• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Worldbuiling

straydelta

Noodlebirb
Hello all! This is my first time posting here, and I figured I'd start off with a new discussion to break the ice.

One of my favorite things about reading Pokémon fanfiction is the amount of worldbuilding authors do. Do Pokémon speak? Why do all Nurse Joys look the same? Why are 10-year-olds allowed to travel a world filled with dangerous creatures all on their own? How do Pokéballs work? What about the PC?

Everyone has their own ideas, and I was wondering what you all think about worldbuilding in Pokémon fanfiction. As both a reader and a writer, what do you prefer? Do you like lots of worldbuilding, where the story creates a realistic world of Pokémon, or do you enjoy the simplicity of Pokémon and simply roll with what they give you, and don't look too much into the reasoning behind it all?
 
Hey! Welcome to SPP! And not a bad way to break the ice if you ask me. To answer your blurbs in no particular order here...

Everyone has their own ideas, and I was wondering what you all think about worldbuilding in Pokémon fanfiction. As both a reader and a writer, what do you prefer? Do you like lots of worldbuilding, where the story creates a realistic world of Pokémon, or do you enjoy the simplicity of Pokémon and simply roll with what they give you, and don't look too much into the reasoning behind it all?

I think that short of writing a gag or deliberately absurd story, most people here would probably tell you that "roll with what they give you" is a little hard for Pokémon as a franchise. As a medium, video games allow for a greater degree of abstraction than most other narrative-driven works. In a game, the primary objective is to be fun to play, even if the logic doesn't always seem to click. Hence why no one questions why PCs heal your team for free or why grade-schoolers give you pocket change for beating their teams in-game much in the same way that no one questions why blocks float and mushrooms give you special powers in Mario games as long as they're having fun.

In most other mediums, there's often a lot less tolerance for that level of abstraction because the medium itself leans more heavily on a story that has to make sense under a certain, regular logic. Thus even if how something works isn't fully understood in a setting, what it does, some guesses at what might cause it, and implications for how the world around deals with that 'something' are all things that need to be kept in mind. A rabbit that lives near a regularly used country road fundamentally doesn't need to know that a car is driven by pistons moving thanks to tiny explosions that in turn turns a crankshaft or that it's even a machine, but knowing that it's big, usually sticks to stretches of ground that are hard and black, and doesn't always stop for little animals out in the road might be pivotal knowledge for not becoming roadkill, and for informing decisions and advice to relay to others.

Plus worldbuilding's just plain fun sometimes. It's fun to toy around with the backdrop to a story, how the pieces of that backdrop all fit together, and how those pieces influence and shape whatever yarn you're telling. The primary difficulty is getting it to surface in a way that doesn't distract from the action of the story (i.e. not infodumping), but that's part of why writing's an art and not a science.
 
Thanks!

In most other mediums, there's often a lot less tolerance for that level of abstraction because the medium itself leans more heavily on a story that has to make sense under a certain, regular logic.

Ahhh that's a really good point I hadn't thought of. Games and stories have different purposes, so different things are accepted. I would, however, argue even games like Mario operate under a certain, regular logic, too. You hit question mark blocks in Mario, you're going to get a power-up. Bowser is always the bad guy, he kidnaps Princess Peach, and you, as Mario, have to go rescue her by traveling the world to reach her. Granted it's not logical how that's done, exactly, but there is a logical story behind it.

Beyond that, I would also argue that great games have strong stories as well as good game mechanics (look at the Dragon age series - extremely popular games because of their complex characters and stories as well as fun game mechanics), so while you can be abstract, you can just as easily be detailed and logical, too. It all depends on your player - and I feel the same can be applied to writing, too.

The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy, for example, is fairly absurd. I'll throw this under spoilers in case anyone hasn't read it and plans to:

[SPOIL] Planet Earth gets blown up to make room for essentially a space bypass, and mice are actually an intelligent species that created Earth to experiment on humans in search of the answer to "everything." (Or, rather, the question they're trying to ask to find that answer, because they already know it. It's 42.) [/SPOIL]

It's a silly, absurd story, and yet extremely popular.

