• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

The Burqa

Ladies and gentleman, I provide you with a slice of humble pie sprinkled delicately with some ownage sauce. Thank you Kaiser Soze.

Double standard much?

The word "Pope" is never found in the Bible. If we're going by your standard of "the word burga is never found in the Koran", then that argument is invalid.

IT's also invalid insomuch that Peter established a church and became the first Pope because Peter, and in fact, all of Jesus' followers (the people who knew him) considered themselves Jews until the day they died. Christianity was initially a sect of Judaism and didn't become distinct from Judaism until well after Jesus is consdered to have died.
 
Double standard much?

The word "Pope" is never found in the Bible. If we're going by your standard of "the word burga is never found in the Koran", then that argument is invalid.

IT's also invalid insomuch that Peter established a church and became the first Pope because Peter, and in fact, all of Jesus' followers (the people who knew him) considered themselves Jews until the day they died. Christianity was initially a sect of Judaism and didn't become distinct from Judaism until well after Jesus is consdered to have died.

I was of course referring to the church reference. The pope one isn't really worth debating because there is ambiguity to it. It suggests to me though that there is at least an attempt for each church to have a corporeal figurehead (can't think of any that don't off the top of my head), over which there doesn't seem to be much debate.

The church point is of course not invalid because we're talking about what is referenced in the holy book, not what it constitutes in corporeal/archaeological form. Marioguy asked for references to churches, he was given them. Voila.
 
Last edited:
The Catholics, Eastern Orthodox, and Anglicans/Episcopalians draw a direct line from today's bishops and the Pope (for Catholics) to Peter and the other apostoles. The term is Apostolic Succession. The quote is the point where Jesus made Peter the leader of the Apostles. Peter, being in charge, became the first Bishop of Rome. (For some biblical evidence, he moderated the Council of Jerusalem in the Book of Acts). Hence the Bishop of Rome has been the spiritual leader of all Christians up to the 1054 East-West Schism and the Protestant Reformation. Using the term "pope" for the Bishop of Rome started informally around the 5th century and later became his main title.

As for your minister, I'm going to take a shot in the dark and guess he's an Evangelical Protestant. Most Protestant sects reject Apostolic Succession, and by definition of not being Catholic they don't follow the pope. You might say it's the Christian version of the Sunni-Shi'a split. Don't assume all Christians believe the same thing; it's a big umbrella (case in point Mormons).

[/Christian history tangent]
 
The Catholics, Eastern Orthodox, and Anglicans/Episcopalians draw a direct line from today's bishops and the Pope (for Catholics) to Peter and the other apostoles. The term is Apostolic Succession. The quote is the point where Jesus made Peter the leader of the Apostles. Peter, being in charge, became the first Bishop of Rome. (For some biblical evidence, he moderated the Council of Jerusalem in the Book of Acts). Hence the Bishop of Rome has been the spiritual leader of all Christians up to the 1054 East-West Schism and the Protestant Reformation. Using the term "pope" for the Bishop of Rome started informally around the 5th century and later became his main title.

As for your minister, I'm going to take a shot in the dark and guess he's an Evangelical Protestant. Most Protestant sects reject Apostolic Succession, and by definition of not being Catholic they don't follow the pope. You might say it's the Christian version of the Sunni-Shi'a split. Don't assume all Christians believe the same thing; it's a big umbrella (case in point Mormons).

[/Christian history tangent]

I'm Catholic and spent 12 years in Catholic schooling. I know the Church's history. But if we're using the standard set by Snorunt conservationist of "The Burqa is never literally mentioned in the Koran", then the Pope is also never ever mentioned in the Bible.

What you're talking about is the Church's history and the church's tradition, which has been dismissed as irrelevant by Snorunt conservationist in regards to Islamic history and tradition.
 
I'm Catholic and spent 12 years in Catholic schooling. I know the Church's history. But if we're using the standard set by Snorunt conservationist of "The Burqa is never literally mentioned in the Koran", then the Pope is also never ever mentioned in the Bible.

What you're talking about is the Church's history and the church's tradition, which has been dismissed as irrelevant by Snorunt conservationist in regards to Islamic history and tradition.

Again, show me where Islamic holy texts point to the Burqa and Hijab in explicit terms. Until then you have no argument.

I'd also argue that while the Pope is not explicitly mentioned, there is a clear attempt by Jesus to highlight the role being played by Peter, an individual, at the head of the Church. He goes out of his way to appoint him so, while the clothing question in Islam is left very much ambiguous and there is no attempt to specify what entails modesty other than the coverage of breasts. The church is however given a corporeal figurehead on earth in the Bible.
 
Last edited:
Again, show me where Islamic holy texts point to the Burqa and Hijab in explicit terms. Until then you have no argument

I'd also argue that while the Pope is not explicitly mentioned, there is a clear attempt

So wait a second, so with Islam and the Burga, there needs to be an "explicit" term. But even when you admit that the Catholic Church's Pope is not said "explict[ly]", it's okay because it's a "clear attempt"

That's a double standard.

Remember, I'm not arguing the Bible DOES NOT name Peter the Pope. I'm simply using your standard of "The Koran doesn't say the burqa" similarly in that the Bible never uses the word "Pope" and that Peter himself died a Jew.
 
