• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Morality

Status
Not open for further replies.

The_Panda

恭喜發財
Remake of Babylon's "Let's talk Morals" thread, approved by Eszett.

This came up in a thread earlier, and since this is an off the cuff idea, I'm not bothering to make a whole introduction on it.

Here's the question: What is right, what is wrong, and more importantly, can we make judgements on this?
 
Thanks for ruining our fun.
 
^someone needs a warm glass of milk :(
 
Yeah let's all spam instead of debate, and earn us some awesome infractions.

I'm lazy but I'll start off.

----------------

Morality is a human construct. It came about when people stuck together in groups. People who had morals and shared, didn't kill or steal from one another, and treated each other with compassion stuck together as a group, whereas the ones who lacked morals died, as humans are a social species and cannot survive on their own very well, especially lacking modern knowledge or technology. Thus, a general 'need' for a moral code evolved through natural selection.

Since this is the case, morality is certainly not an absolute, concrete thing. Morals have always been different in every society since the beginnings of humanity. Since people invented morals, people decide what they are, and every society comes to a different conclusion on what is right and what is wrong based on the views, knowledge, and needs of the society. Who can say which morals are correct? In our society today, it is considered immoral to cut up goats for no reason. But in times past, people sacrificed goats to appease different gods that they believed existed and that we don't believe in anymore. To them, NOT sacrificing a goat was immoral and would lead to incurring divine wrath. To us their beliefs are just superstitions.

Morals are not concrete or absolute, they are simply a human construct. They change with the needs and perceptions of a society.
 
I'm lazy but I'll start off.
And I'll attempt to refute.

First of all, yes morals are a man made thing, designed to alleviate pressures in society. I think we can all agree on that. However, morals are all losely based on the concepts of right and wrong, good or bad. These are not man made concepts. They exist in mind because they exist as abstract forms. When a dog is kicked it feels pain and knows this pain is bad, it did not create this badness to help it within society. The badness has always existed.

So morals therefore may not seem to be absolute, but they are based on absolute concepts of good and bad. This is, I postulate, the reason why seperate societies have shared a lot of common moral ground throughout history despite a lack of communication, because all humans will have some rudimentary knowledge of these abstract forms.
 
I agree with PsiUmbreon

*Throws a spanner in the works* Tim, what if the dog in question is a masochist??

The similarities between the fundamental morality of different groups can be explained by convergent evolution. I will avoid using the terms "good" and bad", because they are decidedly ambiguous. Simply, peoples living under similar conditions discovered that certain behaviour (morals) was simultaneously advantageous for personal gain and social gain; e.g. not killing each other. Natural selection would have weeded out communities where morals were significantly less than optimal; e.g. they would have killed each other.

Morality is very much a human construct.
 
I find one of the most interesting aspects of morality is how we can apply it to make judgements in debates - whether something is right or wrong (this comes up quite a bit, usually resulting in Babylon bashing relativism). The problem with morality is that unlike other things as premises for moral arguments, it's more than difficult to try get the agreement of the other side to use it as a premise. Granted, things like murder is wrong are always assumed; but other statements, like an eye for an eye tooth for a tooth often attract great disagreement not just amongst debaters but also the general population. This is where I think the standard a posteriori argument for moral absolutism starts to fail; where morality is taken up a further level from "is murder wrong" to much more complex thoughts like "if we know somebody holds vital information to a terrorist attack should he be tortured" and disagreements within the population become extremely apparent - thus rendering a judgement of the absolute value of such a statement almost impossible by the aforementioned means.

I don't want so much this thread to turn into a theoretical thread on morality as much as I want a debate on how we can apply morality to our lives and how can we make judgements. While both aspects are good for discussion past threads have generally featured a perceived lack of the latter; a change from the trend would be nice (and such debates aren't always completely cyclical).
 
And I'll attempt to refute.

First of all, yes morals are a man made thing, designed to alleviate pressures in society. I think we can all agree on that. However, morals are all losely based on the concepts of right and wrong, good or bad. These are not man made concepts. They exist in mind because they exist as abstract forms. When a dog is kicked it feels pain and knows this pain is bad, it did not create this badness to help it within society. The badness has always existed.

So morals therefore may not seem to be absolute, but they are based on absolute concepts of good and bad. This is, I postulate, the reason why seperate societies have shared a lot of common moral ground throughout history despite a lack of communication, because all humans will have some rudimentary knowledge of these abstract forms.
Actually, yes they are man-made concepts. Is it at all bad when a bear catches a salmon from the water instead of eating berries? Does the salmon not feel pain as it is consumed? How about when the father rat cannibalizes his own children? Or when one male cat claws the face of another to keep the other male from intruding on his territory?

How about when a group of humans tortures another human for not being the same religion, race, or sexual preference? How about when humans attach explosives to themselves to deliberately cause harm to other people, not caring about their own fate? What about when one subgroup of the human race deliberately tries to wipe another subgroup of humanity from existence?

