• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

The Burqa

Pulling a card from the Stephen Cobert/Jonathan Swift playbook...

Habits:

The Security Risk they Pose and How they are a Catholic Plot to Rule the World

With Pics to Prove it​

For those of you not familiar with Catholicism, many Religious orders force their members to wear a habit as a symbol of their membership to the order and commitment to an alternative lifestyle of religious devotion. It consists of a large tunic and a hood for men or a veil for women, This covers almost as much of one's body as a Burqa. All you can see is their face and their hands. Why are they a threat?

1) They are a symbol of oppression. Clearly no one chooses to wear a habit, right? Why wear something that covers your complete body and gives you no individualism?

2) They pose a security risk. Can you identify a nun in a habit? Try it. I can't tell them apart. I can't even tell what color their hair is! How can we ID these people?! How can we tell if a monk walking into a bank has a gun under his robe? We obviously can't trust anyone in bulky clothing.


You need more proof that habits are a security threat? Go watch The Sound of Music and fast-forward to the end where the nuns sabotage the Nazis's car. They obviously want to overthrow the government.​

3) They want to institute Canon Law across the world. There's a Catholic school in almost every country. What does this mean? They're trying to corrupt people's minds at a young age. Why hasn't Congress done anything about this?!! It's clearly unconstitutional!!! It gets worse. They have hospitals and missions across the world. People wearing habits will force you to be Catholic. It's clear what their true mission is: To get every country under the rule of Vatican City!!!!!!!!!!


4) It's not in the Bible. Can you find the passage in scripture where Jesus commands his followers to wear habits? That's because it doesn't exist. It's another papal plot for power.
==============================================================================================


Too long; Didn't Read, Too Stupid to Understand Parody: It's unjust to ban the religious garments of a specific religion when we claim to have Freedom of Religion and Separation of Church and State. People that wear them in our countries have their own reasons for wearing them. They don't want to make you wear one, only that you allow them to wear theirs. And just because someone wears a Burqa doesn't automatically make them a suspicious character. I'm fairly confident that anyone choosing to wear a burqa is aware that there's a good chance they will be targeted for additional screening or at least looked at suspiciously; it's not a good terrorist strategy in a Western country. Anyone can commit an act of terrorism, regardless of religion, race, nationality, or clothing. As for what they do in Islamic countries, there's not much you as a non-citizen can do about it. They have sovereignty; you can't go across the world changing the laws of a different state.

Also I am Catholic, so I'm allowed to make fun of my own religion :P
 
Last edited:
Also I am Catholic, so I'm allowed to make fun of my own religion :P

They even have two Catholics running for President*, and Future President of the World Newt Gingrich was a recent convert. I bet the VATICAN got to him and FORCED him to convert!

yes, Rick Santorum is Catholic, he's just the kind of CAtholic who hates Vatican II
 
That is easily the best post in this thread and could be the best post in this forum. Great job at summarizing and condensing the anti-burqa-ban argument in such a beautiful parody form. You put real effort into that post and it shows.
 
I have no idea what a habit is, let alone care about it. Just the same way you people wouldn't care about a kapuxi or labrys.

The point is, a burqa is only a piece of cloth. It is the political agenda behind it that is using it as a front to demand more "rights". Wear whatever you damn please on your head, even a deuce as long as I am not near you. But then don't try to make it out to be some kind of holy war based on some archaic custom with no discernible use.
 
What does the political agenda of radical Muslims have to do with whether or not burqas should be banned in the US?
 
No, I'm pretty certain that when Christianity was the official religion of countries, they did stuff like persecute non-Christians and stone them and feed them to lions and all kinds of evil crap. This supposed "political element of Islam" hasn't affected much of the west. Hell, there's a lot more of the "political element" in the US politics and Christianity than any other religion.

And before someone goes "But that happened hundreds of years ago!" in regards to past Christian empires abusing non-believers, that's true. And for all intents and purposes, much of the middle east is still stuck in a mindset as if still was the 1500s, if not earlier, due to the systematic repression of...well, a lot, due to the dictators that run those countries.
I know the political element in Islam has had very little effect on the West. But a balanced perspective on the issue (avoiding "they're all terrorists" and "none are terrorists") will acknowledge that Muhammad himself was a political figure.

Jesus was not. Nor is the Catechism something that speaks of earthly punishment for nonbelievers. And I think you'd need proof of any Christians feeding anyone to the lions, seeing as that was Rome's line of work.