So, going back to Pokémon - is it possible to ignore worldbuilding, as writers, and simply work with the information the games provide us? Would a story that doesn't try to explain PCs or Pokémon Centers or why 10-year-olds can run around on their own, where food comes from (Pokémon? animals?), and all of that, still be a good story? Or would it suffer from being illogical if it tried to be a serious story and not, as you said, a gag or absurd story?

That being said, I definitely can't argue with you that worldbuilding is fun. It is. Especially with stories that have less logic, because it's more of a challenge to try and explain everything reasonably without going overboard or contradicting yourself and creating more issues.
 
As with most other things, a middle point is fine when it comes to worldbuilding but extremes on the other side don't work that well and require careful handling. A story that takes only the information that the games give us, at face value, would suffer from it depending on the audience you are aiming it to. People who read Pokémon fanfiction, I'd like to think, read it precisely because the canon doesn't really answer any questions, nor pose the questions that is of interest to ask. A story that doesn't answer or pose questions is no better for them than sitting down and playing the game. Of coursey, to an audience that doesn't want to ask any questions and is there for the face value of the trip instead, it would hopefully be an enjoyable reading. Similarly and conversely, a story that goes into too much detail in the worldbuilding and builds up concepts and ideas from every little hook, would suffer from it if aimed at an audience that wants specific answers as well, as the more you define the world, the less open and fuzzy it becomes, and thus the more it deviates from what makes people ask about in Pokémon stories; yet of course, to an audience that is there for the value of the questions asked, for the philosophy or study behind it and how much "consequence" is drawn out from it, such stories would also be enjoyable.

tl;dr: Define your audience. Both airport novels and bible-sized mystery doorstoppers work for a reason - but still you might want to sit somewhere in the middle.

Lots of stories, in particular short thematic / topical ones -oneshots, contest prompts, backstory glances-, do not need to pose or answer many of the various questions that a Pokémon world brings up -no "why PCs", no "why 10-year-olds", no "why food"-; they can afford to handle only one or two relevant questions and deal with them, and the ability to close those stories well in their subject is an important component of the enjoyment factor there: the ending should not prompt, by itself, the reader to question the why of something that was not posed during the story. It can happen, but that's for later, when the enjoyment has sunk in and the reader is reaching to their fridge for a dinner, and he is free to ask "what about...?" for himself, not for the story.

Now, "taking merely what the games give us" is also something that is nowhere as simple as it sounds. There's a lot of stuff that is nonsensical but also isn't easy to dance around and out from if one focus only (and truly) on the games as a guide. Why are people capable of walking in eight directions in Kalos and Hoenn, but only in four directions and in a grid in Kanto, Sinnoh and the other regions? How do Flying Pokémon, once frozen, somehow apparently remain in the air? Why doesn't fire continuously consume the body of a Grass-type Pokémon rather than dying out "by the end of the turn", whatever that means? Is Goldenrod City a sustainable city with a population of less than ~130 people? Because that's how the games work, and that's the story only they tell. In other words, how much would you want to limit yourself to truly "games only" and why? What belongs to the games as a concept and what lies there merely as a limitation to the interface we're sold to consume the story?

Speaking of, may I ask, why focus only on the games as a source of worldbuilding value? There's so much more to offer and mixing and matching between the various canons does help to close some of the gaps a "games only" view leaves, or at least fortify the foundations for building stuff to address them.
 
People who read Pokémon fanfiction, I'd like to think, read it precisely because the canon doesn't really answer any questions, nor pose the questions that is of interest to ask.

That's a valid point. People read fanfiction because they want to see more of this world that they already love so much, and I can easily see that for Pokémon - especially with older fans - readers want answers that the games never provide. That's definitely one of the driving factors for writing worldbuilding fanfiction too, I would say. The writers want to explore these questions, too, and give their own take as to what those answers may be.