If absolute concepts of good and bad are not evident throughout nature, much less throughout humanity, then tell me, where are these absolute concepts of good and bad? Where do they come from? In every counterexample there is a situation where one group perceives an action as "good" and another one perceives the very same action as "bad".
 
Morality is a human construct. It came about when people stuck together in groups. People who had morals and shared, didn't kill or steal from one another, and treated each other with compassion stuck together as a group, whereas the ones who lacked morals died, as humans are a social species and cannot survive on their own very well, especially lacking modern knowledge or technology. Thus, a general 'need' for a moral code evolved through natural selection.

Heh, i was going to say the same sort of thing :D

I think that "morality" is doing something that doesn't upset another person - such as stealing etc, yet being upset over that is the human mind at work again, as the mind "loves" it (to an extent) and it literally mourns for its loss, but what if we evolved differently, and morality was stealing from people, and then that made them happy knowing that they had something that was worthwhile to steal etc... Then, morality would be a completely different thing in the human mind.

So technically speaking, morality does not exist - its just sadness and the thought of not making someone sad/whatever.

Anyone understand me? XD
 
In every counterexample there is a situation where one group perceives an action as "good" and another one perceives the very same action as "bad".
So? For every person who gets an answer in a test right there are those who get it wrong.

Is it at all bad when a bear catches a salmon from the water instead of eating berries?
I don't know, possibly.

How about when a group of humans tortures another human for not being the same religion, race, or sexual preference? How about when humans attach explosives to themselves to deliberately cause harm to other people, not caring about their own fate? What about when one subgroup of the human race deliberately tries to wipe another subgroup of humanity from existence?
What about them? Just because some people do things does not make their actions right.

I've already posted this in anther topic, buy here you go.

Add in goodness for the abstract and you're off.

Premise 1: Some things are more (insert abstract concept here) than others.

Premise 2: Therefore (insert abstract concept here) exists or nothing would be more of it than something else.

Premise 3: If such is true then that means that there is something more (insert abstract concept here) than everything that I know of because I know of nothing that is fully (insert abstract concept here)

Premise 4: There cannot be an infinite amount of things which are more (insert abstract concept here) than everything else, neither can there be an infinite amount of things that are less (insert abstract concept here) than anything else because that would mean there must be an infinite amount of things in the universe which is not possible in a finite universe.

Premise 5: Therefore there must be an absolute form of (insert abstract concept here), that being the thing which is more (insert abstract concept here) than everything else.

Premise 6: This form of (insert abstract concept here) must be universal because it is (insert abstract concept here) and that is a necesary truth like "black is black" or "a chair is a chair" so (insert abstract concept here) is (insert abstract concept here)

Premise 7: If we have an absolute of (insert abstract concept here) then we know what (insert abstract concept here) "looks like".

Premise 8: All things that "look" more like (insert abstract concept here) than others are more like (insert abstract concept here) than others.

Premise 9: Since we know what (insert abstract concept here) "looks like" we know how like (insert abstract concept here) these things that are less of (insert abstract concept here) are.

Conclusion: All things relating to (insert abstract concept here) are calculable in their relationship with (insert abstract concept here)
 
how do you know premise 4 100%?
 
So? For every person who gets an answer in a test right there are those who get it wrong.
Find me the answers to the test on morality and then we can talk about who is "right" and who is "wrong". If such a thing even exists, I'd expect you to prove it!

What about them? Just because some people do things does not make their actions right.

I've already posted this in anther topic, buy here you go.

Add in goodness for the abstract and you're off.

Premise 1: Some things are more (insert abstract concept here) than others.

Premise 2: Therefore (insert abstract concept here) exists or nothing would be more of it than something else.

Premise 3: If such is true then that means that there is something more (insert abstract concept here) than everything that I know of because I know of nothing that is fully (insert abstract concept here)

Premise 4: There cannot be an infinite amount of things which are more (insert abstract concept here) than everything else, neither can there be an infinite amount of things that are less (insert abstract concept here) than anything else because that would mean there must be an infinite amount of things in the universe which is not possible in a finite universe.

Premise 5: Therefore there must be an absolute form of (insert abstract concept here), that being the thing which is more (insert abstract concept here) than everything else.

Premise 6: This form of (insert abstract concept here) must be universal because it is (insert abstract concept here) and that is a necesary truth like "black is black" or "a chair is a chair" so (insert abstract concept here) is (insert abstract concept here)

Premise 7: If we have an absolute of (insert abstract concept here) then we know what (insert abstract concept here) "looks like".

Premise 8: All things that "look" more like (insert abstract concept here) than others are more like (insert abstract concept here) than others.

Premise 9: Since we know what (insert abstract concept here) "looks like" we know how like (insert abstract concept here) these things that are less of (insert abstract concept here) are.

Conclusion: All things relating to (insert abstract concept here) are calculable in their relationship with (insert abstract concept here)

Your logic falters in several places. Replying is a matter of hitting the cracks until the argument falls apart.

