Negrek
Lost but Seeking
DreamSayer
Thanks for taking the time to read all this and leave a review! Let's dive right in.
As a few people have said, it's not a problem if you dislike, or even hate the protagonist. I mean, as long as it doesn't too much detract from your enjoyment of the story. I'll be interested to hear whether your opinion on it ever changes.
FWIW, the cop is actually Officer Feldhorn. We'll see more of him eventually, too!
Softboiled and so on aren't usually a problem for pokémon because they have much more energy to spare than humans. Even so, you couldn't just keep spamming softboiled on something without consequences.
It's true, the protagonist's character development is quite slow, particularly in the earlier chapters. There's only so much time it can spend as a total jerk before people get exasperated with it, for sure, and I think the number of chapters that go by without much sign of progression may be too much for a lot of people. Unfortunately I'm not sure whether there's any way I can accelerate it given the constraints of the plot, but hopefully you'll start to notice signs of the protagonist being less of a jerkface.
quietly shoves latest chapter out of sight while whistling innocently. The issue is that there aren't a ton of generally-useful spread moves that can replace it--it's usually the most powerful and reliable option.
And thank you for writing such a wonderful comprehensive review! I really enjoyed reading it, and you brought up lots of excellent points, especially with regards to the portrayal of the protagonist. I seriously appreciate it.
Thanks for taking the time to read all this and leave a review! Let's dive right in.
I'd say that's pretty accurate, yeah.With that out of the way, I just want to say that my first impressions were that we have ourselves an mc who’s overpowered, sociopathic, selfish, has a superiority complex, an adamant self-righteousness, short fused, disrespectful, all around creepy and other times obnoxious.
As a few people have said, it's not a problem if you dislike, or even hate the protagonist. I mean, as long as it doesn't too much detract from your enjoyment of the story. I'll be interested to hear whether your opinion on it ever changes.
More an obsession than anything else, I suppose! And yes, the protagonist doesn't treat Titan all that well, here especially, despite saying repeatedly that he's its friend.One thing I want to say is that I certainly did not like how Mc practically forced Titan to obey, nor did I like how Mc kept insisting that they were Garret. Is it a fetish or an obsession, or just plain psychotic?
Hmmm, not quite either, I don't think? One of the inspirations I had in wanting to write this story was to take a character that would be off the charts on a Mary Sue test, with all kinds of powers and special traits and relationships to canon characters, etc., but then try to play it in a way that they wouldn't come off as a Mary Sue. Though there was some element of wanting to explore what would happen if you really did give a kid all these ridiculous upgrades, I suppose. (Children fighting to save the world: generally bad idea, imo.)Is Mc inspired by someone else, or are you trying to teach your readers what would happen if someone with the mentality of an 8 year old had the most powerful ability in the world and how they’d use this. I would like to know for sure.
No, generally I'm not aiming for "touching" if one of the characters is going on about murdering people. XD It's true, the way the protagonist destroyed the computer was pretty extra and not the most efficient way to go about things... but it does have a little tendency to panic or rage more or less at the drop of a hat, heh.I don’t know if you wanted to make it a touching, but it was nothing but creepy and off putting, at least not in a bad way.
I'm glad you like Leo! He hasn't gotten a lot of love, heh. He does appear more in the second half of the story.As for that Cop dad, Kerrigan was his name? [...] I was disappointed that Kerrigan didn’t appear much for the next several chapters after this one. Kinda a bummer really.
FWIW, the cop is actually Officer Feldhorn. We'll see more of him eventually, too!
Thanks, I'm glad you like him! It's true, I do find Nate a ton of fun to write. I'm always pleased when people like him, he's one of my favorites.The Great Nathaniel Morgan was easily the best character you’ve introduced into this story. The way both he and mc are messed up, yet contrast heavily with each other is simply a delight. His interactions and dialogue are always very fun to read and I can’t help but feel that you have more fun writing him the most.
Interesting! The flashback chapter is definitely long, primarily because I didn't think the story would make too much sense without giving a fairly full account of that period for Mew and Sara. Like, I could have restricted it to a line or scene or two along the lines of, "I was part of the expedition that found Mew and was at the lab when Mewtwo was created," but I thought that would be unsatisfying and perhaps raise more questions than it answered. I think this chapter could stand a little trimming though... to try to keep it focused on information the reader is going to find interesting and relevant.Before I go on, I want to point out a few things I learned from reading that backstory chapter. If I’m being honest with you, I could not concentrate on it at all. At first, I thought that maybe it was too expositional or something, but I soon found out that the reason I skipped most of it was because I was only interested in knowing how they met Mewtwo at the time, and not their entire backstory.
Oh no, Mew is DEFINITELY more powerful than the protagonist. We haven't really gotten a chance to see her in action, but she did only give it a piece of her power. Overall the protagonist is less strong than it is flexible; it can adapt well to a lot of situations, and excels in one-on-one sorts of fights, but bring more opponents in and its advantage starts to erode. It can take Red's pikachu one-on-one for example, but if it had to fight both Pikachu and Charizard at the same time, it would have a great deal of trouble.As for what I read, how come Mew giving the mc a literal piece of her to keep her alive cause the mc to become stronger than Mew will ever be? Is there even a limit to how strong Mc can become? From what I’ve seen so far, hardly.