Lots of stories, in particular short thematic / topical ones -oneshots, contest prompts, backstory glances-, do not need to pose or answer many of the various questions that a Pokémon world brings up

So not explaining things/worldbuilding is more forgivable in shorter stories than it is in longer works? I can understand that, absolutely. The longer you spend in a world, the harder it is to ignore all the illogical elements within it. I do want to ask, though: do you think it's possible to simply ignore those inconsistencies as "Oh, that's just how Pokémon is?" and be able to continue with the story? Or would that be an immediate turn-off?

Why are people capable of walking in eight directions in Kalos and Hoenn, but only in four directions and in a grid in Kanto, Sinnoh and the other regions? How do Flying Pokémon, once frozen, somehow apparently remain in the air? Why doesn't fire continuously consume the body of a Grass-type Pokémon rather than dying out "by the end of the turn", whatever that means? Is Goldenrod City a sustainable city with a population of less than ~130 people?

I didn't quite mean to be that literal - I would hope one would take graphical limitations into account and adjust them in a story to what they were implied to mean. Using your examples: people being able to walk in all directions, Goldrenrod is an actual city populated by thousands of people, etc. Though I do see your point about the fire and Grass-type Pokémon thing. ...Stop, drop, and roll?

But allow me to be more specific, then - should we accept, at face value, what the games provide for us story-wise. I.e. 10-year-old's traveling the world on their own, Pokémon allowing themselves to be used in battles, Nurse Joys all looking the same, etc. Do we stop to take the time and explain each of these illogical things, or do we just roll with it as accepted canon and move on?

In other words, how much would you want to limit yourself to truly "games only" and why?

I like how you use the word "limit," because I believe that's a valuable point about worldbuilding. If you decide to stay true only to what the games explain, and nothing more, you do limit yourself, in a way. Kind of like a sonnet. It's got a structure, and it's limiting because you have to force yourself into those constraints - but does that make a sonnet lesser than a free-verse poem?

Speaking of, may I ask, why focus only on the games as a source of worldbuilding value? There's so much more to offer and mixing and matching between the various canons does help to close some of the gaps a "games only" view leaves, or at least fortify the foundations for building stuff to address them.

Fair point. I said games simply because that's the main source of everything else - *****, anime, etc. Those things are based on the games and are, in their own way, worldbuilding themselves. But yeah, you're getting into another aspect of this discussion that I wanted to talk about: how do you like to worldbuild? Drawing from more sources than just the games is definitely one of those ways.
 
Hey, welcome to the board! You totally ninja'd me with this topic; I was thinking of starting a worldbuilding discussion, but decided to hold off until the NaNo hype had died down. So obviously it's something I'm interested in.

While I do enjoy the amount of leeway Pokemon allows for in terms of worldbuilding--there are so many strange or unexplained things or things that just don't work if you try to approach them from a real world context--I absolutely think it's possible to ignore it completely and write something straight with the material provided in the games/anime/whichever canon. Solovino pretty much made my point on that one in mentioning short stories in particular as ones in which you typically have little room for worldbuilding unless that worldbuilding is the point of the story. For example, if in your short story your character needs to run to the PC to heal up, you can probably assume that the Center works as everyone expects: it provides cheap, free healing for pokémon, and no more time need be spent on it than that. On the other hand, you might write a short story (or even a longer one, depending on your goals) about the daily life and operations of a Pokecenter, and in those cases you're probably going to be doing a much closer examination of how the system works.

I think that even in longer works, though, it's rare that you need an extensive amount of worldbuilding. One story can only address so much, so if your focus isn't on the world itself, your worldbuilding is probably going to be relatively limited--there simply isn't space to address all the weird logic of the pokéverse and address the other theme(s) you want to explore, at least not without sacficing some of the other narrative elements.

