• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

The Burqa

Strict modesty is. The burqa provides covering that fulfills those strict codes of modesty. I don't see what's so hard for you to understand about this...

I understand the reasons for it, it's just the ridiculous reasoning that's the problem. Whilst the burqa is also not explicitly mentioned, ergo it is not part of teachings.
 
Last edited:
your opinion on the merits of a religious system that you don't even come close to understanding means little in this debate

The burqa is not mentioned by letter in Islamic texts, but as I so plainly pointed out strict modesty is. The burqa is their obvious solution to the plain madate of their scripture. It is part of their teachings.

Wait...are you really trying to say that the burqa is not a part of conservative Islamic teachings? That its not mentioned anywhere by Muslims of all stripes, whether agreed upon or not? Where are you getting this nonsense from?
 
Last edited:
your opinion on the merits of a religious system that you don't even come close to understanding means little in this debate

sorry Sheikh Mattj I didn't realise Allah had blessed you with great knowledge of Islam. I understand fine thanks, and I'm really not a fan of being lectured by bible literalists. It's the equivalent of a beggar telling a ceo how to get a job.

The burqa is not mentioned by letter in Islamic texts, but as I so plainly pointed out strict modesty is. The burqa is their obvious solution to the plain madate of their scripture.

OMG how many ****ing times. I understand the reason for it, but the reasoning is faulty because it is patriarchal and sexist.

Also, again, the passage in question does nothing to state that a Burqa like piece of clothing is necessary. it also makes the incredibly sexist argument of placing a woman's beauty in exclusively physical terms.
 
You can disagree with their beliefs all you want. No one cares. But to say that the burqa isn't a part of Islamic teachings is completely false. While it is not mentioned by letter its function plainly is. It is no stretch of the imagination to understand that when the Prophet said
Tell your wives and your daughters and the women of the believers to draw their cloaks (and/or veils) over their bodies.
Not "over their hair". Not "over their arms". Not "over their legs". It says "over their bodies". A burqa would be the modern article of clothing to do that job.
The burqa is not explicitly mentioned, ergo it is not part of teachings.
Why would you claim that the Englicized word "burqa" would have to literally be found letter for letter in the Arabic Koran in order for it to be a part of their modern teachings? This makes no sense. The mandate for modesty comes from their texts, word for word. They talk about burqas in one fashion or another all the time. Some teach that its necessary, some teach that its not, but they do teach about it.
 
Last edited:
You can disagree with their beliefs all you want. No one cares. But to say that the burqa isn't a part of Islamic teachings is completely false.

Um not it's not. Modesty and the Burqa are two separate things.

While it is not mentioned by letter its function plainly is.

What is "the body". We often refer to the body as only being the torso. I rarely refer to the head as my body.

It is no stretch of the imagination to understand that when the Prophet said A burqa would be the modern article of clothing to do that job.

Equally it is no stretch of the imagination to believe that he meant a baggy jumper and a demure ponytail would suffice. This is a pointless and irrelevant argument.

Why would you claim that the Englicized word "burqa" would have to literally be found letter for letter in the Arabic Koran in order for it to be a part of their modern teachings?

**** me you're barrel scraping now. Sorry I haven't taken the time to learn Arabic everyone, however what i can realise is that there are no specific clothing requirements in the Koran regarding full coverage of one's entire person. Even when you try and be pedantic you fail. I am of course not seeking the exact Arabic example of an Anglicised word, but I am looking for specifics, of which there are none re. a Burqa like piece of clothing

This makes no sense. They talk about it all the time. Some teach that its necessary, some teach that its not, but they do teach about it.

They don't talk about it all the time.

Though not from any explicit or specific teachings about what exactly should be worn. Unlike say the stoning of children in the Bible.

Honestly, your attempts at nit-picking are a waste of time. You aren't making any worthwhile points and are clearly unable to understand mine.
 
Last edited:
Sorry I haven't taken the time to learn Arabic everyone,

So maybe you shouldn't be in the Debate forum about a topic you clearly know little about?

One of my favorite religious studies teachers in college was an atheist and grew up in white suburbia. She was able to embrace and study other cultures and their religions in many parts of the US and abroad. In some very poor and crappy parts of the world, and very rich, and very isolated, and everything in between.

Just because you're an atheist doesn't prevent you from learning about religion. You don't get a "get out of jail" free card in a discussion just because you don't personally follow a religion or a culture. If you don't know shi*t about the topic, then don't be surprised when someone challenges the validity of your logic in a debate.

Just because something is not literally mentioned in a text doesn't mean anything. It's been developed as a religious garment over the approximately 1500 years Islam has been a religion. It has a clear evidence of how traditional Islamic women express their modesty. The debate isn't if you, snorunt conservationist personally approve, because no one cares. The debate is do you understand the historical and cultural facts surrounding the burqa?
 