You need more proof that habits are a security threat? Go watch The Sound of Music and fast-forward to the end where the nuns sabotage the Nazis's car. They obviously want to overthrow the government.​
That is, quite simply, awesome.


I think only in certain contexts does an overly obscuring garment need banning. Banks, licenses, etc...you get the idea.
 
What does the political agenda of radical Muslims have to do with whether or not burqas should be banned in the US?

They shouldn't be banned, but if it is unwarranted in certain cases or circumstances, for example they require people to be better identifiable then those muslims just have to follow the law.
 
I have a hunch. If those here on the con side of the "ban burqas" motion are referring to the application of the motion on public locations with little to no security risk, and those here on the pro side of the "ban burqas" motion are referring to the application of the motion on privately-owned locations where pre-existing security laws affect dress and accessories, then never the twain shall berate one another. Right?

The tangents that discussion in this thread has taken to lead to thinly-veiled accusations of racism or anti-theism or non-Koranic-scholar-ism are odd, since the premises upon which the debate operates need not concern any argumentation over those points, let alone insultation.
 
I have a hunch. If those here on the con side of the "ban burqas" motion are referring to the application of the motion on public locations with little to no security risk, and those here on the pro side of the "ban burqas" motion are referring to the application of the motion on privately-owned locations where pre-existing security laws affect dress and accessories, then never the twain shall berate one another. Right?

The tangents that discussion in this thread has taken to lead to thinly-veiled accusations of racism or anti-theism or non-Koranic-scholar-ism are odd, since the premises upon which the debate operates need not concern any argumentation over those points, let alone insultation.

English, please?

While it does seem some of the discussion has veered into other points I believe it has been due to gain more context on the matter. I mean what other kind of religious garb or piece has garnered the same attention as the burqa in recent times? The jews have the kippa, but nobody makes a big deal about it because of both the fact that "hiding yourself" is more important than the religious component with the burqa. It is the belief that without it, women are somehow exposing themselves greatly in a practical/physical sense not the spiritual one.
 
That is easily the best post in this thread and could be the best post in this forum. Great job at summarizing and condensing the anti-burqa-ban argument in such a beautiful parody form. You put real effort into that post and it shows.
Thanks for the compliment (you too TFP).
They even have two Catholics running for President*, and Future President of the World Newt Gingrich was a recent convert. I bet the VATICAN got to him and FORCED him to convert!

yes, Rick Santorum is Catholic, he's just the kind of CAtholic who hates Vatican II
It also fully explains the JFK assassination (although he wasn't a very good Catholic, just ask Marilyn Monroe...) :P

I have no idea what a habit is, let alone care about it. Just the same way you people wouldn't care about a kapuxi or labrys.

The point is, a burqa is only a piece of cloth. It is the political agenda behind it that is using it as a front to demand more "rights". Wear whatever you damn please on your head, even a deuce as long as I am not near you. But then don't try to make it out to be some kind of holy war based on some archaic custom with no discernible use.
Three rules of thumb I've learned for the Debate section:
1) Read through every post
2) Do your research
3) Once you're sure you can prove you know what you're talking about, then you can post.

So you have no idea what a habit is? Of course I'm aware not everyone knows what it is (at least by name), that's why I gift-wrapped a wikipedia link at the top. Common sense would say click on it. And BTW, in faith to my maxims I googled kapuxi and labrys to see if they were relevant.

Countless times in this thread you've been asked for sources to prove how tolerating a Burqa leads to instituting Sharia law or "letting the terrorists win" (so to say), and every time you've dodged the question. To be frank (sorry but there's no nice way to do it), by not reading what other people type and dodging their questions you're coming off as ignorant and a terrible debater. Good day.
 
Last edited:
English, please?

While it does seem some of the discussion has veered into other points I believe it has been due to gain more context on the matter. I mean what other kind of religious garb or piece has garnered the same attention as the burqa in recent times? The jews have the kippa, but nobody makes a big deal about it because of both the fact that "hiding yourself" is more important than the religious component with the burqa. It is the belief that without it, women are somehow exposing themselves greatly in a practical/physical sense not the spiritual one.

Let's be honest, there's a LOT more Muslims than there are Jews (less than 15 million according to Wikipedia, and possibly less if you only count Jews as a religion rather than those who can trace their lineage through Judaism). Also, as I've touched upon previously (and the reason we're discussing burqa bans), there are a lot of Muslim immigrants into the Western world, particularly parts of western Europe. And it's one of the world's fastest growing religions.

So not only are there numbers increasing, but they're moving to places in first world, western countries where their presence is more notable.