Solovino mentioned wanting to read stories that ask questions, which most good stories do, but I don't think they need to do so about the world, per se. Someone might wonder what would happen if (anime) Team Rocket tried to capture Genesect or where N went after the end of B/W, for example, and while I think either have the potential to be engaging and worthwhile stories, they also probably don't need a lot of worldbuilding to go with them. You could, if you wanted to, but it's not necessary. The interest is more in answering questions about characters than it is about the world. There are also some stories where I think it would be straight-up out of place; for example, if you want to tell a story about Ash and his friends having a new adventure, and you want to maintain the tone of an actual anime episode or movie, you probably are going to want to adopt its version of the world uncritically. That kind of a story almost certainly doesn't need any talk about how pokéballs work or what people are actually eating, and tacking some on might even be detrimental.

It really depends on the kind of story you're trying to tell. At the most basic level, if you're writing a one-shot, you're probably not going to have the space to do much worldbuilding unless that particular piece of worldbuilding is the point of the one-shot. If a character needs to run to a Pokemon Center, then you can take it for granted that they're going to be able to get their 'mons healed of almost any injury quickly and for free. On the other hand, if the one-shot centers on what it's "really like" to work at a Center, you would be free to go into much more detail about . You have more space in a larger story to present bigger ideas and to include more headcanons, but even so, a story can only be about so many things at one time. If you want a story that focuses on the anime cast in an anime-style world, for example, then typically you want to accept the anime's conventions unless what you're going for is some kind of deconstruction.

So, basically:

But allow me to be more specific, then - should we accept, at face value, what the games provide for us story-wise. I.e. 10-year-old's traveling the world on their own, Pokémon allowing themselves to be used in battles, Nurse Joys all looking the same, etc. Do we stop to take the time and explain each of these illogical things, or do we just roll with it as accepted canon and move on?
You can, but you don't have to. Some stories call for elaboration on those sorts of issues; some don't. And as Solovino mentioned, mixing canons is quite common with Pokémon, and is usually used to come up with a baseline world that the author thinks will work well for their stories--for example, many people ignore the four-move limit from the games, because in the anime pokémon can use more attacks than that (although they've been tightening that up in recent seasons, I believe). It's also commonly accepted to ignore things that are probably artifacts of the games' limitations rather than actual features of the world--for example, I think most people consider the identical nurses an anime trope. It's true that in the games they all use the same sprite, but then again, so do all characters of a particular trainer class, and I think it would be strange for most stories to present a scenario in which all the hiker trainers encountered happened to look identical, even though that's true of the games.

As to which I, I like stories that use an appropriate amount of world-building, which is sort of a cop-out answer, but really, I enjoy both stories that incorporate a lot of headcanon to try and make sense of things just as much as those that handwave the weird bits. In general I'm more likely to get annoyed with stories that try to do more worldbuilding versus those that roll with less, because so often it ends up being half-assed or poorly thought out, and that irritates me more than a story that doesn't try anything fancy (provided it doesn't need to). In general I prefer smaller bits of worldbuilding to large ones--details that add texture to the world, like nods to local heroes or folk history, or adding festivals, eletctions, etc., the stuff of actual life (especially life outside training) that the franchise usually glosses over. Stuff like that adds character the world and makes it feel more lived-in. Everybody loves to share their ideas about how pokemon speech works or why all nurses are identical (if you're even going to roll with that), but these are tricky beasts to play with. You have to think the implications through very carefully; for example, a world where pokemon can easily communicate with humans is going to operate EXTREMELY differently than the one we're presented with in the games or anime. Or if nurse joys are actually clones or what have, you're implying some potentially rather dark things about how the pokemon world works, and you can't really just drop info like that in without dedicating some narrative time to what that means. And if the macro-level worldbuilding isn't essential to your story it probably straight-up doesn't belong in there. Do a side post about it or something.
 
Do I enjoy worldbuilding? Oh yes, to a bit of a fault honestly. An awful lot of my writing and planning time goes into hashing out weird setting and character details for the story that end up being completely redundant to the plot I actually end up following. A bit of a bad habit from starting out with GMing/RPing, I suppose.