On premise 3, isn't it possible that you know of the most (insert abstract concept here) in the universe, but you don't know that said thing is the most (insert abstract concept here)?

On premise 4 and 5, can you rule out the possibility that there is something that is as (insert abstract concept here) as something else? Do you truly expect me to believe that everything in the universe can be ranked neatly in terms of how much or how little of an abstract concept it represents? What if there's a tie as to how much of (abstract concept here) there is between two, or possibly more, objects?

Which reminds me. Is this more of a chair than this? What about this? On a scale of one to chair, how do you rank this one?

Take note of the chairs and how they are all different. Yet can you say any one of them is less of a chair than another one? So it is with any other more abstract concept. Can you say that I love my girlfriend any more than you love yours, if you have one? Can you tell me which work of art is the best in the world and why? Can you tell me which band produces the best music in the world? Can you tell me which place in the world is the most tranquil? Well, can you? Better yet, tell me the top 5 most tranquil places in the world in order. Can't do it can you?
 
So? For every person who gets an answer in a test right there are those who get it wrong.
What color does that tree look to you? A matter of opinion can't be wrong. I see Dragonite as an orange color, but in the pokedex he's labeled brown.

I've already posted this in anther topic, buy here you go.

Add in goodness for the abstract and you're off.

Premise 1: Some things are more (insert abstract concept here) than others.

Premise 2: Therefore (insert abstract concept here) exists or nothing would be more of it than something else.

Premise 3: If such is true then that means that there is something more (insert abstract concept here) than everything that I know of because I know of nothing that is fully (insert abstract concept here)

Premise 4: There cannot be an infinite amount of things which are more (insert abstract concept here) than everything else, neither can there be an infinite amount of things that are less (insert abstract concept here) than anything else because that would mean there must be an infinite amount of things in the universe which is not possible in a finite universe.

Premise 5: Therefore there must be an absolute form of (insert abstract concept here), that being the thing which is more (insert abstract concept here) than everything else.

Premise 6: This form of (insert abstract concept here) must be universal because it is (insert abstract concept here) and that is a necesary truth like "black is black" or "a chair is a chair" so (insert abstract concept here) is (insert abstract concept here)

Premise 7: If we have an absolute of (insert abstract concept here) then we know what (insert abstract concept here) "looks like".

Premise 8: All things that "look" more like (insert abstract concept here) than others are more like (insert abstract concept here) than others.

Premise 9: Since we know what (insert abstract concept here) "looks like" we know how like (insert abstract concept here) these things that are less of (insert abstract concept here) are.

Conclusion: All things relating to (insert abstract concept here) are calculable in their relationship with (insert abstract concept here)

Premise 1: Matters of opinion can NOT be wrong.

Premise 2: People have very different morals

Premise 3: People have very different opinions

Premise 4: Opinions can be influenced by culture, friends, etc.

Premise 5: People with TOTALLY different opinions and morals grew up in different enviroments.

Premise 6: Different enviroments cause different influences.

Premise 7: Influences shape opinion and morals

Conclusion: Morals are opinionated, and as such, can not be wrong.
 
Morality is an ever changing thing that goes with the times rather then a person or persons. Take the discrimination of gays. In medieval times up until now gays have been murdered for simply loving someone of the same sex. That being sad, civilization as a whole though homosexuality was a "Bad" way of life. Now in the new millenium, people are almost forced to respect people for who they are because now if you don't go by that everyone love each other mind set you can get yelled at by almost anyone or even taken into custody for a hate crime. Morals aren't absolute, they change with a popular standard overtime. The ones who don't share that popular standard are shunned.
 
My goodness. I typed so much up from the last thread, I'll be making a few quotes. I will reiterate my main argument. I believe that there are moral relativists and that there are moral absolutes. An example of relativist morals would be whether you think stealing to burn CD's. An example of an absolute moral would a situation say, your family was brutally murdered and raped and the person that did it, did it for fun. You will not find a soul on this planet that agrees that murdering and raping ones family is good. Perhaps a few satists but then why should we give them the BOTD when they don't even argue for what they think is moral in the first place? If morals are a human construct, and every person agrees on whether a certian moral is good or bad, then that particular moral is objective. Period. Panda, if you want to bring up hypothetical cases again, you may do that.

Second I will point out that simply because there are humans that disagree with certian morals, that doesn't mean that the morals in question are not absolute. It merely casts doubt on whether they are or not. By the very definition of objective, it is true regardless of another persons opinion. So you are dead wrong in saying ____ moral is absolute because ____ people in _____ country disagree. That's hardly an argument for moral relativism.


I will be coming later to quote myself from the previous thread.
 
Last edited:
appeal to majority.
 
appeal to majority.

I believe that you went full circle with me over in the last thread and you eventually dropped your case. Again in all politeness, this only proves that you are unable to respond to my posts in a proper manner or make a constructive argument and you do not deserve to be dealt with by me on this matter anymore.
 
all i have to do is tell you the fallacy. its not rocket science. accept that your argument is fallacious because youre just appealing to the majority of the people.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top