Now if Islam is like most other major religions, a LOT of Muslims are very casual believers. They might own the religious garb and the mat they use to pray on, but probably don't do it every day and rarely where the garb outside of mosque services. I mean, I live about 10 minutes from a mosque and sometimes ride my bicycle there around the time their services end and they all seem to be wearing their usual Sunday best and not religious clothes. I imagine in most places, seeing something in a full out burqa is similar to seeing someone decked out in full out Amish stuff: Rare.
 
I know the political element in Islam has had very little effect on the West. But a balanced perspective on the issue (avoiding "they're all terrorists" and "none are terrorists") will acknowledge that Muhammad himself was a political figure.

Jesus was not. Nor is the Catechism something that speaks of earthly punishment for nonbelievers. And I think you'd need proof of any Christians feeding anyone to the lions, seeing as that was Rome's line of work.

Jesus might not have been a political leader, but it can't really be denied that the Roman Catholic Church (and I guess the Orthodox ones too, though I don't know much about them) played a huge role in the politics of European countries for over a thousand years. It's also well known that over that time the Roman church had a tendency to stray from that whole bit about loving your neighbors and all and instead torturing them some heathens or heretics.

Also, Turkey is actually very forcefully secular, much more so than the USA in the politics. Not all Islamic countries are theocracies.

Anyway, yeah, the burqa. I don't see an issue there, really, so I'm not for the bans. Besides, Islam only even makes up somewhere around half of a percent of the US population, about a third of the Jewish, so that sounds like very little to be making a fuss over, for here at least. Again, Halloween costumes sound like a more pressing concern than that.
 
Last edited:
^^^To be clear, these types of bans (as well as the minaret ban in Switzerland....sure it says minarets on ANY buildings, but who puts minarets on buildings besides Muslims and Mosques? Anyone?) are mostly being contemplated in Europe, which are seeing a large chunk of muslims from Northern Africa (And other parts of the world? I'm not certain) immigrating in places they haven't before.

Now western Europe is overwhelmingly Christian (and white as well), so it's taken the Muslim population only up to 4% in France. I suspect (complete speculation, based on no evidence or research) that the recent immigration are probably settling in specific areas, thus making the appearance seem greater than it actually is.

And hey, this has happened in the US throughout history whenever one culture or religion starts immigrating here, the people already here treat them like crap. Happened with the Irish back in the days of the early 1900s, the Japanese during WWII, and I'm sure it'll happen in the future
 
I can't believe mattj is the Voice of Reason in this thread.
I too enjoy this other side of mattj. Hopefully we'll se more of it in the future. On a related note, it is no surprise who the voices of unreason in this thread are.

You need more proof that habits are a security threat? Go watch The Sound of Music and fast-forward to the end where the nuns sabotage the Nazis's car. They obviously want to overthrow the government.​
I always wondered what happened to those nuns after that scene...

My whole family is Muslim, but none of the women wear burqas or even hijabs. I think that hijabs and burqas are counter-productiive because in America they actually draw attention towards whoever is wearing the burqa/hijab. I know some Muslim girls who choose to wear hijabs, not because they were told to by someone, but because they believe it is what God wants of them.

I personally believe that wearing a hijab is stupid. I also smoking is stupid. I also believe that the republican party is evil. I have no right to ban hijabs, outlaw cigarettes, or execute republicans though.
 
And hey, this has happened in the US throughout history whenever one culture or religion starts immigrating here, the people already here treat them like crap. Happened with the Irish back in the days of the early 1900s, the Japanese during WWII, and I'm sure it'll happen in the future.

Not exactly proud moments in our history, so I'm not too sure why anyone would want to emulate them... though, small point, the Japanese didn't start immigrating during World War II so much, or at least that wasn't the reasoning behind our nation's horrible treatment of them. As I understand it, that was more due to the Ni'ihau Incident raising concerns about how trustworthy the Japanese already present in the country were. Similarly, many German and I think also some Italian Americans were interned for those sorts of reasons.
 
That's because they are frankly revealing stuff that people don't want to see.

Is someone dressed in traditional religious clothes showing something that is visibly repulsive to you? Would small children be exposed to sexual organs if someone is dressed like a nun?