With regards to what I prefer as a reader and writer, a symbiotic relationship is the short of it. What I mean by that is that the worldbuilding and the plot of the story should inform and enhance each other rather than one being advanced at the expense of the other. A story focused on explaining and elaborating on aspects of the pokémon universe can and should be extensive in its worldbuilding because that worldbuilding is the focal point of the story, but if what you're trying to get across is an emotional story then that same exhaustiveness and detail becomes a detriment because it's too detached and remote, which detracts from the point of your story rather than enhancing it. What you choose to describe and how much detail you put into it sets the focus and emphasis of your story, and if that focus does not line up with what you're trying to tell your reader, your narrative is weakened because different parts of it are pulling in contradictory directions.

To use the two stories I'm currently working on as examples, one is a what if scenario about a mystery dungeon type setting where the pokémon having been human is the rule rather than the exception, with main series technology in the mix. In this case, I feel that going into more detail is warranted. Firstly, because it's a foreign setting, so explanation is needed to help the reader follow what is going on, and secondly because the effects of foreign technology on a PMD-type world are a key part of the plot and so a certain amount of explanation is necessary to bring across the stakes. By contrast, the other story I'm working on is a fairly short PoV of a pokémon going through a very particular experience as described in its pokédex entries, and while that is also worldbuilding in a fashion I don't intend to explain much because the core of the story is in bringing across the PoV character's subjective experience, so elaborating on things they themselves do not comprehend would harm the story rather than help it, since it'd would place the reader in a position of knowledge about the world that would work against the sense of apprehension and uncertainty that I want to bring across.

So yeah, know what you're going for and tailor your worldbuilding (or lack thereof) to fit is what I'd say. For my part, I like to create a decadent excess of detail for my own satisfaction about how things work in my story's world, then pare the actual in-story worldbuilding down to only the bits that are relevant to story and character arcs.

Also, to comment on a couple of things:

I didn't quite mean to be that literal - I would hope one would take graphical limitations into account and adjust them in a story to what they were implied to mean. Using your examples: people being able to walk in all directions, Goldrenrod is an actual city populated by thousands of people, etc. Though I do see your point about the fire and Grass-type Pokémon thing. ...Stop, drop, and roll?

But allow me to be more specific, then - should we accept, at face value, what the games provide for us story-wise. I.e. 10-year-old's traveling the world on their own, Pokémon allowing themselves to be used in battles, Nurse Joys all looking the same, etc. Do we stop to take the time and explain each of these illogical things, or do we just roll with it as accepted canon and move on?

At the risk of being a bit pedantic about it, that's a rather fuzzy line you're working with. Sure, the difference in movement is very obviously a technical limitation of the earlier systems...but then, the same goes for multiple NPCs sharing the same sprite. The identical-looking nurse Joy thing is itself a rationalization invented for the anime (as is calling them all Joy for that matter) rather than taking the games at face value too, since there's no ingame reference to any of them looking the same or what their names are. Similarly, there are no real figures on ingame population for towns or on the age of any of the game protagonists. Granted, you can argue that certain things are implied (the protagonist being young enough to be called kid, Goldenrod being a pretty big city etc.) but making those kinds of assumptions is in itself venturing outside the scope of taking the game at face value. As Solovino pointed out, it's not that easy to make the distinction between what is an intended part of the story and what is a concession to the limitations of the delivery method.

As for the should...well, as a hard should, definitely not. Pokémon is a many-headed beast at this point, and I see no reason why everyone should scrape and bow to the games just because they came out first. Besides, even the games themselves have wildly contradicting approaches at this point because of how many of them there are, particularly when spin-offs are factored in.

As a softer 'should you do this because it'd be helpful' sort of thing, I'd say that depends from person to person. If you think it'd be an interesting challenge or it'd improve your your skills to limit your sources of reference then by all means, go for it. If you don't...well, then you don't. I don't consider the games to be in any way superior or inferior as a source of canon to base yourself on. The key's not where you start but what you make of it.