Last edited:
In the same way that the bible condones child abuse, the Hadith condones murdering apostates. There is no debate to be had here. Mainstream monotheistic teachings are violent.
I just want to start by saying that I'm glad you don't condemn Christianity while ignoring or glossing over wrongs done by Muslims. Your view has the benefit of being balanced. However, your final sentence there is the fallacy of selective attention writ large. You don't agree with my view of Christianity? Fine. I won't worry about my belief system at the moment. But even though I hold a more generally negative view of Islam than some, it simply isn't true that Islam as a whole is violent.

It's part of how people raise children. Always has been.
I agree, and, I might add, it probably always will be.

They are sheets with holes.
i.e.

a burqa
This thread is making me LOL.




On a slightly different note, I'd just like to point out that bigotry against Muslims is stereotyped as racism waaaaaaay too often. A certain Hadith even speaks of Muhammad as being very light skinned. He was Mediterranean Caucasian. Plenty of Muslims are black, but plenty of others are (approximately) white. Laws that restrict Muslims may be bigoted with no reference to race per se. I believe some in this thread are forgetting that.



Now regarding the main topic, I don't feel afraid when I see people with certain well-covering garments in most public locations. I think there are probably some security risks in certain locations like banks and stuff. For banks to require you not wear anything like that should be no problem (I hear many of them already ban sunglasses). Obviously, no one should expect to be able to wear a garment that obscures much of the face when getting a driver's license--though I've heard that a few have tried to file lawsuits against this perfectly reasonable restriction!
 
Um not it's not. Modesty and the Burqa are two separate things.
The purpose of the burqa is to fulfil the Koran's standard of modesty.
What is "the body". We often refer to the body as only being the torso. I rarely refer to the head as my body.
Exactly. The command clearly says to cover the body. The burqa covers the body. It does not say to simply cover their hair, or arms, or legs. It says to cover their entire body. The reason these people wear burqas is because of what their religious text says.
Equally it is no stretch of the imagination to believe that he meant a baggy jumper and a demure ponytail would suffice. This is a pointless and irrelevant argument.
That could very well be an accurate interpretation. But it is not the interpretation that many Muslims take. Considering that you don't care to bother yourself with learning much, if anything, about their religion, I'd take their interpretation over yours.
**** me you're barrel scraping now. Sorry I haven't taken the time to learn Arabic everyone, however what i can realise is that there are no specific clothing requirements in the Koran regarding full coverage of one's entire person. Even when you try and be pedantic you fail. I am of course not seeking the exact Arabic example of an Anglicised word, but I am looking for specifics, of which there are none re. a Burqa like piece of clothing
Are you seriously claiming that a "cloak" is not a "burqa like piece of clothing"? What is there to not understand? The modern Conservative Muslim use of burqas comes from the plain Koranic commands concerning modesty. It is a common teaching now and has been for over a thousand years. You were clearly mistaken.
They don't talk about it all the time.
you can't be serious
Once again you find yourself on the wrong side of reality.
Though not from any explicit or specific teachings about what exactly should be worn. Unlike say the stoning of children in the Bible.
It looks explicit enough to me and the millions of Conservative Muslims around the world. You not getting it =/= it not being based in their religious text.
Honestly, your attempts at nit-picking are a waste of time. You aren't making any worthwhile points and are clearly unable to understand mine.
I could report you for taking a personal stab at me, but I'm too cool for that, so I'm just going to publicly call you out on it.
 
Last edited:
If they really care about following Islam they should go back to their countries and join a closed conservative community. Democracy and strict religious observances are only compatible when there is a separation. Now we have muslims asking for Sharria's law because it just another afront from them wanting to subdue everyone's else secular way of culture to their supremacist ideals based on their identity as muslims, not merely out of piety for their religion.
 
If they really care about following Islam they should go back to their countries and join a closed conservative community. Democracy and strict religious observances are only compatible when there is a separation. Now we have muslims asking for Sharria's law because it just another afront from them wanting to subdue everyone's else secular way of culture to their supremacist ideals based on their identity as muslims, not merely out of piety for their religion.
That's not really what this debate is about. While it may be true that a considerable number of Muslims want others to live under their rules, not all of them do this. I agree with you hat Sharia law is not compatible with the Constitution. Yet none of this is any reason for them to leave.
 
If they really care about following Islam they should go back to their countries and join a closed conservative community. Democracy and strict religious observances are only compatible when there is a separation. Now we have muslims asking for Sharria's law because it just another afront from them wanting to subdue everyone's else secular way of culture to their supremacist ideals based on their identity as muslims, not merely out of piety for their religion.
That's a rather closed-minded way of thinking...

One of the pillars of modern western society is that it's a plural society; two people in a country can have radical differences but still coexist without killing each other. Banning religious clothing only removes thousands of years of progress. And allowing people to wear a Burqa is in no way instituting Sharia law; that's just discrimination and fear-mongering.
 
That's a rather closed-minded way of thinking...

