series aired yesterday.
 
Eh, I don't know about Iris being "the most hated poké-girl". From what I've seen, every poké-girl after May seems to get their fair share of (often irrational) fan-hate.

After May, you say? I didn't like May when she first came on mostly because i thought the original trio would be together for the whole run of the show. In any case, my hatred soon shifted to Max and hasn't really lifted. Iris had the unfortunate timing of debuting in somewhat of a dork age, where they tried but failed to emulate OS, and the fact that the others have nostalgia (and in Dawn's case, shipping goggles) (technically this applies to the other two as well but I believe Pearl had the strongest following until XY aired) on their side certainly doesn't help.
 
I wish that Axew fully evolved. If they wanted a cute head pet, they could've easily given her Deino
 
i thought may got an insane amount of hate at first because she replaced misty and everyone thought misty would be permanent. and then iris and cilan both got hate because people were still sad about dawn leaving and nobody thought they would replace brock (another character people thought would be permanent given his presence in 4 regions).

makes you wonder what the fan response would be if they actually replaced ash someday.
 
I feel like they could have at least played more on Axew's skills and desire to evolve rather than just keeping him a supposed undeveloped baby. Like, maybe after being around Pikachu (and so many other BW Pokemon, as well as Piplup) maybe he started to feel more comfortable as he was and realised he could still get good skills out of his Axew form.
 
Last edited:
Personally, I prefer Iris a lot to Dawn and Serena, because Iris was a very different female character than anyone who followed Ash, and everyone forgets that it was a very positive point.

And also, one feels that she had an enormous potential scenario, but like all the good bridges that could have made Best Wishes the best series, it was ridiculed.

This is really what Iris misses, a good evolution. Well, unlike Serena, at least with Iris, I was not bored.
 
Last edited:
Those did have interesting adventures of their own, Serena was more simplistic... But the newer characters could also have quite active plots, based on the games! We'll have to see...
 
Serena has a good evolution, because she's simple, like May. There is no severe regression like Dawn, there one can say "It will come out on its own". But let's say that the problem comes from the fans who see something exceptional while... No... It has a very simple evolution.

I really feel that if people love Serena, it is because they hated Iris... But on this account, we can go further, if the fans hated Iris, it is because they loved Dawn, because they hated May, because they loved Misty... Meh...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top