The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy, for example, is fairly absurd. I'll throw this under spoilers in case anyone hasn't read it and plans to:

That's not quite the same thing though. Yes, Hitchhiker's Guide is an absurd story, but then that's the point. It's a story about characters trying to rationalize a fundamentally irrational world, so the absurdity of the situations plays straight into the core theme of the story. It has the appearance of randomness and absurdity, but when you look at the story thematically it is clearly structured, planned out and executed. By contrast, your average game story (RPG stories in particular) has to account for an unknown variable in player behavior and the expectation of player agency. It has to find ways to communicate controls and gameplay concepts to the player without breaking the flow of the game and be structured so that the player can't completely break it if they do something unexpected, and since it usually can't force the protagonist forward it instead has to be designed to try and tempt the player to go where the story needs them to. This can make things really absurd, but unlike a book like the Hitchhiker's Guide, that absurdity is born out of an oversight in design rather than as an intentional choice by the creator and usually doesn't have the kind of thematic point or message you'd expect out of a traditional narrative.

Some games are an exception to this of course, The Stanley Parable and Undertale being two obvious examples in recent memory which incorporate player agency as a central theme and use the player's failure (or refusal) to follow the suggested critical path as part of the story. But yeah, 'just roll with it' is more of an acceptable answer with games because there is more to command the audience's attention than just the words you put down, much like it's entirely possible to enjoy a movie where the plot makes no sense so long as the scenes are good and the acting is enjoyable. Hence why story can be a non-issue or even a detriment depending on the game you're playing.
 
Last edited:
I think there also ends up being a lot of space in the strange things that fics neither explain properly, nor try to omit from the story, so they have to stand out in their absurdity -- the simple example is when a darker fic shows the death of a young trainer. If the legal age is ten, you think there must be a good reason for it -- parents aren't going to let their children out in the world to die. Yet in a lot of fics I've read, they don't propose a reason -- instead, a child dies, and they just die: nobody even questions why it happened. That can be a powerful situation too. I ultimately think that so many stories offer dark reasons for holes in the canon's explanation, because these holes are fissures in the fabric of the canon -- the canon is trying to put out this perfect, adventurous place where kids can rule, and if there's evil, it can always be heroically defeated. But if at any point it fails to put out that image -- then there's a long, long way down.

(I'm always optimistic, so I'm trying to write a story where kids can in fact rule, but with some realistic caveats and struggles. Think about it -- how can you even imagine a world where a toddler is standing in a wild route far away from any habitation, and when she meets you, she wallops you with her precocious pokemon? This is a challenge of the imagination, if you take it seriously.)

Then also, I think there's a good amount of ground you could break by accepting that the game is made of things that were never meant to be a coherent, unified, morally explained story. If you read Pokespecial, it reads kind of like a fanfic. What Pokespecial is doing is starting from the initial 'pitch' of pokemon -- young trainers in a kind of Gym League world who hold monsters in their pockets -- and creating 'a pokemon story', one of the possible results of that plot bunny. The basic journeyfic is doing the exact thing -- that's why worldbuilding becomes necessary, because 'pokemon' as a fandom is no more than a plot bunny ("what if monsters lived in balls"), and any fanfic is an attempt to cast this into a fantasy, science fiction story. Or any other genre -- that's why, as Negrek says, you can have sooo many different kinds of pokemon fics. Like, of course canon exists -- but you can see it as just another story that lays down some basic, structural rules for everyone to follow -- how do pokemon battle, how do they heal, how do the trainers live, etc.

So what could you gain by accepting that the game was made to be a game...? Oh, I don't know. That was a goal of my fic, but I've ended up making it yet another journey story, and of course I'm worldbuilding for it. Personally to answer the question, I always care about only two things: 1) characters, and 2) (canonical) locations. If I have to worldbuild I do just enough to make a good environment for the characters. Not everyone does the same!

Negrek said:
In general I prefer smaller bits of worldbuilding to large ones--details that add texture to the world, like nods to local heroes or folk history, or adding festivals, eletctions, etc., the stuff of actual life (especially life outside training) that the franchise usually glosses over. Stuff like that adds character the world and makes it feel more lived-in.