It doesn’t matter if people “want to see it” or not. The poster in which I was responding to when making this point implied that anyone should be able to live life how they wish and dress as they wish, and bringing this up shows how naive and idealistic that it.
If a naturist who wants to live life in their way and dress how they like doesn’t get the same rights as a muslim who wants to live life in their way and dress how they like then how is this fair?
The point being made is that regardless of religion or preferred lifestyle, freedom is limited by the law. You can’t just do anything you want because you want to or because a book is telling you too. Therefore just like nudity is disallowed for obvious reasons for naturists, the full burqa being disallowed for security implications really wouldn’t be so unfair, especially when the hijab is a reasonable substitute.
And your point about people wanting to see something – things are not banned by what people want to see. I personally don’t like the way the burqa looks (to be honest I don’t see how anyone could actually think it’s a “pleasant” sight) but this is too shallow of a reason for it to be banned.

Being in public, in an open space, a security risk?

Fortunately, I don't live my life in fear. Seriously, do you live in fear walking down the street? Do people in your country or city or whatever just get randomly stopped in public areas?

Different sects of Islam judge modesty differently. Depending on the circumstances and so on. I'm betting the hijab and burqa both exist for a reason and aren't interchangeable.

It’s not about living life in fear, it’s simply about preventing a potential security risk. That’s all.
And you don’t sound too sure about the hijab or the burqa. Both are there for the same reason, in that muslim women want to cover themselves and prevent men from being “aroused”. The burqa is worn by those muslim who take it to the extreme and go over the top to cover absolutely every human feature other than the eyes. Even a lot of muslims ridicule the burqa.

If anything it makes them easily identifiable since in most parts of the western world, Islam is a minority religion, and traditional Islam (IE those who would most likely be wearing the burqa in public) even more so.

And seriously: You live in fear when at the supermarket?

Islam is a minority religion? REALLY? You obviously have VERY little knowledge about islam, especially in countries like the UK, France etc. where its spreading more and more rapidly. And again it’s not about living in fear, it’s about preventing a potential security risk. Wanting to prevent it doesn’t mean you live in fear.


Hi. My name is CAH and I have no understanding of any culture that isn't my own.

LOL disagreeing with an idea doesn’t mean you have no understanding of it. I actually have a great deal of understanding about islam and muslims (hence why I even started this topic), but yet I and even many muslims will agree that the burqa is extreme and unnecessary. Furthermore, you have no idea what my culture is, and seem to think that it's not possible for a muslim or anyone part of an islamic culture to disagree with the burqa. Whilst rare it's not impossible, and I've seen several muslims openly criticize the full burqa.


While you're free to criticize, you're approaching it with your own biases that don't account for how people within the religion view their practices and traditions. While you might see yourself as being more "open minded" about criticizing Islam from the outside, those knowledgable about Islam might say you're criticism is based in ignorance.

I would say it’s more likely that someone WITHIN the religion would be approaching this with their own biases. Obviously they have dedicated their life to this and most would sooner die than to question anything that it says. I don’t have a bias, I simply disagree with the idea of the burqa. Using your logic, anyone who isn’t muslim is “biased”, which would leave only the muslim opinion, and that would be truly biased seeing as most believe you can’t even question the quran. Furthermore using the word “ignorant” for anyone who criticizes a religion or any of its practices is done far too commonly, usually under the assumption that said person knows nothing about the religion, hasn’t researched it or even read the holy book. I do not fit this description.

Then Islam isn't for you. Feel free to choose another religion.

You think that simply thinking the burqa is outrageous means islam isn’t for me? That’s pretty ignorant in itself, especially as it’s arguably (by many muslims themselves) not compulsory, or even necessary to be a muslim. You don’t seem to know much about islam yourself, and I’d suggest reading up on the burqa/hijab, asking any muslim friends etc. to gain more of an understanding before you go around making statements like this.



2) They pose a security risk. Can you identify a nun in a habit? Try it. I can't tell them apart. I can't even tell what color their hair is! How can we ID these people?! How can we tell if a monk walking into a bank has a gun under his robe? We obviously can't trust anyone in bulky clothing.


The "habit" is much more like the hijab than the burqa. At least with both the hijab and the habit you can see the person's face. This is not as extreme as wearing the full burqa in which the person doesn't even have any facial features other than a small gap for the eyes. It's the equivalent of wearing a mask. The habit and the hijab cover the hair only, which isn't much different from a person walking down the street with a hat covering their hair. Besides, haircuts change over time anyway, the face is the main form of identification, and whether your hair is showing or not isn't usually an issue.

http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_6zRI79kEqUk/TTgMGqAJ8LI/AAAAAAAAB3g/w-dVFvn0wCU/s1600/Burqa****on.jpg - No faces. Unidentifiable.

http://images.mylot.com/userImages/images/postphotos/2082830.jpg - Hair covered yet due to having faces that you can see, pretty easy to distinquish and identify.
 
