• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

...Items?

FlameRose

Well-Known Member
I've been wondering, how do you think someone could correctly display the use of items like a Potion or Antidote? In the games you can use them almost whenever you want/need to, but would there be enough time if you base your battles like the ones in the show? I don't remember any time when a Trainer was allowed to interrupt a battle to use a Hyper Potion.

My question is basically: how do you use Items correctly in a story? Any thoghts?
 
It's not whether or not you're allowed, but it's just not really possible. Unless your Pokemon battle right in front of you (which would be highly unsafe), you wouldn't be able to run into the middle of a fray to spray a Potion on them. You'd have to wait until the battle was over.
 
I generally don't show items being used in-battle, reserving them for use after battles. (It wouldn't be very fair, anyway, if the one with the most items could just keep healing their Pokémon in an actual battle.)
 
I don't think that there's a 'correct' way to use items. I figure the use of items would depend mostly on the circumstances. There are differences between, say, a friendly battle and a fight to the death.

In the first scenario, for example, it would probably depend on the terms set by the participants. That is, wether they're willing to interrupt the battle so that items may be used.

This is in contrast with the second scenario where could very well be a necessity in order to survive. It would probably be extremely unlikely that either side would allow the other to use items so if one side needed to they'd have to find shelter/use another Pokémon to defend themselves/etc. in order to create a situation where they could use the items they need.

So it all depends on the circumstances that the author creates. As for official battles... well, it would depend on the author and the rules that they set. The reason why you probably don't see them used all that much is because there is a high chance that it could ruin the flow or the emotion in the battle.
 
Unless you can impliment that the spray's radius was very far and therefore reach the wounds it's impossible. As Dragonfree said you should reserve them for after the battle.
 
I think the only time I used items like potions and antidotes in any story was because the trainers were far away from a pokemon center and HAD to use those items before their pokemon got extremely hurt. Like ... pokemon center on the go. Or something more creative.

Since we're on a similar topic, does anyone here use held items in their stories? How exactly do you portray that? Do you actually use the bonuses the items give?

As for me, I think I only have them as decoration, and they're usually mentioned in small parts of the story that no one cares about. :3 And then we all forget.
 
Last edited:
Well, one of the held items I used are the plates. Now those are tricky as I have to come up with how the Pokemon are able to hold those things. What I came up with is there are chains on them, so the Pokemon would wear them as a necklace. Yeah, not a very original idea. XD And also, I did have the plates' bonus in boosting powers to type moves.
 
I would say that potions and other forms of medicine are useable but not during battles. Even if it were allowed they'd be no way for the trainer to safely get to his Pokémon to administer the medicine. However, I'd say that any competent trainer carries a small supply of such things on them for emergencies.

As for held items and the like, I feel that they shouldn't be used at all. Decorative purposes might be okay, but items providing a boost to the Pokémon’s damage are just a little silly in my opinion. Fanfiction and video games are two completely different things really.
 
Well, what about little self-imposed interludes? At the end of a particularly painful series of moves, both trainers could unanimously declare a stalemate and get their Hyper Potions and Full Heals out while the pokémon are holding reasonably still. (Alternately, if you interpreted Pokémon Restoration Machines as essentially light-based, you could create some advanced technology for shooting a beam of restorative light and... *rambles off into crack theories*

In-story, I've rarely brought them into light (despite the importance the games put into them). Generally I reserve them for after the battle. No need for more than minimal artificial interference in what is a pokémon battle.
 
Since we're on a similar topic, does anyone here use held items in their stories? How exactly do you portray that? Do you actually use the bonuses the items give?

Well, I once had one of my characters using a TM, she basically placed it on her head and the disk turned to dust as she learned the move.

Okay, so I write a PMD fanfic, and I don't need to worry about antidotes/paralyz heal or anything like that because I can make do with berries. But when it comes to potions or things like that, I remember how the trainers sprays on the wounds after the battle--because a battle wouldn't be fair if a trainer goes "hey stop for a moment! I'll just apply this potion..." and that battle would either go on forever with both trainer healing their Pokemon endlessly...

...my words never make sense. *got shot*
 
I've used TMs as producing pseudo-Psychic signals from a crystal on the TM case. It has to be pseudo-Psychic, because otherwise Darks couldn't learn anything. So the case itself gets a use there.

Hold items could be used as psychological boosts, influencing confidence (Example: see Dumbo's magic feather). In case of 'magical' items (like the Plates), like Bay pointed out, if you can get it on the Pokemon, it works. That causes a problem with small Pokemon though. The Mind or Sky Plate would seriously interfere with a Natu's ability to battle.

As for Potions in battle... berries are easier to write with, but those still cause a pause (lost turn) in which the opponent can still KO the hurt Pokemon. I haven't used Potions in battles.

Of course, since I write fantasy, I can get away with healing spell use...
 