I think in their own way, everyone write pokemon fanfic because they want to bring pokemon into their (imagined) life. Like the idea of pokemon participating in an election or a folk ceremony is very charming. This is also what anime and ***** indulges in more often than not. How would we be able to build a society or a life with pokemon? How could we pray to elemental powers that are pokemon?

EDIT: Oh yes! Within my priorities, I often approach worldbuilding from the perspective of "what would really matter to my characters". My characters aren't political and for a large part of the story, they won't know that much about greater Hoenn. But a government is what forms a society, and a society forms a home, and a home forms a house, a city block, a communal eating place, etc. The kind of world a character lives in will greatly affect how they live -- I can tell you that I had a vastly different experience of living in the two countries I've been in. I often try to take cues from other countries, from the art depicting life in those countries, from poetry etc, to cobble together what I want Hoenn to feel like. That detail is very important to me.
 
Last edited:
As someone who is working on an original story, world building is different in its own way. You gotta build it from scratch, and it is no easy task. First and foremost, you need to visualize yourself as a viewer watching the place in the distance you desire. Then chose the point of view you want to show and tell the details and essentials of the location.

Example from my work of a Graveyard using 3RD POV Omniscient:

Vitandes Cemetery, it is the last resting place of the peaceful dead. Filled with swaying grass and flowers, it resembles the day one person’s travel back in the times one lives through life, how much one’s achieve, how one’s actions evolve, and how one’s life contributed for their fellow tivanians and Vitandes, their heavenly home planet. A few trees give a chilly relief if anyone visits the cemetery during the morning. However, amongst the many uprooted graveyards, one monument statue resembles a heroic beacon to the people of Tivanes. The statue’s six different colors of diamond resembling a body of a human being wearing a monk scholar’s clothes, somehow not giving the face any detail at all, refracts an eye catching charm. What made the human crystal so special –if one looks closely at its chest- is the heart: carved with the most lustrous crystals emanating light. If one gets to see it at night, it emits a beautiful rainbow light to those who closely stare directly at it.

This is from personal experience as to how one could map the world. I prefer starting out with the little basic details of a place being described briefly. Once you have those done, you show or tell the most iconic parts of a location. Most recommended if you are going third person point of view omniscient. But 3rd PoV limited, it can be tricky.

However, if you are describing a place using a character is something you should treat as a writer carefully. Why you ask? You need to be mindful of the current knowledge the character you are using has about the location. Does your character know this place very well? Is it his/her first time in this place? Do they interpret the designs and positions of the place that either contradicts or sides with the residents of the place?
 
I think there also ends up being a lot of space in the strange things that fics neither explain properly, nor try to omit from the story, so they have to stand out in their absurdity -- the simple example is when a darker fic shows the death of a young trainer. If the legal age is ten, you think there must be a good reason for it -- parents aren't going to let their children out in the world to die. Yet in a lot of fics I've read, they don't propose a reason -- instead, a child dies, and they just die: nobody even questions why it happened. That can be a powerful situation too. I ultimately think that so many stories offer dark reasons for holes in the canon's explanation, because these holes are fissures in the fabric of the canon -- the canon is trying to put out this perfect, adventurous place where kids can rule, and if there's evil, it can always be heroically defeated. But if at any point it fails to put out that image -- then there's a long, long way down.
Yeah, people really do reach for sinister reasons behind a lot of canon weirdness. It's kind of depressing, really--a lot of people want to make the world seem more "realistic," so they load it up with a lot of dark stuff because how could you ever send a bunch of ten-year-olds out into the world with super-powered monsters and not have it end poorly, really? Like, a lot of people accept that a darker view of how things work is more realistic and construct their interpretations around that, rather than thinking, "Well, maybe this wouldn't work in our world right now, but is there some way it could work?" I do love me a good darkfic, but it would be nice to see some more optimistic interpretations of the canon that actually try to make a more believable pokémon world that maintains the overall idealistic tone. Aside from yours, the only one I can remember seeing is deleted now, although I'm probably forgetting a couple. Writing a story like that would probably be a good exercise for me, since it seems like anything I write tends to go grimdark even if it wasn't my original intent. :P
 