So wait a second, so with Islam and the Burga, there needs to be an "explicit" term. But even when you admit that the Catholic Church's Pope is not said "explict[ly]", it's okay because it's a "clear attempt"

That's a double standard.

Remember, I'm not arguing the Bible DOES NOT name Peter the Pope. I'm simply using your standard of "The Koran doesn't say the burqa" similarly in that the Bible never uses the word "Pope" and that Peter himself died a Jew.

No it's not a double standard because I acknowledge that there is no mention of a Pope in the Bible. I do however argue that there is a more specific attempt to establish a singular figurehead at the apex of the Church Jesus asks to be founded than there is to specify what items of clothing should be worn by Muslims beyond the limitations of "modesty". As in, there are degrees of ambiguity. Something can be more or less ambiguous than something else. It's really not that compliated.

At no point do I argue that the position of Pope is created in the Bible, simply that there is more scope for specifics in what "Jesus" says than what is said in the Quran regaring specific clothing.

Honestly, these attempts are getting a bit poor now. Or even more poor than they were previously, and considering that they were limited to finger pointing unfounded accusations of racism that is saying something. It's quite sad when one of the better debaters in the forum is resorting to such lame attempts.

If you really think that I seek to value christianity over Islam, then you clearly haven't read many of my posts.

EDIT: Having discussed the nature of ambiguity with my mother, we concluded (reluctantly in my case) that there probably cannot be degrees of ambiguity. Consider then I am arguing that the bible provides more or a closer level of specification.
 
Last edited:
Well the pope not being mentioned in the bible would be because the office of the pope didn't exist till Catholics came on the scene.
 
My apologies. I believe I have misquoted my teacher. I think He said the Bible has no mention of the church, as in the Vatican. Can someone verify this for me?
 
My apologies. I believe I have misquoted my teacher. I think He said the Bible has no mention of the church, as in the Vatican. Can someone verify this for me?

Jesus says "On this rock I will build my church, and the gates of Hell will not prevail against it." (Matthew 16:18)
 
Should we also assume the Jews have always lived in Jerusalem?

Once again, Marioguy can't follow his own advice...
 
I don't really mind the Burqa being worn, though I do sympathize with people that wish for it to be taken off in places like airports and banks, or not just that, but really any place that requires photo identification. It's not that big of a deal, I don't think. You simply take off your hood for a short period of time, and you let the person with match up your face with your ID. If Muslim women feel uncomfortable doing that, why not simply ask for another woman to identify you?

I saw this occur at Singapore Airport when I travelled through there recently. The woman simply had a female passport inspector check her face and compare it with her passport. It was done discreetly with no fuss or outrage or children being compromised.

To say this couldn't be done in other situations where there is a legitimate safety/security issue with a face covering is ludicrous. Banning the burqa is a thinly-veiled anti-Islamic movement that stands in the face of basic civil rights.
 
I saw this occur at Singapore Airport when I travelled through there recently. The woman simply had a female passport inspector check her face and compare it with her passport. It was done discreetly with no fuss or outrage or children being compromised.

To say this couldn't be done in other situations where there is a legitimate safety/security issue with a face covering is ludicrous. Banning the burqa is a thinly-veiled anti-Islamic movement that stands in the face of basic civil rights.

It's nice to see members who have disagreed on previous issues come together to fight intolerance towards a religion.
 
Well, I've heard of a study that shows that humans cannot recognize other human's faces very well from a picture if the other person is a stranger. Some people cannot recognize faces at all. Which would lead me to believe that fingerprints would be better, burqa or no.

Posted by randomspot555
Who said anything about women and their rights? These women are part of a religion that they are voluntarily a part of.

I will be something like the hundreth person to point out that it is not always by choice. A lot of children are pretty much forced into their parents religion. However, it is not the government's job to figure out whether or not someone wants to wear something. After all, girls have peer pressure to wear skinny jeans and uggs. (Yes, I know that in the case of burqa's the pressure is more extreme, but my point is still made.) The separation of Church (or any othe religion) and state is important.

Who are you to judge whether or not a religion brainwashes their adherents? That cannot be quantified and cannot weigh on whether or not a government bans burqas. Let them be.

Exactly. When considering whether or not to banish burqas, the reasons of the people wearing them isn't the first concern. Saying, oh, look, some people are being forced to wear these things, so let's put a ban on them, is not the way to go. Those who wear them, or at least some, are going to be accustomed to wearing them, and forcing change on them isn't the way to go here. And it will just make a lot of resentment.

Okay, let's think about this for a second.

You're concerned about a traditional Muslim going to a night club?

Yeah, because the bars and clubs I go to are FILLED with amish and Hasidic Jews.

[/end sarcasm]

Yeah, well, someone could use a burqa to get into a bar, even if they weren't Muslim. Yeah, I know, it's a bad argument, but I had to point it out.

If they choose to hide themselves, it's their choice. It only appears that they are being oppressed, because that's what you want to think.

If someone's being forced to wear a garmet that steals any form of identity from them, then they are being oppressed. If they voluntarily wear such a garmet, that is their choice. Choosing to hide yourself over being beaten or something like that (the law isn't everywhere) isn't exactly much of a choice.

However, as I've said before, I say let's use fingerprints. Short of burning your fingers, you can't change those, whereas heavy makeup could change how your face looks, and fingerprints are more reliable.
 
Back
Top