Last edited:
Okay, so you say you know about Islam. Please provide a source that backs up your claim that the burqa and hijab are essentially interchangeable.
 
Last edited:
Islam is a minority religion? REALLY? You obviously have VERY little knowledge about islam, especially in countries like the UK, France etc. where its spreading more and more rapidly. And again it’s not about living in fear, it’s about preventing a potential security risk. Wanting to prevent it doesn’t mean you live in fear.


Forgive me if the fact that the UK and France respectively have about three and four percent of the population being Muslims sounds underwhelming, but... well... That's not really that much, at all. It's certainly less than Christianity's fraction, even if you take out the folks that don't go to Church regularly... which is to say, the vast majority. Saying that Islam is a minority religion would certainly be accurate.

Are there actually epidemics of people running around and committing crimes hidden in burqas in Europe to justify this?
 
Are there actually epidemics of people running around and committing crimes hidden in burqas in Europe to justify this?
Yes, yes, YES!! There was...there was that guy! He giggled like a little girl. He obviously thought no one would contact the authorities because they'd be embarrassed that they got robbed and beat up by a little girl! How nefarious!



(Bill Nye the Sneasel Guy, you nailed it!)
 
So maybe you shouldn't be in the Debate forum about a topic you clearly know little about?

This argument makes little to no sense.

One of my favorite religious studies teachers in college was an atheist and grew up in white suburbia. She was able to embrace and study other cultures and their religions in many parts of the US and abroad. In some very poor and crappy parts of the world, and very rich, and very isolated, and everything in between.


http://browncardigan.com/?p=10102


Just because you're an atheist doesn't prevent you from learning about religion.

I know plentiful things about religion thanks.

You don't get a "get out of jail" free card in a discussion just because you don't personally follow a religion or a culture.

Nor have I attempted to use one.

If you don't know shi*t about the topic, then don't be surprised when someone challenges the validity of your logic in a debate.

Except I can't think of anything that I have stated re.Islam which si factually incorrect.

Just because something is not literally mentioned in a text doesn't mean anything.

Well it often means quite a lot actually, particularly in religious texts.

It's been developed as a religious garment over the approximately 1500 years Islam has been a religion. It has a clear evidence of how traditional Islamic women express their modesty.

I wonder who created the Burqa? Or who transcribed the "teachings of Allah" in the first place.

The debate isn't if you, snorunt conservationist personally approve, because no one cares. The debate is do you understand the historical and cultural facts surrounding the burqa?

Well actually the debate is on people's opinions about the Burqa as stated in the very first post.

The purpose of the burqa is to fulfil the Koran's standard of modesty.Exactly.

Well given that the Quran does not include the covering of one's head it clearly seeks to fulfill more than was originally expressed in my opinion.

The command clearly says to cover the body.

Which is an ambiguous term.

The burqa covers the body.

It covers more than what I constitute the body to be in that context.

It does not say to simply cover their hair, or arms, or legs. It says to cover their entire body.

Citation please. A citation where we are told exactly what parts of the body should be covered, what the body is classified as encompassing, and what should be used to do this please.

The reason these people wear burqas is because of what their religious text says.

Not exclusively. However, I don't think I've denied this to be the case.

That could very well be an accurate interpretation. But it is not the interpretation that many Muslims take.

So?

Considering that you don't care to bother yourself with learning much, if anything, about their religion, I'd take their interpretation over yours.

Pointless argument. I guess that this means none of us had the right to post in the Mohammed paedophilia thread because the majority of us aren't muslims? Try harder.

Are you seriously claiming that a "cloak" is not a "burqa like piece of clothing"?

Well they're not, as one takes the rather extreme step of covering the head and face while the other doesn't. Cloaks also leave the torso exposed often.


I was referring to the Koran and Hadith.


Once again you find yourself on the wrong side of reality.It looks explicit enough to me and the millions of Conservative Muslims around the world.

http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/explicit Read up.

You not getting it =/= it not being based in their religious text.I could report you for taking a personal stab at me, but I'm too cool for that, so I'm just going to publicly call you out on it.

Where's the personal stab here? I'm happy for you to do so, just don't expect me to sit on the times you have made me cry myself to sleep by calling me a moron :(. It is also rather funny to see you try and act with reserve, because of course you have such a great record on that. Any luck trying to to find those specific degrees of libel?
 
Last edited:
Back
Top