One of the pillars of modern western society is that it's a plural society; two people in a country can have radical differences but still coexist without killing each other. Banning religious clothing only removes thousands of years of progress. And allowing people to wear a Burqa is in no way instituting Sharia law; that's just discrimination and fear-mongering.

What you are saying is, we have to be the suckers to bend down for others. A society might not want something like a burqa for several reasons and occasions. Banning it completely like it was a swastika is dumb too. So there can be a middle ground. However, when you go to an islamic country they could care less about your customs, you have to follow theirs otherwise you are committing a crime. Then some of those people carry that same kind of mentality to other more "open" countries, and feel that their way is correct. Nobody is really going to their countries trying to legislate things to them.
Some of these people say that honor killings are "honorable", but following the customs in their host country is a "grave sin" sounds like nauseous bs.
 
If they really care about following Islam they should go back to their countries and join a closed conservative community. Democracy and strict religious observances are only compatible when there is a separation. Now we have muslims asking for Sharria's law because it just another afront from them wanting to subdue everyone's else secular way of culture to their supremacist ideals based on their identity as muslims, not merely out of piety for their religion.

what does this have to do with this thread
 
What you are saying is, we have to be the suckers to bend down for others. A society might not want something like a burqa for several reasons and occasions. Banning it completely like it was a swastika is dumb too. So there can be a middle ground.
What I'm saying is that we have seperation of Church and State and Freedom of Speech and Religion. It doesn't matter if it's a Burqa, a Habit, or a Kasaya. We have respect for people of other walks of life. This is middle ground.

However, when you go to an islamic country they could care less about your customs, you have to follow theirs otherwise you are committing a crime. Then some of those people carry that same kind of mentality to other more "open" countries, and feel that their way is correct. Nobody is really going to their countries trying to legislate things to them.
Some of these people say that honor killings are "honorable", but following the customs in their host country is a "grave sin" sounds like nauseous bs.
a) If you really have a problem with the laws of one country, don't go there. The world does not revolve around Tisub.
b) How can you expect another country to be accepting of your culture if you can't accept theirs? Once again the world does not revolve around Tisub.
c) You're also assuming Western Muslims have no appreciation for Western cultures.
 
"They aren't oppressed as long as they don't believe they are" is basically what you just said. Which is pretty stupid, tbh.

It's not stupid. You can't liberate someone against their own will, or it ceases to be liberation. Their definition of their liberation depends on what they believe and hence want.
 
a) If you really have a problem with the laws of one country, don't go there. The world does not revolve around Tisub.

Tell that to those who feel so offended about the restriction on a burqa.

b) How can you expect another country to be accepting of your culture if you can't accept theirs? Once again the world does not revolve around Tisub.

There will never be total acceptance in anything, only a way to compromise.
 
If they really care about following Islam they should go back to their countries

"Their countries"

And a second or third or fourth generation family of Muslims residing in America should go where?

and join a closed conservative community.

There's a long tradition of traditional religious sects residing within, or on the boundaries of, modern society. Hell, some American colonies were established so that their "odd" sect of Christianity would be accepted there. There's a good chunk of Hasidic Jews within parts of New York City. There's the Amish and Menonites.

Democracy and strict religious observances are only compatible when there is a separation.

Okay...


Now we have muslims asking for Sharria's law

[citation needed]

because it just another afront from them wanting to subdue everyone's else secular way of culture to their supremacist ideals based on their identity as muslims, not merely out of piety for their religion.

This might shock you, but ALL RELIGIONS HAVE A BOOK OF LAWS!

But for some reason, I don't see the fear-stroking about the Catechism that I see about Sharia.

As to "BUT BUT BUT IN THEIR MOSLEM COUNTRIES", that's because their countries are both dictatorships and theocracies. The US is not.

EDIT: I can't believe mattj is the Voice of Reason in this thread.
 
Last edited:
This might shock you, but ALL RELIGIONS HAVE A BOOK OF LAWS!

But for some reason, I don't see the fear-stroking about the Catechism that I see about Sharia.

As to "BUT BUT BUT IN THEIR MOSLEM COUNTRIES", that's because their countries are both dictatorships and theocracies. The US is not.
In fairness, it may also have something to do with the prevalence of the political element in Islam compared with many other religions.
 
In fairness, it may also have something to do with the prevalence of the political element in Islam compared with many other religions.

No, I'm pretty certain that when Christianity was the official religion of countries, they did stuff like persecute non-Christians and stone them and feed them to lions and all kinds of evil crap. This supposed "political element of Islam" hasn't affected much of the west. Hell, there's a lot more of the "political element" in the US politics and Christianity than any other religion.

And before someone goes "But that happened hundreds of years ago!" in regards to past Christian empires abusing non-believers, that's true. And for all intents and purposes, much of the middle east is still stuck in a mindset as if still was the 1500s, if not earlier, due to the systematic repression of...well, a lot, due to the dictators that run those countries.
 
Back
Top