Healing items, I use frequently. Only after the battle. On the progress of my current fic, the character Brock will, as a breeder, eventually have access to Pokémon that can heal, but so early in the adventure, he'll be their portable Pokémon Centre.

When I use hold items, I usually change their size. Sharp Beak, for example, becomes a lot smaller and is held on a chain around the neck, but you do see the changes. When a Pokémon uses a flying-type move, the Sharp Beak will glow teal (the colour of energy I use for flying-type moves) and transfer its power to the Pokémon's attack.

With the plates, when I come to them, I'll be having the trainer hold the plate out when they order an attack, sending similarly typed energy to their Pokémon.

I've only ever used TM's once, and I used the Teachy TV as a computer. Disc enters the TV, shows the attack to the Pokémon, who copies it. Now, I just use other trainers, same as I do with move tutors.

Iota
 
When I use hold items, I usually change their size. Sharp Beak, for example, becomes a lot smaller and is held on a chain around the neck, but you do see the changes. When a Pokémon uses a flying-type move, the Sharp Beak will glow teal (the colour of energy I use for flying-type moves) and transfer its power to the Pokémon's attack.

With the plates, when I come to them, I'll be having the trainer hold the plate out when they order an attack, sending similarly typed energy to their Pokémon.

Both ideas sound like they could work rather well, especially the transfer of energy you mentioned for items like Sharp Beak. The problem I have with that is it still seems like something people would object to in actual Pokémon battles, especially the league and gym leaders, as it gives the item holding Pokémon and trainers a massive advantage.

I mean, it's alone the lines of a footballer, or any athlete for that matter, using performance enhancing drugs. Or that's the way I see it at least.

The above ideas could work in terms of practise though, to help the Pokémon focus their abilities better and become stronger that way.

I've only ever used TM's once, and I used the Teachy TV as a computer. Disc enters the TV, shows the attack to the Pokémon, who copies it. Now, I just use other trainers, same as I do with move tutors.

Iota

Think I'm planning on doing the same thing myself. Pokémon can learn any move on their move list, TM/HM list and in some cases egg group list but they have to be taught that move first. Kind of like how Ash's Pikachu learnt iron tail.
 
In official battles, you're right, I believe they would be frowned upon if not banned, but as you say, in practice battles it would be fine, honing and refining elemental abilities.

Iota
 
Potions? Give me a break...I don;'t use silly things like potions. I don't portray them. i replace them instead with a Duex-ex-Machina scenario where everyone is healed immediately by magic...
But talking seriously...no...after a serious battle, maybe. But i don't say potions can heal...they are disinfectants, not healing magic...
 
Magic? This is a world where berries that grow on trees can dramatically increase the energy and stamina of an animal that shoots elemental projectiles from its mouth.

You could quite easily turn potions into actual drinks rather than sprays, although sprays would work just fine, and have it as a mixture of different types of berries, giving it varying strength.

There's no need to attempt sarcasm and call it magic, when quite clearly, Pokémon can cure themselves with techniques a lot more like magic. Never taken medicine in your life?

Iota
 
I think the only time I used items like potions and antidotes in any story was because the trainers were far away from a pokemon center and HAD to use those items before their pokemon got extremely hurt. Like ... pokemon center on the go. Or something more creative.
If I remember correctly, Brendan gave his Lanturn some food during his first gym battle in HLBMA

Anyway, it depends on how you want to do it. You can make it possible. There's no saying you can't "invent" special rules for battling, as long as it doesn't feel too out of place.

Out of battle, I feel it's like using a spray version of ointment; to improve wounds well enough to hang on well enough until a Pokémon Center. Antidotes are like, well, easy-to-use antibiotics or something to use when the Pokémon is poisoned, and the same goes for the other status healers. That's how I view it, at least ;)
 
I think the only time I used items like potions and antidotes in any story was because the trainers were far away from a pokemon center and HAD to use those items before their pokemon got extremely hurt. Like ... pokemon center on the go. Or something more creative.
If I remember correctly, Brendan gave his Lanturn some food during his first gym battle in HLBMA

Anyway, it depends on how you want to do it. You can make it possible. There's no saying you can't "invent" special rules for battling, as long as it doesn't feel too out of place.

Out of battle, I feel it's like using a spray version of ointment; to improve wounds well enough to hang on well enough until a Pokémon Center. Antidotes are like, well, easy-to-use antibiotics or something to use when the Pokémon is poisoned, and the same goes for the other status healers. That's how I view it, at least ;)
 
Besides possibly held items, it's generally accepted that realistically, items wouldn't be used in mid-battle. I've seen someone try to portray the use of a Revive by throwing it at the Pokémon from the sidelines, which kinda worked. It's all a matter of if you think you can write it in and make it sound believable.

Potions, status healers and the like seem to come in bottles with spray nozzles in most interpretations, so that's probably how they're used, if that's what we're after here.
 
Back
Top