Haha, yup! It's definitely a hypocrite on top of everything else. I get why you found the battle anticlimactic, I think... cheating tends to take a lot of the tension out of situations like that. It makes wins feel cheap and too simple.And Mc sure is a hypocrite and they know it. Calls someone a cheat and then cheats to win a badge the next goddamn day! Worst part is that they keep using their self-entitled ‘Mission’ as an excuse for every wrongdoing and every ill-advised decision they make.
Nope, no good guys here! I've had fun writing a story where Team Rocket are (occasionally) the "good guys," or where they act more noble than the protagonist itself.Normally, I’d be rooting for the good guys to win this one and defeat Team Rocket! Unfortunately, there weren’t any good guys in this battle. No morally ambiguous folk, no antiheroes, just bad guys fighting a sociopathic demon. I honestly rooted for Team Rocket though, I just want to see someone prove to Mc that they aren’t infallible or the ‘chosen one with a mission’ they think they are.
In general Mew can do anything the protagonist can do and more, so yes, she could mess with her brain in the same way. And sure, the protagonist could change its brain so that it would think rather differently... but why? It's convinced it's awesome!Which is ironic because we learn that Mc has the power to change their brain structure to change the way they think (Can Mew even do that?) and yet they’re somehow always a dickhead all the time.
We'll learn how Red captured Mewtwo later in the story! For now, the only hint I'll give is that, given how powerful Mewtwo is, there's no way Red could have beat him in a contest that relied on power!Next chapter has Mewtwo going on a total KILLING SPREE!!! I mean, really, I know Mewtwo is a powerful pokemon and all, but this is just overkill. How in the world did Red even stand a chance against this monster? I honestly can’t picture anything standing against him and not winding up dead, the way you made him that powerful.
Well, Nate does say something to that effect at least once or twice. XDOkay, yeah, I know they’re serious, but come on! They have no right to call anyone evil! Not when they’re so oppressive, cold, uncaring, egotistical. I want someone to flat out tell them that they’re no child, just a demon spawned from hell below.
Softboiled and other healing attacks use primarily the target's own energy to work. It basically accelerates the body's natural healing process: think about a broken bone healing in a few seconds instead of a few weeks. All the effort your body would ordinarily put in to make repairs is concentrated into a very brief period of time, which is probably going to make you pretty tired! Nate had a lot of injuries to deal with, which would have ordinarily needed a prolonged healing process. Making it all happen super fast took a ton out of him, which is why he loses weight the way he does: his body has to burn some of his fat stores in order to provide enough energy to complete the healing the softboiled sets off.I wonder why you made healing to cause Nate to lose so much weight each time it’s used on him. It’s kind of counterproductive, don’t you think? I’m sure you’ve mentioned the reason somewhere and I just wasn’t paying much attention to catch up on it.
Softboiled and so on aren't usually a problem for pokémon because they have much more energy to spare than humans. Even so, you couldn't just keep spamming softboiled on something without consequences.
I'm glad you liked Nate's reunion with his pokémon. The reveal of how much they mean to him and how he relates to pokémon in general was one of my favorites in the first couple arcs, so it's always nice to see that people enjoyed it.One thing I wasn’t expecting was that Nate actually cared about his pokemon that much. It was something I wasn’t expecting, considering his personality. It was kind of heartwarming seeing him reunite with them, though their journey to the hospital only added more to my distaste for Mc. They think they’re always in the right even when it’s blatantly obvious they’re not. It’s a bit worrying that Mc has yet to experience any major character growth even at this point. I’m hoping you’ll rectify that soon enough. It’s hard to keep reading about someone’s journey when you can’t feel anything for them but irritation.
It's true, the protagonist's character development is quite slow, particularly in the earlier chapters. There's only so much time it can spend as a total jerk before people get exasperated with it, for sure, and I think the number of chapters that go by without much sign of progression may be too much for a lot of people. Unfortunately I'm not sure whether there's any way I can accelerate it given the constraints of the plot, but hopefully you'll start to notice signs of the protagonist being less of a jerkface.
Hmm, what made you think it let them win?I would be celebrating Nate’s pokemon beating the **** out of Mc if I didn’t remember that they totally let them win.
I'm always surprised by how much people like Alice, heh. I'm glad you enjoyed the battle and the personality of the pokémon! The raichu was a character concept I'd had in mind for a while and wasn't sure what to do with, so it was nice to be able to bring him into the story here. And yes, if the story were about Alice it would definitely be a bit more relaxing. XD Perhaps some other time, eh?The first battle against The Awesome One Time Appearance Alice was a blast! Even in the brief time it was active, that Raichu had plenty of personality. I almost wish the story was about Alice, but that’s another story entirely, we have our Mc already.
I'm really tickled that you figured out it was Leo who was behind the League summons right away like that! I think most people were surprised to see him return here... as far as I know you're the only person who guessed it was him before he actually shows up again in the story. It's true he can't do much to stop the protagonist here, but it's definitely accruing a lot of bad karma. I assure you it's all going to come due someday.Luck finally ran out for Nate with the cops finally figuring out that he stole his pokedex. Seriously, is there anything on this guy that wasn’t stolen from somewhere? This has Kerrigan’s fingerprints all over it. I can’t wait to see how this plays out.