Negrek: Yeah, I agree that porting parts of pokemon canon directly into the real world, and treating them how a political novel, a pulp fiction, a thriller, etc set in our world would happen, might not always be the only choice (or the most interesting). I guess you always have to write in a tradition! The tradition that a story belongs to, can really affect how its world is made. In my knowledge, there's no major fiction writing that's canon in pokemon, although some people make some very strong fics by writing like a pokeani or movie narration. Anyway, writing fantastic situations is always about imagining how life would be if the world was much different from how ours works, and in fact, most fics already end up doing this.

What would a worldbuilding be like that doesn't pose all its questions as 'caveats' to the canon's naivete? I think there are usually agendas or spirits to any worldbuilding; in the one we described, the spirit is often one of cynicism. In a lot of famous examples of worldbuilding, the writer does it in a spirit of expanding our cultural world, or imagining a place different from ours that can comment and shed light on ours.

I think my favorite examples of worldbuilding are those with a strong cultural and artistic focus, and which draw a lot from real world cultures (as far as I'm concerned, a real culture is always going to dwarf any imagined one in terms of richness, historic power and complexity). The easy example is Obsession by Blackjack Gabbiani.

Oh, this is very off topic now. Cultural worldbuilding is a whole another thing from mechanics world building.
 
Last edited:
As both a writer and a reader, I love worldbuilding, though I will admit I prefer writing it over reading it.

One of the most amazing things about Pokemon is the sheer level of flexibility both the canon material and the fandom gives you. The fandom for Pokemon is one of the least "canon policing" I've ever met. Even if you don't state something is a heavy AU, if you have some AU elements, no one throws a fit and claims you aren't a "true fan". Something I've experienced in my time in the major comic book fandoms. In Pokemon, you can follow the games, the anime, the *****, the card game, the spin-offs, etc., as closely or as loosely as you want. You can combine them, add your own things, etc.

And that's not even including the possibilities once you get into original characters and your own interpretations. Pokemon is basically a giant spring board for such ideas, something that has always greatly endeared me to the fandom. Your original character stories will get reviews! Your world building one shots get likes and favourites! It's a pretty incredible things, and I think that's part of why world building in Pokemon is so much fun, for me at least, because you aren't punished for it.

But getting back into world building itself for Pokemon...

With world building, I am definitely a fan of taking the basics and building up my own world, as opposed to sticking strictly to "canon" material. And I don't tend to veer toward grimdark or "gritty realism" portrayals either. I've never been a fan of them, to be honest. If other people are, that's great, but it's not for me. I've actually had the same Pokemon "world" for about four years now? Going on five? And while it's evolved over time, it's remained largely the same.

I call it the Legendary 'Verse, based on the main story in the canon. And I'm actually reworking Evolution of an Aura to be in that 'Verse, something I never thought I could do.

The whole idea of world building, for me, particularly with my own interpretation in this verse, is to fill in the details. Gather up all the interesting tidbits about the world, borrow some age old fan interpretations (old wars), and my own things (the legendaries actually being GODS, for one), and see how I can sort it all together. To me, the beauty is in the details, and even the most throwaway things can be worldbuilding.

Of course, that means that you have to be careful with the age old "law of conservation of detail". Not every single detail you mention has to come up again, because otherwise people start thinking that every time you mention the colour of the drapes it's going to be important. But, I do enjoy adding little throwaway details, like the shape of earrings, or the fact that Eterna City has a bunch of suburbs in my verse, and they keep getting closer to the forest. Which is bad.

News reports may be my favourite way to world build though. Stick a TV in the background and have a person doing something where they can listen, and also react, preferably. Boom, instant world details that affect your character and our view of them. Relevant and excellent!
 
Back
Top