Haha, yes, guilty. They're such handy field moves! Surf in particular I actively tried to tone down how often it was being used in the League matches, but yeah, it's still such an easy go-to. I'll try to watch the prevalence of earthquake in the futureThere are so many pokemon using Surf and Earthquake in this fic that I almost forgot there were other options to choose from.
I modeled the tournament on the League tournaments seen in the anime, which don't include Elite Four fights. How it works is mentioned a little bit in the chapter where Leo's reintroduced. Basically, anybody with the requisite gym badges can challenge the E4 whenever they like; it's a separate thing from the tourney. Whoever wins the tournament gets pride of place, though, and a special "priority" change to challenge the Elites right after the tournament wraps up.Just now noticing the fact that there were no Elite Four Battles in this tournament. I wonder what that’s all about, but I’m sure it’s so the arc can get over with already.
Oh, it definitely occurred to him. XD Taking the protagonist at its word on anything is a bit surprissing, yeah, but if it was lying (about Eskar giving it anything), then he still can't really do anything about it, one way or another. He doesn't have any good alternatives to trust.Even though Nate figures out that the sableye was the one he’s boss was using, he doesn’t consider the possibility that Mc’s deal involved him getting sold out. Heck, I’m surprised he even believed Mc either.
Haha, well, I didn't think it would be tremendously realistic for him to be suddenly reformed after one conversation or anything like that. It's hard to make a commitment and completely rework your life from there. So, baby steps, eh?It was a nice moment of character growth for Nate when we saw him contemplating his options for the future, but I was disappointed in him when he decided he’d just keep being a criminal instead. Old habits die hard I suppose.
To me it makes sense that it can mix and match abilities because it can also mix and match the elements of its physical form--for example when it's basically human-looking but grows big salamence claws or what have you. When it uses an ability that relies on biology, its biology does have to change to compensate. Like, it could be a charmander with the rough skin ability, but to do that it would have to become a charmander with literal rough skin, like, physically. A lot of abilities don't have a biological analog that's readily observable, though, like motor drive, so being an off-type pokémon with that ability is basically invisible.don’t think switching abilities without changing the pokemon as well should even be possible since most special abilities are tied to the pokemon’s biology eg a garchomp with rough skin.
The protagonist definitely couldn't beat Mewtwo by transforming into a legendary pokémon. Not only is Mewtwo stronger than a lot of legendaries, but the protagonist isn't able to copy the special abilities of pokémon it turns into, so it would never be as powerful as the original incarnation--and like any pokémon, there are levels and relative skill disparities to take into place. Transforming into a pokémon doesn't automatically make the protagonist as strong as that pokémon, because it's still limited by its own skill at battling (not the best, as you've noticed) and the amount of energy it has to work with (i.e. its level). Like, if it turned into Mewtwo himself, Mewtwo would still handily kick its ***.Mc could even beat Mewtwo by just transforming into a legendary pokemon or something, a thing I’m very positive they’re able to do. There are simply no noticeable thresholds to Mc’s power, and I doubt that’s something that can be changed now.
I probably haven't done a great job of indicating the limits on the protagonist's power. Therre are plenty of things it doesn't do because it can't like, as Ambyssin suggested, turn into a joltik to better traverse the League building's air ducts, but it simply doesn't do them so it's not clear that it wouldn't be an option in the first place. I find it interesting that you say there's nothing really to challenge the protagonist in this story, because I thought I'd been erring on the side of too much challenge, too much failure, rather than too little! Like, the protagonist loses against Nate, against Team Rocket (in the ambush), loses Mewtwo to the Rockets in Viridian, loses to Nate's pokémon, and loses the battle against the League opponent it ends up screwing over (albeit offscreen). Even when it wins, the outcome's generally pretty close and it only scrapes by with the help of something underhanded. Did those failures just not seem significant compared to the successes? Do you think that they're unlucky breaks or that the protagonist was intending for those things to happen (e.g. let Mightyena win)? What I'm going for with the protagonist is "has a ton of power but doesn't know how to use it properly; actually kind of sucks," so it's not good that you see it as more or less invincible.There are simply no noticeable thresholds to Mc’s power, and I doubt that’s something that can be changed now.
Thank you! I'm glad you enjoyed the story, and particularly the battles; I'm very proud of my battles, so it's nice to know that they don't drag on and become boring. I hope some of your problems with the protagonist will be amended as the story goes on, too.My general consensus for the story is that it’s very good. The battles are never boring and manage to keep your adrenaline going. Most of the characters are very intriguing and rightly varied in their roles. If anything, Mc is the only thing I can say is wrong with this story. Everything else is either great or just above average and decent. I dare say it’s as close as it can get to a masterpiece.
And thank you for writing such a wonderful comprehensive review! I really enjoyed reading it, and you brought up lots of excellent points, especially with regards to the portrayal of the protagonist. I seriously appreciate it.